Transition Metal Carbene Research Articles

Redox Approaches to Carbene Generation in Catalytic Cyclopropanation Reactions

AbstractTransition metal‐catalyzed carbene transfer reactions have a century‐old history in organic chemistry and are a primary method for the synthesis of cyclopropanes. Much of the work in this field has focused on the use of diazo compounds and related precursors, which can transfer a carbene fragment to a catalyst with concomitant loss of a stable byproduct. Despite the utility of this approach, there are persistent limitations in the scope of viable carbenes, most notably those lacking stabilizing substituents. By coupling carbene transfer chemistry with two‐electron redox cycles, it is possible to expand the available starting materials that can be used as carbene precursors. In this Minireview, we discuss emerging catalytic reductive cyclopropanation reactions using either gem‐dihaloalkanes or carbonyl compounds. This strategy is inspired by classic stoichiometric transformations, such as the Simmons–Smith cyclopropanation and the Clemmensen reduction, but instead entails the formation of a catalytically generated transition metal carbene or carbenoid. We also present recent efforts to generate carbenes directly from methylene (CR2H2) groups via a formal 1,1‐dehydrogenation. These reactions are currently restricted to substrates containing electron‐withdrawing substituents, which serve to facilitate deprotonation and subsequent oxidation of the anion.

Redox Approaches to Carbene Generation in Catalytic Cyclopropanation Reactions.

Transition metal-catalyzed carbene transfer reactions have a century-old history in organic chemistry and are a primary method for the synthesis of cyclopropanes. Much of the work in this field has focused on the use of diazo compounds and related precursors, which can transfer a carbene fragment to a catalyst with concomitant loss of a stable byproduct. Despite the utility of this approach, there are persistent limitations in the scope of viable carbenes, most notably those lacking stabilizing substituents. By coupling carbene transfer chemistry with two-electron redox cycles, it is possible to expand the available starting materials that can be used as carbene precursors. In this Minireview, we discuss emerging catalytic reductive cyclopropanation reactions using either gem-dihaloalkanes or carbonyl compounds. This strategy is inspired by classic stoichiometric transformations, such as the Simmons-Smith cyclopropanation and the Clemmensen reduction, but instead entails the formation of a catalytically generated transition metal carbene or carbenoid. We also present recent efforts to generate carbenes directly from methylene (CR2H2) groups via a formal 1,1-dehydrogenation. These reactions are currently restricted to substrates containing electron-withdrawing substituents, which serve to facilitate deprotonation and subsequent oxidation of the anion.

DFT Insight into a Strain-Release Mechanism in Bicyclo[1.1.0]butanes via Concerted Activation of Central and Lateral C-C Bonds with Rh(III) Catalysis.

Transition-metal-catalyzed, strain-release-driven transformations of "spring-loaded" bicyclo[1.1.0]butanes (BCBs) are considered potent tools in synthetic organic chemistry. Previously proposed strain-release mechanisms involve either the insertion of the central C-C bond of BCBs into a metal-carbon bond, followed by β-C elimination, or the oxidative addition of the central or lateral C-C bond on the transition metal center, followed by reductive elimination. This study, employing DFT calculations on a Rh(III)-catalyzed model system in a three-component protocol involving oxime ether, BCB ester, and ethyl glyoxylate for constructing diastereoselective quaternary carbon centers, introduces an unusual strain-release mechanism for BCBs. In this mechanism, the catalytic reaction is initiated by the simultaneous cleavage of two C-C bonds (the central and lateral C-C bonds), resulting in the formation of a Rh-carbene intermediate. The new mechanism exhibits a barrier of 21.0 kcal/mol, making it energetically more favorable by 11.1 kcal/mol compared to the previously suggested most favorable pathway. This unusual reaction mode rationalizes experimental observation of the construction of quaternary carbon centers, including the excellent E-selectivity and diastereoselectivity. The newly proposed strain-release mechanism holds promise in advancing our understanding of transition-metal-catalyzed C-C bond activation mechanisms and facilitating the synthesis of transition metal carbene complexes.

IR spectroscopic characterization of 3d transition metal carbene cations, FeCH2+ and CoCH2+: periodic trends and a challenge for DFT approaches.

