Type-1 Copper Site Research Articles

Spectroscopically Validated pH-dependent MSOX Movies Provide Detailed Mechanism of Copper Nitrite Reductases

Copper nitrite reductases (CuNiRs) exhibit a strong pH dependence of their catalytic activity. Structural movies can be obtained by serially recording multiple structures (frames) from the same spot of a crystal using the MSOX serial crystallography approach. This method has been combined with on-line single crystal optical spectroscopy to capture the pH-dependent structural changes that accompany during turnover of CuNiRs from two Rhizobia species. The structural movies, initiated by the redox activation of a type-1 copper site (T1Cu) via X-ray generated photoelectrons, have been obtained for the substrate-free and substrate-bound states at low (high enzymatic activity) and high (low enzymatic activity) pH. At low pH, formation of the product nitric oxide (NO) is complete at the catalytic type-2 copper site (T2Cu) after a dose of 3 MGy (frame 5) with full bleaching of the T1Cu ligand-to-metal charge transfer (LMCT) 455 nm band (S(σ)Cys → T1Cu2+) which in itself indicates the electronic route of proton-coupled electron transfer (PCET) from T1Cu to T2Cu. In contrast at high pH, the changes in optical spectra are relatively small and the formation of NO is only observed in later frames (frame 15 in Br2DNiR, 10 MGy), consistent with the loss of PCET required for catalysis. This is accompanied by decarboxylation of the catalytic AspCAT residue, with CO2 trapped in the catalytic pocket.

Electrochemical characterization of an engineered red copper protein featuring an unprecedented entropic control of the reduction potential

Copper is a ubiquitous metal in biology that, among other functions, is implicated in enzymatic redox catalysis and in protein electron transfer (ET). When it comes to ET, copper sites are found in two main forms, mononuclear type 1 (T1) and binuclear CuA sites, which share a common cupredoxin fold. Other relevant copper sites are the so-called type 2 (T2), which are more resilient to undergo direct electrochemistry and are usually involved in catalysis. Here we report the electrochemical and spectroscopic characterization of a novel T2-like copper site engineered following the loop swapping strategy. The ligand loop sequence of the newly discovered T1 copper site from Nitrosopumilus maritimus was introduced into the CuA scaffold from Thermus thermophilus yielding a chimeric protein that shows spectroscopic features different from both parental proteins, and resemble those of red T2 copper sites, albeit with a shorter Cu-S(Cys) bond length. The novel T2 site undergoes efficient direct electrochemistry, which allows performing temperature-dependent cyclic voltammetry studies. The obtained results reveal that this chimera constitutes the first example of a copper protein with entropically controlled reduction potential, thereby contrasting the enthalpic supremacy observed for all other copper sites reported so far. The underlying bases for this entropic control are critically discussed.

Site-directed mutagenesis of the highly perturbed copper site of auracyanin D

Type-1 copper proteins participate in redox reactions and biological catalysis. Significant variation exists within the electronic structure of type-1 copper sites, producing both blue and green proteins. Classical, “blue” sites have been extensively studied, but “green” sites have been poorly characterized. We recently discovered a green copper protein, called auracyanin D. Here, we report a series of axial ligand mutations in auracyanin D, and characterize the resulting spectral and redox changes. The resulting mutants appear blue, green, and red and vary in redox potential from +56mV to +786mV. This is the largest change in redox potential to date for any type-1 center. We found that in this green protein, modifications of the axial ligand produce significantly larger changes than similar mutations in blue type-1 copper sites.

Pseudoazurin from Sinorhizobium meliloti as an electron donor to copper-containing nitrite reductase: influence of the redox partner on the reduction potentials of the enzyme copper centers

