Treatment Outcome In Obsessive-compulsive Disorder Research Articles

Incompleteness as a clinical characteristic and predictor of treatment outcome in obsessive-compulsive disorder

Incompleteness, that is, a feeling that things are “not just right”, is an understudied symptom of obsessive-compulsive disorder (OCD). We used data from 167 adult individuals with OCD who received internet-delivered cognitive behaviour therapy (ICBT) to examine how incompleteness was associated with clinical characteristics and treatment outcomes. Incompleteness was assessed using the Obsessive-Compulsive Trait Core Dimensions Questionnaire (OCTCDQ). Results showed that the proposed two-factor structure of the OCTCDQ had adequate model/data fit in the present sample. Incompleteness was positively associated with baseline symmetry/ordering symptoms (β = 0.52, [95% CI 0.48 to 0.56], p < 0.001), psychiatric comorbidity (β = 0.23, [95% CI 0.21 to 0.25], p < 0.05) and self-reported symptom severity (Y-BOCS-SR β = 0.35, [95% CI 0.27 to 0.43], p < 0.001; OCI-R β = 0.46, [95% CI 0.34 to 0.59], p < 0.001). Results showed that higher degree of incompleteness predicted a worse treatment outcome on clinician-rated, but not self-rated, measures of symptom severity. Participants with a high (vs. low) degree of incompleteness were less likely to be classified as responders (39% vs. 52%) and remitters (10% vs. 34%) at post-treatment. The results suggest that incompleteness is a clinically relevant feature of OCD, which may require treatment adaptations for some patients but more research is needed to confirm that the findings are not entirely due to measurement error.

The relationship between homework adherence and outcome in family-based cognitive-behavioral therapy for early-onset obsessive compulsive disorder

Family-based cognitive behavioral therapy (CBT) is an effective treatment for obsessive compulsive disorder (OCD), but not all children respond. Children with early-onset OCD may exhibit poorer outcomes, possibly due to developmental factors that affect treatment engagement and distress tolerance, which may ultimately affect treatment dose. Homework adherence between sessions can increase treatment dose and predict improved outcome. However, no studies have specifically examined the effect of homework adherence on treatment outcome for early-onset OCD. This study examined homework adherence during family-based CBT for young children (N = 63) with early-onset OCD. Caregiver and child homework adherence were rated weekly by clinicians and symptom change was assessed at multiple timepoints across treatment. Caregivers and children were both rated as highly adherent with homework, although caregivers were rated as more adherent than children. Structural equation modeling indicated that early homework adherence predicted later homework adherence, which predicted improved treatment outcome.

Cognitive and Experienced Flexibility in Patients With Anorexia Nervosa and Obsessive Compulsive Disorder.

ObjectiveAnorexia nervosa (AN) and obsessive-compulsive disorder (OCD) share a neuropsychological profile characterized by cognitive inflexibility as evident in set-shifting problems, and by strong detail focus. Clinically, both patient groups display a strong rigidity which may be explained by these neurocognitive difficulties. Cognitive inflexibility may hinder treatment uptake and help explain suboptimal treatment outcomes in both AN and OCD. This is the first study to compare clinical AN and OCD groups andto examine similarities and differences in cognitive flexibility. Specifically, this study aims to investigate neuropsychological outcomes and self-reported difficulties in both clinical groups and a control group, and explore associations between the different flexibility outcomes and illness.MethodTwo hundred participants (61 AN, 72 OCD and 67 HC) performed neuropsychological tasks on set-shifting abilities (Trail Making Task, Stroop color-word interference, Intradimensional-Extradimensional shift task), detail focus (Group Embedded Figures Test) and self-reported set-shifting abilities and attention to detail (DFlex).ResultsSimilarities between patient groups were found in terms of reduced set-shifting ability on the Trail Making Task and detail focus. Moreover, both patient groups self-reported more set-shifting problems but a less strong detail focus than HC, which in turn were not related to neuropsychological task outcomes in either of the groups. In both patient groups longer illness duration was associated to longer reaction times in the switching tasks and for both groups symptom severity was associated to higher experienced inflexibility and attention to detail.ConclusionCognitive inflexibility processes are largely similar in patients with AN and OCD. Both patient groups report inflexibility, yet this is unrelated to neuropsychological outcomes. Illness duration seems to contribute to poorer set-shifting and higher illness severity is linked to more experienced inflexibility. Findings highlight the need for entangling different domains of cognitive flexibility and detail focus and examining self-report measures for a cohesive understanding of clinically relevant flexibility weaknesses in AN and OCD.

