Tomato Bushy Stunt Virus Genome Research Articles

First report of Tomato bushy stunt virus naturally infecting sugar beet in the United States.

Sugar beet (Beta vulgaris L.) is an important crop grown for its sucrose content used in sugar production around the world. Tomato bushy stunt virus (TBSV) is an RNA virus that belongs to the Tombusvirus genus of the family Tombusviridae (Hearne et al., 1990). The virus was first isolated from tomato, and it is known to infect a wide range of plants (Smith, 1935; Martelli et al., 1988; Hafez et al., 2010). In 1980, a natural infection of TBSV was reported in sugar beet leaves with chlorotic and necrotic ring spots and line pattern symptoms based on serological affinity to TBSV anti-sera in Czechoslovakia (Novak and Lanzova, 1980). In March 2021, sugarbeet plants showing stunted and bushy growth with yellowing and necrotic leaves were observed in a production field in the Imperial Valley of California. Harvested roots exhibited stunted and abnormal growth compared to roots from healthy plants (sFig. 1A). These symptoms prompted a screen for potential infection by TBSV. Root-tissue harvested from the symptomatic sugar beet was initially screened using a TBSV double antibody sandwich enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (DAS-ELISA; Agdia, Inc., Elkhart, IN), which reacted positive for TBSV. To obtain the full-length sequence of TBSV and potentially other viruses in the sample, total RNA isolated using the RNeasy Plant Mini Kit (Qiagen, Valencia, CA) from the root-tissue was subjected to high-throughput sequencing (HTS). Libraries were prepared using the TruSeq Stranded Total RNA Library Prep kit (Illumina, San Diego, CA) and sequenced using Illumina NovoSeq 6000 paired-end platform (Novogene, Sacramento, CA). A total of 52 million reads were obtained after removing the adapters and reads mapping to the host genome. These high-quality reads were de novo assembled into 75,891 contigs that are larger than 500 base pairs using the SPAdes assembler (Bankevitch et al., 2012; Prjibelski et al., 2020). The resulting contigs were searched for matching sequences to known viruses using the NCBI non-redundant database. A single contig of 4770 nts representing the full-length genome of TBSV was generated (Accession number OP477335), which showed 100% coverage to previously reported TBSV isolates 'statice' (AJ249740.1) and 'nipplefruit' (AY579432.1) with 92.19% and 91.25% nucleotide sequence identities, respectively, and thus confirming the presence of TBSV in sugar beet root-tissue. However, it showed 74% coverage with only 87% nucleotide identity to a previously reported Lettuce necrotic stunt virus (LNSV) from sugar beet, a tombusvirus that was re-classified as Moroccan pepper virus (MPV) due to high degree (>97%) of sequence identity (Obermeier et al., 2001; Wintermantel and Anchieta, 2012; Wintermantel and Hladky, 2013). The coat protein is conserved within species in tombusvirus, and it plays a significant role by providing serological relationships to tombusvirus taxonomy. The coat protein of TBSV-isolate of this study shared 98.45% and 96.91% identities at amino acid level with TBSV 'nipplefruit' (AY579432.1) and TBSV 'statice' (AJ249740.1) isolates, respectively. In contrast, it showed only 61.56% identity with the coat protein of MPV as shown in the phylogenetic tree indicating that the TBSV-isolate reported here is different from MPV (sFig. 2). To confirm the presence of TBSV, reverse-transcription (RT)-PCR was performed using the total RNA isolated from the root-tissue with primers (VR306: 5'-CGCTCACGAGCCCAGCATCCTTGA-3' and VR297: 5'-ACACCGCCACAGGAGCCATGATTG-3') designed based on the HTS data to amplify a portion of the TBSV genome. Sequencing of the RT-PCR product confirmed the presence of TBSV sequence with 99.1% identity to the TBSV-isolate identified in this study. Further, mechanical inoculation of total RNA isolated from the symptomatic sugar beet roots produced local lesions and systemic necrosis symptoms on the leaves of Chenopodium quinoa (sFig. 1B). Sequencing of the amplicon obtained using RT-PCR with primers VR306 and VR297 confirmed the presence of TBSV in C. quinoa. In addition to TBSV, several viral contigs representing Beet necrotic yellow vein virus were identified in the root-tissue indicating mixed infection in the field. To our knowledge, this is the first report that documents the occurrence of TBSV in sugar beet in the United States. Since TBSV is a soil-borne virus, our findings indicate the need for further studies focused on the frequency and coexistence of the TBSV with BNYVV in sugar beet production fields to understand the disease complexity resulting from potential mixed infections.