Pseudoazurin (Paz) is the physiological electron donor to copper-containing nitrite reductase (Nir), which catalyzes the reduction of NO2 (-) to NO. The Nir reaction mechanism involves the reduction of the type1 (T1) copper electron transfer center by the external physiological electron donor, intramolecular electron transfer from the T1 copper center to the T2 copper center, and nitrite reduction at the type2 (T2) copper catalytic center. We report the cloning, expression, and characterization of Paz from Sinorhizobium meliloti 2011 (SmPaz), the ability of SmPaz to act as an electron donor partner of S.meliloti 2011 Nir (SmNir), and the redox properties of the metal centers involved in the electron transfer chain. Gel filtration chromatography and sodium dodecyl sulfate-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis together with UV-vis and EPR spectroscopies revealed that as-purified SmPaz is a mononuclear copper-containing protein that has a T1 copper site in a highly distorted tetrahedral geometry. The SmPaz/SmNir interaction investigated electrochemically showed that SmPaz serves as an efficient electron donor to SmNir. The formal reduction potentials of the T1 copper center in SmPaz and the T1 and T2 copper centers in SmNir, evaluated by cyclic voltammetry and by UV-vis- and EPR-mediated potentiometric titrations, are against an efficient Paz T1 center to Nir T1 center to Nir T2 center electron transfer. EPR experiments proved that as a result of the SmPaz/SmNir interaction in the presence of nitrite, the order of the reduction potentials of SmNir reversed, in line with T1center to T2 center electron transfer being thermodynamically more favorable.

Multicopper oxidases: intramolecular electron transfer and O2 reduction

The multicopper oxidases are an intriguing, widespread family of enzymes that catalyze the reduction of O2 to water by a variety of single-electron and multiple-electron reducing agents. The structure and properties of the copper binding sites responsible for the latter chemical transformations have been studied for over 40years and a detailed picture is emerging. This review focuses particularly on the kinetics of internal electron transfer between the type1 (blue) copper site and the trinuclear center, as well as on the nature of the intermediates formed in the oxygen reduction process.

Structural and functional characterization of the Geobacillus copper nitrite reductase: Involvement of the unique N-terminal region in the interprotein electron transfer with its redox partner

The crystal structures of copper-containing nitrite reductase (CuNiR) from the thermophilic Gram-positive bacterium Geobacillus kaustophilus HTA426 and the amino (N)-terminal 68 residue-deleted mutant were determined at resolutions of 1.3Å and 1.8Å, respectively. Both structures show a striking resemblance with the overall structure of the well-known CuNiRs composed of two Greek key β-barrel domains; however, a remarkable structural difference was found in the N-terminal region. The unique region has one β-strand and one α-helix extended to the northern surface of the type-1 copper site. The superposition of the Geobacillus CuNiR model on the electron-transfer complex structure of CuNiR with the redox partner cytochrome c551 in other denitrifier system led us to infer that this region contributes to the transient binding with the partner protein during the interprotein electron transfer reaction in the Geobacillus system. Furthermore, electron-transfer kinetics experiments using N-terminal residue-deleted mutant and the redox partner, Geobacillus cytochrome c551, were carried out. These structural and kinetics studies demonstrate that the region is directly involved in the specific partner recognition.

In silico study of structural determinants modulating the redox potential of Rigidoporus lignosus and other fungal laccases

Laccases are multicopper oxidases in which substrate oxidation takes place at the type-1 (T1) copper site. The redox potential (E 0) significantly varies amongst members of the family and is a key parameter for substrate specificity. Despite sharing highly conserved features at the T1 copper site, laccases span a large range of E 0, suggesting that the influence of the metal secondary coordination sphere is important. In silico analysis of structural determinants modulating the E 0 of Rigidoporus lignosus and other fungal laccases indicated that different factors can be considered. First, the length of the T1 copper coordinating histidine bond is observed to be longer in high E 0 laccases than in low E 0 ones. The hydrophobic environment around the T1 copper site appeared as another important structural determinant in modulating the E 0, with a stronger hydrophobic environment correlating with higher E 0. The analysis of hydrogen bonding network (HBN) around the T1-binding pocket revealed that the amino acids building up the metal binding site strongly interact with neighbouring residues and contribute to the stabilization of the protein folds. Changes in these HBNs that modified the Cu1 preferred coordination geometry lead to an increase of E 0. The presence of axial ligands modulates the E 0 of T1 to different extent. Stacking interactions between aromatic residues located in the second coordination shell and the metal ion coordination histidine imidazole ring have also been identified as a factor that modulates the E 0. The electrostatic interactions between the T1 copper site and backbone carbonyl oxygen indicate that Cu1–CO=NH distance is longer in the high E 0 laccases. In short, the in silico study reported herein identifies several structural factors that may influence the E 0 of the examined laccases. Some of these are dependent on the nature of the coordination ligands at the T1 site, but others can be ascribed to the hydrophobic effects, HBNs, axial ligations, stacking and electrostatic interactions, not necessary directly interacting with the copper metal.

