Thermodynamics Of DNA Binding Research Articles

DNA binding thermodynamics and site stoichiometry as a function of polyamide size

The interactions of 6–8 ring hairpin polyamides (PAs) with the minor groove of DNA have been investigated extensively. More recent studies of large antiviral PAs (14–20 rings) active against small DNA tumor viruses lead to questions regarding the extent to which the DNA binding behaviors of the well studied, smaller PAs can be reliably extrapolated to the larger ones. Described here is the first reported study of hairpin PA-DNA binding thermodynamics as a function of PA size (6–20 rings). All PAs exhibit binding affinity in the low nM to upper pM range, which indicates that affinity is not a discriminator of antiviral activity. Unlike the smaller PAs, a 20-ring PA does not appreciably dissociate from DNA in competition experiments, which indicates very long residence time that is consistent with antiviral activity. While the DNA binding thermodynamics for the smaller antivirally inactive 6- and 8-ring PAs is clearly enthalpically driven, the larger antiviral PAs (14- and 20-rings) exhibit strongly entropically-driven DNA binding. These distinct energetic signatures indicate that different types of interactions drive these associations. In DNA binding site stoichiometry experiments conducted at both nM and μM concentrations, all PAs except the 6-ring PA bind an isolated site with site stoichiometry of at least two PAs per recognition sequence. Electrostatic contributions to DNA binding affinity are small for all PAs and not correlated with PA size but weakly correlated with the number of imidazole residues. Altogether, these results indicate that DNA binding behaviors of smaller hairpin PAs do not necessarily reflect those of larger PAs. These are vital considerations in the development of hairpin PAs for biological use.

Effects of methyl substitution on DNA binding enthalpies of enantiopure Ru(phenanthroline)2dipyridophenazine2+ complexes.

Isothermal titration calorimetry (ITC) has been utilized to investigate the effect of methyl substituents on the intercalating dppz ligand of the enantiomers of the parent complex Ru(phen)2dppz2+ (phen = 1,10-phenanthroline; dppz = dipyrido[3,2-a:2',3'-c]phenazine) on DNA binding thermodynamics. The methylated complexes (10-methyl-dppz and 11,12-dimethyl-dppz) have large, concentration-dependent, positive heats of dilution, and a strong endothermic background is also apparent in the ITC-profiles from titration of methylated complexes into poly(dAdT)2, which make direct comparison between complexes difficult. By augmenting a simple cooperative binding model with one equilibrium for complex self-aggregation in solution and one equilibrium for complex aggregation on saturated DNA, it was possible to find an excellent global fit to the experimental data with DNA affinity parameters restricted to be equal for all Δ-enantiomers as well as for all Λ-enantiomers. In general, enthalpic differences, compared to the unsubstituted complex, were small and less than 4 kJ mol-1, except for the heat of intercalation of Δ-10-methyl-dppz (-11,6 kJ mol-1) and Λ-11,12-dimethyl-dppz (+4.3 kJ mol-1).

The human mitochondrial single-stranded DNA-binding protein displays distinct kinetics and thermodynamics of DNA binding and exchange

The human mitochondrial ssDNA-binding protein (mtSSB) is a homotetrameric protein, involved in mtDNA replication and maintenance. Although mtSSB is structurally similar to SSB from Escherichia coli (EcoSSB), it lacks the C-terminal disordered domain, and little is known about the biophysics of mtSSB-ssDNA interactions. Here, we characterized the kinetics and thermodynamics of mtSSB binding to ssDNA by equilibrium titrations and stopped-flow kinetic measurements. We show that the mtSSB tetramer can bind to ssDNA in two distinct binding modes: (SSB)30 and (SSB)60, defined by DNA binding site sizes of 30 and 60 nucleotides, respectively. We found that the binding mode is modulated by magnesium ion and NaCl concentration, but unlike EcoSSB, the mtSSB does not show negative intersubunit cooperativity. Global fitting of both the equilibrium and kinetic data afforded estimates for the rate and equilibrium constants governing the formation of (SSB)60 and (SSB)30 complexes and for the transitions between the two binding modes. We found that the mtSSB tetramer binds to ssDNA with a rate constant near the diffusion limit (2 × 109 m-1 s-1) and that longer DNA (≥60 nucleotides) rapidly wraps around all four monomers, as revealed by FRET assays. We also show that the mtSSB tetramer can directly transfer from one ssDNA molecule to another via an intermediate with two DNA molecules bound to the mtSSB. In conclusion, our results indicate that human mtSSB shares many physicochemical properties with EcoSSB and that the differences may be explained by the lack of an acidic, disordered C-terminal tail in human mtSSB protein.

