Treatment Of Benign Tracheal Stenosis Research Articles

Endoscopic treatment of benign tracheal stenosis: a single-centre study.

Benign tracheal stenosis is relatively rare but remains a significant chronic disease due to its drastic symptoms including dyspnoea and inspiratory stridor, and consequent negative effect on quality of life. Traditionally, the surgical approach by resection of the stenotic tracheal segment has been the therapy of choice. However, endoscopic techniques have arisen and may offer a safe and less invasive alternative. The aim of the retrospective study was to evaluate procedure-related safety and outcome of endoscopic treatment of benign tracheal stenosis at a single centre. The study included all patients at our institution who between 2013 and 2022 had received endoscopic treatment of benign tracheal stenosis by rigid tracheoscopy, radial incision by electric papillotomy needle and dilation (endoscopic tracheoplasty) followed by triamcinolone acetonide as a local submucosal injection and additionally, from 2020, budesonide inhalation. A total of 22 patients were treated in a total of 38 interventions, each resulting in immediate improvement of symptoms. There were no peri-interventional complications or mortality. Of the 38 interventions, 11 received no triamcinolone acetonide administration, resulting in a 54.5% recurrence rate after an average of 21.1 (±18.0) months, while 27 had local triamcinolone acetonide, with a 37% recurrence rate. Since 2020, we additionally initiated post-interventional budesonide inhalation as recurrence prophylaxis for newly admitted patients and patients with recurrences(n = 8), of whom only one (12.5%) has to date experienced a recurrence. Our results indicate that endoscopic tracheoplasty offers a safe and successful, minimally invasive alternative to open surgery for patients with benign tracheal stenosis. We recommend local administration of triamcinolone into the mucosa as an additional treatment to decrease the risk of recurrence. However, given the uncontrolled study design and low sample size, safety and effectiveness cannot be conclusively demonstrated. Nonetheless, our findings suggest promising avenues for further investigation. Further studies on the additional benefit of inhaled corticosteroids are warranted.

Modified blade: an interventional option in rigid bronchoscopy for non-resectable benign tracheal stenosis

IntroductionBenign tracheobronchial stenosis is a abnormal tracheal lumen narrowing that may incur progressive dyspnea and life-threatening hypoxemia. There is no consensus on which patients should be treated with endoscopic or surgical method. This study investigates the outcomes of bronchoscopic dilatation in the treatment of benign tracheal stenosis using a device equipped with a blade to cut the stenotic lesions with dense fibrosis.Materials and methodsThe procedure was carried out in an operating room under general anesthesia. All patients were intubated with a Rigid Bronchoscope (RB) placed just above the stenosis. Through Rigid Bronchoscopy combined modalities were used as needed: radial incisions of the mucosal stenosis with blade at the levels of 4, 8 and 12 o’clock, with back and forth movements, then the stenotic area was dilated more easily with a rigid bronchoscope. Dilatation was performed by passing the RB of increasing diameter through stenotic areas and then Balloon dilatation of increasing diameter. There were no complications during the procedure.ResultWe conducted an observational, retrospective, single-centre study in the Thoracic Surgery Unit of the University of ‘Luigi Vanvitelli’ of Naples from November 2011 to September 2021. We included all consecutive patients with benign tracheal stenosis inoperable. During the study period, 113 patients were referred to our department with benign tracheal stenosis inoperable. 61 patients were treated with the blade. During the follow-up, a recurrence of the stenosis was observed in 8 patients in the first month and in 4 patients in the third month. Instead in the patients treated with the use of laser (52 patients), during the follow-up a recurrence was observed in 16 patients in the first month and in 6 patients in the third month; no patient relapsed after 6 months and after 1 year. Long term successful bronchoscopic management with blade was attained by 99% in simple and 93% in mixed stenosis and in complex type stenosis.ConclusionOur study underlines the importance of the use of the blade in bronchoscopic treatment as a valid conservative approach in the management of patients with inoperable benign tracheal stenosis as an alternative to the use of the laser, reducing the abnormal inflammatory reaction in order to limit recurrences.

Multidisciplinary treatment of benign tracheal stenosis—a case report

Video 1 Pre-operative bronchoscopic control that showed a sub-total tracheal stenosis above tracheal cannula, with a residual tracheal lumen of 1–2 mm, at a distance of 2.5 cm from vocal cords.

Tracheal resection and modified T-tube in the treatment of benign tracheal stenosis. A retrospective study of 48 patients.

