With an aging population, the incidence of olecranon fractures in older patients is increasing. The standard of care has traditionally included operative management for displaced fractures. Recent literature has called this standard of care into question. Older patients may be at increased risk of operative complications and may have satisfactory functional outcomes with nonoperative management. Given recently evolving evidence, the current treatment preferences of orthopedic surgeons for older patients with displaced olecranon fractures are unknown. We administered a cross-sectional survey of Canadian orthopedic surgeons via e-mail invitation and online survey form to determine treatment preferences for patients aged 65-75 and>75 years with simple displaced and comminuted displaced stable olecranon fractures. Respondents reviewed representative images and were asked to indicate their preferred treatment based on patient age. We also asked respondents to indicate their perceived importance of 11 patient factors on treatment decision-making. We received 200 responses (33.8% response rate). For patients aged 65-75 years with simple displaced fractures, surgeons preferred tension-band wiring (n=110, 56%) to plating (n=82, 42%, P=.005), while only 3% (n=5) preferred nonoperative treatment. For patients aged >75 years with simple displaced fractures, surgeons preferred operative (n=144, 73%) to nonoperative management (n=51, 26%; P<.01) with either tension-band wiring (n=77, 39%) or plating (n=67, 34%). In these patients, early range of motion (n=35, 18%) was preferred to immobilization (n=16, 8%; P=.004). For comminuted fractures, plate fixation was preferred for patients aged 65-75 years (n=189, 95%) and >75 years (n=131, 68%). In patients aged >75 years, this was followed by early range of motion (n=35, 18%) and immobilization (n=24, 13%). Of the 11 factors surveyed, participation in high-intensity activities (mean rank=9.4), independent living (mean rank=8.8), and disrupted extensor mechanism (mean rank=8.3) were ranked most highly for increasing likelihood of surgical treatment. In patients aged 65 to 75 years, operative management is favored by most surgeons, with tension-band wiring preferred over plating for simple displaced fractures. In patients aged >75 years, operative management is again preferred by most respondents for simple and comminuted fractures. Despite operative preferences, there is a paucity of quality evidence to guide treatment decision-making, particularly in patients aged >75 years.