Tree Seedling Density Research Articles

Influence of wild ungulates on the secondary succession of an Apennine silver fir forest after windthrow

Windstorms are natural factors in vegetation dynamics, but their intensity is increasing and undermines the forest resilience. Post-event interventions depend on forest types and management purposes. To promote mixed stands that are less susceptible to windthrow than monocultures, natural tree regeneration is usually recommended. However, wild ungulates attracted by the increased food supply in the new clearings can influence the secondary succession and slow down vegetation recovery. The impact of ungulate pressure on secondary successions in blowdown areas is still poorly known, especially in Mediterranean areas, which is particularly vulnerable to climate stressors. We investigated this topic using a monospecific silver fir (Abies alba) forest of artificial origin in the Apennines as a model system. The forest was left to natural succession after a severe windthrow in 2015, offering the opportunity to establish an ungulate exclosure experiment to analyse vegetation changes over six years. For the whole plant community, cover and height, α-diversity (species richness, Shannon and evenness indexes), and species composition were recorded yearly, together with tree seedling density, in open and fenced plots at increasing distances from the forest edge. Ecological and functional traits (proportion of light-demanding and forest specialists, endo-/epi-zoochorous species), and life-forms of the community samples were also analysed. Overall, we found that ungulates significantly influenced the dynamic trajectories of secondary succession. The effects on plant cover and diversity were negative and increased with distance from the forest edge. The presence of ungulates favoured generalist species and endozoochorous taxa. However, distance from the forest edge strongly reduced the latter effect. The average density of tree seedlings was overall high (ca. 10,000/ha), but it was strongly reduced by ungulates for three deciduous species and A. alba, the most browsed species. Natural recolonization after windthrow in Apennine pure silver fir stands may favour the formation of mixed, less susceptible forests, but the current ungulate pressure slows down this process, especially in the areas furthest from the forest edge.

Episodic deterioration of plant diversity in rich fens with or without in situ oil sands exploration disturbance

Peatlands with ground surfaces near the water table may be sensitive to disturbances that reduce this distance to water. Shrubby rich fens (SRF) in northern Alberta, Canada, are restricted to the wettest landscape positions and are characterized by brown mosses and stunted trees on weakly consolidated and saturated substrates. In situ oil sands exploration (OSE) practices have established thousands of drilling pads to explore for deeply buried bitumen deposits, with many located on peatlands. In the development of OSE pads on peatlands, the vegetation layer is removed, eliminating the functionally important hummock‐hollow surface topography. We examined the spontaneous regeneration of bryophytes and vascular plants and surface microtopography on SRF, 7 and again 14 years after pad abandonment. In both sampling years, drilling pad surfaces were closer to the water table (mean pad elevation 2012 = 3.3 cm, 2019 = 5.6 cm) and had minor topography compared to adjacent reference habitat. We found, however, over the 7 years, that for both drilling pads and reference habitat, bryophyte and vascular plant richness decreased, and most species declined in frequency. Furthermore, for pads and reference habitat, density of tree seedlings decreased, and expansion of hummock‐forming mosses was limited. Findings suggest that drilling pads and their natural counterparts on SRF may be prone to episodic reductions in plant diversity and ecosystem retrogression, likely resulting from prolonged surface saturation during summers with high rainfall. Because of their wet landscape positions and environmental vulnerability, SRF are likely the peatland habitats slowest to recover following OSE pad construction.

Reproductive characteristics in an understory bamboo and gradual environmental changes after its dieback provide an extended opportunity for overstory tree regeneration in a mixed cool-temperate forest in central Japan.

