Tip-enhanced Raman Spectroscopy Signals Research Articles

Spring constant of an AFM cantilever with a thin-film plasmonic waveguide formed at its end

Abstract Atomic-force-microscope (AFM)-based tip-enhanced Raman spectroscopy (TERS) is a promising analytical technique that can identify the physical and chemical properties of a sample’s surface. In the conventional TERS setup, the tip is directly irradiated by an incident light, which causes degradation of the contrast of the TERS signal due to the Raman scattered light from the surface area around the tip. We recently developed an AFM cantilever for indirect illumination AFM-TERS by milling the tip of the conventional cantilever to form a thin-film waveguide. Since the thin-film waveguide is considered as another cantilever attached at the end of the original cantilever, the waveguide cantilever can be treated as cantilevers connected in series. We then analyzed the static spring constant of the waveguide cantilever by both analytical and numerical methods and found that the static spring constant of the waveguide cantilever is lower than that of the original cantilever, which is advantageous in reducing the contact damage during the TERS measurements. We also proposed procedures to experimentally calibrate the static spring constant of the waveguide cantilever.

Capturing Nano‐Scale Inhomogeneity of the Electrode Electrolyte Interface in Sodium‐Ion Batteries Through Tip‐Enhanced Raman Spectroscopy

AbstractA prime challenge in the development of new battery chemistries is the fundamental understanding of the generation of the electrode–electrolyte interface (EEI) and its evolution upon cycling. Tip‐enhanced Raman spectroscopy (TERS) under an inert gas atmosphere is employed to study the chemical components of the anode/cathode electrolyte interface in a sodium‐ion battery. After the first cycle, TERS reveals that the EEI mostly consists of organic carbonate/dicarbonate, oligoethylene oxides, α,β‐unsaturated vinyl ketones/acetates, and inorganic species ClO4−, ClO3−, and Na2CO3. Whereas after 5× cycling, the EEI composition has evolved to contain long chain monodentate or bridging/bidentate carboxylates and alkoxides. The TERS map reveals the nano‐scale heterogeneity present in the EEI layers and elucidates a multilayered nano‐mosaic coating structure. The sheer volume of Raman signature present in the TERS signal can completely unravel the mysteries regarding the chemical composition and may shed light to the physicochemical behavior of the EEI.

A Full Quantum Mechanical Approach Assessing the Chemical and Electromagnetic Effect in TERS.

Tip-enhanced Raman spectroscopy (TERS) is a valuable method for surface analysis with nanometer to angstrom-scale resolution; however, the accurate simulation of particular TERS signals remains a computational challenge. We approach this challenge by combining the two main contributors to plasmon-enhanced Raman spectroscopy and to the high resolution in TERS, in particular, the electromagnetic and the chemical effect, into one quantum mechanical simulation. The electromagnetic effect describes the sample's interaction with the strong, highly localized, and inhomogeneous electric fields associated with the plasmonic tip and is typically the thematic focus for most mechanistic studies. On the other hand, the chemical effect covers the different responses to the extremely close-range and highly position-sensitive chemical interaction between the apex tip atom(s) and the sample, and, as we could show in previous works, plays an often underestimated role. Starting from a (time-dependent) density functional theory description of the chemical model system, comprised of a tin(II) phthalocyanine sample molecule and a single silver atom as the tip, we introduce the electromagnetic effect through a series of static point charges that recreate the electric field in the vicinity of the plasmonic Ag nanoparticle. By scanning the tip over the molecule along a 3D grid, we can investigate the system's Raman response on each position for nonresonant and resonant illumination. Simulating both effects on their own already hints at the achievable signal enhancement and resolution, but the combination of both creates even stronger evidence that TERS is capable of resolving submolecular features.

Probing the Role of Environmental and Sample Characteristics in Gap Mode Tip-Enhanced Raman Spectroscopy.

