Triple-resonance Experiments Research Articles

Enhancing Spectrometer Performance with Unsupervised Machine Learning.

Solid-state NMR spectroscopy (SSNMR) is a powerful technique to probe structural and dynamic properties of biomolecules at an atomic level. Modern SSNMR methods employ multidimensional pulse sequences requiring data collection over a period of days to weeks. Variations in signal intensity or frequency due to environmental fluctuation introduce artifacts into the spectra. Therefore, it is critical to actively monitor instrumentation subject to fluctuations. Here, we demonstrate a method rooted in the unsupervised machine learning algorithm principal component analysis (PCA) to evaluate the impact of environmental parameters that affect sensitivity, resolution and peak positions (chemical shifts) in multidimensional SSNMR protein spectra. PCA loading spectra illustrate the unique features associated with each drifting parameter, while the PCA scores quantify the magnitude of parameter drift. This is demonstrated both for double (HC) and triple resonance (HCN) experiments. Furthermore, we apply this methodology to identify magnetic field B0 drift, and leverage PCA to "denoise" multidimensional SSNMR spectra of the membrane protein, EmrE, using several spectra collected over several days. Finally, we utilize PCA to identify changes in B1 (CP and decoupling) and B0 fields in a manner that we envision could be automated in the future. Overall, these approaches enable improved objectivity in monitoring NMR spectrometers, and are also applicable to other forms of spectroscopy.

The backbone NMR resonance assignments of the stabilized E. coli β clamp.

The 81 kDa E. coli β clamp is a ring-shaped head-to-tail homodimer that encircles DNA and plays a central role in bacterial DNA replication by serving as a processivity factor for DNA polymerases and a binding platform for other DNA replication and repair proteins. Here we report the backbone 1H, 15N, and 13C NMR resonance assignments of the stabilized T45R/S107R β clamp variant obtained using standard TROSY-based triple-resonance experiments (BMRB 52548). The backbone assignments were aided by 13C and 15N edited NOESY experiments, allowing us to utilize our previously reported assignments of the β clamp ILV side-chain methyl groups (BMRB 51430, 51431). The backbone assignments of the T45R/S107R β clamp variant were transferred to the wild-type β clamp using a minimal set of TROSY-based 15N edited NOESY, NHCO and NHCA experiments (BMRB 52549). The reported backbone and previous ILV side-chain resonance assignments will enable NMR studies of the β clamp interactions and dynamics using amide and methyl groups as probes.

AI-designed NMR spectroscopy RF pulses for fast acquisition at high and ultra-high magnetic fields

Nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) spectroscopy is a powerful high-resolution tool for characterizing biomacromolecular structure, dynamics, and interactions. However, the lengthy longitudinal relaxation of the nuclear spins significantly extends the total experimental time, especially at high and ultra-high magnetic field strengths. Although longitudinal relaxation-enhanced techniques have sped up data acquisition, their application has been limited by the chemical shift dispersion. Here we combined an evolutionary algorithm and artificial intelligence to design 1H and 15N radio frequency (RF) pulses with variable phase and amplitude that cover significantly broader bandwidths and allow for rapid data acquisition. We re-engineered the basic transverse relaxation optimized spectroscopy experiment and showed that the RF shapes enhance the spectral sensitivity of well-folded proteins up to 180 kDa molecular weight. These RF shapes can be tailored to re-design triple-resonance experiments for accelerating NMR spectroscopy of biomacromolecules at high fields.

Conformational Dynamics of Phytoglobin BvPgb1.2 from Beta vulgaris ssp. vulgaris.

