Patients diagnosed with primary sclerosing cholangitis (PSC) but with characteristics of immunoglobulin G4 (IgG4)-associated cholangitis (IAC) have been described. IAC often presents with biliary IgG4-positive plasma cell (IgG4+ PC) infiltration and responds to corticosteroids. In PSC, the frequencies or implications of biliary IgG4+ PC are unknown. We aimed to characterize the phenomenon of biliary IgG4+ PC in patients with an established PSC diagnosis. Bile duct biopsies from 191 surveillance or therapeutic endoscopic retrograde cholangiography of 58 PSC patients were retrospectively analyzed for IgG4+ PC infiltration. Patients with ≥10 IgG4+ PC per high-power field (HPF) were identified and characterized by clinical parameters, including serum IgG4 and cholangiographic presentations. Altogether 39.7% of the PSC patients showed ≥10 IgG4+ PC/HPF in bile duct biopsies. Patients with biliary IgG4+ PC infiltration were significantly younger at diagnosis of PSC (P = 0.023). There was no association between biliary IgG4+ PC infiltration and transplant-free survival (P = 0.618). Patients with IgG4+ PC infiltration in bile duct biopsies showed significantly higher baseline (P = 0.002) and maximum (P = 0.001) serum IgG4 compared to those without. Biliary IgG4+ PC infiltration was associated with high-grade bile duct strictures (P = 0.05). IgG4-positive plasma cell infiltrations were found multifocally in 72.7% of this subgroup of PSC patients. IgG4+ PC ≥10/HPF can be found abundantly in bile duct biopsies in PSC. Histological findings correlated with serum IgG4, age, and high-grade bile duct strictures. IgG4+ PC was located multifocally, hinting at a systemic biliary phenotype.