Tip-enhanced Raman spectroscopy (TERS) has emerged as a powerful analytical tool for nondestructive and label-free molecular characterization at the nanoscale. However, the influence of environmental factors and sample characteristics on the occurrence of spurious signals, enhancement of TERS signals, and longevity of TERS probes is not well understood yet. Herein, we present a detailed investigation of the influence of oxygen, humidity, and atmospheric carbon contaminants on scanning tunneling microscopy-TERS (STM-TERS) measurements of self-assembled monolayer systems in ambient and inert environments. Our results reveal a consistent increase of TERS signals, significant reduction of spurious signals, and drastically improved longevity of TERS probes in the inert environment. Additionally, sample characteristics such as molecular packing, chemisorption behavior, and hydrophilicity are found to have a direct impact on signal enhancement in the TERS measurements of molecular self-assembled monolayers (SAMs). The novel insights gained in this study are expected to pave the way for a more robust data analysis and improved experimental design in the future gap mode STM- and atomic force microscopy-TERS (AFM-TERS) studies.

Regioselective Tip-Enhanced Raman Spectroscopy of Lipid Membranes with Sub-Nanometer Axial Resolution.

Noninvasive and label-free analysis of cell membranes at the nanoscale is essential to comprehend vital cellular processes. However, conventional analytical tools generally fail to meet this challenge due to the lack of required sensitivity and/or spatial resolution. Herein, we demonstrate that tip-enhanced Raman spectroscopy (TERS) is a powerful nanoanalytical tool to analyze dipalmitoylphosphatidylcholine (DPPC) bilayers and human cell membranes with submolecular resolution in the vertical direction. Unlike the far-field Raman measurements, TERS spectra of the DPPC bilayers reproducibly exhibited a uniquely shaped C-H band. These unique spectral features were also reproducibly observed in the TERS spectrum of human pancreatic cancer cells. Spectral deconvolution and DFT simulations confirmed that the TERS signal primarily originated from vibrations of the CH3 groups in the choline headgroup of the lipids. The reproducible TERS results obtained in this study unequivocally demonstrate the ultrahigh sensitivity of TERS for nanoanalysis of lipid membranes under ambient conditions.

Investigating heterogeneous defects in single-crystalline WS2 via tip-enhanced Raman spectroscopy

Nanoscale defects in two-dimensional (2D) transition metal dichalcogenides (TMDs) alter their intrinsic optical and electronic properties, and such defects require investigation. Atomic-resolution techniques such as transmission electron microscopy detect nanoscale defects accurately but are limited in terms of clarifying precise chemical and optical characteristics. In this study, we investigated nanoscale heterogeneous defects in a single-crystalline hexagonal WS2 monolayer using tip-enhanced Raman spectroscopy (TERS). We observed the Raman properties of heterogeneous defects, which are indicated by the shifted A1′(Γ) modes appearing on the W- and S-edge domains, respectively, with defect-induced Raman (D) mode. In the edge region, various Raman features occur with nanoscale defects. In addition, the TERS signals from single-crystalline WS2 indicate the existence of two majority defects in each domain, which imply S- and W-dominated vacancies. Quantum mechanical computations were performed for each majority defect and demonstrated the defect-induced variation in the vibrational phonon modes. TERS imaging promises to be a powerful technique for determining assorted nanoscale heterogeneous defects as well as for investigating the properties of other nanomaterials.

Tip-enhanced Raman spectroscopy with amplitude-controlled tapping-mode AFM

Tip-enhanced Raman spectroscopy (TERS) is a powerful tool for analyzing chemical compositions at the nanoscale owing to near-field light localized at a metallic tip. In TERS, atomic force microscopy (AFM) is commonly used for tip position control. AFM is often controlled under the contact mode for TERS, whereas the tapping mode, which is another major operation mode, has not often been employed despite several advantages, such as low sample damage. One of the reasons is the low TERS signal intensity because the tip is mostly away from the sample during the tapping motion. In this study, we quantitatively investigated the effect of the tapping amplitude on the TERS signal. We numerically evaluated the dependence of the TERS signal on tapping amplitude. We found that the tapping amplitude had a significant effect on the TERS signal, and an acceptable level of TERS signal was obtained by reducing the amplitude to a few nanometers. We further demonstrated amplitude-controlled tapping-mode TERS measurement. We observed a strong dependence of the TERS intensity on the tapping amplitude, which is in agreement with our numerical calculations. This practical but essential study encourages the use of the tapping mode for further advancing TERS and related optical techniques.

