Triplex-forming Peptide Nucleic Acids Research Articles

Next generation triplex-forming PNAs for site-specific genome editing of the F508del CFTR mutation

BackgroundCystic Fibrosis (CF) is an autosomal recessive genetic disease caused by mutations in the gene encoding the cystic fibrosis transmembrane conductance regulator (CFTR) protein for which there is no cure. One approach to cure CF is to correct the underlying mutations in the CFTR gene. We have used triplex-forming peptide nucleic acids (PNAs) loaded into biodegradable nanoparticles (NPs) in combination with donor DNAs as reagents for correcting mutations associated with genetic diseases including CF. Previously, we demonstrated that PNAs induce recombination between a donor DNA and the CFTR gene, correcting the F508del CFTR mutation in human cystic fibrosis bronchial epithelial cells (CFBE cells) and in a CF murine model leading to improved CFTR function with low off-target effects, however the level of correction was still below the threshold for therapeutic cure. MethodsHere, we report the use of next generation, chemically modified gamma PNAs (γPNAs) containing a diethylene glycol substitution at the gamma position for enhanced DNA binding. These modified γPNAs yield enhanced gene correction of F508del mutation in human bronchial epithelial cells (CFBE cells) and in primary nasal epithelial cells from CF mice (NECF cells). ResultsTreatment of CFBE cells and NECF cells grown at air-liquid interface (ALI) by NPs containing γtcPNAs and donor DNA resulted in increased CFTR function measured by short circuit current and improved gene editing (up to 32 %) on analysis of genomic DNA. ConclusionsThese findings provide the basis for further development of PNA and NP technology for editing of the CFTR gene.

Peptide nucleic acids (PNAs) control function of SARS-CoV-2 frameshifting stimulatory element trough PNA-RNA-PNA triplex formation

The highly structured nature of the SARS-CoV-2 genome provides many promising antiviral drug targets. One particularly promising target is a cis-acting RNA pseudoknot found within a critical region called the frameshifting stimulatory element (FSE). In this study, peptide nucleic acids (PNAs) binding to stem 2 of FSE RNA inhibited protein translation and frameshifting, as measured by a cell-free dual luciferase assay, more effectively than PNAs binding to stem 1, stem 3, or the slippery site. Surprisingly, simple antisense PNAs were stronger disruptors of frameshifting than PNA tail-clamps, despite higher thermal stability of the PNA-RNA-PNA triplexes formed by the latter. Another unexpected result was a strong and sequence non-specific enhancement of frameshifting inhibition when using a cationic triplex-forming PNA in conjunction with an antisense PNA targeting key regions of the frameshifting element. Our results illustrate both the potential and the challenges of using antisense PNAs to target highly structured RNAs, such as SARS-CoV-2 pseudoknots. While triplex forming PNAs, including PNA tail-clamps, are emerging as promising ligands for RNA recognition, the binding affinity enhancements when using cationic modifications in triplex-forming PNAs must be carefully balanced to avoid loss of sequence specificity in complex biological systems.

Triplex-forming peptide nucleic acids as emerging ligands to modulate structure and function of complex RNAs.

Over the last three decades, our view of RNA has changed from a simple intermediate supporting protein synthesis to a major regulator of biological processes. In the expanding area of RNA research, peptide nucleic acid (PNA) is emerging as a promising ligand for triple-helical recognition of complex RNAs. As discussed in this feature article, the key advantages of PNAs are high sequence specificity and affinity for RNA (>10 fold higher than for DNA) that are difficult to achieve with small molecule ligands. Emerging studies demonstrate that triple-helical binding of PNAs can modulate biological function and control dynamic conformational equilibria of complex folded RNAs. These results suggest that PNA has a unique potential as a research tool and therapeutic compound targeting RNA. The remaining problems hampering advances in these directions are limitations of sequences that can be recognized by Hoogsteen triplexes (typically purine rich tracts), poor cellular uptake and bioavailability of PNA, and potential off-target effects in biological systems. Recent exciting studies are discussed that illustrate how synthetic nucleic acid chemistry provides innovative solutions for these problems.

Synthesis of 2-Aminopyridine-Modified Peptide Nucleic Acids

AbstractTriplex-forming peptide nucleic acids (PNAs) require chemical modifications for efficient sequence-specific recognition of DNA and RNA at physiological pH. Our research groups have developed 2-aminopyridine (M) as an effective mimic of protonated cytosine in C+•G-C triplets. M-modified PNAs have a high binding affinity and sequence specificity as well as promising biological properties for improving PNA applications. This communication reports the optimization of synthetic procedures that give PNA M monomer in seven steps, with minimal need for column chromatography and in good yields and high purity. The optimized route uses inexpensive reagents and easily performed reactions, which will be useful for the broad community of nucleic acid chemists. Thought has also been given to the potential for future development of industrial syntheses of M monomers.

