Abstract Serum creatinine is an important biomarker used for estimating glomerular filtration rate (eGFR). The present study was designed after a patient at our institution had a significantly elevated creatinine result taken from an i-STAT point of care test that utilizes electrochemical detection. The patient’s creatinine from the i-STAT was 3.8 mg/dL and was not consistent with their clinical history. The patient’s previous creatinine taken 2 days prior was 1.39 mg/dL and 1.27 mg/dL seven days prior. Both previous readings were measured with the Siemens Dimension Vista 1500 using a colorimetric enzymatic creatinine method. A subsequent creatinine measured on the Siemens Dimension Vista 1500 was 1.30 mg/dL. Upon chart review, the clinical team noted that the patient is taking 500 mg of hydroxyurea daily for treatment of a myeloproliferative disorder. Review of the i-STAT package insert revealed hydroxyurea as a known interfering substance and states for every 100 µmol/L hydroxyurea in the specimen, creatinine will be increased by approximately 1.85 mg/dL. Review of literature described the positive interference caused by hydroxyurea for the i-STAT creatinine and glucose assays but did not explain the mechanism of this positive interference. In order to characterize the mechanism of hydroxyurea interference, we investigated the situation further. A pool of plasma was spiked with hydroxyurea. The spiked pool was serial diluted (x2, x4, x8, x16, x32, x64, x128) to observe the creatinine results in the presence of and absence of hydroxyurea. The dilution series was analyzed using the Vista enzymatic creatinine and the Abbott i-STAT enzymatic creatinine methods. The i-STAT creatinine results show increasing creatinine concentration from interference as the concentration of hydroxyurea increased. The dilution series suggests increasing positive interference with hydroxyurea. Positive creatinine interference with hydroxyurea was not observed when analyzed on the Vista platform. Hydroxyurea is a widely used treatment for myeloproliferative disorders and also for managing sickle cell disease. Hydroxyurea is known to cause positive interference in the i-STAT enzymatic creatine method that uses electrochemical detection, with the degree of interference correlating with the concentration of hydroxyurea. The Vista colorimetric enzymatic creatinine method was not observed to have hydroxyurea interference. While both methods employ enzymatic reagent systems the final detection approach is important. Patients undergoing hydroxyurea treatment should avoid i-STAT measurement systems for creatinine.