Visual Literacy Instruction Research Articles

It’s Hard Because I Don’t Know Anything about It”: Second Graders’ Understanding of Visual Graphics in Science

Using a verbal protocol, this study investigated how 38 second-grade students identify, describe, and interpret five types of commonly used visual graphics in science texts (i.e., cut-away diagrams, maps, captioned photographs, flow diagrams, and hybrids). Additionally, we explored the challenges students encountered when interpreting these visuals. Our findings demonstrated that, overall, a majority of second graders struggled to correctly name and identify the purposes of the selected visuals, with the exception of maps. Furthermore, there was significant variation in students’ interpretations of the visuals in science texts. When interpreting the visuals, students’ perceptions of the task’s difficulty level were influenced by factors such as the amount of information, overall organization, concreteness of visuals, use of visual conventions, lack of prior knowledge, and vocabulary knowledge. We recommend that classroom teachers integrate more explicit visual literacy instruction into science education, incorporating a variety of visuals.

The Power of Visuals: The Significance of Higher Education Teacher Professional Development in Visual Literacy in Kuwait

This study explores the role of higher education professional development in the integration of visual literacy instruction at the university level. Visual literacy is a crucial skill that empowers students to comprehend and generate visual content across diverse domains. However, many instructors lack necessary training and support to effectively incorporate visual literacy into their teaching practices. The research survey investigates the significance of teacher professional development in visual literacy implementation, encompassing the status of training, effective professional development programs for teachers, suitable teaching methods, education technologies, attitudes of higher education instructors towards visual literacy, and the influence of student engagement with visual materials on visual literacy advancement in Kuwait. The questionnaire was administered to a sample of higher education teachers. That data was analyzed employing descriptive and inferential statistical techniques, with SPSS v.26 software. Regression analysis and other multivariate analyses were conducted to test the research hypothesis and model. The outcomes should provide insights into the effectiveness of collaborative, experiential, and technology-enhanced teacher professional development programs in fostering visual literacy development within higher education, the significance of student engagement with visual materials, and the necessity for further research on effective teaching methods and educational technologies for promoting visual literacy. The findings can inform policy and practice by highlighting the importance of equipping higher education instructors with necessary skills and resources to effectively incorporate visual literacy into their teaching approaches, enhancing the quality of higher education by fostering competencies among students and facilitating their engagement with visual materials across various disciplines.

Identifying Student Misconceptions in Biomolecular Visualization in the Context of the BioMolViz Framework

BioMolViz is a community dedicated to improving visual literacy instruction in biology, chemistry, and biochemistry classrooms. To help instructors approach biomolecular visualization instruction, visual literacy concepts are catalogued through the BioMolViz Framework, which presents overarching themes that are subdivided into learning objectives and goals. A main focus of our project is the creation of open‐access assessments associated with each of the Framework learning goals. Through nationwide workshops held over the past four years, faculty teams wrote and revised assessments to probe students’ visual literacy utilizing the BioMolViz Framework. As part of a pre‐workshop activity, we asked faculty to identify student misconceptions in visualization that they observed in their teaching. These were collected, mapped to the framework, and coded for Bloom's taxonomy level. Frequently mentioned misconceptions of broad relevance to biomolecular visualization skills were mapped to the BioMolViz Framework and formatted into a biomolecular visualization literacy misconception survey. We present the process of survey development and invite educators from any higher education institution to contribute to understanding the prevalence of these misconceptions among student populations by participating in our survey. We hope the survey data will allow the community to develop better pedagogical approaches to biomolecular visualization through awareness of student misunderstandings. Our collective contributions can help our students overcome the most common challenges in biomolecular visualization while improving abilities in this foundational skill set.

Mind Maps: Processed as Intuitively as Thought? Investigating Late Elementary Students' Eye-Tracked Visual Behavior Patterns In-Depth.

In this study, 44 late elementary students’ visual behavior patterns when reading mind maps were investigated, more particularly, the intuitive processing nature of their visual characteristics, reading sequence and presentation mode (i.e., mind map before or after text). Eye-tracked data were investigated by means of static early attention and dynamic educational process mining (EPM) analysis and combined with learning performance and retrospective interview data. All students seem to struggle with the map’s radial structure during initial reading. Also, the picture’s position in the map diverts students from consecutively reading interconnected branches. EPM analyses revealed different reading patterns in proceeding reading behavior. Students receiving a text first, seem to grasp the radial structure slightly more and show higher information integration attempts. They also attained higher free recall and coherence scores. The study concludes with instructional design principles for urgently needed explicit visual literacy instruction in elementary grades.