Plant hemoglobins, often referred to as phytoglobins, play important roles in abiotic stress tolerance. Several essential small physiological metabolites can be bound to these heme proteins. In addition, phytoglobins can catalyze a range of different oxidative reactions in vivo. These proteins are often oligomeric, but the degree and relevance of subunit interactions are largely unknown. In this study, we delineate which residues are involved in dimer formation of a sugar beet phytoglobin type 1.2 (BvPgb1.2) using NMR relaxation experiments. E. coli cells harboring a phytoglobin expression vector were cultivated in isotope-labeled (2H, 13C and 15N) M9 medium. The triple-labeled protein was purified to homogeneity using two chromatographic steps. Two forms of BvPgb1.2 were examined, the oxy-form and the more stable cyanide-form. Using three-dimensional triple-resonance NMR experiments, sequence-specific assignments for CN-bound BvPgb1.2 were achieved for 137 backbone amide cross-peaks in the 1H-15N TROSY spectrum, which amounts to 83% of the total number of 165 expected cross-peaks. A large proportion of the non-assigned residues are located in α-helixes G and H, which are proposed to be involved in protein dimerization. Such knowledge around dimer formation will be instrumental for developing a better understanding of phytoglobins' roles in planta.

1H, 13C and 15N assignment of the human mitochondrial paramagnetic iron-sulfur protein CISD3.

CISD3 is a mitochondrial protein that contains two [2Fe-2S] clusters. This protein is overexpressed in some types of cancer, so it has emerged as a potential drug target. A detailed characterization of this protein is crucial to understand how CISD3 is involved in these physiopathologies. In this study, isotopically labeled human CISD3 was expressed in Escherichia coli. A set of double and triple resonance experiments performed with standard parameters/datasets provided the assignment of 40% of the HN resonances, 47% of Cα, and 46% of C' resonances. Tailored paramagnetic HSQC, CON and CACO experiments extended up to 59% for HN, 70% for Cα and 69% for C'. The 1H, 13C and 15N NMR chemical shift assignment of human CISD3 is reported here.

Band-selective universal 90° and 180° rotation pulses covering the aliphatic carbon chemical shift range for triple resonance experiments on 1.2 GHz spectrometers

Biomolecular NMR spectroscopy requires large magnetic field strengths for high spectral resolution. Today’s highest fields comprise proton Larmor frequencies of 1.2 GHz and even larger field strengths are to be expected in the future. In protein triple resonance experiments, various carbon bandwidths need to be excited by selective pulses including the large aliphatic chemical shift range. When the spectrometer field strength is increased, the length of these pulses has to be decreased by the same factor, resulting in higher rf-amplitudes being necessary in order to cover the required frequency region. Currently available band-selective pulses like Q3/Q5 excite a narrow bandwidth compared to the necessary rf-amplitude. Because the maximum rf-power allowed in probeheads is limited, none of the selective universal rotation pulses reported so far is able to cover the full ^{13}C aliphatic region on 1.2 GHz spectrometers. In this work, we present band-selective 90° and 180° universal rotation pulses (SURBOP90 and SURBOP180) that have a higher ratio of selective bandwidth to maximum rf-amplitude than standard pulses. Simulations show that these pulses perform better than standard pulses, e. g. Q3/Q5, especially when rf-inhomogeneity is taken into account. The theoretical and experimental performance is demonstrated in offset profiles and by implementing the SURBOP pulses in an HNCACB experiment at 1.2 GHz.

Heteronuclear transfers from labile protons in biomolecular NMR: Cross polarization, revisited

INEPT- and HMQC-based pulse sequences are widely used to transfer polarization between heteronuclei, particularly in biomolecular spectroscopy: they are easy to setup and involve low power deposition. Still, these short-pulse polarization transfers schemes are challenged by fast solvent chemical exchange. An alternative to improve these heteronuclear transfers is J-driven cross polarization (J-CP), which transfers polarization by spin-locking the coupled spins under Hartmann-Hahn conditions. J-CP provides certain immunity against chemical exchange and other T2-like relaxation effects, a behavior that is here examined in depth by both Liouville-space numerical and analytical derivations describing the transfer efficiency. While superior to INEPT-based transfers, fast exchange may also slow down these J-CP transfers, hurting their efficiency. This study therefore explores the potential of repeated projective operations to improve 1H→15N and 1H→15N→13C J-CP transfers in the presence of fast solvent chemical exchanges. It is found that while repeating J-CP provides little 1H→15N transfer advantages over a prolonged CP, multiple contacts that keep both the water and the labile protons effectively spin-locked can improve 1H→15N→13C transfers in the presence of chemical exchange. The ensuing Looped, Concatenated Cross Polarization (L-CCP) compensates for single J-CP losses by relying on the 13C’s longer lifetimes, leading to a kind of “algorithmic cooling” that can provide high polarization for the 15N as well as carbonyl and alpha 13Cs. This can facilitate certain experiments, as demonstrated with triple resonance experiments on intrinsically disordered proteins involving labile, chemically exchanging protons.

