Metal phosphonates show promise for recovery of valuable lanthanide (Ln) elements from acidic waste streams due to their selectivity, high capacity, fast kinetics and chemical stability. To optimise these properties, a balance is needed between free phosphonate groups available to bind Ln and P-O-metal linkages to provide stability. This work demonstrates how astute choice of metal precursors can be used to control the phosphonate structure and maximise both sorption and stability. Relative to single metal zirconium phosphonate, mixed metal zirconium titanium phosphonate sorbents had more free phosphonate groups and greater porosity, increasing Ln capacity by 30 % and the kinetic rate constant by 90 %. Acid stability was also improved upon Ti inclusion. Use of metal propoxide and tert-butoxide precursors were also compared, revealing different reactivities with Zr versus Ti. Specifically, the tert-butoxide precursor increased P-O-Zr linkages and acid stability with Zr, but increased formation of leachable P-O-Na2 groups in the presence of Ti that decreased acid stability. The optimised zirconium titanium phosphonate sorbent used metal propoxide precursors and a Zr:Ti molar ratio of 1:1 to achieve (1) selectivity for Ln over Co, Sr and Cs, (2) sorption capacity of approximately 70 mg Eu/g, (3) fast kinetics with > 99 % sorption in 10 min and (4) retention of 60 % sorption capacity after contact with 5 M nitric acid. The enhanced chemical stability, capacity and kinetics achieved via incorporating Ti drastically improves the practicality of these sorbents for Ln recovery from acidic leachates of magnets, phosphors and other wastes.
Read full abstract