Unstructured Clinical Narratives Research Articles

A Case Demonstration of the Open Health Natural Language Processing Toolkit From the National COVID-19 Cohort Collaborative and the Researching COVID to Enhance Recovery Programs for a Natural Language Processing System for COVID-19 or Postacute Sequelae of SARS CoV-2 Infection: Algorithm Development and Validation.

A wealth of clinically relevant information is only obtainable within unstructured clinical narratives, leading to great interest in clinical natural language processing (NLP). While a multitude of approaches to NLP exist, current algorithm development approaches have limitations that can slow the development process. These limitations are exacerbated when the task is emergent, as is the case currently for NLP extraction of signs and symptoms of COVID-19 and postacute sequelae of SARS-CoV-2 infection (PASC). This study aims to highlight the current limitations of existing NLP algorithm development approaches that are exacerbated by NLP tasks surrounding emergent clinical concepts and to illustrate our approach to addressing these issues through the use case of developing an NLP system for the signs and symptoms of COVID-19 and PASC. We used 2 preexisting studies on PASC as a baseline to determine a set of concepts that should be extracted by NLP. This concept list was then used in conjunction with the Unified Medical Language System to autonomously generate an expanded lexicon to weakly annotate a training set, which was then reviewed by a human expert to generate a fine-tuned NLP algorithm. The annotations from a fully human-annotated test set were then compared with NLP results from the fine-tuned algorithm. The NLP algorithm was then deployed to 10 additional sites that were also running our NLP infrastructure. Of these 10 sites, 5 were used to conduct a federated evaluation of the NLP algorithm. An NLP algorithm consisting of 12,234 unique normalized text strings corresponding to 2366 unique concepts was developed to extract COVID-19 or PASC signs and symptoms. An unweighted mean dictionary coverage of 77.8% was found for the 5 sites. The evolutionary and time-critical nature of the PASC NLP task significantly complicates existing approaches to NLP algorithm development. In this work, we present a hybrid approach using the Open Health Natural Language Processing Toolkit aimed at addressing these needs with a dictionary-based weak labeling step that minimizes the need for additional expert annotation while still preserving the fine-tuning capabilities of expert involvement.

Text mining for disease surveillance in veterinary clinical data: part one, the language of veterinary clinical records and searching for words.

The development of natural language processing techniques for deriving useful information from unstructured clinical narratives is a fast-paced and rapidly evolving area of machine learning research. Large volumes of veterinary clinical narratives now exist curated by projects such as the Small Animal Veterinary Surveillance Network (SAVSNET) and VetCompass, and the application of such techniques to these datasets is already (and will continue to) improve our understanding of disease and disease patterns within veterinary medicine. In part one of this two part article series, we discuss the importance of understanding the lexical structure of clinical records and discuss the use of basic tools for filtering records based on key words and more complex rule based pattern matching approaches. We discuss the strengths and weaknesses of these approaches highlighting the on-going potential value in using these "traditional" approaches but ultimately recognizing that these approaches constrain how effectively information retrieval can be automated. This sets the scene for the introduction of machine-learning methodologies and the plethora of opportunities for automation of information extraction these present which is discussed in part two of the series.

An open source corpus and automatic tool for section identification in Spanish health records

Background:Electronic Clinical Narratives (ECNs) store valuable individual’s health information. However, there are few available open-source data. Besides, ECNs can be structurally heterogeneous, ranging from documents with explicit section headings or titles to unstructured notes. This lack of structure complicates building automatic systems and their evaluation. Objective:The aim of the present work is to provide the scientific community with a Spanish open-source dataset to build and evaluate automatic section identification systems. Together with this dataset, the purpose is to design and implement a suitable evaluation measure and a fine-tuned language model adapted to the task. Materials and Methods:A corpus of unstructured clinical records, in this case progress notes written in Spanish, was annotated with seven major section types. Existing metrics for the presented task were thoroughly assessed and, based on the most suitable one, we defined a new B2 metric better tailored given the task. Results:The annotated corpus, as well as the designed new evaluation script and a baseline model are freely available for the community. This model reaches an average B2 score of 71.3 on our open source dataset and an average B2 of 67.0 in data scarcity scenarios where the target corpus and its structure differs from the dataset used for training the LM. Conclusion:Although section identification in unstructured clinical narratives is challenging, this work shows that it is possible to build competitive automatic systems when both data and the right evaluation metrics are available. The annotated data, the implemented evaluation scripts, and the section identification Language Model are open-sourced hoping that this contribution will foster the building of more and better systems.