Minimizing Pervasive Artifacts in 4D Covariance Maps for Protein Side Chain NMR Assignments.

Nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) is a mainstay of biophysical studies that provides atomic level readouts to formulate molecular mechanisms. Side chains are particularly important to derive mechanisms involving proteins as they carry functional groups, but NMR studies of side chains are often limited by challenges in assigning their signals. Here, we designed a novel computational method that combines spectral derivatives and matrix square-rooting to produce reliable 4D covariance maps from routinely acquired 3D spectra and facilitates side chain resonance assignments. Thus, we generate two 4D maps from 3D-HcccoNH and 3D-HCcH-TOCSY spectra that each help overcome signal overlap or sensitivity losses. These 4D maps feature HC-HSQCs of individual side chains that can be paired to assigned backbone amide resonances of individual aliphatic signals, and both are obtained from a single modified covariance calculation. Further, we present 4D maps produced using conventional triple resonance experiments to easily assign asparagine side chain amide resonances. The 4D covariance maps encapsulate the lengthy manual pattern recognition used in traditional assignment methods and distill the information as correlations that can be easily visualized. We showcase the utility of the 4D covariance maps with a 10 kDa peptidyl carrier protein and a 52 kDa cyclization domain from a nonribosomal peptide synthetase.

Triple Resonance Experiments for the Rapid Detection of 103Rh NMR Shifts: A Combined Experimental and Theoretical Study into Dirhodium and Bismuth-Rhodium Paddlewheel Complexes.

A H(C)Rh triple resonance NMR experiment makes the rapid detection of 103Rh chemical shifts possible, which were previously beyond reach. It served to analyze a series of dirhodium and bismuth–rhodium paddlewheel complexes of the utmost importance for metal–carbene chemistry. The excellent match between the experimental and computed 103Rh shifts in combination with a detailed analysis of the pertinent shielding tensors forms a sound basis for a qualitative and quantitative interpretation of these otherwise (basically) inaccessible data. The observed trends clearly reflect the influence exerted by the equatorial ligands (carboxylate versus carboxamidate), the axial ligands (solvents), and the internal “metalloligand” (Rh versus Bi) on the electronic estate of the reactive Rh(II) center.

Evaluation of highly entangled states in asymmetrically coupled three NV centers by quantum simulator

Despite numerous efforts, the coupling between randomly arranged multi-NV centers and also resonators has not been improved significantly mainly due to our limited knowledge of their free evolution time for entanglement (2τent). Here, we demonstrate very strong coupling between three NV centers by using a simulated triple electron-electron resonance experiment based on a quantum (UC) gate on an IBM quantum simulator with 2τent ∼ 12.5 μs arranged in a triangular configuration. Interestingly, through breaking, the symmetry of couplings an even lower 2τent ∼ 6.3 μs can be achieved. This simulation not only explains the luminescence spectra in recently observed three NV centers but also shows a large improvement of the entanglement in artificially created structures through a cyclic redistribution of couplings. Realistically disordered coupling configurations of NV center qubits with short time periods and high (0.89–0.99) fidelity of states clearly demonstrate the possibility of accurate quantum registers operated at room temperature.

The long-standing relationship between paramagnetic NMR and iron-sulfur proteins: the mitoNEET example. An old method for new stories or the other way around?