Spectroelectrochemical Investigation of Intramolecular and Interfacial Electron-Transfer Rates Reveals Differences Between Nitrite Reductase at Rest and During Turnover

A combined fluorescence and electrochemical method is described that is used to simultaneously monitor the type-1 copper oxidation state and the nitrite turnover rate of a nitrite reductase (NiR) from Alcaligenes faecalis S-6. The catalytic activity of NiR is measured electrochemically by exploiting a direct electron transfer to fluorescently labeled enzyme molecules immobilized on modified gold electrodes, whereas the redox state of the type-1 copper site is determined from fluorescence intensity changes caused by Förster resonance energy transfer (FRET) between a fluorophore attached to NiR and its type-1 copper site. The homotrimeric structure of the enzyme is reflected in heterogeneous interfacial electron-transfer kinetics with two monomers having a 25-fold slower kinetics than the third monomer. The intramolecular electron-transfer rate between the type-1 and type-2 copper site changes at high nitrite concentration (≥520 μM), resulting in an inhibition effect at low pH and a catalytic gain in enzyme activity at high pH. We propose that the intramolecular rate is significantly reduced in turnover conditions compared to the enzyme at rest, with an exception at low pH/nitrite conditions. This effect is attributed to slower reduction rate of type-2 copper center due to a rate-limiting protonation step of residues in the enzyme's active site, gating the intramolecular electron transfer.

Models of noncoupled dinuclear copper centers in azurin

The successful modeling of metalloproteins is an important step in understanding their structure and function. Toward this goal, models of the noncoupled copper centers found in the enzymes peptidyl alpha-hydroxylating monooxygenase (PHM), dopamine beta-monooxygenase (DBM), and nitrite reductase (NiR) were designed into the small soluble protein azurin. The models are significant because they maintain the existing type 1 (T1) copper, electron transfer site of azurin while including the second designed type 2 (T2) copper center that mimics the T2 catalytic sites in the target enzymes. UV-vis absorption and EPR spectroscopy data of the model sites are consistent with T2 centers and establish copper binding at the sites, thus modeling those found in PHM/DBM and NiR. Importantly the models' approximate 11-13 A separation between the T1 and T2 copper sites is comparable with the separations in the native systems. This, along with the power to tune the T1 site redox potential in azurin, allows for the future evaluation of relevant activity assays in these models.

Conformation of Pseudoazurin in the 152 kDa Electron Transfer Complex with Nitrite Reductase Determined by Paramagnetic NMR

Copper-containing nitrite reductase is able to catalyze the reduction of nitrite with a turnover rate of several hundreds per second. Electrons for the reaction are donated by the electron transfer protein pseudoazurin. The process of protein complex formation, electron transfer and dissociation must occur on the millisecond timescale to enable the fast turnover of the enzyme. The structure of this transient protein complex has been studied using paramagnetic NMR spectroscopy. Gadolinium complexes were attached specifically through two engineered Cys residues on three sites on the surface of nitrite reductase, causing strong distance-dependent relaxation effects on the residues of pseudoazurin. Docking of the two proteins based on these NMR-derived distance restraints and the chemical shift perturbation data shows convergence to a cluster of structures with an average root-mean-square deviation of 1.5 Å. The binding interface consists of polar and non-polar residues surrounded by charges. The interprotein distance between the two type-1 copper sites is 15.5(± 0.5) Å, enabling fast interprotein electron transfer. The NMR-based lower limit estimate of 600 s −1 for the dissociation rate constant and the fast electron transfer are consistent with the transient nature of the complex.