Enthalpic switch-points and temperature dependencies of DNA binding and nucleotide incorporation by Pol I DNA polymerases

This study examines the relationship between the DNA binding thermodynamics and the enzymatic activity of the Klenow and Klentaq Pol I DNA polymerases from Escherichia coli and Thermus aquaticus. Both polymerases bind DNA with nanomolar affinity at temperatures down to at least 5°C, but have lower than 1% enzymatic activity at these lower temperatures. For both polymerases it is found that the temperature of onset of significant enzymatic activity corresponds with the temperature where the enthalpy of binding (ΔHbinding) crosses zero (TH) and becomes favorable (negative). This TH/activity upshift temperature is 15°C for Klenow and 30°C for Klentaq. The results indicate that a negative free energy of DNA binding alone is not sufficient to proceed to catalysis, but that the enthalpic versus entropic balance of binding may be a modulator of the temperature dependence of enzymatic function. Analysis of the temperature dependence of the catalytic activity of Klentaq polymerase using expanded Eyring theory yields thermodynamic patterns for ΔG‡, ΔH‡, and TΔS‡ that are highly analogous to those commonly observed for direct DNA binding. Eyring analysis also finds a significant ΔCp‡ of formation of the activated complex, which in turn indicates that the temperature of maximal activity, after which incorporation rate slows with increasing temperature, will correspond with the temperature where the activation enthalpy (ΔH‡) switches from positive to negative.

Drug–DNA binding thermodynamics: A comparative study of aristololactam-β-d-glucoside and daunomycin

Thermal melting and microcalorimetric studies have been carried out to investigate and compare the thermodynamics of interaction of two sugars bearing drugs viz. the aristololactam-β-d-glucoside (ADG) and daunomycin (DAU) with DNA. Both compounds stabilized DNA against thermal strand separation but daunomycin promoted a much higher stability compared to ADG. The binding affinity of ADG was of the order of 105M−1 while that of daunomycin was higher by one order (106M−1). There is only one class of binding site on DNA for both ADG and DAU. The binding was predominantly enthalpy driven for both compounds but the entropy contribution was different. Although higher salt concentration decreased the binding affinity in both cases the variation was higher for DAU compared to ADG. Temperature dependent calorimetric data suggested that the enthalpy and entropy changes reduced but compensated each other to keep the Gibbs free energy change almost same and gave negative ΔCp∘ values. The complexation of both drugs to DNA appears to be similar with higher affinity for DAU over ADG but the energetics are different. DAU is a better DNA intercalator compared to ADG.

