We explore rogue wave emergence in generic wave systems governed by the nonlinear Schrödinger equation. We highlight the interplay between the stochastic focusing induced by a random chirp of a continuous wave condensate and modulation instability of the condensate to periodic and/or random perturbations. We show that regardless of its statistical properties, the random chirp of the condensate leads to a non-Gaussian, heavy-tailed probability density distribution of peak powers of the waves excited atop of the condensate, which is a statistical signature of rogue waves, or more broadly, extreme events in physics.