Paramagnetic NMR spectroscopy and iron-sulfur (Fe-S) proteins have maintained a synergic relationship for decades. Indeed, the hyperfine shifts with their temperature dependencies and the relaxation rates of nuclei of cluster-bound residues have been extensively used as a fingerprint of the type and of the oxidation state of the Fe-S cluster within the protein frame. The identification of NMR signals from residues surrounding the metal cofactor is crucial for understanding the structure-function relationship in Fe-S proteins, but it is generally impaired in standard NMR experiments by paramagnetic relaxation enhancement due to the presence of the paramagnetic cluster(s). On the other hand, the availability of systems of different sizes and stabilities has, over the years, stimulated NMR spectroscopists to exploit iron-sulfur proteins as paradigmatic cases to develop experiments, models, and protocols. Here, the cluster-binding properties of human mitoNEET have been investigated by 1D and 2D H diamagnetic and paramagnetic NMR, in its oxidized and reduced states. The NMR spectra of both oxidation states of mitoNEET appeared to be significantly different from those reported for previously investigated proteins. The protocol we have developed in this work conjugates spectroscopic information arising from "classical" paramagnetic NMR with an extended mapping of the signals of residues around the cluster which can be taken, even before the sequence-specific assignment is accomplished, as a fingerprint of the protein region constituting the functional site of the protein. We show how the combined use of 1D NOE experiments, direct-detected experiments, and double- and triple-resonance experiments tailored using R- and/or R-based filters significantly reduces the "blind" sphere of the protein around the paramagnetic cluster. This approach provided a detailed description of the unique electronic properties of mitoNEET, which are responsible for its biological function. Indeed, the NMR properties suggested that the specific electronic structure of the cluster possibly drives the functional properties of different proteins.

Power of Pure Shift HαCα Correlations: A Way to Characterize Biomolecules under Physiological Conditions.

Intrinsically disordered proteins (IDPs) constitute an important class of biomolecules with high flexibility. Atomic-resolution studies for these molecules are essentially limited to NMR spectroscopy, which should be performed under physiological pH and temperature to populate relevant conformational ensembles. In this context, however, fundamental problems arise with established triple resonance NMR experiments: high solvent accessibility of IDPs promotes water exchange, which disfavors classical amide 1H-detection, while 13C-detection suffers from significantly reduced sensitivity. A favorable alternative, the conventional detection of nonexchangeable 1Hα, so far resulted in broad signals with insufficient resolution and sensitivity. To overcome this, we introduce here a selective Hα,Cα-correlating pure shift detection scheme, the selective Hα,Cα-HSQC (SHACA-HSQC), using extensive hetero- and homonuclear decoupling applicable to aqueous samples (≥90% H2O) and tested on small molecules and proteins. SHACA-HSQC spectra acquired on IDPs provide uncompromised resolution and sensitivity (up to fivefold increased S/N compared to the standard 1H,13C-HSQC), as shown for resonance distinction and unambiguous assignment on the disordered transactivation domain of the tumor suppressor p53, α-synuclein, and folded ubiquitin. The detection scheme can be implemented in any 1Hα-detected triple resonance experiment and may also form the basis for the detection of isotope-labeled markers in biological studies or compound libraries.

NMR Spectroscopy in the Conformational Analysis of Peptides: An Overview.

NMR spectroscopy is one of the most powerful tools to study the structure and interaction properties of peptides and proteins from a dynamic perspective. Knowing the bioactive conformations of peptides is crucial in the drug discovery field to design more efficient analogue ligands and inhibitors of protein-protein interactions targeting therapeutically relevant systems. This review provides a toolkit to investigate peptide conformational properties by NMR. Articles cited herein, related to NMR studies of peptides and proteins were mainly searched through PubMed and the web. More recent and old books on NMR spectroscopy written by eminent scientists in the field were consulted as well. The review is mainly focused on NMR tools to gain the 3D structure of small unlabeled peptides. It is more application-oriented as it is beyond its goal to deliver a profound theoretical background. However, the basic principles of 2D homonuclear and heteronuclear experiments are briefly described. Protocols to obtain isotopically labeled peptides and principal triple resonance experiments needed to study them, are discussed as well. NMR is a leading technique in the study of conformational preferences of small flexible peptides whose structure can be often only described by an ensemble of conformations. Although NMR studies of peptides can be easily and fast performed by canonical protocols established a few decades ago, more recently we have assisted to tremendous improvements of NMR spectroscopy to investigate instead large systems and overcome its molecular weight limit.

