Tree-related Microhabitats Research Articles

3D dataset generation using virtual reality for forest biodiversity

ABSTRACT While forest biodiversity faces a concerning decline, modern technology presents promising avenues for mitigation. However, a critical gap persists in reconciling ecological knowledge with the technical expertise required to use state-of-the-art technologies in 3D data classification. Currently, one main issue is the scarcity of 3D datasets for biodiversity, particularly within the context of machine learning applications. Unlike the straightforward classification of human-made structures, forest environments are uniquely intricate and nuanced due to its inherently complex nature. This study addresses this challenge by introducing a fully automated pipeline for tree stem 3D point cloud segmentation, focussing on a biodiversity indicator: tree-related microhabitats (TreMs). Furthermore, our research advances the field by demonstrating that machine learning models trained with labels generated by our proposed virtual reality (VR) method, Labelling Flora, yield predictions statistically similar to the traditional desktop-based labelling methods. This implies that existing 3D datasets could be augmented using the more rapid approach of VR labelling. Additionally, the findings of this paper demonstrate the potential integration of VR and immersive technology into the 3D labelling workflow, facilitating a quicker and more intuitive labelling process. This could empower users, who are non-familiar with 3D modelling, to contribute their expertise to the segmentation process.

The Effects of the Selective Removal of Adjacent Trees on the Diversity of Oak-Hosted Epiphytes and Tree-Related Microhabitats.

Restoration efforts to maintain oak-dominated habitats and enhance biodiversity often employ selective thinning, but its long-term effect on multiple taxa remains unclear. This study examines the effects of halo thinning around pedunculate oak on epiphytic and tree-related microhabitat (TreM) diversity in the boreal-nemoral forest zone. We revisited nine sites in Latvia with 150-331-year-old oaks, where thinning was conducted in 2003-2004. Epiphyte species composition and cover were assessed, and TreMs were evaluated using standardised methods. Diversity indices (Hill numbers, q = 0; 1; 2; 3) and statistical models (LMMs, Poisson GLMMs) were used to analyse the effects of thinning on species richness and TreM occurrence. Halo thinning over the past 20 years has not caused significant differences in epiphyte or TreM diversity, though managed trees exhibited a higher occurrence of the most common microhabitats. These findings suggest halo thinning may enhance specific TreM features but do not substantially promote epiphyte and TreM diversity. Future research should implement systematic monitoring, deriving the relationships between the conditions after the thinning and their effects, thus serving as the basis for adaptive habitat management strategies. Expanding the scope of such studies is essential for developing evidence-based forest management strategies.

I want to climb to the tops of trees! Factors facilitating the development of ivy vines in central European forests

Abstract Lianas, which are considered to form tree-related microhabitats, are known as important elements of tropical forests; however, their ecological function and relationships with host trees (phorophytes) in temperate forests are poorly known. This gap in knowledge stems from a low species diversity and abundance of lianas in temperate forests. An exception is common ivy (Hedera helix), which is widely distributed and is currently increasing its abundance in temperate forests. In this study, we examined the relationships between ivy vines with features of their phorophytes, using Central European upland mixed forests as an example. We assess the presence and density of ivy within 69 study plots, established in the forest interior and ecotone. We use generalized linear mixed-effects models to assess drivers of ivy’s presence and its density, while accounting for the tree diameter at breast height, bark roughness, and the canopy light transmittance. We show that ivy is able to grow on nearly all tree species, although it prefers phorophytes with rough bark and a large diameter. Large generative individuals (ivy vines that produce fruits) were found mostly on veteran trees (usually oaks, alders, or pines). For its growth, ivy requires tree phorophytes with only a moderate transparency of light through the tree crowns, which is likely related to evergreen leaves that enable ivy vines to also develop during leaf-off periods. The features of phorophytes preferred by ivy indicate that the vine finds optimal conditions for development in old patches of tree stand, often in areas inaccessible or unprofitable for forest management. We propose using large and fruiting ivy vines as indicators of old-growth forests that deserve protection, which would be in line with the current policy of sustaining and restoring close-to-natural forests in Europe.