The objective was to prove efficiency of tracheal resection in the cohort of patients of our clinic and to introduce our own modification of T-cannula as a surgical alternative if tracheal resection is contraindicated. Benign tracheal stenosis, the most often represented by post tracheostomy (PTTS) and post intubation (PITS) stenosis, is a rare, but serious and potentially life-threatening medical condition. We present our experience with the management of the patients, who were referred with a benign tracheal stenosis. In the retrospective study, patient's outcome was evaluated after tracheal resection or treatment with T-cannula from all the patients presented with a benign tracheal stenosis from January 2015 to January 2021. The cohort consists of forty-eight patients. Thirty-one (64,6 %) patients underwent a tracheal resection and seventeen (35,4 %) were treated with tracheostomy and T-tube insertion. In the series of patients after tracheal resection, we observed no mortality, complications occurred in ten (32,2 %) patients. They were spread proportionally; anastomotic complications were noticed in 5 (16,1 %) patients, as well as non-anastomotic complications. Tracheal resection is a safe and effective procedure with good results. T- tube insertion presents a surgical alternative if bronchoscopy is unavailable or failed (Tab. 4, Fig. 2, Ref. 20).

Bronchoscopic management as an alternative treatment in non‐operable benign tracheal stenosis

Endoluminal therapy either by dilatation, scar tissue resection or stent insertion is an established treatment for non-malignant airway stenosis although the surgical approach is still considered the "gold standard." No clear consensus exists on the structured role of each modality. We aimed to investigate the role of bronchoscopic management in non-operable tracheal stenosis cases, evaluating the effectiveness and safety of each procedure based on a structured algorithmic approach. This prospective study was carried out on (40) consecutive patients diagnosed between March 2017 and March 2020 with tracheal stenosis not amenable to surgery. All strictures were first evaluated by flexible bronchoscopy and classified as simple or complex. Patients were treated following a standardised therapeutic algorithm approach based on published evidence and our own expertise. The mean age of the study population was 45.25±18.79; lesions were classified as simple (14) and complex (24), while two patients had mixed type stenosis. Long term success rate was 100% in simple stenosis and 87.5% in the complex ones. Stents were deployed in 24 cases, most of which were of the complex type and only two of the simple type. Post-procedural mild to moderate complications were detected overall in 70% of the patients. All complications were non-life threatening, mostly stent-related and were effectively managed. We conclude that after accurate classification and a structured algorithmic approach, interventional bronchoscopic management may play a crucial role in the effective treatment of benign tracheal stenosis.

Surgical Treatment of Benign Tracheal Stenosis: Analysis of Twenty-One Patients

Surgical Treatment of Benign Tracheal Stenosis: Analysis of Twenty-One Patients

Holmium Laser for Endoscopic Treatment of Benign Tracheal Stenosis.

Introduction Laryngotracheal stenosis is a difficult problem with varied etiology and various treatment options. The holmium laser represents another tool for the treatment of benign tracheal stenosis. Objectives To determine the utility of holmium laser treatment for benign tracheal stenosis with regards to safety and efficacy. Methods This was a retrospective case study examining patients with benign tracheal stenosis from 1998–2016 who underwent holmium laser treatment. Determining the safety of this procedure was the primary goal, and complications were monitored as a surrogate of safety. Results A total of 123 patients who underwent holmium laser treatment for benign tracheal stenosis were identified. In total, 123 patients underwent 476 procedures, with follow-up ranging from 1 month to 14 years. No intraoperative or post-operative complications were identified as a direct result of the use of this particular laser. Conclusions The holmium laser is an effective and safe laser to use for tracheal stenosis treatment. It is a contact laser with a short acting distance, which reduces the risk of injury to distal airway structures. Given the favorable experience reported here, the holmium laser should be considered when tracheal surgery is attempted.

Bronchoscopic Treatment in the Management of Benign Tracheal Stenosis: Choices for Simple and Complex Tracheal Stenosis

