Ground Thermal Regime Research Articles

Thermal performance of heat drain under the road embankment near Hudson Strait Coast, Canada

Climate warming has affected the transportation infrastructure in Nunavik, Quebec, Canada. Heat drain is an innovative heat extraction technique using density-driven convection of the pore air in the geocomposite of the heat drain to cool the ground during winter. This paper examines the thermal conditions of the road embankment including a heat drain installed in the shoulder at Salluit, Nunavik, Quebec, Canada. Following the installation of the heat drain, a decrease of the soil temperatures was observed. A 2-D finite element geothermal model was developed to reproduce the thermal regime underneath the heat drain, based on the site condition at Salluit. Field measurement of ground temperature for the four year monitoring period from 2012 to 2016, were used to calibrate the model. After the calibration, the long-term climate warming effects on the ground thermal regime was investigated using the model developed.

Simulating the Thermal Regime and Surface Energy Balance of a Permafrost‐Underlain Forest in Mongolia

AbstractForests overlap with large parts of the northern hemisphere permafrost area, and representing canopy processes is therefore crucial for simulating thermal and hydrological conditions in these regions. Forests impact permafrost through the modulation of radiative fluxes and exchange of turbulent fluxes, precipitation interception and regulation of transpiration. Forests also feature distinct soil layers of litter and organic matter, which play central roles for the infiltration and evaporation of water, while also providing thermal insulation for deeper ground layers. In this study, we present a new module within the CryoGrid community model to simulate forest ecosystems and their impact on the surface water and energy balance. The module includes a big‐leaf vegetation scheme with adaptations for canopy heat storage and transpiration. Furthermore, we account for the effect of surface litter layers on water and energy transfer. We show that the model is capable of simulating radiation, snow cover and ground temperatures below a deciduous needleleaf forest on a north‐facing slope in the Khentii Mountains in Central Mongolia. A sensitivity analysis of topographic aspect and ecosystem configuration confirms the important role of the litter layers for the energy and water balance of the ground. Furthermore, it suggests that the presence of permafrost is primarily linked to topographic aspect rather than the presence of forest at this site. The presented model scheme can be used to study the development of the ground thermal regime in forests, including the state of permafrost, under different climate, ecosystem, and land use scenarios.

Modelling air, ground surface and permafrost temperature variability across four dissimilar valleys, Yukon, Canada

Spatial maps of the air and ground thermal regime were generated for four Yukon valleys. The aim was to model air, ground surface and ground temperature (at fine spatial resolution) using locally measured inverted surface lapse rates (SLR), to better predict temperature along an elevation gradient. These local models were then compared to a regional permafrost probability model, which utilized differing inversion assumptions, as well as circumpolar and national models generated without considering inversions. Overall, permafrost probability in the regional model matched well with the local models where assumptions of treeline and inverted SLRs held true. When normal SLRs were assumed, permafrost presence was overestimated in each valley. This discrepancy was greatest at high elevations where permafrost was predicted to be coldest and most widespread. However, the difference between valleys was dependent on surface and subsurface characteristics such as higher snow cover, mature forest or thick organic layers showed a greater disassociation from the air temperature overall. Appropriate characterization of the SLR is essential for accurate predictions of the ground thermal regime’s spatial distribution and permafrost presence. These models also provide a starting point for better predictions of warming in these valleys and other areas subject to inversions of similar magnitudes.

Influences of Snow Cover on the Thermal Regimes of Xing'an Permafrost in Northeast China in 1960s–2010s

ABSTRACTThe distributive characteristics of snow cover and their impacting mechanisms on ground thermal regimes in Northeast China remain evasive because of limited systematic studies. In this study, based on long‐term ground‐based observational data and auxiliary topographic data, geographically weighted regression kriging (GWRK) method and the temperature at the top of permafrost (TTOP) model were used to analyze the influences of snow cover duration (SCD) and average snow depth over the SCD (ASDSCD) on the thermal regimes of Xing'an permafrost in Northeast China in the 1960s–2010s. The results show a remarkable reduction of permafrost extent in Northeast China from the 1960s to 2010s, with an average reduction rate of 4.115 × 104 km2/decade. In permafrost regions, from the 1960s to 2010s, average SCD varied between 150 and 160 days, and the regional average of ASDSCD between 8 and 14 cm. Increases in ASDSCD led to a rise of TTOP. From the 1960s to 2010s, the regional average of ASDSCD increased by 3.53 cm, and that of TTOP by 2.02°C. The research results can provide scientific basis and data support for evaluating the responses of permafrost and cold region ecosystems to climate change in Northeast China.