Context-influenced cap-independent translation of Tombusvirus mRNAs in vitro

Tomato bushy stunt virus (TBSV) possesses a positive-strand RNA genome that is not 5′-capped or 3′-polyadenylated. Previous analysis revealed that the TBSV genome contains a 3′-cap-independent translational enhancer (3′CITE) in its 3′-untranslated region (3′UTR) that facilitates translation of viral mRNAs in vivo. A long-range 5′–3′ RNA–RNA interaction between the 3′CITE and the 5′UTR of viral mRNAs is necessary for function, and this RNA bridge has been proposed to mediate delivery of translation-related factors bound to the 3′CITE to the 5′-end of the message. Although fully functional when assayed in plant protoplasts, the TBSV 3′CITE was previously found to be unable to activate translation in vitro in wheat germ extract (wge). In the current report we have determined that (i) another Tombusvirus, Carnation Italian ringspot virus (CIRV), contains a TBSV-like 3′CITE that is active in wge; (ii) the CIRV 3′CITE functions in vitro in a manner analogous to the TBSV 3′CITE in vivo; (iii) the TBSV 3′CITE is able to competitively inhibit CIRV 3′CITE-dependent translation in wge and (iv) the TBSV 3′CITE can enhance translation in wge when present in short viral messages. These results reveal the contrasting activities of different TBSV-like 3′CITEs in vitro and shed light on the nature of the defect in TBSV.

Conformational organization of the 3′ untranslated region in the tomato bushy stunt virus genome

The 3' untranslated regions (UTRs) of positive-strand RNA viruses often form complex structures that facilitate various viral processes. We have examined the RNA conformation of the 352 nucleotide (nt) long 3' UTR of the Tomato bushy stunt virus (TBSV) genome with the goal of defining both local and global structures that are important for virus viability. Gel mobility analyses of a 3'-terminal 81 nt segment of the 3' UTR revealed that it is able to form a compact RNA domain (or closed conformation) that is stabilized by a previously proposed tertiary interaction. RNA-RNA gel shift assays were used to provide the first physical evidence for the formation of this tertiary interaction and revealed that it represents the dominant or "default" structure in the TBSV genome. Further analysis showed that the tertiary interaction involves five base pairs, each of which contributes differently to overall complex stability. Just upstream from the 3'-terminal domain, a long-distance RNA-RNA interaction involving 3' UTR sequences was found to be required for efficient viral RNA accumulation in vivo and to also contribute to the formation of the 3'-terminal domain in vitro. Collectively, these results provide a comprehensive overview of the conformational and functional organization of the 3' UTR of the TBSV genome.

Tomato bushy stunt virus: a resilient model system to study virus–plant interactions

SUMMARY Taxonomy: Tomato bushy stunt virus (TBSV) (Fig. 1) is the type species of the plant-infecting Tombusvirus genus in the family Tombusviridae. Physical properties: TBSV virions are non-enveloped icosahedral T = 3 particles assembled from 180 coat protein subunits (42 kDa) whose arrangement causes a granular appearance on the surface structure. The particles are approximately 33 nm in diameter and composed of 17% ribonucleic acid and 83% protein. Encapsidated within the virion is the TBSV genome that consists of a positive-sense single-stranded RNA of approximately 4.8 kb, which lacks the 5'-cap or 3'-poly(A) tail typical for eukaryotic mRNAs. In nature, TBSV has a fairly restricted host range, mostly encompassing a few dicotyledonous species in separate families, and affected agricultural crops comprise primarily vegetables. The experimental host range is broad, with over 120 plant species in more than 20 different families reported to be susceptible although in most plants the infection often remains localized around the site of entry. The differences between hosts with regards to requirements for cell-to-cell and long-distance movement have led to the development of TBSV as an attractive model system to obtain general insights into RNA transport through plants. SYMPTOMS induced by TBSV are largely dependent on the host genotype; they can vary from necrotic and chlorotic lesions, to a systemic mild or severe mosaic, or they may culminate in a lethal necrosis. The original TBSV isolates from tomato plants caused a mottle, crinkle and downward curling of leaves with the youngest leaves exhibiting tip necrosis upon systemic infection. Tomato fruit yield can be greatly reduced by virus infection. Plants may be stunted and a proliferation of lateral shoots leads to a bushy appearance of the infected tomato plants, hence the nomenclature of the pathogen. Useful sites: http://image.fs.uidaho.edu/vide/descr825.htm; http://www.ictvdb.rothamsted.ac.uk/ICTVdB/74010001.htm (general information); http://mmtsb.scripps.edu/viper/info_page.php?vipPDB=2tbv (structural information).