Triplex-Forming Peptide Nucleic Acid Controls Dynamic Conformations of RNA Bulges.

RNA folding is driven by the formation of double-helical segments interspaced by loops of unpaired nucleotides. Among the latter, bulges formed by one or several unpaired nucleotides are one of the most common structural motifs that play an important role in stabilizing RNA-RNA, RNA-protein, and RNA-small molecule interactions. Single-nucleotide bulges can fold in alternative structures where the unpaired nucleobase is either looped-out (flexible) in a solvent or stacked-in (intercalated) between the base pairs. In the present study, we discovered that triplex-forming peptide nucleic acids (PNAs) had unusually high affinity for single-purine-nucleotide bulges in double-helical RNA. Depending on the PNA's sequence, the triplex formation shifted the equilibrium between looped-out and stacked-in conformations. The ability to control the dynamic equilibria of RNA's structure will be an important tool for studying structure-function relationships in RNA biology and may have potential in novel therapeutic approaches targeting disease-related RNAs.

The 2-Aminopyridine Nucleobase Improves Triple-Helical Recognition of RNA and DNA When Used Instead of Pseudoisocytosine in Peptide Nucleic Acids

Pseudoisocytosine (J), a neutral analogue of protonated cytosine, is currently the gold standard modified nucleobase in peptide nucleic acids (PNAs) for the formation of J·G-C triplets that are stable at physiological pH. This study shows that triple-helical recognition of RNA and DNA is significantly improved by using 2-aminopyridine (M) instead of J. The positively charged M forms 3-fold stronger M+·G-C triplets than J with uncompromised sequence selectivity. Replacement of six Js with Ms in a PNA 9-mer increased its binding affinity by ∼2 orders of magnitude. M-modified PNAs prefer binding double-stranded RNA over DNA and disfavor off-target binding to single-stranded nucleic acids. Taken together, the results show that M is a promising modified nucleobase that significantly improves triplex-forming PNAs and may provide breakthrough developments for therapeutic and biotechnology applications.

Pyridazine Nucleobase in Triplex-Forming PNA Improves Recognition of Cytosine Interruptions of Polypurine Tracts in RNA.

Sequence specific recognition of regulatory noncoding RNAs would open new possibilities for fundamental science and medicine. However, molecular recognition of such complex double-stranded RNA (dsRNA) structures remains a formidable problem. Recently, we discovered that peptide nucleic acids (PNAs) form an unusually stable and sequence-specific triple helix with dsRNA. Triplex-forming PNAs could become universal tools for recognition of noncoding dsRNAs but are limited by the requirement of polypurine tracts in target RNAs as only purines form stable Hoogsteen hydrogen bonded base triplets. Herein, we systematically surveyed simple nitrogen heterocycles PN as modified nucleobases for recognition of cytosine in PN*C-G triplets. We found that a 3-pyridazinyl nucleobase formed significantly more stable PN*C-G triplets than other heterocycles including the pyrimidin-2-one previously used by us and others for recognition of cytosine interruptions in polypurine tracts of PNA-dsRNA triplexes. Our results improve triple helical recognition of dsRNA and provide insights for future development of new nucleobases to expand the sequence scope of noncoding dsRNAs that can be targeted by triplex-forming PNAs.

Impact of Chirality and Position of Lysine Conjugation in Triplex-Forming Peptide Nucleic Acids.

Conjugation with cationic lysine residues improves the biophysical and biological properties of peptide nucleic acids (PNAs). A single lysine is routinely used to improve the solubility and prevent aggregation of the neutral and hydrophobic amide backbone of PNA. Literature precedents include the attachment of lysine at either the N- or the C-terminus. Moreover, conjugation with short lysine peptides (four to eight residues) improves the cellular uptake of PNA akin to more complex cell-penetrating peptides. Herein, we report a systematic study of the effect of lysine location (N- vs C-terminus) and chirality (d- vs l-) on triple-helical binding of PNA to double-stranded RNA and DNA (dsRNA and dsDNA). The results confirmed our earlier findings that conjugation with lysine significantly increased the stability of PNA-dsRNA and PNA-dsDNA triplexes and that PNA affinity for dsRNA was about an order of magnitude higher than for the same sequence of dsDNA. In contrast, conjugation of PNA with noncharged amino acids decreased the affinity of PNA. Surprisingly, neither the location nor the chirality of lysine had significant impact on PNA affinity for either dsRNA or dsDNA. The results are consistent with the lack of chiral preorganization of single-stranded PNAs, even after conjugation with four d- or l-amino acids. Instead, the positive charge of lysine appears to be the main driving force behind the increased affinity.