The reproductive characteristics of understory bamboo and the effects of dieback on overstory tree seedlings through temporal changes in the environment at the forest floor have only been examined in a few bamboo species, due to the unpredictable occurrence of flowering events and long intervals between them but provide valuable information on tree regeneration and succession in a forest with dense dwarf bamboo cover. We investigated environmental conditions and assessed seedlings (< 30-cm tall) of the dwarf bamboo Sasa borealis and overstory tree species at 44-50 measurement points during 2016-2021, which included a S. borealis mass flowering event in 2017. We also conducted seed germination tests to determine germination rates and patterns in S. borealis. Environmental factors affecting seedling recruitment of S. borealis and of overstory trees were analysed using spatiotemporal generalized linear mixed models in the Bayesian framework. We observed gradual temporal changes in the environment, including increasing canopy openness and decreasing maximum height of dead S. borealis culms. The seeds germinated slowly and the emergence of current-year S. borealis seedlings peaked in spring-summer in 2019. The tree seedling density after 2019 increased significantly compared to that before the dieback. The model results suggest that tree seedling establishment was enhanced by increased light availability. Continuous field observation beginning before S. borealis dieback revealed gradually enhanced tree recruitment in response to slow decay of the remaining dead culms and slow recovery of S. borealis. The seedling regeneration pattern of understory bamboo partly contributes to a prolonged opportunity for overstory tree regeneration.

Fire Impacts and Dynamics of Seasonally Dry Tropical Forest of East Java, Indonesia

(1) Background: Seasonally dry tropical forests (SDTFs) are globally important ecosystems which receive less research attention compared to tropical rainforests but are equally under serious threat. The objectives of this paper are to characterize the vegetation structure, diversity and composition of SDTF of Baluran National Park, East Java, Indonesia, and to assess the impact of burning this SDTF and its post-fire recovery. (2) Methods: In the field, we measured floristic composition and dominance at sites with different fire histories in both SDTF and adjacent savannas of Baluran. Remote sensing image analysis was also employed using the MODIS burn area product and various thematic maps. (3) Results: SDTF at Baluran has moderately high tree cover, is less diverse in species than rainforest, and has a prominent vegetative response to fire, especially in the tree layer. The immediate post-fire period in SDTF featured lower densities of tree seedlings and saplings, more grasses and herbs, and lower species richness than older unburned forest. Species composition varied with fire age and vegetation type, with relatively rapid recovery with time since fire evident, although there was some convergence of long-unburned savanna and SDTF sites in terms of floristics. (4) Conclusions: The SDTF of Baluran recovers after fire principally via resprouting but also via seedling regeneration, with structural attributes returning more quickly (&lt;10 years) than floristic composition (&gt;10 years). We did not find consistent evidence of ecosystem transitions between SDTF and savanna despite a small number of long-unburned savanna sites having floristic similarities to dry forest (particularly in terms of characteristic tree species), and we identify the need for more study to determine the degree and mechanisms of forest–savanna transitions in the region, with a future research agenda outlined. Relatively large areas of savanna–dry forest transitions demonstrated from remote sensing analyses were primarily attributed to spread of Acacia nilotica (an alien invasive small tree or shrub) into long-unburned savanna, and its decline in areas where the species is being successfully controlled via burning and cutting. Knowledge of such ecological shifting is important for the ecosystem management, especially in terms of their usage by large mammals.

Synergetic Roles of Mangrove Vegetation on Sediment Accretion in Coastal Mangrove Plantations in Central Thailand

Mangrove plantations can potentially restore the vegetation structures protecting coastal areas. In Avicennia alba plantations in central Thailand, we investigated the vegetation structures (trees, seedlings, pneumatophores, and belowground roots), sedimentation rates, and elevation changes over one year across the shore. The results showed a heterogeneous vegetation structure with an increasing tree basal area (BA) and seedling density towards the interior. The pneumatophore quantitative characteristics decreased towards the interior in association with the topographic gradient and inundation period. The sedimentation rates, which were greater in the plantation than on the mudflat, showed a negative correlation with the height, total surface area, and total volume of the pneumatophores. This indicates that the pneumatophores facilitated the transportation of fine sediments into the interior. Our results suggest that an optimal complexity of the aboveground vegetation structure might enhance the sedimentation rates. According to the gradient of tree BA and seedling density, the fine root density increased towards the interior. The monthly elevation changes in the plantation showed less fluctuation than those on the mudflat. The net elevation changes indicated sediment accretion within the plantation and erosion on the mudflat. Our results demonstrate the synergetic roles of mangrove plantations in which the aboveground structures facilitate sediment redeposition and the belowground roots stabilize sediment accretion in coastal areas.