5′-3′ RNA-RNA Interaction Facilitates Cap- and Poly(A) Tail-independent Translation of Tomato Bushy Stunt Virus mRNA: A POTENTIAL COMMON MECHANISM FOR TOMBUSVIRIDAE

Tomato bushy stunt virus (TBSV) is the prototypical member of the genus Tombusvirus in the family Tombusviridae. The (+)-strand RNA genome of TBSV lacks both a 5' cap and a 3' poly(A) tail and instead contains a 3'-terminal RNA sequence that acts as a cap-independent translational enhancer (3' CITE). In this study, we have determined the RNA secondary structure of the translation-specific central segment of the 3' CITE, termed region 3.5 (R3.5). MFOLD structural modeling combined with solution structure mapping and comparative sequence analysis indicate that R3.5 adopts a branched structure that contains three major helices. Deletion and substitution studies revealed that two of these extended stem-loop (SL) structures are essential for 3' CITE activity in vivo. In particular, the terminal loop of one of these SLs, SL-B, was found to be critical for translation. Compensatory mutational analysis showed that SL-B functions by base pairing with another SL, SL3, in the 5' untranslated region of the TBSV genome. Thus, efficient translation of TBSV mRNA in vivo requires a 5'-3' RNA-RNA interaction that effectively circularizes the message. Similar types of interactions are also predicted to occur in TBSV subgenomic mRNAs between their 5' untranslated regions and the 3' CITE, and both genomic and subgenomic 5'-3' interactions are well conserved in all members of the genus Tombusvirus. In addition, a survey of other genera in Tombusviridae revealed the potential for similar 5'-3' RNA-RNA-based interactions in their viral mRNAs, suggesting that this mechanism extends throughout this large virus family.

A second functional RNA domain in the 5' UTR of the Tomato bushy stunt virus genome: intra- and interdomain interactions mediate viral RNA replication.

The 5' untranslated regions (UTRs) of (+)-strand RNA viruses play a variety of roles in the reproductive cycles of these infectious agents. Tomato bushy stunt virus (TBSV) belongs to this class of RNA virus and is the prototype member of the genus Tombusvirus. Previous studies have demonstrated that a T-shaped domain (TSD) forms in the 5' half of the TBSV 5' UTR and that it plays a central role in viral RNA replication. Here we have extended our structure-function analysis to the 3' half of the 5' UTR. Investigation of this region in the context of a model viral replicon (i.e., a TBSV-derived defective interfering [DI] RNA) revealed that this segment contains numerous functionally relevant structural features. In vitro solution structure probing along with comparative and computer-aided RNA secondary structure analyses predicted the presence of a simple stem loop (SL5) followed by a more complex downstream domain (DSD). Both structures were found to be essential for efficient DI RNA accumulation when tested in a plant protoplast system. For SL5, maintenance of the base of its stem was the principal feature required for robust in vivo accumulation. In the DSD, both helical and unpaired regions containing conserved sequences were necessary for efficient DI RNA accumulation. Additionally, optimal DI RNA accumulation required a TSD-DSD interaction mediated by a pseudoknot. Modifications that reduced accumulation did not appreciably affect DI RNA stability in vivo, indicating that the DSD and SL5 act to facilitate viral RNA replication.

An internally located RNA hairpin enhances replication of Tomato bushy stunt virus RNAs.

Defective interfering (DI) RNAs of Tomato bushy stunt virus (TBSV), a plus-sense RNA virus, comprise four conserved noncontiguous regions (I through IV) derived from the viral genome. Region III, a 70-nucleotide-long sequence corresponding to a genomic segment located 378 nucleotides upstream of the 3' terminus of the genome, has been found to enhance DI RNA accumulation by approximately 10-fold in an orientation-independent manner (D. Ray and K. A. White, Virology 256:162-171, 1999). In this study, a more detailed structure-function analysis of region III was conducted. RNA secondary-structure analyses indicated that region III contains stem-loop structures in both plus and minus strands. Through deletion analyses of a DI RNA, a primary determinant of region III activity was mapped to the 5'-proximal 35-nucleotide segment. Compensatory-type mutational analyses showed that a stem-loop structure in the minus strand of this subregion was required for enhanced DI RNA replication. The same stem-loop structure was also found to function in a position-independent manner in a DI RNA (albeit at reduced levels) and to be important for efficient accumulation within the context of the TBSV genome. Taken together, these observations suggest that the 5'-proximal segment of region III is a modular RNA replication element that functions primarily through the formation of an RNA hairpin structure in the minus strand.

