Engineering black carbon (e.g. biochar) has been widely found in natural environments due to natural processes and extensive applications in engineering systems, and could influence the geochemical processes of coexisting arsenic (AsV) and FeII, especially when they are exposed to oxic conditions. Here, we studied time-varying kinetics and efficiencies of AsV immobilization by solid-phase FeII (FeIIsolid) and FeIII (FeIIIsolid) in FeII-AsV-biochar systems under both anoxic and oxic conditions at pH 7.0, with focuses on the effects of biochar surface and biochar-derived dissolved organic carbon (DOC). Under anoxic conditions, FeII could rapidly immobilize AsV via co-adsorption onto biochar surfaces, which also serves as the dominant pathway of AsV immobilization at the initial stage of reaction (0–5 min) under oxic conditions at high biochar concentrations. Subsequently, with increasing biochar concentrations, FeIIIsolid precipitation from aqueous FeII (FeIIaq) oxidation (5–60 min) starts to play an important role in AsV immobilization but in decreased efficiencies of AsV immobilization per unit iron. In the following stage (60–300 min), FeIIsolid oxidation is suppressed and leads to AsV release into solutions at >1.0 g·L−1 biochar. The decreasing efficiency of AsV immobilization over time is attributed to the gradual release of DOC into solution from biochar particles, which significantly inhibit AsV immobilization when FeIIIsolid is generated from FeIIsolid oxidation in the vicinity of biochar surfaces. Specifically, 4.06 mg·L of biochar-derived DOC can completely inhibit the immobilization of AsV in the 100 μM FeII system under oxic conditions. The findings are crucial to comprehensively understand and predict the behavior of FeII and AsV with coexisting engineering black carbon in natural environments.