Design of Fluorescent Peptide Nucleic Acid Probes Carrying Cyanine Dyes for Targeting Double-Stranded RNAs for Analytical Applications

Abstract With the increasing knowledge about the diverse roles of RNAs within cells, much attention has been paid to the development of RNA-binding fluorescent probes for the study of RNA functions. Especially, the probes for double-stranded RNA (dsRNA) structures are highly useful given the importance of the secondary and tertiary RNA structures on their biological functions. This account describes our recent efforts to develop synthetic fluorescent probes based on peptide nucleic acids (PNAs) carrying fluorogenic cyanine dyes for targeting the overhang structures of dsRNAs with a view toward the analysis of the intracellular delivery process of small interfering RNAs. We also describe the design of triplex-forming PNA probes carrying cyanine dye base surrogates for the sequence-selective detection of dsRNAs.

γ-(S)-Guanidinylmethyl-Modified Triplex-Forming Peptide Nucleic Acids Increase Hoogsteen-Face Affinity for a MicroRNA and Enhance Cellular Uptake.

γ-Modified (i.e., (S)-aminomethyl, (S)-acetamidomethyl, (R)-4-(hydroxymethyl)triazol-1-ylmethyl, and (S)-guanidinylmethyl) triplex-forming peptide nucleic acids (TFPNAs) were synthesized and the effect of the backbone modifications on the binding to a miR-215 model was studied. Among the modifications, an appropriate pattern of three γ-(S)-guanidinylmethyl modifications increased the affinity and Hoogsteen-face selectivity for the miR-215 model without ternary (PNA)2 /RNA complex formation. Moreover, the γ-(S)-guanidinylmethyl groups were observed to facilitate internalization of the TFPNAs into living PC-3 prostate cancer cells.

Synthesis and RNA-Binding Properties of Extended Nucleobases for Triplex-Forming Peptide Nucleic Acids.

Triple-helix formation, using Hoogsteen hydrogen bonding of triplex-forming oligonucleotides, represents an attractive method for sequence-specific recognition of double-stranded nucleic acids. However, practical applications using triple-helix-forming oligonucleotides and their analogues are limited to long homopurine sequences. The key problem for recognition of pyrimidines is that they present only one hydrogen-bond acceptor or donor group in the major groove. Herein, we report our first attempt to overcome this problem by using peptide nucleic acids (PNAs) modified with extended nucleobases that form three hydrogen bonds along the entire Hoogsteen edge of the Watson-Crick base pair. New nucleobase triples (five) were designed, and their hydrogen bonding feasibility was confirmed by ab initio calculations. PNA monomers carrying the modified nucleobases were synthesized and incorporated in short model PNA sequences. Isothermal titration calorimetry showed that these nucleobases had a modest binding affinity for their double-stranded RNA (dsRNA) targets. Finally, molecular modeling of the modified triples in PNA-dsRNA helix suggested that the modest binding affinity was caused by subtle structural deviations from ideal hydrogen-bonding arrangements or disrupted π-stacking of the extended nucleobase scaffolds.

Synthetic, Structural, and RNA Binding Studies on 2-Aminopyridine-Modified Triplex-Forming Peptide Nucleic Acids.

The development of new RNA-binding ligands is attracting increasing interest in fundamental science and the pharmaceutical industry. The goal of this study was to improve the RNA binding properties of triplex-forming peptide nucleic acids (PNAs) by further increasing the pKa of 2-aminopyridine (M). Protonation of M was the key for enabling triplex formation at physiological pH in earlier studies. Substitution on M by an electron-donating 4-methoxy substituent resulted in slight destabilization of the PNA-dsRNA triplex, contrary to the expected stabilization due to more favorable protonation. To explain this unexpected result, the first NMR structural studies were performed on an M-modified PNA-dsRNA triplex which, combined with computational modeling identified unfavorable steric and electrostatic repulsion between the 4-methoxy group of M and the oxygen of the carbonyl group connecting the adjacent nucleobase to PNA backbone. The structural studies also provided insights into hydrogen-bonding interactions that might be responsible for the high affinity and unusual RNA-binding preference of PNAs.

Sequence-specific recognition of structured RNA by triplex-forming peptide nucleic acids.

