Temperature Reaction Norms Research Articles

Evolutionary divergence of reaction norms in ecological context: a commentary.

Evolutionary divergence of reaction norms in ecological context: a commentary.

Differing responses of marine N2 fixers to warming and consequences for future diazotroph community structure

AME Aquatic Microbial Ecology Contact the journal Facebook Twitter RSS Mailing List Subscribe to our mailing list via Mailchimp HomeLatest VolumeAbout the JournalEditorsSpecials AME 72:33-46 (2014) - DOI: https://doi.org/10.3354/ame01683 Differing responses of marine N2 fixers to warming and consequences for future diazotroph community structure Fei-Xue Fu*, Elizabeth Yu, Nathan S. Garcia, Jasmine Gale, Yunsheng Luo, Eric A. Webb, David A. Hutchins Department of Biological Sciences, The University of Southern California, 3616 Trousdale Parkway, Los Angeles, California 90089, USA *Corresponding author: ffu@usc.edu ABSTRACT: The globally distributed colonial cyanobacterium Trichodesmium and unicellular diazotrophs including Crocosphaera together carry out the majority of marine biological nitrogen (N2) fixation. Future sea surface warming is predicted to influence their abundance and distribution, but temperature reaction norms have been determined for very few representatives of each genus. We compared thermal responses within and between the 2 genera Trichodesmium and Crocosphaera by measuring reaction norms for growth, N2 fixation, carbon fixation, and elemental ratios in 7 strains from a global culture collection. Temperature reaction norms of Trichodesmium and Crocosphaera were remarkably similar for all isolates within each genus, regardless of their geographic origin. Thermal limits of Trichodesmium and Crocosphaera ranged from 18 to 32°C and 24 to 32°C, and optimum growth temperatures were ~26 and ~30°C, respectively. The highest cellular ratios of nitrogen to phosphorus and carbon to nitrogen were found at optimum growth temperatures, and the lowest ratios near their thermal limits. In a mixed competition experiment, Trichodesmium growth rates were ~25% higher than those of Crocosphaera at 24°C, while those of Crocosphaera were ~50% higher at 28°C. Comparison of these results to current and projected seasonal temperature regimes in the subtropical Atlantic and Pacific Oceans suggests that predicted warmer temperatures may favor Crocosphaera over Trichodesmium, but that both genera may be excluded where future temperatures consistently exceed 32°C. Sea surface warming could profoundly alter the community structure and stoichiometry of marine N2-fixing cyanobacteria, thus fundamentally changing the biogeochemical cycling of this globally significant source of new nitrogen. KEY WORDS: Global change · Warming · Temperature · Nitrogen fixation · Trichodesmium · Crocosphaera Full text in pdf format PreviousNextCite this article as: Fu FX, Yu E, Garcia NS, Gale J, Luo Y, Webb EA, Hutchins DA (2014) Differing responses of marine N2 fixers to warming and consequences for future diazotroph community structure. Aquat Microb Ecol 72:33-46. https://doi.org/10.3354/ame01683 Export citation RSS - Facebook - Tweet - linkedIn Cited by Published in AME Vol. 72, No. 1. Online publication date: March 07, 2014 Print ISSN: 0948-3055; Online ISSN: 1616-1564 Copyright © 2014 Inter-Research.

Local Adaptation at the Transcriptome Level in Brown Trout: Evidence from Early Life History Temperature Genomic Reaction Norms