Binary acronym disambiguation in clinical notes from electronic health records with an application in computational phenotyping

ObjectiveThe use of electronic health records (EHR) systems has grown over the past decade, and with it, the need to extract information from unstructured clinical narratives. Clinical notes, however, frequently contain acronyms with several potential senses (meanings) and traditional natural language processing (NLP) techniques cannot differentiate between these senses. In this study we introduce a semi-supervised method for binary acronym disambiguation, the task of classifying a target sense for acronyms in the clinical EHR notes. MethodsWe developed a semi-supervised ensemble machine learning (CASEml) algorithm to automatically identify when an acronym means a target sense by leveraging semantic embeddings, visit-level text and billing information. The algorithm was validated using note data from the Veterans Affairs hospital system to classify the meaning of three acronyms: RA, MS, and MI. We compared the performance of CASEml against another standard semi-supervised method and a baseline metric selecting the most frequent acronym sense.Along with evaluating the performance of these methods for specific instances of acronyms, we evaluated the impact of acronym disambiguation on NLP-driven phenotyping of rheumatoid arthritis. ResultsCASEml achieved accuracies of 0.947, 0.911, and 0.706 for RA, MS, and MI, respectively, higher than a standard baseline metric and (on average) higher than a state-of-the-art semi-supervised method. As well, we demonstrated that applying CASEml to medical notes improves the AUC of a phenotype algorithm for rheumatoid arthritis. ConclusionCASEml is a novel method that accurately disambiguates acronyms in clinical notes and has advantages over commonly used supervised and semi-supervised machine learning approaches. In addition, CASEml improves the performance of NLP tasks that rely on ambiguous acronyms, such as phenotyping.

Clinical Concept Extraction with Lexical Semantics to Support Automatic Annotation.

Extracting clinical concepts, such as problems, diagnosis, and treatment, from unstructured clinical narrative documents enables data-driven approaches such as machine and deep learning to support advanced applications such as clinical decision-support systems, the assessment of disease progression, and the intelligent analysis of treatment efficacy. Various tools such as cTAKES, Sophia, MetaMap, and other rules-based approaches and algorithms have been used for automatic concept extraction. Recently, machine- and deep-learning approaches have been used to extract, classify, and accurately annotate terms and phrases. However, the requirement of an annotated dataset, which is labor-intensive, impedes the success of data-driven approaches. A rule-based mechanism could support the process of annotation, but existing rule-based approaches fail to adequately capture contextual, syntactic, and semantic patterns. This study intends to introduce a comprehensive rule-based system that automatically extracts clinical concepts from unstructured narratives with higher accuracy and transparency. The proposed system is a pipelined approach, capable of recognizing clinical concepts of three types, problem, treatment, and test, in the dataset collected from a published repository as a part of the I2b2 challenge 2010. The system’s performance is compared with that of three existing systems: Quick UMLS, BIO-CRF, and the Rules (i2b2) model. Compared to the baseline systems, the average F1-score of 72.94% was found to be 13% better than Quick UMLS, 3% better than BIO CRF, and 30.1% better than the Rules (i2b2) model. Individually, the system performance was noticeably higher for problem-related concepts, with an F1-score of 80.45%, followed by treatment-related concepts and test-related concepts, with F1-scores of 76.06% and 55.3%, respectively. The proposed methodology significantly improves the performance of concept extraction from unstructured clinical narratives by exploiting the linguistic and lexical semantic features. The approach can ease the automatic annotation process of clinical data, which ultimately improves the performance of supervised data-driven applications trained with these data.

Automated detection of substance use information from electronic health records for a pediatric population.