An RNA domain within the 5′ untranslated region of the tomato bushy stunt virus genome modulates viral RNA replication

The terminal half of the 5′ untranslated region (UTR) in the (+)-strand RNA genome of tomato bushy stunt virus was analyzed for possible roles in viral RNA replication. Computer-aided thermodynamic analysis of secondary structure, phylogenetic comparisons for base-pair covariation, and chemical and enzymatic solution structure probing were used to analyze the 78 nucleotide long 5′-terminal sequence. The results indicate that this sequence adopts a branched secondary structure containing a three-helix junction core. The T-shaped domain (TSD) formed by this terminal sequence is closed by a prominent ten base-pair long helix, termed stem 1 (S1). Deletion of either the 5′ or 3′ segment forming S1 (coordinates 1–10 or 69–78, respectively) in a model subviral RNA replicon, i.e. a prototypical defective interfering (DI) RNA, reduced in vivo accumulation levels of this molecule approximately 20-fold. Compensatory-type mutational analysis of S1 within this replicon revealed a strong correlation between formation of the predicted S1 structure and efficient DI RNA accumulation. RNA decay studies in vivodid not reveal any notable changes in the physical stabilities of DI RNAs containing disrupted S1s, thus implicating RNA replication as the affected process. Further investigation revealed that destabilization of S1 in the (+)-strand was significantly more detrimental to DI RNA accumulation than (−)-strand destabilization, therefore S1-mediated activity likely functions primarily via the (+)-strand. The essential role of S1 in DI RNA accumulation prompted us to examine the 5′-proximal secondary structure of a previously identified mutant DI RNA, RNA B, that lacks the 5′ UTR but is still capable of low levels of replication. Mutational analysis of a predicted S1-like element present within a cryptic 5′-terminal TSD confirmed the importance of the former in RNA B accumulation. Collectively, these data support a fundamental role for the TSD, and in particular its S1 subelement, in tombusvirus RNA replication.

In planta expression of HIV-1 p24 protein using an RNA plant virus-based expression vector.

Plant viruses show significant potential as expression vectors for the production of foreign proteins (e.g., antigens) in plants. The HIV-1 p24 nucleocapsid protein is an important early marker of HIV infection and has been used as an antigen in the development of HIV vaccines. Toward developing a plant-based expression system for the production of p24, we have investigated the use of a (positive)-strand RNA plant virus, tomato bushy stunt virus (TBSV), as an expression vector. The HIV p24 open reading frame (ORF) was introduced into a cloned cDNA copy of the TBSV genome as an in-frame fusion with a 5'-terminal portion of the TBSV coat protein ORF. In vitro-generated RNA transcripts corresponding to the engineered virus vector were infectious when inoculated into plant protoplasts; Northern and Western blot analyses verified the accumulation of a predicted p24-encoding viral subgenomic mRNA and the production of p24 fusion product. Whole-plant infections with the viral vector led to the accumulation of p24 fusion protein in inoculated leaves, which cross-reacted with p24-specific antibodies, thus confirming the maintenance of key antigenic determinants. This study is the first to demonstrate that TBSV can be engineered to express a complete foreign protein of clinical importance. Strategies for optimizing protein yield from this viral vector are discussed.

A primary determinant of cap-independent translation is located in the 3'-proximal region of the tomato bushy stunt virus genome.

Tomato bushy stunt virus (TBSV) is a positive-strand RNA virus and is the prototype member of the genus Tombusvirus. The genomes of members of this genus are not polyadenylated, and prevailing evidence supports the absence of a 5' cap structure. Previously, a 167-nucleotide-long segment (region 3.5) located near the 3' terminus of the TBSV genome was implicated as a determinant of translational efficiency (S.K. Oster, B. Wu and K. A. White, J. Virol. 72:5845-5851, 1998). In the present report, we provide evidence that a 3'-proximal segment of the genome, which includes region 3.5, is involved in facilitating cap-independent translation. Our results indicate that (i) a 5' cap structure can substitute functionally for the absence of region 3.5 in viral and chimeric reporter mRNAs in vivo; (ii) deletion of region 3.5 from viral and chimeric mRNAs has no appreciable effect on message stability; (iii) region 3.5 represents part of a larger 3' proximal element, designated as the 3' cap-independent translational enhancer (3'CITE), that is required for proficient cap-independent translation; (iv) the 3'CITE also facilitates cap-dependent translation; (v) none of the major viral proteins are required for 3'CITE activity; and (vi) no significant 3'CITE-dependent stimulation of translation was observed when mRNAs were tested in vitro in wheat germ extract under various assay conditions. This latter property distinguishes the 3'CITE from other characterized plant viral 3'-proximal cap-independent translational enhancers. Additionally, because the 3'CITE overlaps with cis-acting replication signals, it could potentially participate in regulating the initiation of genome replication.