The Behavior Avoidance Test: Association With Symptom Severity and Treatment Outcome in Obsessive-Compulsive Disorder.

Behavior therapy of obsessive-compulsive disorder (OCD) aims to reduce avoidance, rituals, and discomfort in OCD-relevant situations. The Behavioral Avoidance Test (BAT) measures these behavior-related outcomes in individually challenging OCD-related situations. The association of the BAT with OCD severity measures and its relevance for treatment outcome is, however, still unclear. The current study investigates with a retrospective analysis of a subsample of a pilot study, (1) if reactions on the BAT are related to OCD severity measures in an OCD sample (n = 28), (2) if treatment with two variants of cognitive-behavior therapy (exposure and response prevention vs. metacognitive therapy) changes the BAT scores and (3) if these changes as well as pretreatment BAT avoidance are relevant for OCD treatment outcome as measured by the Yale-Brown Obsessive Compulsive Scale (Y-BOCS). Participants rated avoidance, ritual, and discomfort in three individually challenging OCD-related situations before and after therapy. For one of these situations, BAT dimensions were rated by the therapist and an independent rater in addition to the patients' ratings. Correlational analyses found significant correlations between BAT discomfort and OCD severity measures like the Y-BOCS. A repeated measures ANOVA with pre- and posttest scores showed that all three BAT dimensions significantly decreased during both treatments. Hierarchical regression analyses (controlling for Y-BOCS pretest scores) revealed that changes in BAT discomfort as well as pretreatment BAT avoidance scores predicted the Y-BOCS posttest score. These findings suggest that the BAT is a distinct measure of behavior-related outcomes partly being relevant for OCD treatment outcome.

Trajectory of Change in Parental Accommodation and Its Relation to Symptom Severity and Impairment in Pediatric OCD.

Family accommodation (FA) has been shown to relate to poorer treatment outcomes in pediatric obsessive compulsive disorder (OCD), yet few studies have examined the trajectory of change in FA throughout treatment and its relation to treatment outcomes. This study examined change in FA in relation to change in symptom severity and impairment in 63 youth receiving a family-based intervention for early-onset OCD. FA, symptom severity and functional impairment were assessed at baseline, week 5, week 9, and post-treatment (week 14). Results suggested that changes in FA in the beginning stages of treatment preceded global symptom improvement (but not OCD specific improvement) whereas changes in functional impairment preceded changes in FA. In the latter half of treatment, changes in FA preceded improvement in global and OCD specific symptom severity as well as functional impairment. These findings highlight the importance of reducing FA, especially in the later stages of treatment, in order to optimize treatment outcomes in early-onset OCD.

Electroencephalographic Correlates and Predictors of Treatment Outcome in OCD: A Brief Narrative Review.

Electroencephalography (EEG) measures the brain's electrical activity with high temporal resolution. In comparison to neuroimaging modalities such as MRI or PET, EEG is relatively cheap, non-invasive, portable, and simple to administer, making it an attractive tool for clinical deployment. Despite this, studies utilizing EEG to investigate obsessive-compulsive disorder (OCD) are relatively sparse. This contrasts with a robust literature using other brain imaging methodologies. The present review examines studies that have used EEG to examine predictors and correlates of response in OCD and draws tentative conclusions that may guide much needed future work. Key findings include a limited literature base; few studies have attempted to predict clinical change from EEG signals, and they are confounded by the effects of both pharmacotherapy and psychotherapy. The most robust literature, consisting of several studies, has examined event-related potentials, including the P300, which several studies have reported to be abnormal at baseline in OCD and to normalize with treatment; but even here the literature is quite heterogeneous, and more work is needed. With more robust research, we suggest that the relatively low cost and convenience of EEG, especially in comparison to fMRI and PET, make it well-suited to the development of feasible personalized treatment algorithms.