Modeling the Link Between Air Convection and the Occurrence of Short‐Term Permafrost in a Low‐Altitude Cold Talus Slope

ABSTRACTWe extend a numerical modeling approach developed to explicitly model convective heat transfer in periglacial landforms to represent the ground thermal regime of low‐altitude talus slopes. Our model solves for heat conduction and accounts explicitly for air convection adopting a Darcy term with a Boussinesq approximation for air circulation in the porous ground. Numerical model experiments for the low‐altitude talus slope Dreveneuse, Switzerland, confirm that air convection is the key to forming and maintaining ground ice. In the model, the porous talus slope is underlain by a layer of water‐bearing morainic material. In years, where the gradient between air and talus temperature is sufficiently large to result in increased convection and therefore cooling, ground ice forms due to air convection within the porous material and lasts for more than a year. It is only by considering convection that the model is able to represent the occurrences of ground ice, in accordance with temperature observations on‐site. These findings are important, as they confirm that ground ice can be formed and maintained in landforms with a mean annual air temperature > 0°C if ground air convection is present combined with the presence of water.

The thermal effect of snow cover on ground surface temperature in the Northern Hemisphere

Snow cover is critical to the ground thermal regime because it affects surface conditions and the energy balance. Prior work inherently included confounding effects from vegetation and the soil when estimating the snow’s effect by using the differences between air and ground surface or soil temperature. Here we use the Kudryavtsev model including a snow module to isolate the effect of only the snow cover during winter, based on observational sites across the Northern Hemisphere. We find that snow’s damping of annual mean ground surface temperature averages 5.06 ± 3.15 °C and ranges 0 °C–10 °C, while damping of the annual ground surface temperature amplitude is 7.95 ± 4.95 °C, ranging 0 °C–20 °C. Greater insulation occurs in the high-latitudes. The insulating effect is primarily driven by snow depth, but also the combination of air temperature and its amplitude, snow depth, and duration. Snow cover duration and low air temperature enhance snow’s insulating ability. These observational results that isolate the damping effect of only the snow could play a significant role in better understanding the energy change between air and the ground.

Spatiotemporal variations in frost cracking measures in two dimensions: A case study for rock walls in Jotunheimen, southern Norway

The ground thermal regime has a profound impact on geomorphological processes and has been suggested to be particularly important for weathering processes in periglacial environments. Several frost-related damage indices have hitherto been developed to link climate and frost weathering potential in bedrock, although only for individual points or grid cells. Here, we model ground temperature and frost weathering potential in steep rock walls in the Jotunheimen Mountains, southern Norway, along a two-dimensional profile line for the Younger Dryas Stadial-Preboreal transition (c. 11.5 ka), the Holocene Thermal Maximum (c. 7.5 ka), the Little Ice Age (1750), and the 2010s. We use an established heat flow model and frost-cracking index based on the ice segregation theory. A central innovation of our model treatment is the implementation of ensemble simulations using distributions of automatically mapped crack radii in a rock wall, whereas previous frost damage models considered only a single characteristic crack radius. Our results allowed for the identification of sites with enhanced frost weathering. Such sites are typically found between rock walls and retreating glaciers, as well as in areas where snow depth changes abruptly, resulting in large thermal gradients. Hence, frost weathering may be highly active during glacier retreat, enhancing the damage to rock walls during deglaciation by adding to the damage from stress release. The coldest climates of the Younger Dryas Stadial-Preboreal transition and the Little Ice Age were generally most favorable for frost cracking. Such timing compares well with the knowledge about the timing of rockfall accumulations in Norway.