ObjectiveSubstance use screening in adolescence is unstandardized and often documented in clinical notes, rather than in structured electronic health records (EHRs). The objective of this study was to integrate logic rules with state-of-the-art natural language processing (NLP) and machine learning technologies to detect substance use information from both structured and unstructured EHR data.Materials and MethodsPediatric patients (10-20 years of age) with any encounter between July 1, 2012, and October 31, 2017, were included (n = 3890 patients; 19 478 encounters). EHR data were extracted at each encounter, manually reviewed for substance use (alcohol, tobacco, marijuana, opiate, any use), and coded as lifetime use, current use, or family use. Logic rules mapped structured EHR indicators to screening results. A knowledge-based NLP system and a deep learning model detected substance use information from unstructured clinical narratives. System performance was evaluated using positive predictive value, sensitivity, negative predictive value, specificity, and area under the receiver-operating characteristic curve (AUC).ResultsThe dataset included 17 235 structured indicators and 27 141 clinical narratives. Manual review of clinical narratives captured 94.0% of positive screening results, while structured EHR data captured 22.0%. Logic rules detected screening results from structured data with 1.0 and 0.99 for sensitivity and specificity, respectively. The knowledge-based system detected substance use information from clinical narratives with 0.86, 0.79, and 0.88 for AUC, sensitivity, and specificity, respectively. The deep learning model further improved detection capacity, achieving 0.88, 0.81, and 0.85 for AUC, sensitivity, and specificity, respectively. Finally, integrating predictions from structured and unstructured data achieved high detection capacity across all cases (0.96, 0.85, and 0.87 for AUC, sensitivity, and specificity, respectively).ConclusionsIt is feasible to detect substance use screening and results among pediatric patients using logic rules, NLP, and machine learning technologies.

Abstract PO-050: Identifying de novo stage IV breast cancer (DNIV) cases in Electronic Health Records (EHR) using natural language processing

Abstract Background: DNIV accounts for 6%–10% of newly diagnosed breast cancer cases. Despite widespread mammography screening, its incidence is increasing in the United States and survival of this disease has only modestly improved since the late 1970s. As patient data accumulates in EHR, it’s promising to generate practice-based evidence through utilization of observational data sources. However, assembly of a DNIV cohort based on EHR data is challenging, as key pathologic and staging information are stored in unstructured clinical narratives and not available as structured data. In this study, we developed a rule-based algorithm to phenotype DNIV using natural language processing (NLP) techniques, and implemented the algorithm on our institutional EHR to extract potential DNIV cases. Methods and Results: We defined DNIV as those with either (1) M1 disease identified at time of initial presentation or M1 disease identified within 4 months after definitive surgery. We first developed a reference case list of DNIV verified by physician chart review of the EHR. We next refined the algorithm on a training dataset containing 51 positive and 38 negative reference cases. Next we tested the performance on the testing data containing 23 positive and 55 negative cases. The phenotyping algorithm identified key data elements using NLP, i.e., stage IV breast cancer, definitive surgery, stage 0-III, recurrent breast cancer and associated dates. To identify DNIV cases, phenotyping algorithm integrated temporal relations among the key data elements. The following steps were conducted in the following sequential order: (1) Identification of patients with breast cancer diagnosis using ICD-9 and ICD-10 codes. (2) Patients are positive cases if there are explicit mentions that delineate DNIV from recurrent metastatic breast cancer, such as “de novo stage IV” or “primary intact” detected by NLP at time of diagnosis. (3) Otherwise, patients with definitive surgery are selected if stage IV was within 5 years before definitive surgery or within 4 months after definitive surgery, along with patients with stage IV but without definitive surgery. (4) We further excluded patients with stage 0-III detected within 5 years after stage IV. (5) We further excluded patients with recurrent breast cancer detected before or at time of detection of stage IV. The remaining patients were left as positive cases. Precision of the algorithm was 70%, recall was 87% and F1, the weighted average of precision and recall, was 77%. We implemented our algorithm to interrogate 10 million clinical documents in a cohort of 56,548 patients with breast cancer diagnosis codes who presented to our institution between 2004 and 2018 and had research authorization. We identified 1918 potential DNIV cases. Conclusion: Our future focus is on algorithm refinement. An algorithm-generated cohort could serve as a data source for further study on outcomes related to DNIV and ideally as automated data abstractor and staging process. Citation Format: Liwei Wang, Karthik Giridhar, Kimberly Corbin, Brenda Ernst, Sadia Choudhery, Emmanuel Gabriel, Feichen Shen, Hongfang Liu, James Jakub. Identifying de novo stage IV breast cancer (DNIV) cases in Electronic Health Records (EHR) using natural language processing [abstract]. In: Proceedings of the AACR Virtual Special Conference on Artificial Intelligence, Diagnosis, and Imaging; 2021 Jan 13-14. Philadelphia (PA): AACR; Clin Cancer Res 2021;27(5_Suppl):Abstract nr PO-050.