The behavior avoidance test: Association with symptom severity and treatment outcome in obsessive-compulsive disorder

The behavior avoidance test: Association with symptom severity and treatment outcome in obsessive-compulsive disorder

Health anxiety symptoms in pediatric obsessive-compulsive disorder: patient characteristics and effect on treatment outcome.

The aim was to explore the potential clinical role of health anxiety (HA) symptoms in children and adolescents diagnosed with obsessive-compulsive disorder (OCD). The study investigated differences in demographic and various clinical variables between young people with OCD, with and without HA symptoms, and the effect of HA symptoms on overall OCD treatment outcome. The study sample comprised 269 children and adolescents with OCD (aged 7-17years) from the large Nordic Long-term OCD Treatment Study. OCD symptoms and severity were assessed with The Children's Yale-Brown Obsessive-Compulsive Scale (CY-BOCS), which includes one item regarding HA-like obsessions and one item regarding HA-like compulsions that were used to define the HA group. Several other instruments were used to assess comorbidity and other clinical aspects. All participants were treated with 14 weekly protocolled sessions of exposure-based cognitive behavioral therapy (CBT). HA symptoms were present in 31% of participants. Other anxiety symptoms and comorbid anxiety disorders were more prevalent among those with HA symptoms. These patients also presented with significantly more types of OCD symptoms. HA symptoms were reduced following OCD treatment with CBT and having HA symptoms did not affect CBT outcome. Results suggest that pediatric OCD with HA symptoms is characterized by more anxiety symptoms and a more heterogeneous OCD symptom profile. Standardized CBT seems equally effective in treating child and adolescent OCD with or without HA symptoms.Clinical trials registration: Nordic Long-term Obsessive-Compulsive Disorder Treatment Study: www.controlled-trials.com ; ISRCTN66385119.

Indices of change in exposure and response prevention for contamination-based OCD

Few studies have examined indices of change in treatment for obsessive compulsive disorder (OCD). The current study evaluated within- and between-session trajectories of fear, disgust, and urge to wash in exposure and response prevention (ERP) for contamination-based OCD and tested whether change in these indices were associated with treatment outcomes. Forty-one participants (75.6% female) engaged in three sessions of ERP for contamination OCD. Participants provided ratings of fear, disgust, and urge to wash during each session, and contamination symptoms were assessed at pre- and post-treatment and two-week follow-up. Fear, disgust, and urge to wash all significantly decreased both within and between sessions. Both fear and disgust declined significantly faster than urge to wash within session, though declines in fear and disgust did not significantly differ from each other. Within-session changes in fear were significantly associated with reduced symptoms at post-treatment, whereas within-session changes in disgust were associated with symptoms at two-week follow-up. The current study highlights the roles of fear and disgust in the context of ERP as unique indicators of treatment outcome for contamination-based OCD. Only within-session fear was uniquely associated with treatment outcome at post, while within-session disgust predicted outcome at follow-up. Theoretical and clinical implications are discussed.

Predictors of family accommodation in obsessive compulsive disorder.

Family accommodation (FA) has been consistently recognized as a predictor of treatment outcome in obsessive-compulsive disorder (OCD). However, the factors determining FA are not clearly understood, especially in adult patients with OCD. We recruited a consecutive sample of predominantly adult subjects (n=100), who presented to the specialty OCD Clinic with a primary diagnosis of OCD along with a suitable caregiver. Patient and family members completed measurements assessing FA along with other clinical variables of interest. Clinical variables found statistically significant in bivariate analyses (p < 0.05) were examined in multivariate linear regression analysis to determine the predictors of FA. Age, gender and marital status of the patient, contamination symptom dimension, severity of avoidance, severity scores on Yale-Brown Obsessive Compulsive Scale (Y-BOCS) and scores on work and social adjustment scale were associated with FA in bivariate analysis. In multiple regression analysis, contamination dimension, the severity of avoidance, relationship of caregiver and poorer work and social adjustment predicted FA. Patients with poor socio-occupational functioning, severe avoidance, caregiver being spouse and contamination related symptoms are accommodated more by family members. Screening and management of FA, particularly in patients with the contamination dimension may thus help improve treatment outcome.