Quantifying restoration success via natural recovery in forested areas following pipeline construction

Natural recovery is a restoration technique that relies on natural ecological processes to reestablish native ecosystems. This “minimal intervention” approach is typically more cost‐effective, less labor intensive, and can result in more diverse communities than more intensive restoration techniques. The purpose of this study was to determine if boreal forest vegetation can reestablish naturally after pipeline construction, and whether a site can be identified as similar to adjacent undisturbed areas within 10 years of pipeline construction. Four naturally recovered pipeline segments (1, 3, 5, and 10 years postreclamation) in west‐central Alberta were assessed. Plots were established on and off each pipeline segment right‐of‐way (ROW) in upland, transitional, and wetland habitats. Vegetation percent cover, vigor, and tree seedling density data were used to determine characteristic and indicator species, regulated weeds and agronomic species, richness, diversity, evenness, and tree establishment for each pipeline segment, habitat type, and site type (on‐ vs. off‐ROW). Threshold values for species richness and community diversity were determined using data collected from sites off‐ROW. Sites which fell within established thresholds were identified as on a trajectory toward restoration within 10 years postconstruction. Metrics for the older pipeline segments, including species richness, diversity, evenness, and seedling count were typically closer to threshold values, and sometimes exceeded them. Only the youngest pipeline segment had tree establishment values below calculated thresholds. This study is the first to provide empirical evidence and a method for identifying successful restoration trajectories for natural recovery of pipeline ROWs in boreal forest.

Initial succession after wildfire in dry boreal forests of northwestern North America

Wildfires in the boreal forest of North America are generally stand renewing, with the initial phase of recovery often governing the vegetation trajectory for decades. Here, we investigated post-fire vegetation changes in dry boreal forests of the Northwest Territories, Canada, during the first 5 years following the unusually severe 2014 wildfire season. We sampled post-fire tree regeneration and the understory plant community at 1, 3, and 5 years post-fire across different stand types within fires that burned in 2014. Post-fire trajectories of tree recruitment, understory cover by plant functional types, and plant diversity varied widely among sampled stands, as well as among years post-fire. Tree seedling density reached relative equilibrium by 3-years post-fire, whereas trends in understory plant cover and understory species assemblages suggested an ongoing change that will extend beyond 5 years of observation. In almost half of sampled stands, the composition of recruited trees differed from that of the pre-fire stand, suggesting a change in tree species dominance. An analysis of regional climate revealed a significant, albeit spatially variable, warming and drying trend that will further accelerate forest stand transformation through both climate drivers of plant community composition and indirectly through increasing fire activity. While the 2014 wildfires enhanced the structural and compositional heterogeneity of the region, they also triggered vegetation changes that are likely to be persistent. As such, this study exemplifies the speed and variability that characterizes post-fire stand development in a strongly moisture-limited part of North America.

Species richness, diversity, structure, and distribution patterns across dominating forest communities of low and mid-hills in the Central Himalaya

ABSTRACT The forests of the central Himalayan region are characterized by the dominance of some populous and conspicuous tree species across altitudes that are crucial for ecosystem functions and services. An understanding of such forests with relation to species richness, diversity, structural pattern, and distribution is crucial in maintaining ecosystem stability. Considering this, the present study was undertaken on the four most common forest types dominated with Sal (Shorea robusta), Chir-pine (Pinus roxburghii), and Banj-oak (Quercus leucotrichophora), and mixed-oak (Q. lanuginosa and Q. floribunda) between 300 and 2250 m msl. Across the studied forest stands, we recorded a total of 110 plant species, belonging to 53 families. The most dominating life form was herbaceous (52%), followed by trees (27%), and shrubs (21%). Tree density was recorded maximum (884 ind. ha−1) at the mixed oak stand and minimum (652 ind. ha−1) recorded at the chir-pine forest; however, maximum (51.58 m2 ha−1) total basal area (TBA) was recorded in banj-oak forest and minimum (33.42 m2 ha−1) at mixed-oak forest stand. Tree density, seedling density, and TBA are significantly varied among the forest stands. The temperate oak forests comprised higher species richness and diversity at tree and shrub stratum. However, subtropical sal and chir-pine stand recorded higher regeneration. All stands exhibited high community dependence on forest resources that may increase the vulnerability of forest with respect to human interference, thus deserve immediate attention. Site-specific management and conservation measures have been suggested to provide opportunities for sustainable management of all forest stands.