Ultrashort Pulse Excited Tip-Enhanced Raman Spectroscopy in Molecules.

Vibrational fingerprints of molecules and low-dimension materials can be traced with subnanometer resolution by performing Tip-enhanced Raman spectroscopy (TERS) in a scanning tunneling microscope (STM). Strong atomic-scale localization of light in the plasmonic nanocavity of the STM enables high spatial resolution in STM-TERS; however, the temporal resolution is so far limited. Here, we demonstrate stable TERS measurements from subphthalocyanine (SubPc) molecules excited by ∼500 fs long laser pulses in a low-temperature (LT) ultrahigh-vacuum (UHV) STM. The intensity of the TERS signal excited with ultrashort pulses scales linearly with the increasing flux of the laser pulses and exponentially with the decreasing gap-size of the plasmonic nanocavity. Furthermore, we compare the characteristic features of TERS excited with ultrashort pulses and with a continuous-wave (CW) laser. Our work lays the foundation for future experiments of time-resolved femtosecond TERS for the investigation of molecular dynamics with utmost spatial, temporal, and energy resolutions simultaneously.

Molecular Perturbation Effects in AFM-Based Tip-Enhanced Raman Spectroscopy: Contact versus Tapping Mode.

Tip-enhanced Raman spectroscopy (TERS) is a powerful tool for nondestructive and label-free surface chemical characterization at nanometer length scales. However, despite being considered nondestructive, the interaction of the TERS probe used in the analysis can alter the molecular organization of the sample. In this study, we investigate the role of the atomic force microscopy (AFM) feedback (contact mode and tapping mode) on molecular perturbation in TERS analysis of soft samples using a self-assembled monolayer (SAM) of 2-chloro-4-nitrobenzene-1-thiol (Cl-NBT) as a test sample. Surprisingly, the tapping mode shows a consistently higher TERS signal resulting from a minimal perturbation of the Cl-NBT SAM compared to the contact mode. This study provides novel insights into the choice of the correct AFM-TERS operation mode for nanoscale chemical analysis of soft and delicate samples and is expected to expedite the growing application of TERS in this area.

Low-Background Tip-Enhanced Raman Spectroscopy Enabled by a Plasmon Thin-Film Waveguide Probe.

Tip-enhanced Raman spectroscopy (TERS) is a nano-optical approach to extract spatially resolved chemical information with nanometer precision. However, in the case of direct-illumination TERS, which is often employed in commercial TERS instruments, strong fluorescence or far-field Raman signals from the illuminated areas may be excited as a background. They may overwhelm the near-field TERS signal and dramatically decrease the near-field to far-field signal contrast of TERS spectra. It is still challenging for TERS to study the surface of fluorescent materials or a bulk sample that cannot be placed on an Au/Ag substrate. In this study, we developed an indirect-illumination TERS probe that allows a laser to be focused on a flat interface of a thin-film waveguide located far away from the region generating the TERS signal. Surface plasmon polaritons are generated stably on the waveguide and eventually accumulated at the tip apex, thereby producing a spatially and energetically confined hotspot to ensure stable and high-resolution TERS measurements with a low background. With this thin-film waveguide probe, TERS spectra with obvious contrast from a diamond plate can be acquired. Furthermore, the TERS technique based on this probe exhibits excellent TERS signal stability, a long lifetime, and good spatial resolution. This technique is expected to have commercial potential and enable further popularization and development of TERS technology as a powerful analytical method.