Recent ground thermo-hydrological changes in a southern Tibetan endorheic catchment and implications for lake level changes

Abstract. Climate change modifies the water and energy fluxes between the atmosphere and the surface in mountainous regions such as the Qinghai–Tibet Plateau (QTP), which has shown substantial hydrological changes over the last decades, including rapid lake level variations. The ground across the QTP hosts either permafrost or is seasonally frozen, and, in this environment, the ground thermal regime influences liquid water availability, evaporation and runoff. Consequently, climate-induced changes in the ground thermal regime may contribute to variations in lake levels, but the validity of this hypothesis has yet to be established. This study focuses on the cryo-hydrology of the catchment of Lake Paiku (southern Tibet) for the 1980–2019 period. We process ERA5 data with downscaling and clustering tools (TopoSCALE, TopoSUB) to account for the spatial variability of the climate in our forcing data (Fiddes and Gruber, 2012, 2014). We use a distributed setup of the CryoGrid community model (version 1.0) to quantify thermo-hydrological changes in the ground during this period. Forcing data and simulation outputs are validated with data from a weather station, surface temperature loggers and observations of lake level variations. Our lake budget reconstruction shows that the main water input to the lake is direct precipitation (310 mm yr−1), followed by glacier runoff (280 mm yr−1) and land runoff (180 mm yr−1). However, altogether these components do not offset evaporation (860 mm yr−1). Our results show that both seasonal frozen ground and permafrost have warmed (0.17 ∘C per decade 2 m deep), increasing the availability of liquid water in the ground and the duration of seasonal thaw. Correlations with annual values suggest that both phenomena promote evaporation and runoff. Yet, ground warming drives a strong increase in subsurface runoff so that the runoff/(evaporation + runoff) ratio increases over time. This increase likely contributed to stabilizing the lake level decrease after 2010. Summer evaporation is an important energy sink, and we find active-layer deepening only where evaporation is limited. The presence of permafrost is found to promote evaporation at the expense of runoff, consistently with recent studies suggesting that a shallow active layer maintains higher water contents close to the surface. However, this relationship seems to be climate dependent, and we show that a colder and wetter climate produces the opposite effect. Although the present study was performed at the catchment scale, we suggest that this ambivalent influence of permafrost may help to understand the contrasting lake level variations observed between the south and north of the QTP, opening new perspectives for future investigations.

Simulating ice segregation and thaw consolidation in permafrost environments with the CryoGrid community model

Abstract. The ground ice content in cold environments influences the permafrost thermal regime and the thaw trajectories in a warming climate, especially for soils containing excess ice. Despite their importance, the amount and distribution of ground ice are often unknown due to lacking field observations. Hence, modeling the thawing of ice-rich permafrost soils and associated thermokarst is challenging as ground ice content has to be prescribed in the model setup. In this study, we present a model scheme, capable of simulating segregated ice formation during a model spinup together with associated ground heave. It provides the option to add a constant sedimentation rate throughout the simulation. Besides ice segregation, it can represent thaw consolidation processes and ground subsidence under a warming climate. The computation is based on soil mechanical processes, soil hydrology by the Richards equation and soil freezing characteristics. The code is implemented in the CryoGrid community model (version 1.0), a modular land surface model for simulations of the ground thermal regime. The simulation of ice segregation and thaw consolidation with the new model scheme allows us to analyze the evolution of ground ice content in both space and time. To do so, we use climate data from two contrasting permafrost sites to run the simulations. Several influencing factors are identified, which control the formation and thaw of segregated ice. (i) Model results show that high temperature gradients in the soil as well as moist conditions support the formation of segregated ice. (ii) We find that ice segregation increases in fine-grained soils and that especially organic-rich sediments enhance the process. (iii) Applying external loads suppresses ice segregation and speeds up thaw consolidation. (iv) Sedimentation leads to a rise of the ground surface and the formation of an ice-enriched layer whose thickness increases with sedimentation time. We conclude that the new model scheme is a step forward to improve the description of ground ice distributions in permafrost models and can contribute towards the understanding of ice segregation and thaw consolidation in permafrost environments under changing climatic conditions.

Transcriptomic evidence indicates that montane leaf beetles prioritize digestion and reproduction in a sex-specific manner during emergence from dormancy

During winter, many organisms conserve resources by entering dormancy, suppressing metabolism and biosynthesis. The transition out of winter dormancy to summer activity requires a quick reversal of this suppression, in order to exploit now-favorable environmental conditions. To date, mechanisms by which winter climate variation affects this transition remains unelucidated. Here we experimentally manipulated snow cover for naturally overwintering montane leaf beetles (Chrysomela aeneicollis), and profiled changes in gene expression during the transition out of dormancy in spring. Upon emergence, beetles up-regulate transcripts associated with digestion and nutrient acquisition and down regulate those associated with lipid metabolism, suggesting a shift away from utilizing stored lipid and towards digestion of carbohydrate-rich host plant tissue. Development of digestive capacity is followed by up-regulation of transcripts associated with reproduction; a transition that occurs earlier in females than males. Snow manipulation strongly affected the ground thermal regime and correspondingly gene expression profiles, with beetles showing a delayed up-regulation of reproduction in the dry compared to snowy plots. This suggests that winter conditions can alter the timing and prioritization of processes during emergence from dormancy, potentially magnifying the effects of declining snow cover in the Sierra's and other snowy mountains.