Effect of the Methionine Ligand on the Reorganization Energy of the Type-1 Copper Site of Nitrite Reductase

Copper-containing nitrite reductase harbors a type-1 and a type-2 Cu site. The former acts as the electron acceptor site of the enzyme, and the latter is the site of catalytic action. The effect of the methionine ligand on the reorganization energy of the type-1 site was explored by studying the electron-transfer kinetics between NiR (wild type (wt) and the variants Met150Gly and Met150Thr) with Fe(II)EDTA and Fe(II)HEDTA. The mutations increased the reorganization energy by 0.3 eV (30 kJ mol-1). A similar increase was found from pulse radiolysis experiments on the wt NIR and three variants (Met150Gly, Met150His, and Met150Thr). Binding of the nearby Met62 to the type-1 Cu site in Met150Gly (under influence of an allosteric effector) lowered the reorganization energy back to approximately the wt value. According to XRD data the structure of the reduced type-1 site in Met150Gly NiR in the presence of an allosteric effector is similar to that in the reduced wt NiR (solved to 1.85 A), compatible with the similarity in reorganization energy.

Spectroscopic Characterization of a High-Potential Lipo-Cupredoxin Found in Streptomyces coelicolor

For many streptomycetes, a distinct dependence on the "bioavailability" of copper ions for their morphological development has been reported. Analysis of the Streptomyces coelicolor genome reveals a number of gene products encoding for putative copper-binding proteins. One of these appears as an unusual copper-binding protein with a lipoprotein signal sequence and a cupredoxin-like domain harboring a putative Type-1 copper-binding motif. Cloning of this gene from S. coelicolor and subsequent heterologous expression in Escherichia coli has allowed for a thorough spectroscopic interrogation of this putative copper-binding protein. Optical and electron paramagnetic resonance spectroscopies have confirmed the presence of a "classic" Type-1 copper site with the axial ligand to the copper a methionine. Paramagnetic NMR spectroscopy on both the native Cu(II) form and Co(II)-substituted protein has yielded active-site structural information, which on comparison with that of other cupredoxin active sites reveals metal-ligand interactions most similar to the "classic" Type-1 copper site found in the amicyanin family of cupredoxins. Despite this high structural similarity, the Cu(II)/(I) midpoint potential of the S. coelicolor protein is an unprecedented +605 mV vs normal hydrogen electrode at neutral pH (amicyanin approximately +250 mV), with no active-site protonation of the N-terminal His ligand observed. Suggestions for the physiological role/function of this high-potential cupredoxin are discussed.

The Role of Hydrogen Bonding at the Active Site of a Cupredoxin: The Phe114Pro Azurin Variant,

The Phe114Pro mutation to the cupredoxin azurin (AZ) leads to a number of structural changes at the active site attributed to deletion of one of the hydrogen bonds to the Cys112 ligand, removal of the bulky phenyl group from the hydrophobic patch of the protein, and steric interactions made by the introduced Pro. The remaining hydrogen bond between the coordinating thiolate and the backbone amide of Asn47 is strengthened. At the type-1 copper site, the Cu(II)-O(Gly45) axial interaction decreases, while the metal moves out of the plane formed by the equatorial His46, Cys112, and His117 ligands, shortening the bond to the axially coordinating Met121. The resulting distorted tetrahedral geometry is distinct from the trigonal bipyramidal arrangement in the wild-type (WT) protein. The unique position of the main S(Cys) --> Cu(II) ligand-to-metal charge-transfer transition in AZ (628 nm) has shifted in the Phe114Pro variant to a value that is more typical for cupredoxins (599 nm). This probably occurs because of the removal of the Phe114-Cys112 hydrogen bond. The Phe114Pro mutation results in a 90 mV decrease in the reduction potential of AZ, and removal of the second hydrogen bond to the Cys ligand seems to be the major cause of this change. The C-terminal His117 ligand does not protonate in the reduced Phe114Pro AZ variant, which suggests that none of the structural features altered by the mutation are responsible for the absence of this effect in the WT protein. Upon reduction, the copper displaces further from the equatorial ligand plane and the Cu-S(Met121) bond length decreases. These changes are larger than those seen in the WT protein and contribute to the order of magnitude decrease in the intrinsic electron-transfer capabilities of the Phe114Pro variant.