A combination of IR multiple-photon dissociation (IRMPD) action spectroscopy and quantum chemical calculations was employed to investigate the [M,C,2H]+ (M = Fe and Co) species. These were formed by reacting laser ablated M+ ions with oxirane (ethylene oxide, c-C2H4O) in a room temperature ion trap. IRMPD spectra for the Fe and Co species are very similar and exhibit one major band. Comparison with density functional theory (DFT) and coupled cluster with single and double excitations (CCSD) calculations allows assignment of the spectra to MCH2+ carbene structures. For these 3d transition metal systems, experimental IRMPD spectra compare relatively poorly with DFT calculated IR spectra, but CCSD calculated spectra are a much better match primarily because the M-C stretch gains significant intensity. The origins of this behavior are explored in some detail. The present results are also compared to previous results for the 4d and 5d congeners and the periodic trends in these structures are evaluated.

Gauging Radical Stabilization with Carbenes.

Carbenes, including N‐heterocyclic carbene (NHC) ligands, are used extensively to stabilize open‐shell transition metal complexes and organic radicals. Yet, it remains unknown, which carbene stabilizes a radical well and, thus, how to design radical‐stabilizing C‐donor ligands. With the large variety of C‐donor ligands experimentally investigated and their electronic properties established, we report herein their radical‐stabilizing effect. We show that radical stabilization can be understood by a captodative frontier orbital description involving π‐donation to‐ and π‐donation from the carbenes. This picture sheds a new perspective on NHC chemistry, where π‐donor effects usually are assumed to be negligible. Further, it allows for the intuitive prediction of the thermodynamic stability of covalent radicals of main group‐ and transition metal carbene complexes, and the quantification of redox non‐innocence.

Gauging Radical Stabilization with Carbenes

AbstractCarbenes, includingN‐heterocyclic carbene (NHC) ligands, are used extensively to stabilize open‐shell transition metal complexes and organic radicals. Yet, it remains unknown, which carbene stabilizes a radical well and, thus, how to design radical‐stabilizing C‐donor ligands. With the large variety of C‐donor ligands experimentally investigated and their electronic properties established, we report herein their radical‐stabilizing effect. We show that radical stabilization can be understood by a captodative frontier orbital description involving π‐donation to‐ and π‐donation from the carbenes. This picture sheds a new perspective on NHC chemistry, where π‐donor effects usually are assumed to be negligible. Further, it allows for the intuitive prediction of the thermodynamic stability of covalent radicals of main group‐ and transition metal carbene complexes, and the quantification of redox non‐innocence.

Schrock‐TypeSilylidenesandGermylidenesFound Among the Silylene and Germylene Complexes of the Early and Mid‐Transition Metals

AbstractThe chemistry of Schrock‐type silylidene/germylidene complexes is the subject of this review. This is preceded by the general consideration of the prototypical transition metal carbene complexes and their classification as either Fischer or Schrock carbene complexes. Following this background, silylene/germylene complexes of the early (groups 3–4) and mid‐ (groups 5–7) transition metals are briefly discussed in terms of their synthesis and nature of the transition metal‐silylene/germylene bonding interaction. Major attention will be paid for the preparation, bonding nature, and particular reactivity of those complexes, which, on the basis of their spectroscopic, structural, and computational studies, are reliably categorized as the Schrock‐type silylene/germylene transition metal complexes, that is silylidenes/germylidenes.

Photoactive N‐heterocyclic carbene transition metal complexes in bond‐forming photocatalysis: State‐of‐the‐art and opportunities

AbstractThis Minireview presents and discusses recent developments in photoactive/photoluminescent N‐heterocyclic carbene (NHC) transition metal complexes and their viability as catalysts in bond‐forming photocatalysis. Specifically, we summarise key structural motifs adopted by photoactive NHC transition metal complexes and highlight some of their photophysical properties. Representative examples of their applications as catalysts in bond‐forming photochemical reactions are also showcased presenting the state‐of‐the‐art and future opportunities for this exciting class of NHC transition metal complexes.

Partial Double Metal-Carbon Bonding Model in Transition Metal Methyl Compounds.