Public safety considerations constraint the conservation of large old trees and their crucial ecological heritage in urban green spaces

Large old trees in urban public green spaces deliver a diversity of values essential for human well-being, including biodiversity conservation. Yet, the conservation of large old trees bearing key wildlife microhabitats interferes with safety considerations. This intuitive notion, however, is backed by an insufficient and scattered body of evidence. Here, we empirically examined this process using data on 5974 trees across 510 sample plots, organized as quintuplets within 102 sample sites, including urban parks, cemeteries, recreational forests, and historic reserves in the urban agglomeration of Kraków, Poland. Our analyses demonstrate that trees situated in areas frequently visited by people, or those near walking paths, benches, or playgrounds, have elevated accident hazards and, therefore, necessitate intensive tree surgeries (pruning and logging) to remain harmless. Large old trees, which bear the most diverse microhabitats and pose greater risks when they collapse, are especially affected by these measures. Accordingly, we found that the co-occurrence of large trees with elevated accident hazards results in significant losses of dead and sloped trees, and trees with cavities, injuries, crown deadwood, fungal fruiting bodies, or epiphytes, particularly in parks and, to a lesser extent, in recreational forests. Apparently, some tree-related microhabitats, such as injuries, cavities, and microsoils, also emerge in risky spots after pruning. Our findings underscore that the conservation of large old trees and their ecological functions faces significant challenges due to safety considerations. To address conservation challenges and harmonize human coexistence with biodiversity, we recommend enhancing environmental awareness and reevaluating arboricultural and planning policies. This would involve establishing strategic and pocket reserves on city peripheries and interiors, allowing larger older trees to thrive and develop important microhabitats without compromising public safety. Otherwise, we risk losing many large old trees and/or their superior value for wildlife, which will regenerate over decades, if not centuries.

Tree inventory data from permanent plots in French forest reserves.

We present a data set resulting from the first round of a national monitoring program of forest reserves. It contains 9538 permanent plots, distributed across 111 study sites in mainland France (including Corsica). Notably focusing on dead wood measurement, this protocol has primarily been applied in strict forest reserves and special nature reserves (sensu Bollmann & Braunisch 2013), with 68% (6494) of the plots being currently located in strict forest reserves (unmanaged) and 24.7% (2363 plots) in forests unmanaged for at least 50 years. Sites cover a large variety of ecological conditions, from lowland to subalpine forests, but with an underrepresentation of Mediterranean forests (Table 1). The protocol assesses all the stages of a tree's life cycle, from seedling to decomposed lying dead wood. On each plot, a combination of three sampling techniques was used: (1) fixed-area inventory for regeneration, standing dead trees, living trees, and coarse woody debris (CWD) with diameter over 30 cm; (2) transect lines for CWD with diameter <30 cm; and (3) fixed-angle plot method for living trees with diameter at breast height (DBH) >30 cm (using a relascopic angle of 3%). Measurements include exact tree location (azimuth, distance), species, diameter(s), tree-related microhabitats, decay stage and bark cover, and seedling cover. With ongoing climate change, the program network can also provide important information to monitor changes in forest ecosystems. It can also be used as forest management monitoring or conservation status assessment. These data are freely available for noncommercial scientific use (Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 CC BY SA 4.0) with attribution, and this paper must be cited if this material is reused.

Small oases below the canopy: The cooling effects of water-filled tree holes on the local microclimate in oak-dominated stands

The relevance of forests in mitigating biodiversity loss and the negative effects of climate change on the biota is largely shaped by below-canopy microclimatic conditions, which are buffered, cooler and more humid compared to adjoining open habitats. Water-filled tree holes (dendrotelms, DTs) are special tree-related microhabitats that host semi-aquatic communities and are important substrates or water sources for numerous taxa (e.g., birds, mammals, insects, fungi, bryophytes). Despite their microrefugia-role might be more pronounced under climate change-induced drought events, little is known about their microclimate and its potential drivers.In an abandoned Turkey oak-dominated coppice stand in Hungary, the microclimates of 80 paired dendrotelms and adjacent forest plots were measured in the summer of 2021. Compared to nearby open areas, under closed forests, air temperature maxima were up to 5 °C cooler, DTs had an additional negative offset of 2.5 °C and increased air humidity by 15 percentage points (5% vs. 20 %). The local microclimate of DTs and the adjacent closed forest differed significantly in means and extremes of air temperature, relative humidity and vapour pressure deficit, which was mainly driven by DT entrance area and water volume and seemed independent from local stand structure. On the contrary, nearby below-canopy microclimate was shaped by the distance from forest edge, incoming light and tree density. Water volume in DTs also influenced local forest microclimates up to 0.5–1 m from the entrances.As the frequency and severity of extreme weather events such as heatwaves are likely to intensify due to climate change, the importance of microhabitats and habitat trees for invertebrates and vertebrates will increase further, and will additionally contribute to the microclimatic refugia role of forests. Active protection of veteran trees under the scheme of continuous cover forestry or conservation-oriented management is essential facing climate change to mitigate its negative effects on forest biodiversity.