A Random-sequential Mechanism for Nitrite Binding and Active Site Reduction in Copper-containing Nitrite Reductase

The homotrimeric copper-containing nitrite reductase (NiR) contains one type-1 and one type-2 copper center per monomer. Electrons enter through the type-1 site and are shuttled to the type-2 site where nitrite is reduced to nitric oxide. To investigate the catalytic mechanism of NiR the effects of pH and nitrite on the turnover rate in the presence of three different electron donors at saturating concentrations were measured. The activity of NiR was also measured electrochemically by exploiting direct electron transfer to the enzyme immobilized on a graphite rotating disk electrode. In all cases, the steady-state kinetics fitted excellently to a random-sequential mechanism in which electron transfer from the type-1 to the type-2 site is rate-limiting. At low [NO(-)(2)] reduction of the type-2 site precedes nitrite binding, at high [NO(-)(2)] the reverse occurs. Below pH 6.5, the catalytic activity diminished at higher nitrite concentrations, in agreement with electron transfer being slower to the nitrite-bound type-2 site than to the water-bound type-2 site. Above pH 6.5, substrate activation is observed, in agreement with electron transfer to the nitrite-bound type-2 site being faster than electron transfer to the hydroxyl-bound type-2 site. To study the effect of slower electron transfer between the type-1 and type-2 site, NiR M150T was used. It has a type-1 site with a 125-mV higher midpoint potential and a 0.3-eV higher reorganization energy leading to an approximately 50-fold slower intramolecular electron transfer to the type-2 site. The results confirm that NiR employs a random-sequential mechanism.

A Förster-resonance-energy transfer-based method for fluorescence detection of the protein redox state

A method for fluorescence detection of a protein’s redox state based on resonance energy transfer from an attached fluorescence label to the prosthetic group of the redox protein is described and tested for proteins containing three types of prosthetic groups: a type-1 copper site (azurin, amicyanin, plastocyanin, and pseudoazurin), a heme group (cytochrome c550), and a flavin mononucleotide (flavodoxin). This method permits one to reliably distinguish between reduced and oxidized proteins and to perform potentiometric titrations at submicromolar concentrations.

Reduction Potential Tuning at a Type 1 Copper Site Does Not Compromise Electron Transfer Reactivity

Type 1 (T1) copper sites promote biological electron transfer (ET) and typically possess a weakly coordinated thioether sulfur from an axial Met [Cu(II)-Sdelta approximately 2.6 to 3.3 A] along with the conserved His2Cys equatorial ligands. A strong axial bond [Cu(II)-Oepsilon1 approximately 2.2 A] is sometimes provided by a Gln (as in the stellacyanins), and the axial ligand can be absent (a Val, Leu or Phe in the axial position) as in ceruloplasmin, Fet3p, fungal laccases and some plantacyanins (PLTs). Cucumber basic protein (CBP) is a PLT which has a relatively short Cu(II)-S(Met89) axial bond (2.6 A). The Met89Gln variant of CBP has an electron self-exchange (ESE) rate constant (k(ese), a measure of intrinsic ET reactivity) approximately 7 times lower than that of the wild-type protein. The Met89Val mutation to CBP results in a 2-fold increase in k(ese). As the axial interaction decreases from strong Oepsilon1 of Gln to relatively weak Sdelta of Met to no ligand (Val), ESE reactivity is therefore enhanced by approximately 1 order of magnitude while the reduction potential increases by approximately 350 mV. The variable coordination position at this ubiquitous ET site provides a mechanism for tuning the driving force to optimize ET with the correct partner without significantly compromising intrinsic reactivity. The enhanced reactivity of a three-coordinate T1 copper site will facilitate intramolecular ET in fungal laccases and Fet3p.