The CryoGrid community model (version 1.0) – a multi-physics toolbox for climate-driven simulations in the terrestrial cryosphere

Abstract. The CryoGrid community model is a flexible toolbox for simulating the ground thermal regime and the ice–water balance for permafrost and glaciers, extending a well-established suite of permafrost models (CryoGrid 1, 2, and 3). The CryoGrid community model can accommodate a wide variety of application scenarios, which is achieved by fully modular structures through object-oriented programming. Different model components, characterized by their process representations and parameterizations, are realized as classes (i.e., objects) in CryoGrid. Standardized communication protocols between these classes ensure that they can be stacked vertically. For example, the CryoGrid community model features several classes with different complexity for the seasonal snow cover, which can be flexibly combined with a range of classes representing subsurface materials, each with their own set of process representations (e.g., soil with and without water balance, glacier ice). We present the CryoGrid architecture as well as the model physics and defining equations for the different model classes, focusing on one-dimensional model configurations which can also interact with external heat and water reservoirs. We illustrate the wide variety of simulation capabilities for a site on Svalbard, with point-scale permafrost simulations using, e.g., different soil freezing characteristics, drainage regimes, and snow representations, as well as simulations for glacier mass balance and a shallow water body. The CryoGrid community model is not intended as a static model framework but aims to provide developers with a flexible platform for efficient model development. In this study, we document both basic and advanced model functionalities to provide a baseline for the future development of novel cryosphere models.

Simulating the thermal regime of a railway embankment structure on the Tibetan Plateau under climate change

With global warming and its amplified effect on the Tibetan Plateau, the permafrost on the Tibetan Plateau has been significantly degraded, manifested by decreased permafrost thickness, increased active layer thickness, thermokarst, and surface subsidence, causing severe damage to infrastructure. To better understand and assess the future stability of the Qinghai-Tibet Railway, we used a laterally coupled version of the one-dimensional CryoGrid3 land surface model to simulate the thermal regimes of the railway subgrade under current climate conditions. By modeling ground subsidence (i.e., by simulating the melting of excess ice) we provide estimates of future subgrade stability under low (Representative Concentration Pathway 2.6 [RCP2.6]) and high (RCP8.5) climate warming scenarios. Our modeled results reveal satisfactory performance with respect to the comparison of measured and modeled ground thermal regimes. Under current climate conditions, we infer that mostly thaw-stable conditions as maximum thaw depths do not reach the embankment base. The sunny side of the embankment (southeast-facing) reveals being more vulnerable to suffering from thaw settlement or thermal erosion than the shady side (northwest-facing). The extent of future railway failure due to thawing permafrost will depend on the magnitude of the warming. For conditions typical of Beiluhe (situated on continuous permafrost in the central Tibetan Plateau), the railway embankment might largely maintain safe operation until the end of the century under a scenario of climate stabilization. In contrast, under strong warming the railway subgrade is likely to destabilize from the 2030s onwards and embankment subsidence is initiated at mid-century through the melting of excess ice.

Effect of Culverts on the Thermal Regime of a Railway Embankment

A common issue for Canadian railway operators is the development of localized frost heave near railway culverts, which leads to nonuniform deformation of the track surface and degradation of the track geometry, damages the track component, and affects the quality of rides in railway operations. Frequent maintenance including placing wooden shims between rail and ties and often the reduction of train speeds are required to ensure safe operating conditions. Given the future expected climate patterns, freeze–thaw cycles are anticipated to become more frequent, and therefore, a greater understanding of their effect on the changing ground thermal regime under railway embankments is essential. This paper investigates the effects of culverts and insulation layers on changing the temperature regime of the ground during the winter–spring period through numerical modeling in TEMP/W (version 2019) two-dimensional (2D) and three-dimensional (3D) software. The model was calibrated using actual field measurements collected from an instrumented section of the track that has suffered from frost heaves at the proximity of a culvert. Using the results from 2D simulation, the effect of culverts on extending the frost zone, in both horizontal and vertical directions, was quantified. In addition, the effects of shape, installation depth, and the number of culverts on the frost penetration depth were discussed. Using TEMP/W 3D results, the most appropriate configuration to install the culverts was studied to minimize frost penetration.

