The trial of Dr Sidney Gee's ?bel action against the BBC over allegations about his slimming treatment broadcast on That s Life adjourned for the Christmas break on 20 December, Dr Gee's 28th day in the witness box. In a lengthy cross examination about Dr Gee's use of thyroid extract in treating obesity Andrew Rankin QC, leading counsel for the BBC, suggested that to give a eu thyroid patient just one of Dr Gee's thyroid tablets a day would result in virtual suppression of the thyroid gland over a period of time. This would cause no harm because the gland would remain suppressed and the patient would receive sufficient thyroid hormone from the tablet. But given two tablets, patients would become hyperthyroid within months. In reply Dr Gee referred to a 1968 article that showed that thyroxine was poorly absorbed. Thyroid extract, he said, had an even worse absorption rate?only 30-40%. Mr Rankin countered that the replacement dose of 300 \x% for patients without any thyroid function mentioned in the article was now outdated; 150 jig was now considered to be the correct dose. Dr Gee replied that at the absorption rate specified in the article 150 \ig would mean only about 60 ug available to the body. He did not accept Mr Rankin's suggestion that the replacement dose already took into account the rate of absorption. Counsel quoted from an article on the administration of thyroid hormone to obese patients: Four out of 21 subjects had to discontinue thyroid because of ill effects. The subjects developed angina on effort in the absence of a prior history of coronary disease. Though he accepted that the dosage of thyroid hormone was 480 mg a day (230 mg a day more than Dr Gee's dose), the article showed that giving thyroid hormone in a particular dose could produce angina. He quoted further: Cardiac arrhythmias have been reported during weight loss. Under such circumstances a subject may well be more vulnerable to the sympathomimetic effect of thyroid and develop a variety of cardiac abnormalities. Dr Gee replied that the adverse circumstances in these cases were due to a combination of large doses and potassium depletion. The patients were receiving not thyroid extract but a synthetic mixture, and the daily doses were 360-840 mg. The paper, he pointed out, went on: With four exceptions, these subjects seemed to tolerate the large amounts of thyroid given without developing the usual manifestations of toxicity. This experience parallels the observations of others who described only minor ill effects in obese subjects or in mildly overweight, healthy volunteers to whom thyroid in equivalent as well as larger doses was given.