FasTag: Automatic text classification of unstructured medical narratives.

Unstructured clinical narratives are continuously being recorded as part of delivery of care in electronic health records, and dedicated tagging staff spend considerable effort manually assigning clinical codes for billing purposes. Despite these efforts, however, label availability and accuracy are both suboptimal. In this retrospective study, we aimed to automate the assignment of top-level International Classification of Diseases version 9 (ICD-9) codes to clinical records from human and veterinary data stores using minimal manual labor and feature curation. Automating top-level annotations could in turn enable rapid cohort identification, especially in a veterinary setting. To this end, we trained long short-term memory (LSTM) recurrent neural networks (RNNs) on 52,722 human and 89,591 veterinary records. We investigated the accuracy of both separate-domain and combined-domain models and probed model portability. We established relevant baseline classification performances by training Decision Trees (DT) and Random Forests (RF). We also investigated whether transforming the data using MetaMap Lite, a clinical natural language processing tool, affected classification performance. We showed that the LSTM-RNNs accurately classify veterinary and human text narratives into top-level categories with an average weighted macro F1 score of 0.74 and 0.68 respectively. In the “neoplasia” category, the model trained on veterinary data had a high validation accuracy in veterinary data and moderate accuracy in human data, with F1 scores of 0.91 and 0.70 respectively. Our LSTM method scored slightly higher than that of the DT and RF models. The use of LSTM-RNN models represents a scalable structure that could prove useful in cohort identification for comparative oncology studies. Digitization of human and veterinary health information will continue to be a reality, particularly in the form of unstructured narratives. Our approach is a step forward for these two domains to learn from and inform one another.

EMR-Based Phenotyping of Ischemic Stroke Using Supervised Machine Learning and Text Mining Techniques.

Ischemic stroke is a major cause of death and disability in adulthood worldwide. Because it has highly heterogeneous phenotypes, phenotyping of ischemic stroke is an essential task for medical research and clinical prognostication. However, this task is not a trivial one when the study population is large. Phenotyping of ischemic stroke depends primarily on manual annotation of medical records in previous studies. This article evaluated various strategies for automated phenotyping of ischemic stroke into the four subtypes of the Oxfordshire Community Stroke Project classification based on structured and unstructured data from electronical medical records (EMRs). A total of 4640 adult patients who were hospitalized for acute ischemic stroke in a teaching hospital were included. In addition to the structured items in the National Institutes of Health Stroke Scale, unstructured clinical narratives were preprocessed using MetaMap to identify medical concepts, which were then encoded into feature vectors. Various supervised machine learning algorithms were used to build classifiers. The study results indicate that textual information from EMRs could facilitate phenotyping of ischemic stroke when this information was combined with structured information. Furthermore, decomposition of this multi-class problem into binary classification tasks followed by aggregation of classification results could improve the performance.

Constituency Parser for Clinical Narratives using NLP

Clinical parsing is useful in medical domain .Clinical narratives are difficult to understand as it is in unstructured format .Medical Natural language processing systems are used to make these clinical narratives in readable format. Clinical Parser is the combination of natural language processing and medical lexicon .For making clinical narrative understandable parsing technique is used .In this paper we are discussing about constituency parser for clinical narratives, which is based on phrase structured grammar. This parser convert unstructured clinical narratives into structured report. This paper focus on clinical sentences which is in unstructured format after parsing convert into structured format. For each sentence recall ,precision and bracketing f- measure are calculated .

Identifying Breast Cancer Distant Recurrences from Electronic Health Records Using Machine Learning.