Tree-Related Microhabitats and Multi-Taxon Biodiversity Quantification Exploiting ALS Data

The quantification of tree-related microhabitats (TreMs) and multi-taxon biodiversity is pivotal to the implementation of forest conservation policies, which are crucial under the current climate change scenarios. We assessed the capacity of Airborne Laser Scanning (ALS) data to quantify biodiversity indices related to both forest beetle and bird communities and TreMs, calculating the species richness and types of saproxylic and epixylic TreMs using the Shannon index. As biodiversity predictors, 240 ALS-derived metrics were calculated: 214 were point-cloud based, 14 were pixel-level from the canopy height model, and 12 were RGB spectral statistics. We used the random forests algorithm to predict species richness and the Shannon diversity index, using the field plot measures as dependent variables and the ALS-derived metrics as predictors for each taxon and TreMs type. The final models were used to produce wall-to-wall maps of biodiversity indices. The Shannon index produced the best performance for each group considered, with a mean difference of −6.7%. Likewise, the highest R2 was for the Shannon index (0.17, against 0.14 for richness). Our results confirm the importance of ALS data in assessing forest biodiversity indicators that are relevant for monitoring forest habitats. The proposed method supports the quantification and monitoring of the measures needed to implement better forest stands and multi-taxon biodiversity conservation.

Relating forest structural characteristics to bat and bird diversity in the Italian Alps

The global decline of biodiversity has affected European forests, involving many tree species and forest-dwelling threatened animals. An integrated approach linking forest structure and multi-taxon diversity is increasingly needed to maintain the multifunctionality of forest ecosystems. We investigated the relationship between forest structure, deadwood elements, canopy attributes, and tree-related microhabitats on bat and bird communities in the north-eastern Italian Alps. We collected forest attributes, bats, and bird data on 40 forest plots encompassing the diversity of forest types. To assess the different contributions of each forest attribute variables we performed a two-step statistical analysis using generalised and linear models, including bat and bird taxonomical and functional diversity indices as response variables. Our findings reveal that bats and birds respond differently to variation in forest structural characteristics. Specifically, bat species richness was higher in forests with both higher standing tree and lying deadwood volume. The Shannon diversity index for bird community was higher in forests with high volumes of coarse lying deadwood and stumps. Moreover, plots with mature trees, gaps, and heterogeneous diameter distribution fostered the presence of generalist species of bats and birds, while the abundance of tree-related microhabitats was not significant for these two taxa. This study demonstrates that the optimal habitat conditions for bats and birds in Alpine forests are multifaceted. Promoting distinctive elements within forest stands and a complex forest structure through adaptations in forest management interventions would enhance the conservation of multi-taxon forest biodiversity.

The confinedness of undergrowth Picea obovata and Abies sibirica (Pinaceae) to tree-related microhabitats and their development features at various phases of post-fire succession in green-moss dark coniferous forests in the Northern Pre-Urals