The chemical bond between a transition metal and a methyl group (M-CH3) is typically defined as a single covalent bond, which is of fundamental significance and general interest in understanding the structural properties and reactivity of transition metal alkyl compounds. Herein, we demonstrate that the M-CH3 bonding involves varying σ and π components and thus should be best described in terms of the partial double M═CH3 bond. The often-neglected π bonding stems from an occupied π-symmetric orbital of the methyl group comprising all three C-H σ bonds (but one C-H' contributes more than the other two) and a vacant low-lying metal d(π) orbital, and is associated with the intramolecular C-H'···M agostic effect (i.e., an acute M-C-H' angle and a short H'···M distance), whose origin is still controversial. We quantify the geometric and energetic impacts of the π interaction involved in the M-CH3 bond by explicitly computing the intramolecular πCH' → dM interaction with the ab initio valence bond (VB) theory. Our computations of the ligand-free [TiCH3]3+ and a series of metallocene catalysts provide a direct proof for the presence of the π bonding in M-CH3 bonds, which is the cause for the agostic effect. The partial double M═CH3 bonding model is not only validated by a range of bonding analyses including VB self-consistent field (VBSCF)-based energy decomposition and quantum theory of atoms in molecules (QTAIM) but also authenticated by the specific activity of double M═CH3 bonds in the C-H activation and olefin insertion. More importantly, the σ bond gradually switches from a classical covalent bond to a novel charge-shift bond with the π bonding becoming increasingly significant. We anticipate that the recognition of the π interaction between electrophilic metal centers and C-H bonds can benefit the understanding of the nature of metal-carbon bonds in transition metal ethyl, alkyl, and carbene compounds.

Evidence for πCHR→dM bonding in transition metal carbene compounds (LnMCHR) and its decisive role in the α-agostic effect.

It has been generally recognized that the α-agostic interaction (M⋯H-C) in transition metal carbene compounds LnMCHR (R = H, Me etc.) can be interpreted with a double metal-carbon bonding model. This bonding model involves the reorganization of the σ component, which can be illustrated in terms of three-center two-electron (3c-2e) M-H-C covalent bond as in transition metal alkyl compounds. Herein, we propose an alternative partial triple metal-carbon bonding model to elucidate the agostic interaction in LnMCHR. Apart from the well-defined σ and π bonds, there exists a seemingly weak but decisive third force, namely the πCHR→dM bonding between an occupied π-like symmetric CHR orbital and a vacant metal d orbital, which is the true origin of the α-agostic effect. This partial triple bonding model is authenticated on both Fischer- and Schrock-type carbenes by an ab initio valence bond (VB) method or the block-localized wavefunction (BLW) method, which has the capability to quantify this notable π bonding and further demonstrate its geometric, energetic and spectral impacts on agostic transition metal carbene compounds. We also show that ancillary ligands can modulate the πCHR→dM bonding through electronic and steric effects.

Valorization of a CO2‐Derived Lactone by Acyclic Diene Metathesis Polymerization

AbstractThe exploitation of carbon dioxide (CO2) as a feedstock for the chemical processes has been an evasive venture due to its thermodynamic stability. The synthesis of highly functionalized metastable δ‐lactone (3‐ethylidene‐6‐vinyltetrahydro‐2H‐pyran‐2‐one) was reported in 1970s which is formed by the condensation of CO2 and 1,3‐butadiene in the presence of palladium catalyst. Several attempts have been made to utilize the intermediate for the polymerization processes, however, only a few have been successful. Here, we report a novel mechanism of metathesis polymerization of the metastable monomer by the action of a transition metal carbene complex (Hoveyda Grubb's II generation catalyst) to yield a new class of materials. The reaction mechanism for the polymerization has been proposed and substantiated by nuclear magnetic spectroscopic analysis. The obtained polymeric species consist of a complex unit structure where the cyclic lactone groups are connected by the olefin groups in different combinations.