Reduction thermodynamics of the T1 Cu site in plant and fungal laccases

The thermodynamic parameters for reduction of the type-1 (T1) copper site in Rhus vernicifera and Trametes versicolor laccases and for the derivative of the former protein from which the type-2 copper has been selectively removed (T2D) have been determined with UV-vis spectroelectrochemistry. In all cases, the enthalpic term turns out to be the main determinant of the Eo' of the T1 site. Also the difference between the reduction potentials of the two laccases is enthalpy-based and reflects differences in the coordination features of the T1 sites and their protein environment. The T1 sites in native R. vernicifera laccase and its T2D derivative show the same Eo', as a result of compensatory differences in the reduction thermodynamics. This suggests that removal of the type-2 (T2) copper results in modification of the reduction-induced solvent reorganization effects, with no influence in the structure of the multicopper protein site. This conclusion is supported by NMR data recorded on the native, the T2D, and Hg-substituted T1 derivatives of R. vernicifera laccase, which show that the T1 and T2/T3 sites are largely noninteracting.

Electrochemical redox transformations of T1 and T2 copper sites in native Trametes hirsuta laccase at gold electrode.

Mediatorless, electrochemically driven, redox transformations of T1 (type 1) and T2 copper sites in Trametes hirsuta laccase were studied by cyclic voltammetry and spectroelectrochemical redox titrations using bare gold electrode. DET (direct electron transfer) between the electrode and the enzyme was observed under anaerobic conditions. From analysis of experimental data it is concluded that the T2 copper site is in DET contact with gold. It was found that electron transfer between the gold surface and the T1 copper site progresses through the T2 copper site. From EPR measurements and electrochemical data it is proposed that the redox potential of the T2 site for high-potential 'blue' laccase is equal to about 400 mV versus NHE (normal hydrogen electrode) at pH 6.5. The hypothesis that the redox potentials of the T2 copper sites in low- and high-potential laccases/oxidases from totally different sources might be very similar, i.e. approx. 400 mV, is discussed.

Ligand and loop variations at type 1 copper sites: influence on structure and reactivity

Type 1 (T1) copper sites promote biological electron transfer and are found in the cupredoxins and a number of copper-containing enzymes including the multi-copper oxidases. A T1 copper site usually has a distorted tetrahedral geometry with strong ligands provided by the thiolate sulfur of a Cys and the imidazole nitrogens of two His residues. The active site structure is typically completed by a weak axial Met ligand (a second weak axial interaction is found in azurin resulting in a trigonal bipyramidal geometry). The axial Met is not conserved and Gln, Phe, Leu and Val are also found in this position. Three of the four ligands at a T1 copper site are situated on a single C-terminal loop whose length and structure varies. Studies are discussed which investigate both the influence of physiologically relevant axial ligand alterations, and also of mutations to the length and structure of the ligand-containing loop, on the properties of T1 copper sites.

The structural role of the copper-coordinating and surface-exposed histidine residue in the blue copper protein azurin

Copper K-edge extended X-ray absorption fine structure (EXAFS) spectroscopy and 15N NMR relaxation studies were performed on samples of a variant azurin in which the surface-exposed histidine ligand of the copper atom (His117) has been replaced by glycine. The experiments were performed to probe the structure of the active site and the protein dynamics. The cavity in the protein structure created by the His → Gly replacement could be filled by external ligands, which can either restore the spectroscopic properties of the original type-1 copper site or create a new type-2 copper site. The binding of external ligands occurs only when the copper atom is in its oxidised state. In the reduced form, the binding is abolished. From the EXAFS experiments, it is concluded that for the oxidised type-1 copper sites the protein plus external ligand (L) provide an NSS∗L donor set deriving from His46, Cys112, Met121 and the external ligand. The type-2 copper site features an S(N/O)3 donor set in which the S-donor derives from Cys112, one N-donor from His46 and the remaining two N or O donors from one or more external ligands. Upon reduction of the type-1 as well as the type-2 site, the external ligand drops out of the copper site and the coordination reduces to 3-fold with an SS∗N donor set deriving from His46, Cys112 and Met121. The Cu-Sδ(Met) distance is reduced from about 3.2 to 2.3 Å. Analysis of the NMR data shows that the hydrophobic patch around His117 has gained fluxionality when compared to wild-type azurin, which may explain why the His117Gly variant is able to accommodate a variety of external ligands of different sizes and with different chelating properties. On the other hand, the structure and dynamics of the β-sandwich, which comprises the main body of the protein, is only slightly affected by the mutation. The unusually high reduction potential of the His117Gly azurin is discussed in light of the present results.