Using permanent forest plots to evaluate the resilience to fire of Tasmania’s tall wet eucalypt forests

The vulnerability to repeated high severity fires of tall wet eucalypt forests (TWEF) dominated by obligate seeder species is widely understood. However, 80% of Tasmania’s TWEF are dominated by resprouter species, and while these forests are more resilient to wildfire than those dominated by obligate seeders, the degree of their resilience is not well documented. Recently, two wildfires affected five 1-ha forest plots that had been previously measured, providing the opportunity to assess fire effects on these forest stands. We characterised these wildfires using remote sensing and field measurements of char height (a proxy for fire intensity) and canopy scorch (fire severity). We assessed the influence of tree diameter, fire intensity and seedling densities on the survival and resprouting responses of eucalypt overstorey trees and mixed species understorey trees. Our results showed that these fires were predominantly of low to moderate intensity and severity. Our results showed that mature TWEF were resilient to these wildfires, with overall eucalypt survival of 75%. The major eucalypt species were either mostly not defoliated (E. regnans), or could recover rapidly by epicormic resprouting (E. delegatensis and E. obliqua). Results from this and other studies show recovery from topkill caused by high severity fires occurs but is slower, by basal resprouting (E. obliqua) or from seed (all species). By contrast, understorey species suffered high mortality (85% overall), with few species showing substantial resprouting. Fire resistance in both groups increased markedly with tree diameter.Our results have implications for forest management. The high survival of overstorey eucalypts leads to a multi-aged stand structure in most unlogged old growth TWEF in Tasmania. On the other hand, clearfell logging, originally designed to mimic stand replacing wildfire in obligate seeder systems, creates a vulnerable, even aged stand of young regrowth, and at a landscape scale, it also reduces average tree size, reducing overall resistance to fire. Adopting alternatives to clearfelling, such as partial logging systems, will increase landscape resilience to fire, as well as providing other previously shown benefits.

The potential of natural succession to restore degraded areas of a Ugandan rainforest dominated by the exotic paper mulberry Broussonetia papyrifera (L.) L'Hér. ex Vent

There are many studies on the applicability of natural regeneration for recovery of degraded forests. Studies of the potential of natural regeneration and succession to restore degraded forest areas under invasive exotic plants are few in comparison. This study examined the potential of these processes to bring about the recovery of large areas under the exotic paper mulberry Broussonetia papyrifera in Mabira Forest, Uganda. The areas of focus were degraded by farming but abandoned and invaded by mulberry 30 years ago. Sampling was conducted in three mulberry-dominant stands (Int 1, Int 2, and Hv) that were differentiated by the degree of mulberry cutting by local communities and other anthropogenic disturbances. Primary forest (Nt) was a fourth stand used as a reference. Data were collected using Modified-Whittaker Plots, transects and other plot types adapted to record impact of disturbance. Analyses of stem density showed that both mulberry and native trees occurred in all the stands in varying densities and age classes from seedling to tree class size. Non-metric multidimensional scaling showed Int 1 (a relatively undisturbed stand with fully grown mulberry) to be closest to Nt floristically, followed by Int 2 (a disturbed stand with fully grown mulberry). Hv (a disturbed stand with low stature mulberry) was least similar to Nt. Overall, Int 1 was closer to Nt than to any of the other stands; while Int 2 was closer to Hv than to Int 1 or to Nt. Most analyses of seedling and sapling densities and species diversity of native trees showed a pattern whereby Hv < Int 2 < Int 1 < Nt. Numbers of forest-typical species varied between stands but not significantly. Inter-stand differences in the levels of disturbance were pronounced with Hv and Int 2 having significantly higher incidences of illegal indigenous tree cutting and charcoal kilning than Int 1. Regressions of percent cover values on seedling densities, sapling densities and species richness showed negative relationships between mulberry cover and native tree seedling density and species richness but not sapling density. Indigenous tree sapling densities were positively correlated with indigenous tree species cover. These findings suggest that anthropogenic disturbance and to a smaller extent mulberry factors; and not differences in rates of species colonization and degrees of species performance explain the current state of recovery of the stands. Natural regeneration and succession therefore have potential to recover the degraded sites and reverse the dominance of mulberry if the ongoing human disturbance is stopped.