Using magnetic coupling to improve multiple resonance NMR probe circuits

Multiple resonant NMR circuits are an especially important aspect of modern NMR detectors. Today NMR researchers can carry out direct observe, indirect observe and double or triple resonance experiments on many different nuclides without having to change the NMR probe. The price for this convenience is loss of efficiency. In this paper it is explained how by using magnetic coupling and symmetric multiple resonance circuits the efficiency of these experiments can be improved over capacitively coupled circuits to 50 Ω ports.

Resonance assignments and secondary structure prediction of secretory protein Rv0603 from Mycobacterium tuberculosis H37Rv.

We report the NMR resonance assignments of N-terminal signal sequence deleted secretory protein Rv0603 (∆1-28-Rv0603) from Mycobacterium tuberculosis H37Rv. ∆1-28-Rv0603 displayed good peak yield and signal dispersion in 2D [15N-1H] HSQC spectrum, which prompted us to proceed for resonance assignments on this construct. Standard triple-resonance experiments for resonance assignments were recordedon [U-15N]-∆Rv0603 and [U-15N, 13C]-∆Rv0603 samples. We obtained 97% of backbone 1HN, 98% of 13Cα, 98% of 1Hα, 96% of 13C´, 100% of 13Cβ, 100% of 1Hβ and 98% of side-chain 1H chemical shifts. This protein does not show any sequence similarity to any other protein ofknown structure. Determinationof its solution structure would facilitate understanding of its biological function.

NMR mapping of the highly flexible regions of 13C/15N-labeled antibody TTAC-0001-Fab.

Monoclonal antibody (mAb) drugs are clinically important for the treatment of various diseases. TTAC-0001 is under development as a new anti-cancer antibody drug targeting VEGFR-2. As the less severe toxicity of TTAC-0001 compared to Bevacizumab, likely due to the decreased in vivo half-life, seems to be related to its structural flexibility, it is important to map the exact flexible regions. Although the 13C/15N-labeled protein is required for NMR analyses, it is difficult to obtain antibody fragments (Fab and scFv) containing disulfide bonds through general cytosolic expression in Escherichia coli (E. coli). Here, we notably increased the periplasmic expression of the 13C/15N-labeled TTAC-0001-Fab (13C/15N-TTAC-Fab) through simple isopropyl β-D-1-thiogalactopyranoside (IPTG)-induction at an increased optical density (1.5 OD600nm). Through NMR triple resonance experiments, two loop insertions (LI-1 between the VH and CH1; LI-2 between the VL and CL) were confirmed to be highly flexible. The additional LIs could be another way to engineer the antibody by changing the pharmacokinetic properties.

1H, 13C and 15N assignment of the paramagnetic high potential iron\u2013sulfur protein (HiPIP) PioC from Rhodopseudomonas palustris TIE-1

High potential iron–sulfur proteins (HiPIPs) are a class of small proteins (50–100 aa residues), containing a 4Fe–4S iron–sulfur cluster. The 4Fe–4S cluster shuttles between the oxidation states [Fe4S4]3+/2+, with a positive redox potential in the range (500–50 mV) throughout the different known HiPIPs. Both oxidation states are paramagnetic at room temperature. HiPIPs are electron transfer proteins, isolated from photosynthetic bacteria and usually provide electrons to the photosynthetic reaction-center. PioC, the HIPIP isolated from Rhodopseudomonas palustris TIE-1, is the smallest among all known HiPIPs. Despite their small dimensions, an extensive NMR assignment is only available for two of them, because paramagnetism prevents the straightforward assignment of all resonances. We report here the complete NMR assignment of 1H, 13C and 15N signals for the reduced [Fe4S4]2+ state of the protein. A set of double and triple resonance experiments performed with standardized parameters/datasets provided the assignment of about 72% of the residues. The almost complete resonance assignment (99.5% of backbone and ca. 90% of side chain resonances) was achieved by combining the above information with those obtained using a second set of NMR experiments, in which acquisition and processing parameters, as well as pulse sequences design, were optimized to account for the peculiar features of this paramagnetic protein.

