To describe the evolution of external beam radiation therapy (EBRT) from EMBRACE-I (general guidelines for EBRT) to the initial phase of the EMBRACE-II study (detailed protocol for EBRT). EMBRACE-I enrolled 1416 locally advanced cervical cancer patients treated with chemoradiation including image-guided adaptive brachytherapy during 2008 to 2015. From March 2016 until March 2018, 153 patients were enrolled in the ongoing EMBRACE-II study, which involves a comprehensive detailed strategy and accreditation procedure for EBRT target contouring, treatment planning, and image guidance. EBRT planning target volumes (PTVs), treated volumes (V43Gy), and conformity index (CI; V43Gy/PTV) were evaluated in both studies and compared. For EMBRACE-I, conformal radiation therapy (60% of patients) or intensity-modulated radiation therapy (IMRT) and volumetric arc therapy (VMAT; 40%) was applied with 45 to 50Gy over 25 to 30 fractions to the elective clinical target volume (CTV). For pelvic CTVs (82%), median PTV and V43 Gy volumes were 1549 and 2390mL, respectively, and CI was 1.54. For pelvic plus paraortic nodal (PAN) CTVs (15%), median PTV and V43Gy volumes were 1921 and 2895mL, and CI was 1.51. For pelvic CTVs treated with 45 to 46Gy, the use of conformal radiation therapy was associated with a median V43Gy volume that was 546mL larger than with IMRT/VMAT. For pelvic CTVs treated with IMRT, the use of a dose prescription ≥48Gy was associated with a median V43 Gy volumes that was 428mL larger than with a dose prescription of 45 to 46Gy. For EMBRACE-II, all patients were treated with: IMRT/VMAT, daily IGRT, 45Gy over 25 fractions for the elective CTV, and simultaneously integrated boost for pathologic lymph nodes. For pelvic CTVs (61%), median PTV and V43Gy volumes were 1388 and 1418mL, and CI was 1.02. For pelvic plus PAN CTVs (32%), median PTV and V43Gy volumes were 1720 and 1765mL, and CI was 1.03. From EMBRACE-I to initial II, median V43Gy was decreased by 972mL (41%) and 1130mL (39%), and median CI decreased from 1.54 to 1.02 and 1.51 to 1.03 for pelvic and pelvic plus PAN irradiation, respectively. Application of IMRT/VMAT, IGRT, and a 45-Gy dose provides the potential of higher conformality inducing significant reduction of treated volume. Adherence to a detailed protocol including comprehensive accreditation, as in EMBRACE-II, reduces considerably V43Gy and V50Gy and improves conformality and interinstitutional consistency.
Read full abstract