Direct molecular-level near-field plasmon and temperature assessment in a single plasmonic hotspot

Tip-enhanced Raman spectroscopy (TERS) is currently widely recognized as an essential but still emergent technique for exploring the nanoscale. However, our lack of comprehension of crucial parameters still limits its potential as a user-friendly analytical tool. The tip’s surface plasmon resonance, heating due to near-field temperature rise, and spatial resolution are undoubtedly three challenging experimental parameters to unravel. However, they are also the most fundamentally relevant parameters to explore, because they ultimately influence the state of the investigated molecule and consequently the probed signal. Here we propose a straightforward and purely experimental method to access quantitative information of the plasmon resonance and near-field temperature experienced exclusively by the molecules directly contributing to the TERS signal. The detailed near-field optical response, both at the molecular level and as a function of time, is evaluated using standard TERS experimental equipment by simultaneously probing the Stokes and anti-Stokes spectral intensities. Self-assembled 16-mercaptohexadodecanoic acid monolayers covalently bond to an ultra-flat gold surface were used as a demonstrator. Observation of blinking lines in the spectra also provides crucial information on the lateral resolution and indication of atomic-scale thermally induced morphological changes of the tip during the experiment. This study provides access to unprecedented molecular-level information on physical parameters that crucially affect experiments under TERS conditions. The study thereby improves the usability of TERS in day-to-day operation. The obtained information is of central importance for any experimental plasmonic investigation and for the application of TERS in the field of nanoscale thermometry.

Fabrication of a Biocompatible Mica/Gold Surface for Tip-Enhanced Raman Spectroscopy.

Tip‐enhanced Raman spectroscopy (TERS) is a promising technique for structural studies of biological systems and biomolecules, owing to its ability to provide a chemical fingerprint with sub‐diffraction‐limit spatial resolution. This application of TERS has thus far been limited, due to difficulties in generating high field enhancements while maintaining biocompatibility. The high sensitivity achievable through TERS arises from the excitation of a localized surface plasmon resonance in a noble metal atomic force microscope (AFM) tip, which in combination with a metallic surface can produce huge enhancements in the local optical field. However, metals have poor biocompatibility, potentially introducing difficulties in characterizing native structure and conformation in biomolecules, whereas biocompatible surfaces have weak optical field enhancements. Herein, a novel, biocompatible, highly enhancing surface is designed and fabricated based on few‐monolayer mica flakes, mechanically exfoliated on a metal surface. These surfaces allow the formation of coupled plasmon enhancements for TERS imaging, while maintaining the biocompatibility and atomic flatness of the mica surface for high resolution AFM. The capability of these substrates for TERS is confirmed numerically and experimentally. We demonstrate up to five orders of magnitude improvement in TERS signals over conventional mica surfaces, expanding the sensitivity of TERS to a wide range of non‐resonant biomolecules with weak Raman cross‐sections. The increase in sensitivity obtained through this approach also enables the collection of nanoscale spectra with short integration times, improving hyperspectral mapping for these applications. These mica/metal surfaces therefore have the potential to revolutionize spectromicroscopy of complex, heterogeneous biological systems such as DNA and protein complexes.

Electrochemical tip-enhanced Raman spectroscopy imaging with 8 nm lateral resolution

Herein, we report tip-enhanced Raman spectroscopy (TERS) hyperspectral imaging under electrochemical control of a non-Raman-resonant molecular compound. A new setup combining a Scanning Tunneling Microscope (STM) and an optical coupling with high signal excitation and collection efficiency enables fast chemical imaging of an opaque functionalized electrode surface upon polarization. Variations in the TERS signal intensity up to 1.8 were observed across the surface, and correlated with topographic heterogeneities. These fluctuations, attributed to enhancement of the local electromagnetic field below the TERS tip, were used to estimate the lateral resolution of the produced hyperspectral image, which was found greater than 8 nm. This work represents an important step towards the use of electrochemical TERS imaging as a unique tool to unravel electrochemical processes at the nanoscale.