While <2% of DNA encodes for functional proteins, >70% is transcribed into RNA. Although the function of most RNA transcripts is unknown, such non-coding RNAs are attractive targets for molecular recognition because of the potentially important roles they play in regulation of gene expression and development of disease. In this chapter, we describe peptide nucleic acids (PNAs) that form sequence-specific triple helices with double-stranded RNA (dsRNA). We provide protocols for sequence design and biophysical characterization of PNAs and discuss first examples where such PNAs have been used for functional modulation of dsRNA. The triplex-forming PNAs represent a new approach for RNA recognition that may find future applications in fundamental science, biotechnology and medicine.

Gene editing gets a head start

Emerging Therapies The development of gene-editing technologies into therapies for human disease is an exciting prospect. A crucial question is whether there are advantages to correcting disease-causing mutations before rather than after birth, and whether this approach is even feasible. In a proof-of-concept study in mice, Ricciardi et al. accomplished successful in utero correction of a hemoglobin gene mutation that causes β-thalassemia, a serious blood disorder. They injected nanoparticles containing gene-editing machinery (triplex-forming peptide nucleic acids and single-stranded donor DNA) intravenously into midgestational mouse fetuses. After birth, the treated mice showed sustained amelioration of anemia and survived longer than untreated mice. Nat. Commun. 10.1038/s41467-018-04894-2 (2018).

19 F NMR Spectroscopic Analysis of the Binding Modes in Triple-Helical Peptide Nucleic Acid (PNA)/MicroRNA Complexes.

Triplex-forming peptide nucleic acids (TFPNAs) were targeted to double-helical regions of 19 F-labeled RNA hairpin models (a UA-rich duplex with a hexaethylene glycol (heg) loop and a microRNA model, miR-215). In addition to conventional UV- and circular dichroism (CD)-based detection, binding was monitored by 19 F NMR spectroscopy. Detailed information on the stoichiometry and transition between the triple-helical peptide nucleic acid (PNA)/RNA and (PNA)2 /RNA binding modes could be obtained. γ-(R)-Hydroxymethyl-modified thymine-1-yl- and 2-aminopyridin-3-yl-acetyl derivatives of TFPNAs were additionally synthesized, which were targeted to the same RNA models, and the effect of the γ-(R)-hydroxymethyl group on binding was studied. An appropriate pattern of γ-(R)-hydroxymethyl modifications reduced the stability of the ternary complex and preferred stoichiometric binding to the miR-215 model.

In vivo correction of anaemia in β-thalassemic mice by γPNA-mediated gene editing with nanoparticle delivery.

The blood disorder, β-thalassaemia, is considered an attractive target for gene correction. Site-specific triplex formation has been shown to induce DNA repair and thereby catalyse genome editing. Here we report that triplex-forming peptide nucleic acids (PNAs) substituted at the γ position plus stimulation of the stem cell factor (SCF)/c-Kit pathway yielded high levels of gene editing in haematopoietic stem cells (HSCs) in a mouse model of human β-thalassaemia. Injection of thalassemic mice with SCF plus nanoparticles containing γPNAs and donor DNAs ameliorated the disease phenotype, with sustained elevation of blood haemoglobin levels into the normal range, reduced reticulocytosis, reversal of splenomegaly and up to 7% β-globin gene correction in HSCs, with extremely low off-target effects. The combination of nanoparticle delivery, next generation γPNAs and SCF treatment may offer a minimally invasive treatment for genetic disorders of the blood that can be achieved safely and simply by intravenous administration.

Fluorescent 2-Aminopyridine Nucleobases for Triplex-Forming Peptide Nucleic Acids.

Development of new fluorescent peptide nucleic acids (PNAs) is important for fundamental research and practical applications. The goal of this study was the design of fluorogenic nucleobases for incorporation in triplex-forming PNAs. The underlying design principle was the use of a protonation event that accompanied binding of a 2-aminopyridine (M) nucleobase to a G-C base pair as an on switch for a fluorescence signal. Two fluorogenic nucleobases, 3-(1-phenylethynyl)-M and phenylpyrrolo-M, were designed, synthesized and studied. The new M derivatives provided modest enhancement of fluorescence upon protonation but showed reduced RNA binding affinity and quenching of fluorescence signal upon triple-helix formation with cognate double-stranded RNA. Our study illustrates the principal challenges of design and provides guidelines for future improvement of fluorogenic PNA nucleobases. The 3-(1-phenylethynyl)-M may be used as a fluorescent nucleobase to study PNA-RNA triple-helix formation.