Metal Complexes as DNA Intercalators

DNA has a strong affinity for many heterocyclic aromatic dyes, such as acridine and its derivatives. Lerman in 1961 first proposed intercalation as the source of this affinity, and this mode of DNA binding has since attracted considerable research scrutiny. Organic intercalators can inhibit nucleic acid synthesis in vivo, and they are now common anticancer drugs in clinical therapy. The covalent attachment of organic intercalators to transition metal coordination complexes, yielding metallointercalators, can lead to novel DNA interactions that influence biological activity. Metal complexes with σ-bonded aromatic side arms can act as dual-function complexes: they bind to DNA both by metal coordination and through intercalation of the attached aromatic ligand. These aromatic side arms introduce new modes of DNA binding, involving mutual interactions of functional groups held in close proximity. The biological activity of both cis- and trans-diamine Pt(II) complexes is dramatically enhanced by the addition of σ-bonded intercalators. We have explored a new class of organometallic "piano-stool" Ru(II) and Os(II) arene anticancer complexes of the type [(η(6)-arene)Ru/Os(XY)Cl](+). Here XY is, for example, ethylenediamine (en), and the arene ligand can take many forms, including tetrahydroanthracene, biphenyl, or p-cymene. Arene-nucleobase stacking interactions can have a significant influence on both the kinetics and thermodynamics of DNA binding. In particular, the cytotoxic activity, conformational distortions, recognition by DNA-binding proteins, and repair mechanisms are dependent on the arene. A major difficulty in developing anticancer drugs is cross-resistance, a phenomenon whereby a cell that is resistant to one drug is also resistant to another drug in the same class. These new complexes are non-cross-resistant with cisplatin towards cancer cells: they constitute a new class of anticancer agents, with a mechanism of action that differs from the anticancer drug cisplatin and its analogs. The Ru-arene complexes with dual functions are more potent towards cancer cells than their nonintercalating analogs. In this Account, we focus on recent studies of dual-function organometallic Ru(II)- and Os(II)-arene complexes and the methods used to detect arene-DNA intercalation. We relate these interactions to the mechanism of anticancer activity and to structure-activity relationships. The interactions between these complexes and DNA show close similarities to those of covalent polycyclic aromatic carcinogens, especially to N7-alkylating intercalation compounds. However, Ru-arene complexes exhibit some new features. Classical intercalation and base extrusion next to the metallated base is observed for {(η(6)-biphenyl)Ru(ethylenediamine)}(2+) adducts of a 14-mer duplex, while penetrating arene intercalation occurs for adducts of the nonaromatic bulky intercalator {(η(6)-tetrahydroanthracene)Ru(ethylenediamine)}(2+) with a 6-mer duplex. The introduction of dual-function Ru-arene complexes introduces new mechanisms of antitumor activity, novel mechanisms for attack on DNA, and new concepts for developing structure- activity relationships. We hope this discussion will stimulate thoughtful and focused research on the design of anticancer chemotherapeutic agents using these unique approaches.

Correlation Between DNA Binding Thermodynamics and Functional Behavior of Pol I DNA Polymerases

Primer-template DNA (pt-DNA) binding by DNA polymerases is the first step of the polymerization cycle. We have previously characterized the thermodynamics of pt-DNA binding with respect to temperature for the “large fragments” of DNA polymerase I, Klentaq and Klenow, from Thermus aquaticus and Escherichia coli, respectively. Results with both polymerases showed that DNA binding is enthalpy-driven near their respective physiological temperatures. Here, nucleotide incorporation activity was measured with respect to temperature to examine how the thermodynamics of initial pt-DNA binding relates to the enzymatic activities of Klentaq and Klenow. For both polymerases it is observed that a negative enthalpy of initial binding (ΔH) is required for nucleotide incorporation activity, and that a negative entropy of binding (TΔS) inhibits the catalytic activity. Nucleotide incorporation activity was also examined with respect to KCl concentration. As reported previously, thermodynamic linkage plots for pt-DNA binding with respect to KCl concentration (∂ln1/Kd versus∂ln[KCl]) exhibit negative slopes for both polymerases and indicate net ion releases of ∼3 and ∼5 ions upon pt-DNA binding by Klentaq and Klenow, respectively. Interestingly, linkage plots for the steady-state rate of incorporation activity with respect to KCl concentration (∂ln1/ssRateversus∂ln[KCl]) exhibit the same slopes as the linkage plots of pt-DNA binding. This result suggests that salt dependence of initial pt-DNA binding dictates the salt dependence of the overall incorporation activity. It is striking that for both salt and temperature dependences, the detailed thermodynamics of DNA binding so directly correlate with overall functional behavior.This work is supported by National Science Foundation.

Effect of Ancillary Ligands on the DNA Interaction of [Cr(diimine)3]3+ Complexes Containing the Intercalating Dipyridophenazine Ligand