Electrocyclizations of Conjugated Azapolyenes Produced in Reactions of Azaheterocycles with Metal Carbenes

Conjugated azapolyenes (azabuta-1,3-dienes, aza-/diaza-/oxaza-/oxadiazahexa-1,3,5-trienes) are highly reactive in electrocyclization reactions, which makes them convenient precursors for the synthesis of a wide range of four-, five-, and six-membered nitrogen heterocycles that are of relevance for medicinal chemistry. Ring opening reactions of 2H-azirines and azoles containing an N–N or N–O bond, initiated by a transition metal carbene, have become increasingly important in recent years, since they easily allow the generation of azapolyenes with different numbers of double bonds and heteroatoms in various positions. This review summarizes the literature, published mainly in the last decade, on the synthetic and mechanistic aspects of electrocyclizations of azapolyenes generated by the carbene method.

Recent progress in electro- and photo-catalytic CO2 reduction using N-heterocyclic carbene transition metal complexes

CO2 is the main gas causing the greenhouse effect. Electro-/photo-catalysts are important in CO2 reduction for sustainable utilization. Structurally diverse N-heterocyclic carbene (NHC) ligands are highly electronically and sterically tunable. Transition metal complexes with N-heterocyclic carbene ligands have been recently emerging as potential catalysts for electro-/photo-catalytic CO2 reduction. This review focuses on recent structural development and performance evolution of NHC-TM complexes in electro-/photo-catalytic CO2 reduction.

Computational Insights into Different Mechanisms for Ag-, Cu-, and Pd-Catalyzed Cyclopropanation of Alkenes and Sulfonyl Hydrazones.

The [2+1] cycloaddition reaction of a metal carbene with an alkene can produce important cyclopropane products for synthetic intermediates, materials, and pharmaceutical applications. However, this reaction is often accompanied by side reactions, such as coupling and self-coupling, so that the yield of the cyclopropanation product of non-silver transition-metal carbenes and hindered alkenes is generally lower than 50 %. To solve this problem, the addition of a low concentration of diazo compound (decomposition of sulfonyl hydrazones) to alkenes catalyzed by either CuOAc or PdCl2 was studied, but side reactions could still not be avoided. Interestingly, however, the yield of cyclopropanation products for such hindered alkenes were as high as 99 % with AgOTf as a catalyst. To explain this unexpected phenomenon, reaction pathways have been computed for four different catalysts by using DFT. By combining the results of these calculations with those obtained experimentally, it can be concluded that the efficiency of the silver catalyst is due to the barrierless concerted cycloaddition step and the kinetic inhibition of side reactions by a high concentration of alkene.

Non‐Canonical Reactivity of Gold Carbene with Alkyne: An Overview of the Mechanistic Premise

AbstractThe unique nature of gold carbene and its synchronous counterpart gold‐stabilized carbocation, is mainly responsible for the non‐canonical reactivity profile that it demonstrates in comparison to any other transition metal carbene. Being an important subset to this class, reactions of gold carbene with alkyne sponsor products far more diverse than cyclopropenation as canonically expected in case of other transition metal carbenes. These gold‐catalyzed reactions have largely been proposed to follow either a [1,n]‐carbene transfer process or an alternate pathway involving a direct interception of the β‐gold vinyl cation with a nucleophile at the cationic carbon. Despite of a clear distinction in structure, bonding and energy of a vinyl gold carbene and β‐gold vinyl cation; they have been found to exhibit identical reactivities like cyclopropenation, C(sp2)–H insertion, etc. making it extremely difficult to “experimentally” investigate and validate a mechanistic pathway. It is because of lack of conclusive experimental evidence, in addition to the limited number of detailed computational studies, that multiple pathways have been proposed simultaneously to rationalize the product formation. As an effort to shed light on the mechanisms of these reactions, herein, documentation of these reactions with a focus on their mechanistic premise has been presented.

Recent advances on N-heterocyclic carbene transition metal complexes for dehydrogenative catalysis using alcohols

N-heterocyclic carbenes (NHCs) are green and versatile ligands for the development of transition metal (TM) catalysts. Presented is a brief overview of recent advances on NHC-TM complexes for dehydrogenative catalysis using alcohols. Various NHC-TM complexes, mostly based on noble metals Ir, Ru, and Os, as well as some non-noble metals like Cu, Mo, and Mn, are described. These NHC-TM complexes have been applied to acceptorless alcohol dehydrogenation (AAD) to aldehydes or ketones, and dehydrogenative coupling of alcohols for CO bond, CC bond, CN or CN bond formation. In comparison, the NHC-based Ru and Ir systems are relatively widely studied, the development of NHC-based non-noble metals catalysts is still in its infant for sustainable dehydrogenative catalysis using alcohols.