Obsessive-compulsive symptoms and their links to depression and anxiety in clinic- and community-based pediatric samples: A network analysis

BackgroundSymptoms of depression and anxiety are common in children with obsessive-compulsive disorder (OCD) and associated with more severe OCD, greater impairment, and worse treatment outcome. Beyond twin studies showing that genetic factors contribute to the high co-occurrence, few studies have examined how OCD, depression, and anxiety are linked in youth, and current studies often fail to account for OCD and anxiety heterogeneity. MethodsNetwork analysis was used to investigate how OCD were linked to depression and anxiety in multinational youth diagnosed with OCD (total n = 419) and in school-recruited, community-based samples of youth (total n = 2 991). ResultsInitial results aligned with earlier work showing that severity of obsession-related symptoms are important in linking OCD to depression in youth with OCD. However, when symptom content of OCD (e.g., washing, ordering) was fully taken into account and when measures of anxiety were included, specific OCD symptom dimensions (primarily obsessing and doubting/checking) were linked to specific anxiety dimensions (primarily panic and generalized anxiety) which in turn were linked to depression. These results were replicated in three separate community-based samples from Chile, Italy, and Spain using different measures of anxiety and depression. LimitationsCross-sectional data were analyzed which precludes causal inference. Self-report measures were used. ConclusionsYouth with OCD with symptoms related to doubting/checking and obsessing should be carefully assessed for symptoms of panic and generalized anxiety. Non-responders to standard OCD treatment may benefit from interventions targeting panic and generalized anxiety, but more research is needed to test this hypothesis.

Predictors of treatment outcome in OCD: An interpersonal perspective

Although effective treatments for obsessive compulsive disorder (OCD) are increasingly available, a considerable percentage of patients fails to respond or relapses. Predictors associated with improved outcome of OCD were identified. However, information on interpersonal determinants is lacking. This study investigated the contribution of attachment style and expressed emotion to the outcome of exposure and response prevention (ERP), while accounting for previously documented intrapersonal (i.e., symptom severity and personality pathology) predictors. Using logistic regression analyses and multi-level modeling, we examined predictors of treatment completion and outcome among 118 adult OCD patients who entered ERP. We assessed outcome at post treatment, and at four and 13 months from treatment completion. OCD baseline severity and fearful attachment style emerged as the main moderators of treatment outcome. Severe and fearfully attached patients were more likely to dropout prematurely. The improvement of fearful clients was attenuated throughout treatment and follow-up compared to non-fearful clients. However, their symptom worsening at the long-term was also mitigated. Severe OCD patients had a more rapid symptom reduction during treatment and at follow-up, compared to less severe clients. The findings suggest that both baseline OCD severity and fearful attachment style play a role in the long-term outcome of ERP.

Does Family Accommodation Predict Outcome of Concentrated Exposure and Response Prevention for Adolescents?

Findings suggest that increased levels of family accommodation are associated with a poorer treatment outcome in obsessive-compulsive disorder (OCD). A concentrated treatment format, the Bergen 4-day treatment (B4DT), has previously demonstrated promising results in the treatment of adolescents with OCD. The present paper examined changes in family accommodation and investigated whether family accommodation predicted outcome, in a sample of 63 adolescents (age range 11-18) participating in the B4DT. There were significant reductions on CY-BOCS and FAS from pre- to post-treatment and from pre-treatment to follow-up (p < 0.001), with large within-group effect sizes on both measures. Pre-treatment levels of symptom severity or family accommodation was not found to predict outcome at post-treatment or at follow-up. Less OCD-related functional impairment at pre-treatment predicted a better outcome at both post-treatment and follow-up. The findings suggest that the B4DT significantly reduces OCD-symptoms regardless of pre-treatment levels of family accommodation or OCD severity.

Improving treatment outcome in obsessive-compulsive disorder: Does motivational interviewing boost efficacy?