Forest ecology frequently explores the role of microsite mosaics in forest communities for the regeneration of forest-forming tree species. The present study aims to find out whether the ontogenetic structure and differentiation of Siberian spruce (Picea obovata) and Siberian fir (Abies sibirica) undergrowth plants by the plant vitality are associated with their occurrence on various microsites. The study has been carried out in the Pechora-Ilych State Nature Biosphere Reserve, Russia. In green-moss fir-spruce forests, 23 temporary sample plots were established, including 1) forest communities of the intermediate phase of post-fire succession (in areas where fires happened in 1850–1900) and 2) forest communities of the late phase (in areas where there were no fires, at least since the mid-XIX century). On the study plots, P. obovata and A. sibirica undergrowth individuals were recorded indicating ontogenetic state, vitality and microsite substrate for each plant. Using the Z-criterion, a comparison of the occurrence frequencies (%) of various undergrowth groups of P. obovata and A. sibirica on various microsites has been carried out, i.e. within each species and between the studied species, as well as at each phase of post-fire succession and between the phases. The analysis showed that, in communities of both succession phases in both species, undergrowth plants of ontogenetic state im2 occurred on deadwood logs less frequently than the undergrowth plants of the earlier ontogenetic state im1. At the same time, in both species on the flat ground surface an opposite occurrence trend for these ontogenetic states was revealed. In communities of the late succession phase, A. sibirica undergrowth plants of the ontogenetic state im2 and normal vitality occurred on a flat ground surface within inter-crown sites more frequently than plants of reduced and low vitality. A comparison between the species showed that in forest communities of both succession phases, A. sibirica undergrowth plants of im1 and im2 ontogenetic states more frequently occupy flat ground surface than deadwood logs, whereas P. obovata undergrowth plants more frequently grow on deadwood logs than on the flat ground surface. In addition, in communities of the intermediate succession phase, A. sibirica undergrowth is more likely than P. obovata to be found in the under-crown sites (especially on a flat ground surface). In communities of the late succession phase, A. sibirica undergrowth more often grows in under-crown sites on the near-trunk elevations of living trees. In both species, 40–50% of im2 plants of low vitality grow in inter-crown sites. To clarify the influence of the microsite mosaics on the regeneration processes in the studied forests, more detailed and large-scale studies are further needed, which will allow us obtaining more representative samples of undergrowth plants at various ontogenetic states.

Dead Better than Alive—The Case of Retention Trees and Tree-Related Microhabitats in Young Stands of Hemiboreal Forests in Latvia

This study examines microhabitat abundance and composition on retention trees in 20 young stands in Latvia that were clear-cut between 2002 and 2004. Retention trees play a vital role in sustaining biological diversity after clear-cutting, but their mortality rate is often high due to post-harvest environmental changes. This study compares tree-related microhabitat (TreM) abundance and composition on retention trees of different dimensions, species, and vitality. The tree height and diameter were measured, and the living status and position of each tree were determined. The research questions of the study were to assess the relationships between TreMs, tree dimensions, and species, as well as to compare the occurrence of TreMs on living and dead wood. The comprehensive analysis revealed that larger tree diameters and specific tree species (Populus tremula, Fraxinus excelsior, and Salix caprea) lead to a higher abundance of TreMs. The results also highlighted the importance of preserving deadwood within forest stands as it enhances the observed abundance of TreMs. This study provides the missing information on TreMs in Latvia, thus providing data for comparison in a wider region.

Profile of tree-related microhabitats in the primeval Białowieża Forest: A benchmark for temperate woodlands

Tree-related Microhabitats (TreMs) are a key structural element having a significant impact on the biodiversity and functioning of forest ecosystems. Although forests enjoying long-term protection host richer and more abundant TreMs compared to managed stands, the quantity and quality of such microstructures in primeval temperate forests are unknown. This study investigates for the first time the assemblage of TreMs in the Białowieża Forest (BF), which is regarded as the last surviving fragment of pristine lowland forests in the temperate zone of Europe. Relatively undisturbed by human activity since the last glacial period, the BF ecosystem has remained remarkably intact, which may have given rise to its unique TreM assemblage. Here, we show that a primeval forest is characterized by an exceptionally high richness and density of TreMs compared to previously studied natural forests, and that the richness, density and diversity of TreMs are spatially heterogeneous at the micro-scale but homogeneous at the macro-scale. This indicates that adjacent small fragments of habitat (0.05 ha) may have different TreM profiles, but large patches of forest (several ha) host similar assemblages of TreMs. Our profile of TreMs depends on the basal area and density of living trees, the basal area of dead standing trees and the dominance of specific TreM-hosting tree species in a stand. Our study suggests that both the ecological continuity and complexity of a forest supporting many different tree species and the diversity of TreM-forming biota that typically occurs in primeval temperate forests are factors that appear to contribute to the observed profile of TreMs. The results of our study set a benchmark for the quantity and quality of TreMs in broadleaved temperate forests and indicate that the long-term spontaneous natural processes occurring in primeval forests lead to the emergence of ultra-rich, complex assemblages of TreMs.