A short-interval reburn catalyzes departures from historical structure and composition in a mesic mixed-conifer forest

Recent increases in fire frequency and severity across the western US are triggering abrupt changes in ecosystem structure and composition, especially in lower montane forests, but consequences of fire-regime change for mesic, mixed-conifer forests remain uncertain. Glacier National Park (Montana, USA) is characterized by a complex mosaic of species typical of Rocky Mountain, Pacific Northwest and boreal floras, creating opportunities for species composition to shift as species respond individualistically to environmental change. We quantified prefire and postfire stem density and composition in a recent anomalously short-interval fire (15 yrs) and historically typical long-interval fire (88–282 + yrs) to answer two questions: (1) How do the structure and composition of tree regeneration differ after long- and short-interval fires that burned in close proximity? (2) What drivers explain differences in postfire regeneration densities among species? We additionally compared understory cover in each fire to anticipate consequences of contemporary fire for the whole plant community. Mean postfire tree seedling density was 45 times higher after the long- than short-interval fire, and many stands in the short-interval fire lacked any tree regeneration. Postfire tree seedling densities were above prefire stem densities in the long-interval fire but well below in the short-interval fire. After both fires, fire-avoiding conifers (e.g., Picea engelmannii, Abies lasiocarpa) were generally replaced by fire-tolerating or fire-embracing species (e.g., Larix occidentalis, Pinus contorta var. latifolia). Some stands remained dominated by fire-sensitive conifers after long-interval fire but never after short-interval fire. Seedlings of Thuja plicata and Tsuga heterophylla were present after the long-interval fire but absent before and after the short-interval fire, despite historically occupying both burned areas. For all species, seedling density increased with indicators of proximate seed supply. Seedling density of dispersal-dependent species declined with distance to live trees, whereas P. contorta responded to serotiny. Seedlings of drought-intolerant species were more abundant on northerly aspects. Total understory cover was 50% lower after short-interval than long-interval fire, but shrub cover was twice as high. Our study suggests that persistent seed sources will allow L. occidentalis to expand following sequential high-severity fires, while dispersal-limited, drought-intolerant conifers may decline due to loss of seed sources and elevated postfire aridity. Increased fire activity will likely produce sparser forests that are dominated by fire-tolerating and fire-embracing conifers at the expense of fire-avoiding and fire-refuge species. Complete regeneration failure may be delayed by high fire-trait syndrome diversity, but the structure and composition of extant forests will shift.

The response of the invasive princess tree (Paulownia tomentosa) to wildland fire and other disturbances in an Appalachian hardwood forest

This study examined the response of princess tree (Paulownia tomentosa) to different disturbances and its potential to spread throughout its current range in the U.S. The study was established in Shawnee State Forest in southern Ohio, USA, which has historically experienced disturbances from mining, logging, ice storms and wildfire. Plots were established for vegetation sampling where fire had occurred with and without princess tree present, and where no fire had occurred with and without princess tree present. To determine the influence of disturbance types on the density of princess tree, redundancy analysis (RDA) was used. High stem density of princess tree seedlings occurred in areas that experienced high fire intensities and herbicide treatment. Seedlings on southwest slopes increased in abundance as the time from the last logging activity increases. Princess tree saplings were present in greater densities in areas that experienced medium fire intensities and the highest ice storm damage. Sapling density is greatest as ground cover and vegetation height increases and slope decreases. Princess trees reach maximum stem density on northeast slopes in areas not impacted by the 2009 fire. All disturbances considered, including wildfire, have created conditions conducive to princess tree growth and expansion into forest areas.

Plant-plant interactions change during succession on nurse logs in a northern temperate rainforest.