De novo generation of defective interfering RNAs of tomato bushy stunt virus by high multiplicity passage

Defective interfering (DI) RNAs were generated de novo in each of 12 independent isolates of tomato bushy stunt virus (TBSV) upon serial passage at high multiplicities of infection (m.o.i.) in plants, but not in any of 4 additional isolates after 11 serial passages at low m.o.i. The DI RNAs were detected in RNA isolated from virus particles and in 2.3 M LiCl-soluble RNA fractions isolated from inoculated leaves. Symptom attenuation leading to persistent infections was closely correlated with the passage in which DIs first developed. Comparisons of nucleotide sequences of 10 cDNA clones from 2 DI RNA populations and with a previously characterized TBSV DI RNA revealed the same four regions of sequence from the TBSV genome were strictly conserved in each of the DI RNAs: the virus 5′ leader sequence of 168 bases; a region of approximately 200–250 bases from the viral polymerase gene; approximately 70 bases from the 3′ terminus of the viral pl9 and p22 genes; and approximately 130 bases from the 3′terminal noncoding region. Conservation of the sequence motif present in all of the DIs suggests that there might be a common mechanism of DI formation as well as selection pressure to maintain sequences essential for replication and encapsidation.

The complete genome structure and synthesis of infectious RNA from clones of tomato bushy stunt virus

The complete sequence of the genome of the cherry strain of tomato bushy stunt virus (TBSV), a member of the tombusvirus group, was determined. A full-length clone of the genome containing a bacteriophage T7 RNA polymerase promoter was assembled from partial cDNA clones. In vitro transcripts of the genome, either with or without a 5′ cap structure, were highly infectious. In addition, a genomic clone modified to contain an EcoRI restriction site as a signature mutation was infectious. Five genes are encoded by the TBSV genome. The first ORF from the 5′ terminus encodes a p33 protein as well as a p92 product translated by read-through of the amber terminator for p33. The capsid protein gene resides internally, and two ORFs for proteins of 19 and 22 kDa reside at the 3′ terminus. These last three genes are expressed from two subgenomic RNAs. The genomic organization of TBSV agrees with previous models for tombusviruses. Computer alignments of TBSV proteins with those of two other tombusviruses suggest greater relatedness among the members of this group than previously reported.

Organization of tomato bushy stunt virus genome: Characterization of the coat protein gene and the 3′ terminus

We have synthesized cDNA clones of the genome of the cherry strain of tomato bushy stunt virus (TBSV-cherry) and have used them as hybridization probes to identify and position two 3′ coterminal subgenomic RNAs of approximately 2.2 and 0.9 kilobases (kb) in length. The 5′ termini of the two subgenomic RNAs have been mapped to positions located 2156 and 936 nucleotides respectively from the 3′ terminus of the viral genome. The nucleotide sequence of cDNA clones encompassing the region of the genome containing both of the subgenomic RNAs has been determined. The sequence data indicate that two nested open reading frames (ORFs) occur in the most 3′ proximal location on the genome suggesting that the 0.9-kb subgenomic RNA potentially encodes two polypeptides of 19,397 and 21,610 Da. Comparison of the amino acid sequence of a potential translation product of 41,024 Da encoded by the first ORF of the 2.2-kb subgenomic RNA with the published capsid protein amino acid sequence of the BS-3 strain of TBSV indicates that the 2.2-kb subgenomic RNA encodes the capsid protein. The TBSV coat protein cistron is located internally on the genome and thus its genetic organization differs from that reported for most other small, spherical viruses with monopartite genomes. Amino acid sequence comparisons of analogous regions of the cucumber necrosis virus (CNV) genome confirms a close relationship between the viruses.

A defective interfering RNA that contains a mosaic of a plant virus genome

A symptom-modulating RNA associated with tomato bushy stunt virus (TBSV) was investigated with respect to physical and biological properties. Linear RNA of approximately 396 nucleotides was packaged in viral coat protein and was dependent on TBSV for replication. Coinoculation of the small RNA with TBSV resulted in the attenuation of TBSV-induced symptoms and depression of virus synthesis in whole plants. Nucleotide sequence analysis revealed that the symptom-modulating RNA was derived from 5′, 3′, and internal segments of the TBSV genome. The identification of this symptom-modulating RNA as a colinear deletion mutant of the helper virus genome establishes it as the first definitive defective interfering RNA (DI RNA) to be identified in association with a plant virus.