Although exposure and response prevention (ERP) is the first line psychological treatment for individuals with obsessive compulsive disorder (OCD), many people experience partial recovery and others refuse treatment or drop out. This randomized controlled study (n= 40) examined the effect of a three-session motivational interviewing (MI) intervention compared to a three-session relaxation intervention prior to 15 sessions of ERP on treatment dropout, homework compliance, and treatment outcome post-ERP and at follow up. Contrary to hypotheses, there were no group differences in ERP dropout rates or homework compliance. Both groups experienced significant reductions in OCD symptoms post-ERP. Consistent with our hypothesis, the MI group experienced a greater reduction in OCD symptoms (clinician-rated YBOCS) compared to the comparison group immediately post-ERP. However, this difference did not hold over 12-month follow up. There were also no group differences in associated symptoms (depression, anxiety, stress) across treatment. All participants achieved significant symptom reductions that were maintained over time. A correlational analysis of the whole sample revealed that action scores pre-ERP were significantly negatively correlated with post-ERP OCD symptom severity. These findings suggest that MI prior to ERP may confer a small but meaningful benefit for enhancing treatment outcome post ERP.

Anxiety Sensitivity, Obsessive Beliefs, and the Prediction of CBT Treatment Outcome for OCD

Cognitive behavioral therapy (CBT) is an effective treatment for obsessive-compulsive disorder (OCD) although a significant proportion of clients remain symptomatic following treatment. Knowledge regarding individual differences that influence treatment response could help guide future augmentations to CBT. The current study examined two potential predictors of treatment response to CBT for OCD: anxiety sensitivity and obsessive beliefs. Participants (n = 93) with a primary diagnosis of OCD completed measures of anxiety sensitivity (Anxiety Sensitivity Index (ASI); Reiss et al. in Behaviour Research and Therapy, 24(1), 1–8, 1986) and obsessive beliefs (Obsessive Belief Questionnaire (OBQ): OCCWG in Behaviour Research and Therapy, 35(7), 667–681, 1997, 39(8), 987–1006, 2001) before engaging in a course of group CBT for OCD. Obsessive-compulsive symptom severity was measured (Yale-Brown Obsessive-Compulsive Scale; Goodman et al. in Archives of General Psychiatry, 46(11), 1012–1016, 1989a, 1006–1011, 1989b) before and upon treatment completion. Results indicated a significant two-way interaction, whereby elevated ASI-Physical scores by elevated OBQ-Importance/Control significantly predicted higher post-treatment symptom severity. These results have implications for the cognitive modeling of OCD and its treatment with CBT.

Sleep disturbances in treatment-seeking OCD-patients: Changes after concentrated exposure treatment.

Research indicates that patients with Obsessive Compulsive Disorder (OCD) frequently suffer from comorbid sleep difficulties, and that these difficulties often are not clinically recognized and diagnosed. There has been limited research investigating if comorbid sleep difficulties impair treatment outcome for OCD and if the sleep difficulties change following OCD-treatment. Thirty-six patients with obsessive compulsive disorder underwent concentrated exposure treatment delivered in a group over four consecutive days and were assessed with measures of OCD, depressive symptoms and sleep disturbance at three different time points (pre, post and 6 months follow-up). The sample was characterized by a high degree of comorbidity with other psychiatric disorders. At pre-treatment nearly 70% of the patients reported sleep difficulties indicative of primary insomnia. The results showed that patients had large reductions of OCD-symptoms as well as significant improvements in sleep disturbance assessed after treatment, and that these improvements were maintained at follow-up. Sleep disturbance did not impair treatment outcome, on the contrary patients with higher degree of sleep disturbance at pre-treatment had better outcome on OCD-symptoms after treatment. The results indicated that the majority of the OCD sample suffered from sleep disturbances and that these sleep disturbances were significantly reduced following adequate treatment of OCD without specific sleep interventions. However, a proportion of the patients suffered from residual symptoms of insomnia after treatment.

Prediction of outcome in internet-delivered cognitive behaviour therapy for paediatric obsessive-compulsive disorder: A machine learning approach.