Plant–plant interactions change through succession from facilitative to competitive. At early stages of succession, early‐colonizing plants can increase the survival and reproductive output of other plants by ameliorating disturbance and stressful conditions. At later stages of succession, plant interactions are more competitive as plants put more energy toward growth and reproduction. In northern temperate rainforests, gap dynamics result in tree falls that facilitate tree regeneration (nurse logs) and bryophyte succession. How bryophyte‐tree seedling interactions vary through log succession remains unclear. We examined the relationships of tree seedlings, bryophyte community composition, bryophyte depth, and percent canopy cover in 166 1.0 m2 plots on nurse logs and the forest floor in the Hoh rainforest in Washington, USA, to test the hypothesis that bryophyte‐tree seedling interactions change from facilitative to competitive as the log decays. Tree seedling density was highest on young logs with early‐colonizing bryophyte species (e.g., Rhizomnium glabrescens) and lowest on decayed logs with Hylocomium splendens, a long‐lived moss that reaches depths >20 cm. As a result, bryophyte depth increased with nurse log decay and was negatively associated with tree seedling density. Tree seedling density was 4.6× higher on nurse logs than on the forest floor, which was likely due to competitive exclusion by forest floor plants, such as H. splendens. Nurse logs had 17 species of bryophytes while the forest floor had six, indicating that nurse logs contribute to maintaining bryophyte diversity. Nurse logs enable both tree seedlings and smaller bryophyte species to avoid competition with forest floor plants, including the dominant bryophyte, H. splendens. H. splendens is likely a widespread driver of plant community structure given its dominance in northern temperate forests. Our findings indicate that plant–plant interactions shift with succession on nurse logs from facilitative to competitive and, thus, influence forest community structure and dynamics.

Effects of prescribed grazing by goats on non‐native invasive shrubs and native plant species in a mixed‐hardwood forest

Invasion of non‐native shrubs comprises a serious economic and ecological problem in North American forests. Prescribed grazing by goats may offer an effective alternative to traditional methods of control, but has received little study in forest settings. In a 5‐year field experiment, we varied the stocking of goats and number of grazing periods to determine effects of prescribed grazing on both invasive shrubs and native plant species. Specifically, we examined how varied stocking levels and grazing periods affect: (1) the cover and height of invasive shrub and native woody species (2) the cover and diversity of herbaceous species, and (3) the density of native tree seedlings. Data were analyzed with linear mixed‐effects models. We found that prescribed grazing by goats significantly reduced the cover and height of invasive shrubs, regardless of goat stocking or duration. Generally, the greatest reductions in invasive shrub cover occurred in treatments with two grazing periods, regardless of goat stocking. While we observed mostly neutral or positive effects on the herbaceous layer, all grazing treatments reduced the cover and height of native understory woody species. While changes were not significant, we observed a general decline in the aggregate height of native tree species regeneration. Our results suggest that prescribed grazing by goats provides an effective and environmentally friendly treatment for heavy invasions of non‐native shrubs such as Rosa multiflora, but grazing needs to be followed by focused mechanical or chemical treatments to maintain control while allowing the regeneration of native tree species.

Beetlemania: Is the bark worse than the bite? Rocky Mountain subalpine forests recover differently after spruce beetle outbreaks and wildfires

Due to the shifting global climate, the frequency and severity of disturbances are increasing, inevitably causing an increase in disturbances overlapping in time and space. Bark beetle epidemics and wildfires have historically shaped the disturbance regimes of Western North American forests. Their interactive effects on stand dynamics and recovery are inadequately studied in Picea engelmannii (Engelmann spruce)-Abies lasiocarpa (subalpine fir) dominant forests; understanding these interactions is imperative to the management and health of forested ecosystems. This study focuses on the effects of epidemic Dendroctonus rufipennis (spruce beetle) outbreaks, high-severity fires, and the subsequent species and structural diversity of subalpine forest regeneration and structure in Northern Colorado and Southern Wyoming. We compared tree seedling densities and species composition, surface fuel loading, and stand structure characteristics across 80 sites that experienced either high tree mortality from epidemic spruce beetle outbreaks (>50% affected basal area), high-severity wildfire, post-outbreak high-severity wildfire (1–3 years post-outbreak), or no disturbance (control). The beetle outbreak sites span multiple years post-outbreak from 1996 to 2017, ultimately comprising a chronosequence of beetle-affected stands. Analyses indicate a significant increase in fuel loading over time-since-outbreak, as aerial fuels are transferred to the forest floor following high tree mortality. Tree seedling densities among outbreak and control sites differ significantly from burned areas, indicating that wildfires override the effects of repeated disturbances on regeneration. There was consistent Engelmann spruce seedling survival following beetle outbreaks, providing evidence for stable forest recovery following a single disturbance. However, fire was a dominate force in determining post-disturbance species composition, indicating continued prevalence of high severity fire may prove detrimental for the persistence of spruce-fir species, while promoting shifts toward more drought and fire tolerant tree species (e.g., Pinus contorta). It is critical to understand post-disturbance fuel dynamics and stand recovery to identify hazards for subsequent fire suppression, implement treatments to enhance forest resilience, and to understand the potential consequences of climate-induced shifts in disturbance regimes on forest health.