Recording tree-related microhabitats to assess riparian forest contribution to biodiversity in landscapes dominated by conifer plantations

Riparian forests are considered as complex and biologically rich habitats. They play a crucial role for biodiversity conservation, in particular in landscapes under strong management pressure. Tree-related microhabitats (TreMs) support a wide array of biodiversity and some authors have suggested using them as indirect biodiversity indicators in forest ecosystems. This study investigates TreM profiles of a temperate riparian forest as last natural forest ecosystem in a context of intensively managed landscape along the Ciron river and of surrounding pine plantations of the Landes de Gascogne forest (France) and explores their drivers at tree and plot scales. A total of 28 transects perpendicular to the river, representing 84 0.1 ha-plots, were selected along the Ciron river and three of its tributaries. At tree scale, diameter at breast height (dbh), tree species and tree status (living, standing or lying dead) were significant predictors of TreM diversity. At plot scale, Alnus glutinosa was found to significantly contribute to riparian forest TreM profiles by hosting specific TreMs. The same role was highlighted for broadleaved species in pine plantations. At plot scale, the drivers of TreM diversity varied depending on plot location in the transect (riparian forest, plantation forest, intermediate area). We found that the presence of lying dead trees is an important driver of TreM diversity at plot scale, particularly in plantation stand and we thus suggest lying dead trees be included in future studies focusing on TreMs. The rich TreM profile of riparian forests highlights their crucial role in biodiversity conservation.

Trait-Based Response of Deadwood and Tree-Related Microhabitats to Decline in Temperate Lowland and Montane Forests

Trait-Based Response of Deadwood and Tree-Related Microhabitats to Decline in Temperate Lowland and Montane Forests

Drivers of tree-related microhabitat profiles in European and Oriental beech forests

Tree-related microhabitats (TreMs) provide a quantitative indicator of habitat heterogeneity in forests, including beech (Fagus) forests. However, systematic analyses of the factors driving TreM diversity and composition in Fagus sylvatica and F. orientalis forests are lacking. In this study, the TreMs of beech forests on 203 plots of 22 forest sites (production and old-growth forest) across the full longitudinal range of both species were assessed following a standardized TreM protocol. A unified diversity and ordination framework based on Hill numbers was applied to account for unobserved TreM types and to extend the sensitivity of our findings focusing from rare to dominant TreMs. The composition of TreM assemblages was mostly determined by Fagus species and elevation, a surrogate for climate, and with focus on dominant TreMs by DBH, whereas old-growth versus production forest had no effect. The coverage of detected TreMs per plot increased with the number of trees assessed and DBH, but was lower in old-growth than in production forests. When standardized for sampling coverage, the diversity of rare and dominant TreM types was higher in old-growth than in production forests, but increased with elevation only focusing on dominant TreMs. These findings corroborate regional studies showing a higher TreM diversity in old-growth forests. Moreover, they demonstrate the importance of focusing conservation efforts on forests of both Fagus species and at different elevations, covering the full range of TreM assemblages. Future studies comparing TreM diversity in different forests should standardize diversity by sample coverage, as currently done in many biodiversity studies.

Tree-related microhabitat diversity as a proxy for the conservation of beetle communities in managed forests of Fagus sylvatica

Abstract Integrating the conservation of biodiversity into silvicultural practices is one of the main challenges facing forest owners in the promotion of an emergent approach to sustainable forest management across European forests. The Mediterranean forests are among the richest biodiverse forest ecosystems due to their environmental heterogeneity, but climate change is threatening their integrity, with critical implications for the availability of ecosystem services. Forests managed for commercial purposes are under increasing pressure to provide timber while supporting biodiversity. This study aims to analyse the relationship between tree-related microhabitats (TreMs), which are structures occurring on living or standing dead trees that constitute an essential substrate for several living species, and beetles, an important indicator species group for forest biodiversity monitoring. Four generalized linear models were fitted to assess the influence of environmental factors, forest structure, and biodiversity-related parameters on the abundance and richness of beetles, mainly on saproxylic beetles. The study highlights significant associations between the abundance and richness of individual groups and types of TreMs and the Italian Red List of saproxylic species. Therefore, TreMs can serve as a tool to map, monitor, and enhance forest biodiversity in managed forests.