The synthesis of photoluminescent Cr(III) complexes of the type [Cr(diimine)(2)(DPPZ)](3+) are described, where DPPZ is the intercalating dipyridophenazine ligand, and diimine corresponds to the ancillary ligands bpy, phen, DMP, and TMP (where bpy = 2,2'-bipyridine, phen = 1,10-phenanthroline, DMP = 5,6-dimethyl-1,10-phenanthroline, and TMP = 3,4,7,8-tetramethyl-1,10-phenanthroline). For TMP, DMP, and phen as ancillary ligands, the complexes have also been resolved into their Lambda and Delta optical isomers. A comparison of the photophysical and electrochemical properties reveal similar (2)E(g) --> (4)A(2g) (O(h)) emission wavelengths and lifetimes, and a variation of 110 mV in the (2)E(g) excited state oxidizing power. A detailed investigation has been undertaken of ancillary ligand effects on the DNA binding of these complexes with a range of polynucleotides. For all four complexes, emission is quenched by the addition of calf thymus B-DNA, with the emission lifetime data yielding bimolecular quenching rate constants close to the diffusion controlled limit. Equilibrium dialysis studies have established a general predilection for AT base binding sites, while companion experiments with added distamycin (a selective minor groove binder) provide evidence for a minor groove binding preference. For the case of [Cr(TMP)(2)(DPPZ)](3+), concomitant equilibrium dialysis and circular dichroism measurements have demonstrated very strong enantioselective binding by the Lambda optical isomer. The thermodynamics of DNA binding have also been explored via isothermal titration calorimetry (ITC). The ITC data establish that the primary binding mode for all four Cr(III) complexes is entropically driven, a result that is attributed to the highly favorable free energy contribution associated with the hydrophobic transfer of the Cr(III) complexes from solution into the DNA binding site.

Structural Basis of the Transcriptional Regulation of the Proline Utilization Regulon by Multifunctional PutA

The multifunctional Escherichia coli proline utilization A (PutA) flavoprotein functions both as a membrane-associated proline catabolic enzyme and as a transcriptional repressor of the proline utilization genes putA and putP. To better understand the mechanism of transcriptional regulation by PutA, we have mapped the put-regulatory region, determined a crystal structure of the PutA ribbon–helix–helix domain (PutA52, a polypeptide corresponding to residues 1–52 of E. coli PutA) complexed with DNA, and examined the thermodynamics of DNA binding to PutA52. Five operator sites, each containing the sequence motif 5′-GTTGCA-3′, were identified using gel-shift analysis. Three of the sites are shown to be critical for repression of putA, whereas the two other sites are important for repression of putP. The 2.25-Å-resolution crystal structure of PutA52 bound to one of the operators (operator 2; 21 bp) shows that the protein contacts a 9-bp fragment corresponding to the GTTGCA consensus motif plus three flanking base pairs. Since the operator sequences differ in flanking bases, the structure implies that PutA may have different affinities for the five operators. This hypothesis was explored using isothermal titration calorimetry. The binding of PutA52 to operator 2 is exothermic, with an enthalpy of −1.8 kcal/mol and a dissociation constant of 210 nM. Substitution of the flanking bases of operator 4 into operator 2 results in an unfavorable enthalpy of 0.2 kcal/mol and a 15-fold-lower affinity, showing that base pairs outside of the consensus motif impact binding. Structural and thermodynamic data suggest that hydrogen bonds between Lys9 and bases adjacent to the GTTGCA motif contribute to transcriptional regulation by fine-tuning the affinity of PutA for put control operators.

Thermodynamic characterization of specific interactions between the human Lon protease and G-quartet DNA

Lon is an ATP-powered protease that binds DNA. However, the function of DNA binding by Lon remains elusive. Studies suggest that human Lon (hLon) binds preferentially to a G-rich single-stranded DNA (ssDNA) sequence overlapping the light strand promoter of mitochondrial DNA. This sequence is contained within a 24-base oligonucleotide referred to as LSPas. Here, we use biochemical and biophysical approaches to elucidate the structural properties of ssDNAs bound by hLon, as well as the thermodynamics of DNA binding by hLon. Electrophoretic mobility shift assay and circular dichroism show that ssDNAs with a propensity for forming parallel G-quartets are specifically bound by hLon. Isothermal titration calorimetry demonstrates that hLon binding to LSPas is primarily driven by enthalpy change associated with a significant reduction in heat capacity. Differential scanning calorimetry pinpoints an excess heat capacity upon hLon binding to LSPas. By contrast, hLon binding to an 8-base G-rich core sequence is entropically driven with a relatively negligible change in heat capacity. A considerable enhancement of thermal stability accompanies hLon binding to LSPas as compared to the G-rich core. Taken together, these data support the notion that hLon binds G-quartets through rigid-body binding and that binding to LSPas is coupled with structural adaptation.

