Free transverse kinetic energy i.e. perpendicular temperature anisotropy of protons excite the electromagnetic ion/proton cyclotron instability which is pertained to waves associated with prevalent electromagnetic ion/proton cyclotron emissions in various natural regions of plasmas. The transverse dielectric response function of left hand circularly polarized electromagnetic proton cyclotron (EPC) instability is calculated for two models of nonthermal Cairns distributed plasmas. These models are distinguished according to the effective thermal velocities of protons. For the energetic nonthermal protons populations, nonthermality dependent effective temperature model is proposed which significantly contributes in the excitation of aforementioned plasma mode and cause an appreciable enhancement in the instability growth rate. Exact numerical solution of dispersion relation yields oscillatory real frequency and growth rate of instability. A comparative analysis is also carried out to examine the instability behavior in distinct nonthermal and thermal plasma models. Contemporary numerical investigations are highly beneficial to understand the intricate dynamics of space plasmas.