Accurately identifying distant recurrences in breast cancer from the Electronic Health Records (EHR) is important for both clinical care and secondary analysis. Although multiple applications have been developed for computational phenotyping in breast cancer, distant recurrence identification still relies heavily on manual chart review. In this study, we aim to develop a model that identifies distant recurrences in breast cancer using clinical narratives and structured data from EHR. We applied MetaMap to extract features from clinical narratives and also retrieved structured clinical data from EHR. Using these features, we trained a support vector machine model to identify distant recurrences in breast cancer patients. We trained the model using 1,396 double-annotated subjects and validated the model using 599 double-annotated subjects. In addition, we validated the model on a set of 4,904 single-annotated subjects as a generalization test. In the held-out test and generalization test, we obtained F-measure scores of 0.78 and 0.74, area under curve (AUC) scores of 0.95 and 0.93, respectively. To explore the representation learning utility of deep neural networks, we designed multiple convolutional neural networks and multilayer neural networks to identify distant recurrences. Using the same test set and generalizability test set, we obtained F-measure scores of 0.79 ± 0.02 and 0.74 ± 0.004, AUC scores of 0.95 ± 0.002 and 0.95 ± 0.01, respectively. Our model can accurately and efficiently identify distant recurrences in breast cancer by combining features extracted from unstructured clinical narratives and structured clinical data.

TEPAPA: a novel in silico feature learning pipeline for mining prognostic and associative factors from text-based electronic medical records

Vast amounts of clinically relevant text-based variables lie undiscovered and unexploited in electronic medical records (EMR). To exploit this untapped resource, and thus facilitate the discovery of informative covariates from unstructured clinical narratives, we have built a novel computational pipeline termed Text-based Exploratory Pattern Analyser for Prognosticator and Associator discovery (TEPAPA). This pipeline combines semantic-free natural language processing (NLP), regular expression induction, and statistical association testing to identify conserved text patterns associated with outcome variables of clinical interest. When we applied TEPAPA to a cohort of head and neck squamous cell carcinoma patients, plausible concepts known to be correlated with human papilloma virus (HPV) status were identified from the EMR text, including site of primary disease, tumour stage, pathologic characteristics, and treatment modalities. Similarly, correlates of other variables (including gender, nodal status, recurrent disease, smoking and alcohol status) were also reliably recovered. Using highly-associated patterns as covariates, a patient’s HPV status was classifiable using a bootstrap analysis with a mean area under the ROC curve of 0.861, suggesting its predictive utility in supporting EMR-based phenotyping tasks. These data support using this integrative approach to efficiently identify disease-associated factors from unstructured EMR narratives, and thus to efficiently generate testable hypotheses.

Coronary artery disease risk assessment from unstructured electronic health records using text mining

Coronary artery disease (CAD) often leads to myocardial infarction, which may be fatal. Risk factors can be used to predict CAD, which may subsequently lead to prevention or early intervention. Patient data such as co-morbidities, medication history, social history and family history are required to determine the risk factors for a disease. However, risk factor data are usually embedded in unstructured clinical narratives if the data is not collected specifically for risk assessment purposes. Clinical text mining can be used to extract data related to risk factors from unstructured clinical notes. This study presents methods to extract Framingham risk factors from unstructured electronic health records using clinical text mining and to calculate 10-year coronary artery disease risk scores in a cohort of diabetic patients. We developed a rule-based system to extract risk factors: age, gender, total cholesterol, HDL-C, blood pressure, diabetes history and smoking history. The results showed that the output from the text mining system was reliable, but there was a significant amount of missing data to calculate the Framingham risk score. A systematic approach for understanding missing data was followed by implementation of imputation strategies. An analysis of the 10-year Framingham risk scores for coronary artery disease in this cohort has shown that the majority of the diabetic patients are at moderate risk of CAD.

Extracting important information from Chinese Operation Notes with natural language processing methods

Extracting information from unstructured clinical narratives is valuable for many clinical applications. Although natural Language Processing (NLP) methods have been profoundly studied in electronic medical records (EMR), few studies have explored NLP in extracting information from Chinese clinical narratives. In this study, we report the development and evaluation of extracting tumor-related information from operation notes of hepatic carcinomas which were written in Chinese. Using 86 operation notes manually annotated by physicians as the training set, we explored both rule-based and supervised machine-learning approaches. Evaluating on unseen 29 operation notes, our best approach yielded 69.6% in precision, 58.3% in recall and 63.5% F-score.