Bronchoscopic treatment is 1 of the treatment choices for both palliative and definitive treatment of benign tracheal stenosis. There is no consensus on the management of these patients, however, especially patients having complex stenoses. The aim of the present study was to assess, in the largest group of patients with complex stenoses yet reported, which types of tracheal stenosis are amenable to optimal management by bronchoscopic treatment. The present study was a retrospective cohort study including 132 consecutive patients with benign tracheal stenoses diagnosed between August 2005 and January 2013. The mean age of the study population was 52 ± 18 years; 62 (47%) were women and 70 (53%) were men. Their lesions were classified as simple and complex stenoses. Simple stenoses (n = 6) were treated with 12 rigid and flexible bronchoscopic procedures (mean of 2 per patient); 5 stents were placed. The total success rate was 100%. Among the 124 complex stenoses, 4 were treated directly with surgical intervention. In total, 481 rigid and 487 flexible bronchoscopic procedures were performed in these patients. In this group, the success rate was 69.8%. From the present study, we propose that after accurate classification, interventional bronchoscopic management may have an important role in the treatment of benign tracheal stenosis. Bronchoscopic treatment should be considered as first-line therapy for simple stenoses, whereas complex stenoses need a multidisciplinary approach and often require surgical intervention. However, bronchoscopic treatment may be a valid conservative approach in the management of patients with complex tracheal stenosis who are not eligible for operative treatment.

Tracheal resection with end-to-end anastomosis for post-intubation cervical tracheal stenosis: study of 14 cases

The incidence of acquired laryngeal stenosis is increasing. This retrospective study aimed to assess the long term results of circumferential resection with end-to-end tracheal anastomosis for isolated post-intubation stenosis of the cervical trachea, and to review the relevant literature. Twelve male and two female patients (aged 16-30 years, mean age 24 years) treated between February 2003 and December 2008 were included. Hospital and office records were reviewed and relevant surgical details recorded. Indications for tracheal resection anastomosis were post-intubation stenosis (78.57 per cent) and trauma (21.42 per cent). One to five tracheal rings were resected (i.e. 1-2.5 cm of cervical trachea). Tracheal anastomosis was considered successful if the patient remained asymptomatic for 24 months of close follow up (involving regular flexible bronchoscopy and neck X-ray). The anastomotic success rate was 92.85 per cent. Tracheal resection and end-to-end anastomosis is relatively safe and reliable for definitive treatment of benign tracheal stenosis in appropriate patients. Local application of mitomycin C prevents granulation and aids long term airway patency.

Montgomery T-tube placement in the treatment of benign tracheal lesions☆

Although surgery remains the gold standard for the treatment of benign tracheal stenosis, airway stenting may be indicated in the event of complex lesions or associated diseases. We retrospectively investigated Montgomery T-tube placement as an alternative or complementary treatment to surgery. From January 1984 to March 2008, 158 patients were treated for benign tracheal lesions. Eighty-three patients underwent airway resection and reconstruction as the only treatment. Seventy-five other patients with complex lesions or major associated diseases were treated with a T-tube and were retrospectively analysed. Seven of them had undergone unsuccessful treatment with Dumon stents. T-tube placement was the only procedure adopted in 51 patients with a contraindication to surgery (group I), a temporary measure in 15 patients prior to surgery (group II), and in 9 patients (group III) for complications of airway reconstruction, 5 of whom were referred from other institutions. Complications after T-tube placement were: stent dislocation in 3 (4%) patients, endoluminal granulomas in 14 (19%), subglottic edema in 3 (4%), and sputum retention in 7 (9%). Treatment of complications (tracheostomy cannula, steroid infiltration, Argon/LASER coagulation, and bronchoscopy) was required in 20 (27%) patients. In group I, the tube was removed in 12 (24%) patients after 35.3 +/- 8.2 months following resolution of the stenosis. In group II, the tubes were maintained in place before surgery for 17.1 +/- 4.8 months. In group III, three stents were removed following tracheal healing after 115.3 +/- 3.7 months. After 5 years the stents were in place in 82%, 7% and 100% of the patients, respectively in groups I, II and III. Montgomery T-tube placement represents a useful option in patients with complex benign tracheal stenosis or associated diseases as an alternative or complementary treatment to surgery, and is effective even when other types of stents are unsuccessful.

Interventional endoscopy in the management of benign tracheal stenoses: definitive treatment at long-term follow-up