Evaluating state-of-the-art 3D scanning methods for stem-level biodiversity inventories in forests

Monitoring biodiversity in forests is crucial for their management and preservation, especially in light of increasing climatic disturbances. However, traditional methods of surveying forest biodiversity, such as the inventory of tree-related microhabitats (TreMs), are costly and time-consuming. For many years, terrestrial laser scanning (TLS) was the main method for producing highly accurate 3D models of forests. However, with recent advancements in 3D scanning technologies, there are now numerous alternatives available on the market. The aim of this study was to evaluate the performance of four different 3D data acquisition methods, i.e. close-range photogrammetry (CRP), fish-eye photogrammetry (FEP), mobile laser scanning (MLS), and mixed reality depth camera (MRDC), in terms of accuracy and ability to measure biodiversity (TreMs) at tree-stem level, in comparison to TLS. Analysis was performed based on geometric accuracy and point neighbourhood relevance. CRP was the most accurate alternative to TLS for TreM measurement with a median error of 1.5 cm, while FEP provided a good balance between accuracy (median error 1.4 cm) and speed of data collection. Although MLS showed promising results (median error 1.6 cm), noise in the point cloud limited its ability to identify TreMs. MRDC, on the other hand, had lower quality (median error 3.6 cm) and lower point density, making it unsuitable for TreM segmentation. Nevertheless, the study demonstrated the feasibility of augmenting the real world with virtual content at single-tree-stem level using mixed reality technology. Overall, the 3D scanning technologies presented hold great promise for recording the evolution of biodiversity at stem level.

Validation and limitations of large-scale forest condition indicators – An example from Hungary

As the multi-scale study of biodiversity is extremely resource-intensive, proxy indicators taken from various databases are often used to answer questions on a larger spatial scale. Considering differences in the scale and methods, the application of such indicators (especially from different monitoring systems) requires careful consideration and standard methods of validation.In order to demonstrate this, we validated the results of the MAES-HU (National Ecosystem Assessment of Hungary) forest condition assessment (based on the Hungarian NFD – National Forestry Database) with thematically richer, finer-scale field data. We also examined the relationships of some MAES-HU indicators with other variables significant for nature conservation, not currently included in the NFD. We found the MAES-HU scoring was similar to the fine-scale score results in the case of tree species composition indicators, however, less so for structural indicators. The MAES-HU assessment uses the values of the NFD, averaged for forest management units, and thus tends to underestimate structural variety. This highlights a potential loss of important conservation-related information. During the examination of relationships with other indicators that are not included in the large-scale MAES-HU assessment, we found that the presence of large-diameter and old trees correlates with tree-related microhabitats and large standing deadwood, but no relationship was found for other investigated indicators (game pressure, further deadwood indicators). This highlights the need for integrating some key conservation indicators (presence of old and large trees, quantity and quality of standing and lying deadwood) into existing forest monitoring systems in order to optimise the resources dedicated to multipurpose data collection. Our study also highlights that applying indicators as proxies requires the full knowledge of monitoring methods and validated indicator-indicanda relationships.

Evaluating retention forestry 10 years after its introduction in temperate forests regarding the provision of tree-related microhabitats and dead wood