Peptide Nucleic Acid (PNA) Amphiphiles: Synthesis, Self-Assembly, and Duplex Stability

Peptide amphiphiles comprising a class of conjugates of peptide nucleic acid (PNA), natural amino acids, and n-alkanes were synthesized and studied. These PNA amphiphiles (PNAA) self-assemble at concentrations between 10 and 50 muM and exhibit water solubilities above 500 muM. The highly specific, stable DNA binding properties of PNAs are preserved by these modifications, with no significant differences between the thermodynamics of DNA binding of the PNA peptide and the PNA amphiphile. Proper solubilization of the PNAA required the attachment of (Lys)(2) and (Glu)(4) peptides to PNAs, which affected the PNAA-DNA duplex stability by electrostatic interactions between these charged amino acids and the negatively charged DNA backbone. These electrostatic effects did not affect the specificity of DNA binding, however. Electrostatic effects are screened with added salt, in a manner consistent with previous studies of PNA-DNA duplex stability and predictions from a charged-cylinder model for the duplex.

Thermodynamics of DNA Binding and Distortion by the Hyperthermophile Chromatin Protein Sac7d

Sac7d is a hyperthermophile chromatin protein which binds non-specifically to the minor groove of duplex DNA and induces a sharp kink of 66 degrees with intercalation of valine and methionine side-chains. We have utilized the thermal stability of Sac7d and the lack of sequence specificity to define the thermodynamics of DNA binding over a wide temperature range. The binding affinity for poly(dGdC) was moderate at 25 degrees C (Ka = 3.5(+/-1.6) x 10(6) M(-1)) and increased by nearly an order of magnitude from 10 degrees C to 80 degrees C. The enthalpy of binding was unfavorable at 25 degrees C, and decreased linearly from 5 degrees C to 60 degrees C. A positive binding heat at 25 degrees C is attributed in part to the energy of distorting DNA, and ensures that the temperature of maximal binding affinity (75.1+/-5.6 degrees C) is near the growth temperature of Sulfolobus acidocaldarius. Truncation of the two intercalating residues to alanine led to a decreased ability to bend and unwind DNA at 25 degrees C with a small decrease in binding affinity. The energy gained from intercalation is slightly greater than the free energy penalty of bending duplex DNA. Surprisingly, reduced distortion from the double alanine substitution did not lead to a significant decrease in the heat of binding at 25 degrees C. In addition, an anomalous positive DeltaCp of binding was observed for the double alanine mutant protein which could not be explained by the change in polar and apolar accessible surface areas. Both the larger than expected binding enthalpy and the positive heat capacity can be explained by a temperature dependent structural transition in the protein-DNA complex with a Tm of 15-20 degrees C and a DeltaH of 15 kcal/mol. Data are discussed which indicate that the endothermic transition in the complex is consistent with DNA distortion.

DNA Binding Thermodynamics and Sequence Specificity of Chiral Piperazinecarbonyloxyalkyl Derivatives of Anthracene and Pyrene

In this paper we report the DNA binding proper ties of piperazinecarbonyloxy-2-propyl derivatives of anthracene (2), pyrene (3), and phenylanthracene (4). An intercalative binding mode is found for 2 and 3, while the phenyl group of 4 prevents intercalation and leads to external binding. Preferential binding of the (S)-enantiomers is found for both anthracene 2 and pyrene 3. However, the enantiomeric preference is small, with K-(R)/K-(S) being around 0.5 for both the anthracene and the pyrene compounds. This is interpreted in terms of orientation polarity in the binding, by which any intrinsic enantioselectivity is canceled by averaging of opposite binding orientations. The affinities for poly(dA-dT)(2) (AT) are 10(4) M-1 for anthracene derivative 2, and 5 x 10(5) M-1 for pyrene derivative 2. The affinities for poly(dG-dC)(2) (GC) are I order of magnitude lower than those for AT. This is explained by steric interference of the piperazinium tail with the exocyclic amino groups of guanine in the minor groove of GC, leading to a more shallow intercalation in GC than in AT, as also indicated by significantly less negative reduced linear dichroism of the intercalator absorption bands in the GC complexes. This behavior is consistent with that observed for the previously studied achiral analogues.(1) Binding thermodynamics support the difference in binding mode between AT and GC. The binding enthalpy of the AT complexes is significantly more negative than that of the corresponding GC complexes. This indicates a larger overlap of intercalating moiety and nucleobases in the AT complexes, consistent with the linear dichroism results.

