Abstract Aim To perform an audit to check the Quality and compliance of Surgical documentation using STAR Score at a tertiary hospital in India. Method A total of 90 case files were studied and assessed in detail from all surgical departments. The “STAR: Surgical tool for auditing records” tool was used to collect data accordingly. The results were compared with standard guidelines and further analyzed. A series of departmental training and implementation meetings were carried out. Three cycles were carried out and a re-audit was performed at the end of every cycle. Result The overall compliance score of the hospital was found to be 74%. While the departments of General surgery and orthopaedics showed a higher rate of compliance, each constituting 82%, Neurosurgery showed the least compliance at 62%. It was also seen that the maximum percentage of missing information constituted anaesthetic records and subsequent entries. At the end of 3 cycles, a considerable improvement was observed, with the compliance rate improving to 98% in all departments. Conclusion We believe that compliance and implementation of the STAR Score is mandatory, as it can significantly improve the quality of documentation and can be implemented universally.