Single-stranded γPNAs for in vivo site-specific genome editing via Watson-Crick recognition.

Triplex-forming peptide nucleic acids (PNAs) facilitate gene editing by stimulating recombination of donor DNAs within genomic DNA via site-specific formation of altered helical structures that further stimulate DNA repair. However, PNAs designed for triplex formation are sequence restricted to homopurine sites. Herein we describe a novel strategy where next generation single-stranded gamma PNAs (γPNAs) containing miniPEG substitutions at the gamma position can target genomic DNA in mouse bone marrow at mixed-sequence sites to induce targeted gene editing. In addition to enhanced binding, γPNAs confer increased solubility and improved formulation into poly(lactic-co-glycolic acid) (PLGA) nanoparticles for efficient intracellular delivery. Single-stranded γPNAs induce targeted gene editing at frequencies of 0.8% in mouse bone marrow cells treated ex vivo and 0.1% in vivo via IV injection, without detectable toxicity. These results suggest that γPNAs may provide a new tool for induced gene editing based on Watson-Crick recognition without sequence restriction.

RNA triplexes: from structural principles to biological and biotech applications.

The diverse biological functions of RNA are determined by the complex structures of RNA stabilized by both secondary and tertiary interactions. An RNA triplex is an important tertiary structure motif that is found in many pseudoknots and other structured RNAs. A triplex structure usually forms through tertiary interactions in the major or minor groove of a Watson-Crick base-paired stem. A major-groove RNA triplex structure is stable in isolation by forming consecutive major-groove base triples such as U·A-U and C(+) ·G-C. Minor-groove RNA triplexes, e.g., A-minor motif triplexes, are found in almost all large structured RNAs. As double-stranded RNA stem regions are often involved in biologically important tertiary triplex structure formation and protein binding, the ability to sequence specifically target any desired RNA duplexes by triplex formation would have great potential for biomedical applications. Programmable chemically modified triplex-forming oligonucleotides (TFOs) and triplex-forming peptide nucleic acids (PNAs) have been developed to form TFO·RNA2 and PNA·RNA2 triplexes, respectively, with enhanced binding affinity and sequence specificity at physiological conditions. Here, we (1) provide an overview of naturally occurring RNA triplexes, (2) summarize the experimental methods for studying triplexes, and (3) review the development of TFOs and triplex-forming PNAs for targeting an HIV-1 ribosomal frameshift-inducing RNA, a bacterial ribosomal A-site RNA, and a human microRNA hairpin precursor, and for inhibiting the RNA-protein interactions involving human RNA-dependent protein kinase and HIV-1 viral protein Rev.

Incorporation of thio-pseudoisocytosine into triplex-forming peptide nucleic acids for enhanced recognition of RNA duplexes

Peptide nucleic acids (PNAs) have been developed for applications in biotechnology and therapeutics. There is great potential in the development of chemically modified PNAs or other triplex-forming ligands that selectively bind to RNA duplexes, but not single-stranded regions, at near-physiological conditions. Here, we report on a convenient synthesis route to a modified PNA monomer, thio-pseudoisocytosine (L), and binding studies of PNAs incorporating the monomer L. Thermal melting and gel electrophoresis studies reveal that L-incorporated 8-mer PNAs have superior affinity and specificity in recognizing the duplex region of a model RNA hairpin to form a pyrimidine motif major-groove RNA2–PNA triplex, without appreciable binding to single-stranded regions to form an RNA–PNA duplex or, via strand invasion, forming an RNA–PNA2 triplex at near-physiological buffer condition. In addition, an L-incorporated 8-mer PNA shows essentially no binding to single-stranded or double-stranded DNA. Furthermore, an L-modified 6-mer PNA, but not pseudoisocytosine (J) modified or unmodified PNA, binds to the HIV-1 programmed −1 ribosomal frameshift stimulatory RNA hairpin at near-physiological buffer conditions. The stabilization of an RNA2–PNA triplex by L modification is facilitated by enhanced van der Waals contacts, base stacking, hydrogen bonding and reduced dehydration energy. The destabilization of RNA–PNA and DNA–PNA duplexes by L modification is due to the steric clash and loss of two hydrogen bonds in a Watson–Crick-like G–L pair. An RNA2–PNA triplex is significantly more stable than a DNA2–PNA triplex, probably because the RNA duplex major groove provides geometry compatibility and favorable backbone–backbone interactions with PNA. Thus, L-modified triplex-forming PNAs may be utilized for sequence-specifically targeting duplex regions in RNAs for biological and therapeutic applications.