Facing the Challenges of Borderline Oxidation State Assignments Using State-of-the-Art Computational Methods.

The oxidation state (OS) of metals and ligands in inorganic complexes may be defined by carefully curated rules, such as from IUPAC, or by computational procedures such as the effective oxidation state (EOS) or localized orbital bonding analysis (LOBA). Such definitions typically agree for systems with simple ionic bonding and innocent ligands but may disagree as the boundary between ionic and covalent bonds is approached, or as the role of ligand noninnocence becomes nontrivial, or high oxidation states of metals are supported by heavy dative bonding, and so on. This work systematically compares IUPAC, EOS, and LOBA across a series of complexes where OS assignment is challenging. These systems include high-valent transition metal oxides, transition metal complexes with noninnocent ligands such as dithiolate and nitrosyl, metal sulfur dioxide adducts, and two transition metal carbene complexes. The differences in OS assignment by the three methods are carefully discussed, demonstrating the synergy between EOS and LOBA. In addition, a clarity index for LOBA OS assignments is introduced that provides an indication of whether or not its predictions are close to the ionic-covalent boundary.

Manifestation of the β-Silicon Effect in the Reactions of Unsaturated Systems Involving a 1,2-Silyl Shift

Many chemical transformations of organosilicon compounds proceed due to the capability of silyl substituents to stabilize a positive charge in its β-position. This short review provides an overview of the present understanding of the β-silicon effect and focusses on the synthetic applications of 1,2-silyl shifts resulting from non-vertical stabilization of alkylcarbenium ions and vinyl cations. The reactions of silicon containing unsaturated starting materials, alkenes, allenes, and alkynes, involving β-silyl group stabilized cationic intermediates, transition metal carbenes, or vinylidene complexes will be discussed.1 Introduction2 Origins of the β-Silicon Effect3 Reactions of Allenylsilanes4 Reactions of Alkynes4.1 Propargylsilanes4.2 Alkynylsilanes5 Reactions of Alkenes5.1 Allylsilanes5.2 Vinylsilanes6 Conclusions

Carbene complex formation versus cyclometallation from a phosphoryl-tethered methanide ruthenium complex

An oxophosphoryl-substituted methanide ligand system for transition metal complexes has been synthesized and isolated as the sodium salt Na[Ph2P(O)–C(H)–SO2Ph]. This ligand features structural components known to enable the isolation of nucleophilic late transition metal carbene complexes. The corresponding ruthenium(cymene) chlorido complex was readily available by simple salt metathesis reaction. However, in contrast to previously reported thio- and iminophosphoryl-tethered ligand systems, dehydrohalogenation of the chlorido complex led to the formation of a cyclometallated ruthenium complex instead of the carbene complex. All compounds have been characterized in solution and solid state. Additional density functional theory (DFT) studies have been performed to elucidate the mechanism of the observed cyclometallation and to shed light on the effects of different P(V) groups in the ligand system on the stability and reactivity of the corresponding carbene complexes. The calculations show that the weaker coordination of the PO compared to the PS or PN moiety is responsible for the more facile C–H activation.

Deuteration of Formyl Groups via a Catalytic Radical H/D Exchange Approach.

H/D exchange at formyl groups represents the straightforward approach to C-1 deuterated aldehydes. This transformation has been recently realized by transition metal and NHC carbene catalysis. Mechanistically, all these processes involve an ionic pathway. Herein we report a distinct photoredox catalytic, visible light mediated neutral radical approach. Selective control of highly reactive acyl radical in the energy barrier surmountable, reversible reaction enables driving the formation of deuterated products when an excess of D2O is employed. The power of the H/D exchange process has been demonstrated for not only aromatic aldehydes, but also aliphatic substrates, which have been difficult in transitional metal catalyzed H/D exchange reactions, and for selective late-stage deuterium incorporation into complex structures with uniformly high deuteration level (>90%).