Abstract Methionine (Met), cyst(e)ine (Cys), homocysteine and taurine are the four sulfur-containing amino acids. Met can serve as a substrate for protein synthesis or to produce homocysteine, which can be remethylated to Met or irreversibly catabolized to Cys. Unlike dogs, cats are unable to further metabolize Cys to taurine, making the latter an indispensable amino acid for the cat. Met, on the other hand, is a dietary indispensable amino acid for all mammals with Cys having the ability to spare part of the Met requirement (total sulfur amino acid requirement; Met + Cys). The amount of Met that cannot be replaced by Cys is defined as the Met requirement (NRC, 2006). Empirical determinations of the Met requirement in adult dogs and cats are still limited and the recommendations proposed by the NRC (2006) are based on studies that used insensitive techniques for mature animals. When a more robust technique, the indicator amino acid oxidation, and more practical experimental diets were used to empirically determine the Met requirement, a greater estimate was found in adult cats (Pezzali et al., 2022) and adult Labrador Retrievers and Beagles, but not in miniature Dachshunds (Mansilla et al., 2020), compared with the current recommendations proposed by the NRC (2006) and AAFCO (2023). Harrison et al. (2020), however, found a decreased estimate for the Met requirement in adult Labrador Retrievers compared with Mansilla et al. (2020), likely due to differences in experimental design and diet composition. This discrepancy highlights the need to standardize methodologies and to investigate the effect of other dietary factors on the Met and total sulfur amino acid requirements owing to their complex metabolism. Indeed, the metabolism of sulfur amino acids may differ between dog breeds, resulting in differences in Met requirements and potentially making taurine a conditionally indispensable amino acid in some breeds under specific dietary conditions. While dietary Met is usually provided in excess in commercial diets, excess of Met may lead to hyperhomocysteinemia, which has been associated with detrimental health effects in other species. Due to the complex metabolism of sulfur amino acids and the complex matrix of pet foods, determining the ideal provision of sulfur amino acids in commercial diets to maximize animal health is a challenge. More long-term studies investigating the effect of different doses and ratios (Met:Cys) of sulfur amino acids on overall metabolism are necessary, in addition to requirement studies, to optimize the dietary delivery of sulfur amino acids in dogs and cats.