Simulating the effect of subsurface drainage on the thermal regime and ground ice in blocky terrain in Norway

Abstract. Ground temperatures in coarse, blocky deposits such as mountain blockfields and rock glaciers have long been observed to be lower in comparison with other (sub)surface material. One of the reasons for this negative temperature anomaly is the lower soil moisture content in blocky terrain, which decreases the duration of the zero curtain in autumn. Here we used the CryoGrid community model to simulate the effect of drainage on the ground thermal regime and ground ice in blocky terrain permafrost at two sites in Norway. The model set-up is based on a one-dimensional model domain and features a surface energy balance, heat conduction and advection, as well as a bucket water scheme with adjustable lateral drainage. We used three idealized subsurface stratigraphies, blocks only, blocks with sediment and sediment only, which can be either drained (i.e. with strong lateral subsurface drainage) or undrained (i.e. without drainage), resulting in six scenarios. The main difference between the three stratigraphies is their ability to retain water against drainage: while the blocks only stratigraphy can only hold small amounts of water, much more water is retained within the sediment phase of the two other stratigraphies, which critically modifies the freeze–thaw behaviour. The simulation results show markedly lower ground temperatures in the blocks only, drained scenario compared to other scenarios, with a negative thermal anomaly of up to 2.2 ∘C. For this scenario, the model can in particular simulate the time evolution of ground ice, with build-up during and after snowmelt and spring and gradual lowering of the ice table in the course of the summer season. The thermal anomaly increases with larger amounts of snowfall, showing that well-drained blocky deposits are less sensitive to insulation by snow than other soils. We simulate stable permafrost conditions at the location of a rock glacier in northern Norway with a mean annual ground surface temperature of 2.0–2.5 ∘C in the blocks only, drained simulations. Finally, transient simulations since 1951 at the rock glacier site (starting with permafrost conditions for all stratigraphies) showed a complete loss of perennial ground ice in the upper 5 m of the ground in the blocks with sediment, drained run; a 1.6 m lowering of the ground ice table in the sediment only, drained run; and only 0.1 m lowering in the blocks only, drained run. The interplay between the subsurface water–ice balance and ground freezing/thawing driven by heat conduction can at least partly explain the occurrence of permafrost in coarse blocky terrain below the elevational limit of permafrost in non-blocky sediments. It is thus important to consider the subsurface water–ice balance in blocky terrain in future efforts in permafrost distribution mapping in mountainous areas. Furthermore, an accurate prediction of the evolution of the ground ice table in a future climate can have implications for slope stability, as well as water resources in arid environments.

Two-dimensional simulation of island permafrost degradation in Northeastern Tibetan Plateau

Despite the response of ground temperatures to increases in air temperature, discontinuous and isolated bodies of permafrost are strongly affected by lateral heat fluxes from adjacent unfrozen zones. However, many current simulations consider heat flow in only one-dimension (1D) and thus cannot represent two or three-dimensional effects. To address this issue, we use fine-scale in situ measurements and two-dimension (2D) heat conduction simulations and compare the simulated ground thermal evolution and degradation of island permafrost to a 1D simulation. The 2D simulation reasonably represented seasonal and interannual features of the ground thermal regime, such as temperature profile, thawing/frozen depth, and permafrost body width. Lateral thawing of the island permafrost was dominant, and was about one order of magnitude greater than the modelled vertical thaw. In the vertical direction, downward permafrost thaw caused by increase in air temperature rise was restricted by phase change of ground ice near the permafrost table during the simulation period, contributing little to the overall permafrost degradation. Rates of permafrost degradation in the 1D simulation were 1.6–1.8 times lower than the simulation considering lateral heat fluxes. The field monitoring and numerical simulation highlight the importance of coupling lateral heat transfer in permafrost models.

