AbstractIn this paper we show rigidity results for supersolutions to fully nonlinear, elliptic, conformally invariant equations on subdomains of the standard n‐sphere under suitable conditions along the boundary. We emphasize that our results do not assume concavity on the fully nonlinear equations we will work with.This proves rigidity for compact, connected, locally conformally flat manifolds (M, g) with boundary such that the eigenvalues of the Schouten tensor satisfy a fully nonlinear elliptic inequality and whose boundary is isometric to a geodesic sphere ∂D(r), where D(r) denotes a geodesic ball of radius r ∈ (0, π/2] in , and totally umbilical with mean curvature bounded below by the mean curvature of this geodesic sphere. Under the above conditions, (M, g) must be isometric to the closed geodesic ball .As a side product, in dimension 2 our methods provide a new proof to Toponogov's theorem about rigidity of compact surfaces carrying a shortest simple geodesic. Roughly speaking, Toponogov's theorem is equivalent to a rigidity theorem for spherical caps in the hyperbolic three‐space ℍ3. In fact, we extend it to obtain rigidity for supersolutions to certain Monge‐Ampère equations. © 2019 Wiley Periodicals, Inc.