Automated Backbone NMR Resonance Assignment of Large Proteins Using Redundant Linking from a Single Simultaneous Acquisition.

Thanks to magic-angle spinning (MAS) probes with frequencies of 60-100 kHz, the benefit of high-sensitivity 1H detection can now be broadly realized in biomolecular solid-state NMR for the analysis of microcrystalline, sedimented, or lipid-embedded preparations. Nonetheless, performing the assignment of all resonances remains a rate-limiting step in protein structural studies, and even the latest optimized protocols fail to perform this step when the protein size exceeds ∼20 kDa. Here, we leverage the benefits of fast (100 kHz) MAS and high (800 MHz) magnetic fields to design an approach that lifts this limitation. Through the creation, conservation, and acquisition of independent magnetization pathways within a single triple-resonance MAS NMR experiment, a single self-consistent data set can be acquired, providing enhanced sensitivity, reduced vulnerability to machine or sample instabilities, and highly redundant linking that supports fully automated peak picking and resonance assignment. The method, dubbed RAVASSA (redundant assignment via a single simultaneous acquisition), is demonstrated with the assignment of the largest protein to date in the solid state, the 42.5 kDa maltose binding protein, using a single fully protonated microcrystalline sample and 1 week of spectrometer time.

NMR Experiments for Studies of Dilute and Condensed Protein Phases: Application to the Phase-Separating Protein CAPRIN1

Intrinsically disordered proteins (IDPs) or regions of intrinsic disorder in otherwise folded proteins (IDRs) play important roles in many different biological processes, including formation of biological condensates via liquid-liquid phase separation. NMR spectroscopy is a powerful tool for obtaining site-specific structural and dynamical information on IDPs/IDRs, and recent efforts have focused on the development of experiments for atomic-resolution studies of these molecules. These include triple-resonance experiments that are based on 13CO-direct detection of magnetization, exploiting increased sensitivity of cryogenically cooled probes. In order to evaluate the different classes of experiment for studies of IDRs or IDPs in both dilute and phase-separated environments, in particular at neutral and higher pHs where many of these proteins phase separate, we compared 13CO-detect versus 1Hα-detect experiments, showing that significant sensitivity gains are achieved via proton detection under the conditions of our experiments. A suite of 1Hα-detect experiments was subsequently developed for studies of IDPs/IDRs and applied to the dilute phase of a 103-residue disordered region of CAPRIN1 that phase separates at neutral pH. Residue-specific chemical shifts derived from our study enable the accurate prediction of the importance of the N-terminal Arg-containing region of this construct for promoting phase separation relative to other Arg-rich stretches of sequence, subsequently confirmed by mutagenesis. Our study emphasizes that the sequence positions of key residues can be a critical factor in controlling phase separation and highlights the unique role of NMR in establishing the relations between amino acid sequence and phase-separation propensity.

Complete 1H, 13C, 15N resonance assignments and secondary structure of the Vpr binding region of hHR23A (residues 223–363)

Comprehensive resonance assignments and delineation of the secondary structure elements of the C-terminal Vpr-binding region of hHR23A, residues 223-363, were achieved by triple-resonance NMR experiments on uniformly 13C,15N-labeled protein. Assignments are 100% and > 95% complete for backbone and side-chain resonances, respectively. This data constitutes important complementary information for our ongoing structure determination of the Vpr-hHR23A(223-363) complex. At high concentrations, severe line-broadening was observed for several residues in the 1H-15N HSQC spectrum, most likely resulting from inter-molecular interactions.