Thermodynamics of DNA binding of MM17, a 'single chain dimer' of transcription factor MASH-1.

MASH-1, a member of the basic helix-loop-helix (bHLH) family of transcriptional regulators, is a central factor for the regulation of the differentiation of committed neuronal precursor cells of the peripheral nervous system. We have previously produced MM17, a single chain version of this dimeric protein, by linking the C-terminal end of the first subunit to the N-terminal residue of the second subunit through a flexible peptide linker. We have now determined by isothermal titration calorimetry the thermodynamic parameters characterising the DNA binding reactions of MM17. The DNA binding specificity was relatively low and comparable to that observed for wild-type MASH bHLH. At 32 degrees C and pH 7, the concentration of MM17 at which 50% DNA binding occurred was determined as 22.8 and 152 nM for binding to MCK-S and the heterologous SP-1, respectively. Similarly to MASH bHLH the free energy of the association was only slightly temperature dependent, while both the entropy and the enthalpy change were strong functions of temperature. The free energy of DNA binding was independent of the pH for the pH range between 6 and 8. Dissection of the entropy change of the association reaction suggested that the two basic domains and the linker region between the subunits underwent a folding transition from a mainly unfolded to a predominantly ordered conformation. Therefore, like wild-type MASH bHLH, the DNA binding reaction of MM17 follows an induced fit mechanism.

Thermodynamics of DNA binding and condensation: isothermal titration calorimetry and electrostatic mechanism

The thermodynamics of binding of the trivalent cations cobalt hexammine and spermidine to plasmid DNA was studied by isothermal titration calorimetry. Two stages were observed in the course of titration, the first attributed to cation binding and the second to DNA condensation. A standard calorimetric data analysis was extended by applying an electrostatic binding model, which accounted for most of the observed data. Both the binding and condensation reactions were entropically driven (TΔS∼+10 kcal/mol cation) and enthalpically opposed (ΔH∼+1 kcal/mol cation). As predicted from their relative sizes, the binding constants of the cations were indistinguishable, but cobalt hexammine had a much greater DNA condensing capacity because it is more compact than spermidine. The dependence of both the free energy of cobalt hexammine binding and the critical cobalt hexammine concentration for DNA condensation on temperature and monovalent cation concentration followed the electrostatic model quite precisely. The heat capacity changes of both stages were positive, perhaps reflecting both the temperature dependence of the dielectric constant of water and the burial of polar surfaces. DNA condensation occurred when about 67 % of the DNA phosphate charge was neutralized by cobalt hexammine and 87 % by spermidine. During condensation, the remaining DNA charge was neutralized.

Protein chemistry-nuclear magnetic resonance approach to mapping functional domains in single-stranded DNA binding proteins.

DNA binding proteins that bind preferentially to single-stranded DNA with relatively little sequence specificity are widely distributed in both prokaryotic and eukaryotic cells. These proteins function in DNA replication and recombination and are synthesized in high enough copy number to suggest that they act in vivo by forming stoichiometric complexes with exposed single-stranded regions of DNA. Some proteins of this class also have significant affinity for single-stranded RNA and may thus influence translation as well. The single-stranded DNA binding proteins coded for by gene 32 of bacteriophage T4 and by gene 5 of the filamentous bacteriophage fd (M13) are the most extensively investigated examples of this class of proteins. The location of the DNA binding domains in the primary structure, the thermodynamics of DNA binding and the specific amino acid residues responsible for the nucleotide-protein interactions have been successfully determined for these proteins by a variety of physicochemical techniques, which include limited proteolysis to determine minimum DNA binding domains, chemical modification to detect specific types of amino acid side chain involved in DNA binding, and a number of oneand two-dimensional 'H-nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) techniques to detect proteinoligonucleotide interactions. A crystal structure is available for the unliganded gene 5 protein, facilitating the detailed study of these interactions. Recently, a program of site-directed mutagenesis has been untertaken to detect specific residues participating in DNA binding and to assign the 'H-NMR spectra residue by residue. Examples of the information obtained by these methods and the synthesis of the findings into models for the binding of single-stranded DNA by these proteins are covered in this review.