AbstractNovatein is a thermoplastic produced from blood meal and is used in different agricultural applications. Novatein has some unique processing challenges and its rheology was studied using screw‐driven capillary rheometry, with a particular focus on sheet extrusion using ethylene glycol, glycerol, propylene glycol (PG), or triethylene glycol (TEG) as plasticizers. The entrance pressure drop contributed up to 44% of the total pressure drop (entrance and capillary pressure drop), but this was significantly reduced by plasticization or increased temperature. Polyol addition led to higher shear viscosities in comparison to no polyol plasticization, most likely due to improved chain mobility resulting in orientation effects. Elongational flow was dominated by primary plasticization of the protein‐rich phase and changes in secondary structure, whereas secondary plasticization (phase separation into a polyol‐rich phase) played a significant role in the reduction of the shear viscosity. Of the selected plasticizers, PG showed the most efficient plasticization in both shear and elongational flow. When combined with the beneficial secondary structural changes brought about by TEG, the sheet forming ability of Novatein was drastically improved.