Local adaptation and its underlying molecular basis has long been a key focus in evolutionary biology. There has recently been increased interest in the evolutionary role of plasticity and the molecular mechanisms underlying local adaptation. Using transcriptome analysis, we assessed differences in gene expression profiles for three brown trout (Salmo trutta) populations, one resident and two anadromous, experiencing different temperature regimes in the wild. The study was based on an F2 generation raised in a common garden setting. A previous study of the F1 generation revealed different reaction norms and significantly higher QST than FST among populations for two early life-history traits. In the present study we investigated if genomic reaction norm patterns were also present at the transcriptome level. Eggs from the three populations were incubated at two temperatures (5 and 8 degrees C) representing conditions encountered in the local environments. Global gene expression for fry at the stage of first feeding was analysed using a 32k cDNA microarray. The results revealed differences in gene expression between populations and temperatures and population × temperature interactions, the latter indicating locally adapted reaction norms. Moreover, the reaction norms paralleled those observed previously at early life-history traits. We identified 90 cDNA clones among the genes with an interaction effect that were differently expressed between the ecologically divergent populations. These included genes involved in immune- and stress response. We observed less plasticity in the resident as compared to the anadromous populations, possibly reflecting that the degree of environmental heterogeneity encountered by individuals throughout their life cycle will select for variable level of phenotypic plasticity at the transcriptome level. Our study demonstrates the usefulness of transcriptome approaches to identify genes with different temperature reaction norms. The responses observed suggest that populations may vary in their susceptibility to climate change.

The Effect of Fluctuating Temperatures During Development on Fitness-Related Traits ofScatophaga stercoraria(Diptera: Scathophagidae)

Development of ectotherms is highly temperature dependent. Studies using variable thermal environments can improve ecological relevance of data because organisms naturally face day-to-day stochastic temperature fluctuations as well as seasonal changes in the amplitude of such daily fluctuations. The objective of this study was to investigate if, and to what extent, the use of constant temperatures is justified in studies of the model species, yellow dung fly, Scatophaga stercoraria (L.). We examined the effect of temperature fluctuation on the expression of several life history traits and the effect on subsequent adult longevity. We used two fluctuating temperature treatments with the same mean but different amplitudes (15/21°C, 12/24°C; 12/12 h), and three constant temperature treatments spanning the wide temperature range faced in the wild (12, 18, and 24°C). Large temperature fluctuation was mostly detrimental (lower juvenile survival, slower growth, smaller body size, and longer development), whereas moderate temperature fluctuation usually gave responses similar to the constant regime. When developing in fluctuating temperatures, adult longevity (no effect), body size (lower), and wing shape (narrower wings) deviated from the expectations based on the constant temperature reaction norms, presumably because of acclimation responses. Contrary to some studies no obvious beneficial effects of moderate temperature fluctuation were observed. Instead, yellow dung flies seem to canalize development in the face of temperature fluctuation up to a point when detrimental effects become unavoidable. The relatively greater effects of extreme constant developmental temperatures question their biological relevance in experiments.

Temperature reaction norms of Daphnia carinata fitness: the effects of food concentration, population density, and photoperiod

Increasing concerns over climate change have renewed interest in temperature effects on aquatic organisms. The effects of temperature, food concentration, population density, and photoperiod on Daphnia carinata fitness were examined using life-table experiments in a full factorial design. The high temperature enhanced fitness at the high food concentration, but depressed it at the low food concentration. The temperature–food interactions were significant in the four combinations of two population densities and two photoperiods. The temperature–population density interactions were significant in the two combinations of two photoperiods and the high food concentration, in which the high population density masked the temperature effects. The temperature–photoperiod interaction was only significant in one combination with the low population density and the low food concentration, in which the long day length weakened the temperature effects. Such complicated interactions suggest that multiple ecological variables need to be taken into account simultaneously when assessing temperature effects on zooplankton in nature.

Coping with Temperature at the Warm Edge – Patterns of Thermal Adaptation in the Microbial Eukaryote Paramecium caudatum