The Effects of Clear-Cutting on Ground Thermal Regimes After a Wildfire Using Hand-Held Thermal Imaging Camera in a Semi-arid Forest Ecosystems

The Effects of Clear-Cutting on Ground Thermal Regimes After a Wildfire Using Hand-Held Thermal Imaging Camera in a Semi-arid Forest Ecosystems

Ground and Near-Rock Surface Air Thermal Regimes in the High Mountain of the Picos De Europa (Cantabrian Mountains, NW Spain)

Even when the influence of climate on the geomorphological dynamics of mountain areas is well known, the ground and near-rock surface air thermal regimes of the highest altitude Cantabrian massifs still being poorly understood. This study, based on the examination of the thermal data obtained through the use of air and soil temperature dataloggers, aims to characterize the thermal regime of one of the most representative high mountain massifs of the Cantabrian Mountains: the Western Massif of the Picos de Europa. Results show the severe climatic conditions that prevail in the highest areas, where the snow cover lasts for 8 months on average, exerting an important insulating role of the soil. Thus, except on the uncovered rocky walls, the number of freeze-thaw cycles per year is low (0–16), with these cycles having a short duration and a low thermal amplitude. Significantly differences on annual thermal regimes have been confirmed; with two main phases (continued thaw phase and isothermal phase) and two minor transition phases at the ground, and only two main phases in near-rock surfaces (continued thaw phase and phase with a high number of FTCs).

Impact of Climate Change on the Ground Thermal Regime in the Lower Lena Region, Arctic Central Siberia

This paper presents the results of 30 years of permafrost thermal monitoring in the Tiksi area in the eastern Russian Arctic. At a stone ridge site, the mean annual temperatures in the upper 30 m of the ground have increased by 1–2.4 °C compared to the first years of observations, with trends of °C/yr. At the same time, its change was uneven. In the last 20 years, the rate of increase has increased compared with the first decade of observations. At wet tundra sites in the foothill plain, the mean annual temperatures at the top of permafrost have increased by 2.4–2.6 °C between 2005 and 2022 at rates of 0.11–0.15 °C/yr, and the active layer thicknesses have increased at rates of 0.05–0.41 cm/yr.

Influence of Snowpack Cold Content on Seasonally Frozen Ground and Its Hydrologic Consequences: A Case Study From Niwot Ridge, CO

AbstractFrozen ground influences subsurface hydrology by reducing soil permeability, impeding infiltration, and inducing surface runoff. As the seasonal snowpack strongly controls the evolution of the ground thermal regime, it is necessary to represent the snowpack in models simulating frozen ground and its hydrologic consequences. Conventional understanding of the relationship between snowcover and frozen ground considers the snowpack as an insulator, shielding the ground from cold winter temperatures and thus inhibiting frozen ground. However, observations and modeling at Niwot Ridge, a seasonally snow‐covered alpine catchment in the headwaters of the Boulder Creek watershed, illustrate that snowpack cold content can promote and preserve frozen ground beneath the snowpack during the snowmelt season, unlike bare ground patches that thaw relatively rapidly due to exposure to solar radiation and warm spring temperatures. We present results from a coupled snowpack and subsurface thermo‐hydrologic model including freeze‐thaw processes that captures these contrasts reasonably well. Our results suggest that the cold snowpack at this site acts as a heat sink and promotes frozen ground, in contrast to the conventional understanding of the snowpack as an insulator. In the subalpine zone, infiltration simulations show that shallow freezing beneath snow‐covered ground has a much stronger effect on infiltration than shallow freezing beneath bare ground because the soil beneath the snow remained frozen during snowmelt, whereas bare patches thawed by the time they received excess snowmelt run‐on.

Permafrost geomorphology

Abstract Permafrost geomorphology came of age in 1965–2000, evolving from a field-based subdiscipline largely based on qualitative observation to one of detailed process measurement, field experimentation, and analytical modelling. In this, the development of permafrost geomorphology exemplified the change in geomorphology as a whole. Fundamental advances were made in understanding the development of ice wedges and ice-wedge polygons and the genesis and growth of closed-system pingos, especially by J. Ross Mackay working in the continuous permafrost terrain of the western Canadian Arctic coastlands. Mackay also investigated moisture movement in relation to the ground thermal regime, which led to seminal insights regarding ground freezing, frost heave, near-surface ground ice development, and hummocky micro-relief. Others used these ideas to examine frost shattering of rocks and the development of sorted circles, as most well known from Svalbard. In the second half of the period, measurements of permafrost creep and deformation of hillslopes and rock glaciers were presented, complementing antecedent measurements of solifluction in the active layer. Significant investigations of thermokarst development foreshadowed the preoccupation with permafrost thaw that now gathers so much attention.