Interventional bronchoscopy is one of the modalities for palliation and definitive treatment of benign tracheal stenosis. There is however no general agreement on the management of this disease. Aim of this work is to define, in the largest group of patients presented in the literature, what types of tracheal stenosis are amenable to definitive treatment by interventional endoscopy. From January 1996 to June 2006 209 consecutive patients (105 men, 104 women) with benign tracheal stenosis were referred to our center. Etiology included 167 post-intubation and 34 cases of post-tracheostomy stenoses, 8 cases of other diseases. The lesions were classified into two groups: simple and complex. All but nine patients underwent interventional procedures (mechanical dilatation, laser photoresection and placement of a silicone stent). Two years follow-up was complete for all patients. Simple stenoses (n=167) were treated by 346 endoscopic procedures (mean of 2.07 per patient), 16 stents and 1 end-to-end anastomosis. Thirty-eight granulomas were treated by 59 procedures (1.56 per patient), 97 concentrical stenoses by 228 procedures (2.35 per patient) and 32 web-like lesions with 59 operative endoscopies (1.84 per patient). Overall success rate was 96%. Among the 42 complex stenoses, 9 were immediately treated by surgical resection and the remaining 33 lesions underwent 123 endoscopic procedures (3.27 per patient), with 34 stents and 1 end-to-end anastomosis subsequent to recurrence after stent removal. In this group the success rate was 69%. Our study shows that, after a correct classification and stratification, interventional endoscopy may have a crucial role in the treatment of tracheal stenoses. In particular, endoscopy should be considered the first choice for simple stenoses, whereas complex stenoses need a multidisciplinary approach and often require surgery.

Fluoroscopic‐guided balloon dilatation and stenting in tracheal stenosis with metallic self‐expandable stents and long‐term follow‐up results

The purpose of this study was to assess the safety and long-term efficacy of self-expandable stents in the treatment of benign tracheal stenosis. Nine patients (seven men) with tracheal stenosis (including one with fistula) of varied cause were treated by fluoroscopically guided balloon dilatation and stenting with self-expandable metallic stents. The procedure was carried out under topical spray in eight patients and under general anaesthesia in one patient. The patients were followed up for a period ranging between 13 and 60 months. In eight of the nine patients, satisfactory positioning of the stent was achieved at the first instance, with immediate relief of dyspnoea. One patient with innominate artery aneurysm died 16 days after the procedure because of renal failure. At 1 month of follow up, six out of eight (75%) of our live patients were without any respiratory embarrassment. This dyspnoea-free result reached almost 90% by the end of 1 year especially so in the fibrous strictures. Four out of the eight live patients (50%) had cough for 2 months and two (25%) had mild blood-tinged sputum treated by inhalation and mucolytic agents. Secondary intervention was required in one patient at 1 month because of recurrent symptoms. The patient with tracheo-oesophageal fistula required surgical intervention because of fracture of the stent. Fluoroscopically guided balloon dilatation and stenting of the tracheal stenosis is an effective non-surgical therapy resulting in cure of fibrous strictures and palliation in cases of malignancy.

Nitinol stents in the treatment of benign proximal tracheal stenosis or tracheomalacia

Nitinol stents have been used in the treatment of benign tracheal stenosis. A retrospective review of five patients treated at Stobhill Hospital over the last six and a half years is presented. Age at presentation ranged from 17 to 76 years. The minimum follow-up period was 23 months and the maximum was 78 months. All our patients were successfully decannulated, with none requiring recannulation. Four patients developed granulation tissue related to the stent at intervals ranging from three weeks to 41 months post stenting. Topical mitomycin C application has been useful after resection of granulations using the carbon dioxide (CO2) laser. Stent migration occurred in one patient three weeks after insertion. Nitinol stents are easy to insert and effective in the treatment of tracheal stenosis, but can have associated morbidity. Their use should be considered carefully, as insertion should be regarded as permanent. Publications reporting experience and outcome with the use of Nitinol stents in the trachea are reviewed.

Efficacy and Tolerance of a New Silicone Stent for the Treatment of Benign Tracheal Stenosis: Preliminary Results

In inoperable patients with tracheal stenosis who are treated using silicone stents, stent migration occurs in 18.6% of cases. To decrease the migration rate, we have designed a new silicone stent with narrow central and larger distal parts. This study analyzes the stability and tolerance of this new stent. Preliminary prospective study conducted in two French university hospitals. Thirteen inoperable patients with benign complex tracheal stenosis due to intubation or tracheotomy. Tracheal stent insertion was performed under general anesthesia with a rigid bronchoscope. The patients were followed up clinically up to stent removal, which was planned at 18 months. Stent insertion or removal was very simple and did not differ from other silicone stents. No migration occurred after a mean follow-up of 22.8 months. Minimal granuloma formation occurred in only one patient (7.7%). Sputum retention remained similar to that with other silicone stents and could be improved by a smoother internal wall. Stents have been removed in seven patients after a mean duration of 19.6 months, with a complete stenosis cure in four cases. This new stent combines the excellent stability of the metallic stents and the tolerance and easy removal of straight silicone stents. This allows a prolonged use in order to obtain curative action.