There are no consistent predictors of treatment outcome in paediatric obsessive-compulsive disorder (OCD). One reason for this might be the use of suboptimal statistical methodology. Machine learning is an approach to efficiently analyse complex data. Machine learning has been widely used within other fields, but has rarely been tested in the prediction of paediatric mental health treatment outcomes. To test four different machine learning methods in the prediction of treatment response in a sample of paediatric OCD patients who had received Internet-delivered cognitive behaviour therapy (ICBT). Participants were 61 adolescents (12-17years) who enrolled in a randomized controlled trial and received ICBT. All clinical baseline variables were used to predict strictly defined treatment response status three months after ICBT. Four machine learning algorithms were implemented. For comparison, we also employed a traditional logistic regression approach. Multivariate logistic regression could not detect any significant predictors. In contrast, all four machine learning algorithms performed well in the prediction of treatment response, with 75 to 83% accuracy. The results suggest that machine learning algorithms can successfully be applied to predict paediatric OCD treatment outcome. Validation studies and studies in other disorders are warranted.

Anxiety sensitivity as a predictor of outcome in the treatment of obsessive-compulsive disorder

Background and objectivesTo address the fact that not all individuals who receive cognitive-behavioral therapy (CBT) for obsessive-compulsive disorder (OCD) exhibit complete symptom reduction, research has examined factors that predict outcome; however, no studies have examined anxiety sensitivity (AS) as a predictor of outcome of CBT for OCD. AS refers to the fear of anxious arousal that results from mistaken beliefs about the dangerousness of anxiety-related body sensations. It is important to understand whether AS influences OCD treatment outcome, considering that (a) some obsessions directly relate to AS, and (b) OCD patients with high AS may be reluctant to engage in anxiety-provoking components of CBT for OCD. MethodsPatients (N = 187) with a primary diagnosis of OCD who received residential CBT for OCD participated in this study, which involved completing a self-report battery at pre- and post-treatment. ResultsResults supported study hypotheses, in that (a) baseline AS positively correlated with baseline OCD severity, and (b) greater baseline AS prospectively predicted higher posttreatment OCD symptom severity even after controlling for pretreatment OCD and depression severity. LimitationsThe study was limited by its use of an older measure of AS, reliance on self-report measures, and nonstandardized treatment across participants. ConclusionsFindings highlight the importance of AS in the nature and treatment of OCD. Clinical implications and future directions are discussed.

The Potential Use of Neuroimaging Biomarkers in the Treatment of Obsessive-Compulsive Disorder

Predicting treatment outcome in obsessive-compulsive disorder (OCD) has become an important research priority given the prevalence and disability associated with the disorder and the fact that different effective treatments exist. Here, we summarize recent studies that have used neuroimaging to predict treatment outcome across three different treatment modalities: psychological treatment (exposure and response prevention), medication, and neurosurgery. Although several neural baseline variables have been shown to predict treatment outcome in OCD, results are so far not conclusive. We highlight some limitations from the current literature and offer some conceptual and methodological suggestions for future research.

ORBITOFRONTAL THICKNESS AS A MEASURE FOR TREATMENT RESPONSE PREDICTION IN OBSESSIVE-COMPULSIVE DISORDER.

Early prediction of treatment response could reduce exposure to ineffective treatments and optimize the use of medical resources. Neuroimaging techniques have been used to identify biomarkers that are predictive of outcomes. The aims of this study were to investigate orbitofrontal cortex (OFC) thickness as a potential morphometric biomarker to discriminate outcomes in obsessive-compulsive disorder (OCD) and then to reexamine this biomarker in an independent cohort Using a logistic regression model based on the mean baseline thickness of subregions of the OFC, we estimated the probability of treatment response in 29 treatment-naïve OCD patients who participated in a clinical trial. That algorithm was then tested in an independent cohort of 12 patients with a confirmed diagnosis of refractory OCD RESULTS: Among the treatment-naïve OCD patients, measures of OFC thickness statistically significantly differentiated responders (n = 13) and nonresponders (n = 16), with an overall classification accuracy of ≈80%, a sensitivity of 77% (10/13), and a specificity of 81% (13/16). Of the refractory OCD patients in the second independent cohort, 67% were correctly classified as nonresponders. The most discriminative measures in the initial cohort of treatment-naïve patients were the thicknesses of the left and right medial OFC (P = .009 and P = .028, respectively) We found OFC thickness to be a strong predictor of treatment response in treatment-naïve OCD patients. Although there are not yet any brain imaging biomarkers with clinical utility, our results highlight the potential of these measures as tools for predicting treatment outcomes in OCD.