Unraveling the Nanoscale Heterogeneity of Solid Electrolyte Interphase Using Tip-Enhanced Raman Spectroscopy

Summary We employ tip-enhanced Raman spectroscopy (TERS) to study model amorphous silicon (a-Si) thin film anodes galvanostatically cycled for different numbers. For the 1× cycled a-Si, TERS shows good correlation between solid electrolyte interphase (SEI) topography and chemical mapping, corresponding to distribution of lithium ethylene dicarbonate (LEDC) and poly (ethylene oxide) (PEO)-like oligomer species. Subsequent electrochemical cycling makes the SEI relatively thick and rough with the chemical composition heavily dominated by LEDC monomer-dimer for 5× cycled a-Si. For 20× cycled a-Si, the TERS signal is dominated by carboxylate (RCO2Li) compounds of various conformations and fluorinated species (LixPOyFz). A nanomosaic-multilayer hybrid SEI model on top of the a-Si anode is proposed. The significance of this work is applicable not only to silicon, where SEI plays a dominant role in determining the cycle life performance and reversibility, but also for a number of other relevant battery chemistries such as Na-ion and multivalent redox systems.

Combined Tip-Enhanced Raman Spectroscopy and Scattering-Type Scanning Near-Field Optical Microscopy

Tip-enhanced Raman spectroscopy (TERS) and scattering-type scanning near-field optical microscopy (s-SNOM) enable optical imaging with a spatial resolution far below the diffraction limit of light. Although s-SNOM records the elastically scattered light (yielding information about the local refractive index and absorption), in TERS, the Raman scattered light is detected, which provides, for example, chemical information. Here, we introduce a combined TERS and s-SNOM setup for correlative studies of tip-enhanced elastically scattered and Raman scattered light. To that end, we equipped a conventional s-SNOM with a grating spectrometer. We validate our setup by characterizing a sample consisting of a self-assembled para-nitrothiophenol monolayer on an Au surface. Comparing s-SNOM and TERS signals, we demonstrate a qualitative correlation between the tip-enhanced elastic and tip-enhanced Raman scattered light. Thus, recording the tip-enhanced elastically scattered light enables a fast and reliable TERS alignm...

Tip-Enhanced Raman Scattering from Nanopatterned Graphene and Graphene Oxide.

Tip-enhanced Raman spectroscopy (TERS) is particularly sensitive to analytes residing at plasmonic tip-sample nanojunctions, where the incident and scattered optical fields may be localized and optimally enhanced. However, the enhanced local electric fields in this so-called gap-mode TERS configuration are nominally orthogonal to the sample plane. As such, any given Raman active vibrational eigenstate needs to have projections (of its polarizability derivative tensor elements) along the sample normal to be detectable via TERS. The faint TERS signals observed from two prototypical systems, namely, pristine graphene and graphene oxide are a classical example of the aforementioned rather restrictive TERS selection rules in this context. In this study, we demonstrate that nanoindentation, herein achieved using pulsed-force lithography with a sharp single-crystal diamond atomic force microscope probe, may be used to locally enhance TERS signals from graphene and graphene oxide flakes on gold. Nanoindentation locally perturbs the otherwise flat graphene structure and introduces out-of-plane protrusions that generate enhanced TERS. Although our approach is nominally invasive, we illustrate that the introduced nanodefects are highly localized, as evidenced by TERS nanoscale chemical mapping. As such, the described protocol may be used to extend and generalize the applicability of TERS for the rapid identification of two-dimensional material systems on the nanoscale.

Nanoscale chemical imaging of solid-liquid interfaces using tip-enhanced Raman spectroscopy.

