Three-dimensional Quantitative Structure-activity Analysis Research Articles

Abstract CN08-01: 3D-QSAR based design of novel inhibitors of topoisomerase II

Abstract Anticancer drugs that target topoisomerase II are among the most effective and widely used drugs in the anticancer therapeutic armamentarium. Quantitative structure activity relationship (QSAR) analysis of a series of structurally related analogs can be used to design more active analogs. Classical QSAR analysis relies on correlations with “flat” 2D-QSAR parameters to achieve this goal. Examples of 2D parameters might include log Poct, HOMO/LUMO values, numbers of H-bond donors/acceptors, or rotatable bonds. The design of more active analogs may either be ligand-based or structure-based, where the 3D structure of the binding site of the target molecule is known. 3D-QSAR methodology. Three-dimensional quantitative structure-activity analysis (3D-QSAR) is an advance over classical 2D-QSAR methods in that the 3D structures of the ligands are explicitly used to develop a predictive model. It is the interaction of the 3D structure of the drug with its protein or DNA target that determines its degree of binding and hence its activity. A strength of the 3D-QSAR method is that it can be used even when no X-ray structure of the target is available. In fact 3D-QSAR can be used to define the optimum shape of a virtual binding site. 3D-QSAR employs comparative molecular field analysis (CoMFA) and comparative molecular similarity index analysis (CoMSIA) in order to determine the ligand binding-site interaction factors important for activity. In the more sophisticated CoMSIA analysis steric, electrostatic, hydrophobic and H-bond donor and acceptor field energy contributions are all evaluated for their contributions to the activity. CoMFA, however, utilizes only the former two fields. The field energies are calculated by placing the molecules in a 3D lattice of a regularly spaced grid of probe atoms. Bisphenol inhibitors of topoisomerase IIα. As the result of a screen for novel inhibitors of topoisomerase II we identified a new lead bisphenol compound that had low micromolar topoisomerase II and K562 cell growth inhibitory activity (1). Most of the compounds displayed only low-fold resistance to a K562 subline with reduced levels of topoisomerase IIα suggesting that they acted as catalytic inhibitors rather than as topoisomerase II poisons. A 3D-QSAR analysis on 23 analogs was used to identify the ring and bridge substituents that were important for activity and to guide the synthesis of new analogs. H-bond acceptors on the meta position of the phenyl ring and H-bond donors on both the para and meta positions favored inhibition of topoisomerase IIα. Purine inhibitors of topoisomerase IIα. Similarly, a 3D-QSAR model was also developed for a series of 24 substituted purine analogs that had low to sub-micromolar activity for the inhibition of the ATPase activity of topoisomerase IIα (2). None of the compounds increased levels of the topoisomerase IIα-covalent complex, which suggested that they acted as catalytic inhibitors rather than topoisomerase II poisons. 3D-QSAR analysis showed that inhibition of topoisomerase IIα was most strongly correlated with the hydrophobic field generated by a phenyl group bonded to an sulfur atom. Combining 3D-QSAR and structure-based design of DNA intercalating and bisintercalating topoisomerase II targeted anthrapyrazole compounds. Finally, 3D-QSAR methods and structure-based design were combined in designing DNA intercalating and bisintercalating anthrapyrazole analogs of losoxantrone and piroxantrone. In these studies anthrapyrazole analogs were docked into an X-ray structure of DNA and their GOLD docking scores were correlated with DNA binding and inhibition of topoisomerase IIα decatenation catalytic activity (3). Conformations obtained from the results of docking into the DNA gave superior correlations compared to structures that were energy minimized. This result indicated that the docked poses were closer to the biologically active conformations. The 3D-QSAR analysis of K562 cell cytotoxicity, DNA binding and topoisomerase IIα inhibition showed that H-bond donor interactions and electrostatic interactions with the protonated side chains made the largest contribution to the total field. In an extension of this work a series of bisanthrapyrazoles containing ester and amide linkers of varying lengths were synthesized that were designed to be bisintercalators that could span 4 base pairs and thus bind more strongly to DNA (4,5). Several of the bisintercalators bound to DNA as strongly as doxorubicin and displayed low micromolar cell growth and topoisomerase IIα inhibition. Support: CIHR and a Canada Research Chair in Drug Development Citation Information: Mol Cancer Ther 2009;8(12 Suppl):CN08-01.

A Three-Dimensional Quantitative Structure-Activity Analysis of a New Class of Bisphenol Topoisomerase IIα Inhibitors

After the identification of a new lead bisphenol compound that had good topoisomerase IIalpha (EC 5.99.1.3) inhibitory activity, a series of bisphenol analogs were synthesized and tested to identify the structural features that were responsible for their activity. The bisphenols represent a new structural class of topoisomerase II inhibitor that potently inhibited the growth of Chinese hamster ovary and K562 leukemia cells in the low micromolar range. The fact that cell growth inhibition was significantly correlated with topoisomerase IIalpha inhibition suggests that the catalytic inhibition of topoisomerase IIalpha probably contributed to their growth inhibitory activity. Only one of the bisphenols (O3OH) tested significantly induced topoisomerase IIalpha-mediated cleavage of DNA. Most of the bisphenols displayed only low-fold cross-resistance to a K562 subline containing reduced levels of topoisomerase IIalpha Thus, it is likely that most of the bisphenols inhibited cell growth, not by acting as topoisomerase II poisons, but rather by acting as catalytic inhibitors of topoisomerase IIalpha. Three-dimensional quantitative structure-activity analysis (3D-QSAR) was carried out on the bisphenols using comparative molecular field analysis (CoMFA) and comparative molecular similarity index analysis (CoMSIA) to determine the structural features responsible for their activity. The CoMSIA analysis of the topoisomerase IIalpha inhibitory activity yielded a statistically significant model upon partial least-squares analyses. The 3D-QSAR CoMSIA analysis showed that polar meta hydrogen bond acceptor substituents on the phenyl rings favored inhibition of topoisomerase IIalpha. For the hydrogen bond donor field, para- and meta-substituted hydroxyl groups favored inhibition. Hydrophobic substituents on the bridge atoms disfavored inhibition.