BioMolViz: A Community Devoted to the Assessment of Biomolecular Visual Literacy

Educators in the molecular life sciences rely heavily on visual representations of biological molecules. The explicit instruction of visual literacy of the representations, however, is frequently overlooked, leaving students confused about what information is being communicated and/or assessed. The BioMolViz learning community was developed to bring attention to the need for visual literacy instruction and assessment distinct from the interpretation of these representations. Over the past several years, BioMolViz has organized interactive workshops devoted to enhancing instructor skillsets through the collaborative development of biomolecular visualization (BMV) assessments. In response to the pandemic, this year the workshops were moved online. In these workshops, participants engage with like minded scientists to design and peer review BMV assessments and share BMV resources, tools, and activities. Using the BioMolViz Framework (biomolviz.org), a tool that unpacks twelve overarching themes of BMV into a collection of learning goals and objectives, participants produce high-quality assessment instruments for evaluating visual literacy skills, which will be made broadly available to the molecular life sciences community through an online repository. We have found that our process encourages collaboration while developing assessment strategies, which has the added benefit of enriching the pedagogy of our growing community of educators. We will present our strategies for creating engaging workshops, the translation of these meetings to effective online experiences, and challenges resulting from the shift to online format. Guided by participant surveys, we have modified the online experience, and will share our plans for future improvements to increase interactivity and sense of community. We invite the members of ASBMB to join our community of practice, providing an opportunity to expand their engagement with our growing and evolving network of collaborating educators.

Ethical Decision-Making and Visual Literacy Instruction in Architecture

Ethical Decision-Making and Visual Literacy Instruction in Architecture

OpenStreetMap mapathons support critical data and visual literacy instruction.

OpenStreetMap (OSM) mapathons can offer a learner-centered means for critical data literacy and visual literacy instruction. Mapathons are coordinated humanitarian mapping events in which participants use geographic information system (GIS) data and satellite imagery to create open-source maps for humanitarian support. Visual mapping is an effective learning activity because it encourages students to use big data to create a deliverable—an open-source map—that allows instructors to engage learners in data literacy and visual literacy at the highest cognitive level.

Teaching people to read comics: the impact of a visual literacy intervention on comprehension of educational comics

ABSTRACT Evidence suggests that children’s abilities to comprehend information can vary, which may lead to miscommunication and impact on future life outcomes. Previous research suggests that visual literacy interventions may be helpful for children who need to interpret visual sources of information. Recently there has been renewed interest in the potential of comics as assistive tools in pedagogical settings, which are a highly visual medium. However, no research has yet investigated whether a visual literacy intervention can assist children in their comprehension of comics. The current experiment set out to determine if a visual literacy intervention constructed around comics would improve comprehension of educational comics in primary school children. The study consisted of a pre- and post-intervention procedure. Previous comic reading experience was included as a variable. In each session, comprehension and inferential understanding was assessed. Both comprehension and inferential understanding improved following the comics literacy intervention. These results demonstrate that visual literacy instruction can enhance comprehension of educational comics. Findings can be applied to educational settings and have the potential for improving educational outcomes.

Representing Gender: Visual Literacy Instruction in the Academic Library

Abstract Contemporary society is dominated by visual communication, yet visual literacy is a learned skill that requires training. Gender issues, particularly the subjects of gender diversity and power struggles, are deeply pertinent to today’s visual culture. The critical consumption of information has long been taught in libraries, though instruction has typically prioritized text-based sources. However, visual literacy instruction has the capacity to provoke critical inquiry into issues of gender, race, social class, and ethnicity. As institutions that promote social justice, libraries can help improve diversity and inclusion in their communities through teaching visual literacy skills at all levels. Critical visual literacy instruction can also help academic libraries advance student scholarship, which can only be achieved if they are literate in all forms of knowledge production.

Break the Stereotype! Critical Visual Literacy in Art and Design Librarianship

The authors consider an approach to visual literacy instruction that is rooted in the philosophies and practices of critical librarianship and feminist pedagogy. They explore the extent and limitations of existing standards, frameworks, and pedagogical models to support an idea of critical visual literacy, particularly in the context of art and design schools and creative career-focused institutions. By examining practices and examples from other disciplines, the authors identify strategies for teaching critical visual literacy in context. These pedagogical models inform the design and revision of two workshops for art and design students.

Not just a pretty picture: visual literacy education through art for young children