Tip-enhanced Raman spectroscopy (TERS) is a powerful tool for non-destructive and label-free surface molecular mapping at the nanoscale. However, to date nanoscale resolution chemical imaging in a liquid environment has not been possible, in part due to the lack of robust TERS probes that are stable when immersed in a liquid. In this work, we have addressed this challenge by developing plasmonically-active TERS probes with a multilayer metal coating structure that can be successfully used within a liquid environment. Using these novel TERS probes, we have compared the plasmonic enhancement of TERS signals in air and water environments for both gap mode and non-gap mode configurations and show that in both cases the plasmonic enhancement decreases in water. To better understand the signal attenuation in water, we have performed numerical simulations that revealed a negative correlation between the electric field enhancement at the TERS probe-apex and the refractive index of the surrounding medium. Finally, using these robust probes we demonstrate TERS imaging with nanoscale spatial resolution in a water environment for the first time by employing single-wall carbon nanotubes as a model sample. Our findings are expected to broaden the scope of TERS to a range of scientific disciplines in which nanostructured solid-liquid interfaces play a key role.

Damage-free tip-enhanced Raman spectroscopy for heat-sensitive materials.

We report a method to establish experimental conditions for tip-enhanced Raman spectroscopy (TERS) with low thermal and mechanical damage to samples. In this method, we monitor the thermal desorption of thiol molecules from a gold-coated probe of an atomic force microscope (AFM) via TERS spectra. Temperatures for desorption of thiol molecules (60-100 °C) from gold surfaces cover the temperature range for degradation of heat-sensitive biomaterials (e.g. proteins). By monitoring the desorption of the thiols on the probe, we can estimate the power of an excitation laser for the samples to reach their critical temperatures for thermal degradation. Furthermore, we also found that an active oscillation of AFM cantilevers significantly promotes the heat transfer from the probe to the surrounding medium. This enables us to employ a higher power density of the excitation laser, resulting in a stronger Raman signal compared with the signal obtained with a contact mode. We propose that this combinatory method is effective in acquiring strong TERS signals while suppressing thermal and mechanical damage to soft and heat-sensitive samples.

Molecular Bending at the Nanoscale Evidenced by Tip-Enhanced Raman Spectroscopy in Tunneling Mode on Thiol Self-Assembled Monolayers

The sharp and intense Raman features associated with hexil azobenzenethiol self-assembled monolayers on gold(111) make these molecules ideal probes for tip-enhanced Raman spectroscopy (TERS) investigations. Spectroscopic and electrical measurements at the molecular junction were performed by combining TERS with scanning tunneling microscopy. The azobenzene TERS signal was monitored while changing the tip–surface distance and/or increasing the bias applied to the tip. The TERS signal decreases with increasing bias faster than what would be expected if only the effect of the tip distance from the monolayer and the related drop of the optically enhancing near-field intensity were considered. We develop a simple geometrical model accounting for the molecular bending induced by the increasingly higher local field close to the tip apex, which brings an additional modification of the TERS intensity and is able to accurately describe the experimental data.

Tip-enhanced Raman spectroscopic imaging shows segregation within binary self-assembled thiol monolayers at ambient conditions.

Phase segregation of coadsorbed thiol molecules on a gold surface was investigated with nanoscale chemical imaging using tip-enhanced Raman spectroscopy (TERS). Samples were prepared using mixed solutions containing thiophenol (PhS) and an oligomeric phenylene-ethynylene (OPE) thiol, with 10:1, 2:1, and 1:1 molar ratios. Phase segregation into domains with sizes from ≈30 to 240nm is observed with these molar ratios. A comparison of TERS images with different pixel sizes indicates that a pixel size bigger than 15nm is not reliable in defining nanodomains, because of undersampling. In this study, the formation of nanodomains was clearly evident based on the molecular fingerprints provided by TERS, while ambient scanning tunneling microscopy (STM) was not capable of discerning individual domains via their apparent height difference. TERS therefore allows to image nanodomains in binary self-assembled monolayers, which are invisible to methods solely relying on topographic or electron density characteristics of self-assembled monolayers. Moreover, TERS mapping provides statistical data to describe the distribution of molecules on the sample surface in a well-defined manner. Peak ratio histograms of selected TERS signals from samples prepared with different mixing ratios give a better understanding of the adsorption preference of the thiols studied, and the relationship of their mixing ratio in solution and adsorbed on the surface.