Understory vegetation response to mountain pine beetle disturbance in northern Colorado lodgepole pine forests

Understory plants are an important element of forests, having a considerable influence on ecosystem functioning and canopy-tree development following disturbance. Recent bark beetle outbreaks across western North American forests have caused extensive canopy mortality, creating new growing conditions that provide the opportunity for changes within the intact understory. Over a five-year period following peak mountain pine beetle (MPB) activity across lodgepole pine-dominated forests in Rocky Mountain National Park, Colorado, we measured the changes in plant diversity, cover, and dominance by lifeform and quantified tree regeneration rates. Average species richness and diversity increased, but overall plant cover did not change. Graminoids appeared to benefit the most, increasing in average cover, richness, and relative dominance. The rise in graminoid dominance was largely at the expense of shrubs, which showed little ability to benefit from overstory mortality within the first years following attack. Most plant responses were positively related to the total tree basal area lost since the peak of the outbreak, suggesting that increased resource availability following tree death may benefit understory plants. However, a negative relationship between several understory variables and tree sapling density provides evidence that understory plants compete with saplings for the newly available resources. Tree seedling density nearly doubled over the duration of the study, indicating a strong regeneration pulse. Among species, lodgepole pine displayed the greatest tree seedling establishment. This is one of the first studies to use repeated measurements to describe this often-overlooked component of forest change associated with MPB disturbance.

Conservation set-asides improve carbon storage and support associated plant diversity in certified sustainable oil palm plantations

Maintaining forest conservation set-asides is a key criterion of sustainability certification of many crops that drive tropical deforestation, but their value for carbon storage and associated biodiversity is unclear. We conducted vegetation measurements to examine the benefits of set-asides for aboveground carbon stocks (AGC) in certified oil palm plantations on Borneo, and whether their AGC is positively associated with plant diversity. The mean estimated AGC of live trees and palms ≥10 cm diameter in set-asides in certified oil palm plantations (52.8 Mg ha−1) was >1.5-times that of oil palm (30.3 Mg ha−1), with some plots supporting similar AGC to primary forest. For lowland Borneo, we estimate that the average AGC of oil palm plantations with 10% coverage of set-asides is up to 20% greater than the average AGC of oil palm plantations without set-asides, newly demonstrating carbon storage as a benefit of conservation set-asides. We found positive relationships between AGC and plant diversity, highlighting the carbon–biodiversity co-benefits of set-asides. However, set-asides had a lower density of tree seedlings than continuous primary forest, indicating potential suppression of future tree regeneration and AGC. Our findings support the application of zero-deforestation during agricultural development, to conserve areas of remaining forest with high AGC and high biodiversity. We recommend management practices that boost regeneration in existing set-asides (e.g. enrichment planting), which would be most effective in larger set-asides, and could substantially increase the AGC of agricultural landscapes without removing land from production, and help conserve forest-dependent biodiversity.