The individual or grouped retention of habitat trees in managed multiple-use forests has become an approach used to protect biodiversity-related structural attributes typically found in old close-to-nature forests. This study focuses on the effect of one such retention approach in the managed forests of Baden-Württemberg, Germany, ten years after its introduction. Specifically, we asked: (1) How effective are habitat tree groups (HTGs) at providing large living trees (LLTs > 80 cm DBH), tree-related microhabitats (TreMs), and dead wood?, and (2) which tree and stand variables have the greatest influence on the occurrence of TreMs? For this purpose, we inventoried 326 HTGs and 94 reference plots in forests dominated by the most widely occurring native conifer and broadleaf tree species, silver fir (Abies alba) and European beech (Fagus sylvatica). In accordance with our hypotheses, LLTs and TreMs were significantly more abundant in HTGs than in reference plots in both forest types. More importantly, when retaining 5% of the forest area as HTGs (a common retention level), old forest attributes such as woodpecker cavities, rot-holes or exposed heartwood increased significantly at the stand level while the volume of LLTs almost tripled, and volume of snags increased by 25%. However, quantities of these two attributes remain below minimum thresholds recommended in the scientific literature. A conversion of 15–25% of the stand area into HTGs is needed to increase the stand level abundance of TreMs such as concavities, exposed sapwood, or crown dead wood significantly in the short term. At the single-tree level, tree diameter (DBH), tree species, vitality and neighborhood competition had a significant influence on modeled TreM abundance. At the stand level, TreM occurrence increased with stand age and amount of snags, whereas TreM richness declined with stand density. Ten years after introducing the retention approach, forest stands with HTGs comprised significantly more important structural attributes than those without. Selecting HTGs with high stand volume or low tree density that also include snags, a mix of tree species, LLTs, and some low-vitality habitat trees could further improve this practice.

Owner attitudes and landscape parameters drive stand structure and valuable habitats in small-scale private forests of Lower Saxony (Germany)

Small-scale private forests cover large areas in Europe and often contain structures and habitats of high nature conservation value that are increasingly put under pressure due to a rising interest in fuelwood and wood products. We investigate the distribution of variables like living tree and deadwood volumes, management intensity, diversity and density of tree-related microhabitats recorded in 81 small-scale private forest parcels in the Lower Saxon Hills (northwest Germany). We provide an assessment of the influence of predictors like the individual forest owners’ goals and activities, as stated by them in a quantitative survey, as well as landscape parameters like parcel size, slope, landscape fragmentation and forest continuity. Our results indicate that there are two types of structures of conservation value in small-scale private forests: slowly evolving structures (type A) like large-diameter living trees and tree-related microhabitats which mostly depend on landscape parameters that act on longer time scales, and fast evolving structures (type B) like deadwood that are influenced by both owner attitudes and landscape parameters. The resulting implications for integrative forest and conservation management are discussed. When considering the conservation of the slowly evolving type A structures, long-term commitments to conservation legislation, financial incentives and generation-spanning education of forest owners are necessary. Efforts to promote the faster evolving type B structures might prove particularly advantageous in small-scale private forests given the structural diversity of the stands, but also the often strong identification of owners with their land.Graphical abstract

From tree-related microhabitats to ecosystem management: A tree-scale investigation in productive forests in Estonia

A diversity of microhabitats has been suggested to play a key role in mediating the co-occurrence of trees with specific tree-inhabiting biodiversity, which may further influence ecosystem functioning. However, this triple relationship between tree characteristics, tree-related microhabitats (TreMs), and biodiversity has not been described explicitly enough to set quantitative targets of ecosystem management. The two major approaches directly targeting TreMs in ecosystem management are tree-scale field assessment of TreMs and precautionary management, which both require insights into the predictability and magnitude of specific biodiversity-TreM relationships. To obtain such insights, we analysed tree-scale relationships between the diversity of TreM development processes (four classes: peculiarity; pathology; injury; emergent epiphyte cover) and selected biodiversity variables based on 241 live trees (age range 20–188 years) of two species (Picea abies, Populus tremula) in hemiboreal forests in Estonia. We addressed the diversity and abundance of epiphytes, arthropods, and gastropods; their specific response to TreMs was disentangled from tree age and tree size effects. We found that a relatively small improvement in the biodiversity responses studied was attributable solely to TreMs, and that such contribution was more frequently observed in young trees. Unexpectedly, several age- or size-independent effects of TreMs were negative, suggesting trade-offs with other factors of biodiversity relevance (such as tree foliage suppression due to injuries that created TreMs). We conclude that tree-scale microhabitat inventories have only limited potential to resolve the general problem of providing diverse habitats for biodiversity in managed forests. The basic sources of uncertainty are that microhabitat management is mostly indirect (managing TreM-bearing trees and stands rather than TreMs themselves) and that snapshot surveys cannot address various time perspectives. We outline a set of basic principles and constraints for spatially heterogeneous and precautionary forest management that includes TreM diversity considerations. These principles can be further elaborated through multi-scale research on functional biodiversity links of TreMs.