Purpose The purpose of this paper is to understand young children’s knowledge of visual literacy elements as well as their ability to comprehend newly introduced visual literacy concepts. The study also examined existing support for visual literacy programs from parents and educators. Design/methodology/approach The study explored the knowledge of basic visual literacy elements of young children enrolled in two private schools in the New York City metropolitan area. The authors interviewed 17 children, aged four to six years old, about fine art paintings using a semi-structured interview format. Children’s responses were qualitatively analyzed to determine their initial level of visual literacy and their ability to learn and retain the concepts of visual literacy after receiving basic instruction. The children’s educators and parents completed online questionnaires that were quantitatively analyzed to determine their level of support for visual literacy programs. Findings The findings show that young children exhibited extensive knowledge of simple visual literacy elements (color, shape, line), and limited understanding of more abstract elements (perspective and salience). Children’s knowledge of visual elements improved after instruction. Parents and educators expressed support for incorporating visual literacy instruction in early childhood education. Research limitations/implications The study relied on a sample of children and adults drawn from two private schools. The sample’s demographics might have affected study findings. More studies are needed using a larger and more diverse sample. Practical implications The study suggests that young children are ready to receive instruction on visual literacy elements using art images. Children reacted positively to the images and were engaged in the discussions about them, supporting the use of fine art paintings as an instrument to introduce visual literacy concepts to young children. Survey of children’s parents and teachers indicated strong interest in, and support for such programs. Social implications With the increase of visual information production and consumption, it is important to introduce visual literacy early in life. The study advances research in methods for developing visual literacy instruction for young children. Originality/value There are no previously reported studies that have examined pre-kindergarten children’s knowledge of basic visual literacy elements and reactions to visual literacy instruction.

Engaging young children in visual literacy instruction

ABSTRACTVisual literacy is a critical skill that enables individuals to navigate the world of visual media. While research shows multiple benefits of introducing visual literacy early in life, there is a scarcity of visual literacy programs for young children. In an effort to advance development of visual literacy programs for children, we explored techniques for engaging young children in visual literacy instruction using artworks. Our paper reports preliminary study findings and recommendations and outlines directions for future work.

A Collaborative Vision: Partnering with STEM Faculty to Teach Visual Literacy Through Multimedia Research Presentations

This article discusses visual literacy, its connection to information literacy, and its significance to scientific disciplines. It includes a case study from Washington and Lee (W&L) University that showcases how libraries can integrate visual literacy instruction into STEM courses. In the study, two W&L Library staff members partnered with one W&L visiting assistant professor of physics to transform a common assignment, the academic poster, into a digital form of visual communication. This shift resulted in a revised evaluative rubric and led to enhanced library led instruction focusing on information literacy, visual literacy, and digital literacy skills.

Visual Literacy (VL) in Teacher Preparation: Measurement to Direction

>An abridgment of the dissertation Measuring Visual Literacy Ability in Graduate Level Pre-Service Teachers by Teresa A. Farrell, this quantitative descriptive study was designed to establish a baseline of VL ability within this population using a national pool of graduate level students enrolled in teacher preparation programs. Avgerinou’s (2007) VL Index (modified to an online format) was the instrument used to measure VL ability. Results of this study indicate there may be a need for purposeful VL instruction in teacher preparation programs to better equip teachers in K-12 to be visually literate.

A Big Picture Approach: Using Embedded Librarianship to Proactively Address the Need for Visual Literacy Instruction in Higher Education

AbstractAs images become ubiquitous and more accessible in digital culture, their role in the creation and dissemination of knowledge across academic disciplines is growing. Academic institutions need to adapt to this change by introducing new skill sets into the undergraduate curriculum. The term visual literacy encompasses the competencies necessary to critically use, produce, and analyze images. This article surveys the current methods academic librarians are using to introduce visual literacy instruction within their institutions. Each surveyed model focuses on a specific stakeholder group: students, faculty, and librarians. The article advocates for a method of instruction that combines the discussed approaches and stakeholders into a single framework by utilizing embedded librarianship practices.

Cognitive Visual Literacy

AbstractVisual literacy is an important part of being literate in the twenty-first century because people are interacting with visual materials with increasing frequency and immediacy as a result of the digital age. By understanding cognitive theories associated with visual literacy and combining them with the ACRL Visual Literacy Competency Standards for Higher Education, librarians can help students become visually literate. In addition to describing these cognitive theories and ACRL standards, the author provides practical suggestions as to how they may be utilized in visual literacy instruction.

Blurring borders, visualizing connections

PurposeThis paper seeks to offer a rationale and practical suggestions for the integration of visual literacy instruction and information literacy instruction practice and theory.Design/methodology/approachThe paper aligns visual literacy and information literacy competency standards, revealing connections and opportunities for practical integration during library instruction and traditional classroom instruction.FindingsOn analysis of 11 visual literacy competencies, three exhibit a strong relationship with the ACRL's Information Literacy Competency Standards.Practical implicationsThe paper provides guidelines for teaching and learning scenarios that may be used in a library instruction session or as part of a course curriculum.Originality/valueThe paper advocates the alignment of visual literacy and information literacy competencies as a method for connecting multiple literacies in information literacy instruction.

Teaching students with autism to read pictures

This study examined the use of teaching three students with autism how to comprehend pictures. Students were elementary-aged, did not speak, and needed communication training. Students were provided systematic visual literacy instruction. Visual literacy instruction consisted of comprehending familiar people, objects, actions, and sequences through motor demonstration. Students successfully acquired how to read pictures and generalize its understanding. Visual literacy skills were maintained at a 100% level for up to nine weeks.