Factors shaping alternate successional trajectories in burned black spruce forests of Alaska

AbstractDisturbances can interrupt feedbacks that maintain stable plant community structure and create windows of opportunity for vegetation to shift to alternative states. Boreal forests are dominated by tree species that overlap considerably in environmental niche, but there are few tests of what conditions initiate and sustain different forest states. Here, we examine patterns of post‐fire growth and density of tree seedlings in early succession and use structural equation models to estimate relative effects of environmental and pre‐fire conditions, fire characteristics, and biotic interactions. We surveyed tree seedling recruits for 13 yr across a broad range of environmental and fire conditions (n = 89) in Alaskan black spruce stands that burned in 2004. Densities of established seedlings at 13 yr were strongly determined by initial recruitment that occurred within 2 yr after fire. High proportional combustion of the soil organic layer (fire severity) led to increased densities of deciduous seedlings but not of black spruce and had a positive influence on aboveground biomass of all species. Biotic interactions such as mammalian herbivory or woody competition, potential mechanisms for relay floristic succession, had no detectable effects on tree seedling densities or biomass. Repeated surveys instead suggested persistent shifts in successional trajectories of tree communities from spruce to deciduous dominance at sites where high fire severity created positive conditions for deciduous seedling recruitment and growth. Unless future species interactions alter the deciduous dominance of tree seedling composition, the vegetation transformations that we observed in response to high fire severity are likely to persist over the short fire cycle that increasingly characterizes the fire regime of Interior Alaska.

Effects of culling white-tailed deer on tree regeneration and Microstegium vimineum, an invasive grass

Reduction of forest regeneration due to overbrowsing by white-tailed deer is a growing concern for land managers. Abundant deer can impede forest regeneration through direct predation on tree seedlings. Additionally high deer density can facilitate the establishment of a dense understory of browse tolerant plant species that shades seedlings and persists even in the absence of deer. In response to these challenges, land managers have sought to reduce deer herds to restore tree regeneration, but few studies have evaluated the effectiveness of this management. Our study took place in Catoctin Mountain Park, a US National Park Service unit with a history of high deer density. The park has been heavily invaded by Microstegium vimineum, an invasive grass that can completely cover the forest floor. Using permanent plots established prior to the start of deer management, we were able to assess the joint effects of deer culling and M. vimineum on tree seedling density. We found that tree seedling density increased in response to deer reductions. M. vimineum cover initially increased, but then decreased. Seedling densities were higher in plots with more M. vimineum cover, indicating that it did not form a recalcitrant understory that would suppress regeneration. However, eight years after deer management began, few tree seedlings were >30 cm tall, implying that it will be many years before they grow into the sapling stage. Our results indicate that deer culling can be an effective tool in restoring tree regeneration despite the presence of M. vimineum, but that success will require a long-term commitment.

Litter and soil biogeochemical parameters as indicators of sustainable logging in Central Amazonia

One-fourth of Brazilian Amazonia is managed for timber production, but only a small portion of active logging sites follow sustainable forest management plans (SFMPs). Amazon forests without SFMPs are susceptible to deforestation because such plans integrate the use of forest products and conservation goals by allowing selective wood extraction following regulations aimed at reducing the long-term impact of logging. However, it remains uncertain whether reduced-impact selective logging typical of SFMPs (17–20 m3 ha−1 yr−1 of 38–70 species) changes forest regeneration, carbon (C) stocks, and nutrient cycling. Here, we tested the hypothesis that litter and soil biogeochemical parameters serve as indicators of sustainable logging as forest regeneration, C stocks, and C-to-nutrient ratios in soil and litter become progressively similar to those of primary forests as time elapses after logging. We used a chronosequence spanning nine years since logging to relate litter and soil (at 0–10, 10–30, 30–50 cm depth) C stocks and 12 and 15 biogeochemical parameters, respectively, as well as canopy cover and tree seedling density (10–150 cm tall) in upland evergreen Amazon forests. In one unlogged and four logged stands sampled three, five, seven, and nine years after logging, we compared 15 permanent plots (three replicated 0.5 ha plots per time-since-logging category). We found that five parameters explained >80% of the variation in soil and litter properties among logged and unlogged stands. Litter parameters were more sensitive to logging than soil parameters, as litter C stocks and C-to-nutrient ratios increased systematically after logging. Canopy cover decreased over time and was ~14% lower nine years after logging. Total seedling density did not change consistently over time but was ~54% higher seven years after logging. Our data suggest that the SFMP guidelines have served the purpose of maintaining soil quality and forest regeneration. Litter and soil parameters can be useful indicators of sustainable forest management in upland evergreen forests in Central Amazonia.