BackgroundEctothermic organisms are thought to be severely affected by global warming since their physiological performance is directly dependent on temperature. Latitudinal and temporal variations in mean temperatures force ectotherms to adapt to these complex environmental conditions. Studies investigating current patterns of thermal adaptation among populations of different latitudes allow a prediction of the potential impact of prospective increases in environmental temperatures on their fitness.Methodology/Principal FindingsIn this study, temperature reaction norms were ascertained among 18 genetically defined, natural clones of the microbial eukaryote Paramecium caudatum. These different clones have been isolated from 12 freshwater habitats along a latitudinal transect in Europe and from 3 tropical habitats (Indonesia). The sensitivity to increasing temperatures was estimated through the analysis of clone specific thermal tolerances and by relating those to current and predicted temperature data of their natural habitats.All investigated European clones seem to be thermal generalists with a broad thermal tolerance and similar optimum temperatures. The weak or missing co-variation of thermal tolerance with latitude does not imply local adaptation to thermal gradients; it rather suggests adaptive phenotypic plasticity among the whole European subpopulation. The tested Indonesian clones appear to be locally adapted to the less variable, tropical temperature regime and show higher tolerance limits, but lower tolerance breadths.Conclusions/SignificanceDue to the lack of local temperature adaptation within the European subpopulation, P. caudatum genotypes at the most southern edge of their geographic range seem to suffer from the predicted increase in magnitude and frequency of summer heat waves caused by climate change.

The costs of phenotypic adaptation to repeatedly fluctuating temperatures in a soil arthropod

Costs of phenotypic adaptation to changing environments have often been studied in morphological structures. Such structures typically are irreversible for at least some stage in the organism's life. In this study we investigated whether recurrent and reversible adaptation to changes in the thermal environment incurs a cost in terms of some key life-history traits in the collembolan Orchesella cincta. We exposed juvenile O. cincta to two treatments differing in the frequency of temperature fluctuation but with equal total temperature sums. In the high frequency treatment temperature fluctuated daily between 10 and 20 °C, while in the low frequency treatment temperature fluctuated on a weekly schedule. During the treatments we measured juvenile growth rate and juvenile mortality, and after six weeks the animals were transferred to constant 15 °C and adult starvation resistance was assessed. We found no significant differences between the treatments in juvenile growth rate or juvenile survival. Also, adults that had grown up under high frequency temperature fluctuations did not suffer from reduced starvation resistance compared to animals growing under low frequency temperature fluctuations. This finding supports the hypothesis that selection minimizes the production costs of inducible phenotypes and suggests that the development of optimal phenotypes and evolution of temperature reaction norms are not constrained by such costs.

Thermal performance curves of Paramecium caudatum: A model selection approach

The ongoing climate change has motivated numerous studies investigating the temperature response of various organisms, especially that of ectotherms. To correctly describe the thermal performance of these organisms, functions are needed which sufficiently fit to the complete optimum curve. Surprisingly, model-comparisons for the temperature-dependence of population growth rates of an important ectothermic group, the protozoa, are still missing. In this study, temperature reaction norms of natural isolates of the freshwater protist Paramecium caudatum were investigated, considering nearly the entire temperature range. These reaction norms were used to estimate thermal performance curves by applying a set of commonly used model functions. An information theory approach was used to compare models and to identify the best ones for describing these data. Our results indicate that the models which can describe negative growth at the high- and low-temperature branch of an optimum curve are preferable. This is a prerequisite for accurately calculating the critical upper and lower thermal limits. While we detected a temperature optimum of around 29°C for all investigated clonal strains, the critical thermal limits were considerably different between individual clones. Here, the tropical clone showed the narrowest thermal tolerance, with a shift of its critical thermal limits to higher temperatures.

Spatio-temporal patterns of gene flow and dispersal under temperature increase

Recent data show that the Earth climate is undergoing a change at a rate which is outstanding in geologic history. Temperature is one of the major driving forces of gene flow and dispersal. In this paper the spatial dynamics of genetic dispersal is studied under the auspices of temperature increase by means of a mathematical model. The main elements genetics, competition and dispersal are combined in a coherent approach by a system of coupled partial differential equations with non-linear reaction terms describing population dynamics, genetic exchange and competition. Temperature reaction norms are conferred by a two allele system. The non-linearities of the interaction terms give rise to a richness of spatio-temporal dynamic patterns. Here we show how invasion processes in form of travelling waves are initiated by a temperature rise.

Study of intrapopulational variability of duration and temperature norms of development of the linden bug Pyrrhocoris apterus (Heteroptera, Pyrrhocoridae)

The existence of significant variability in duration and temperature norms of development has been shown for the first time between families within insect populations. This variability is infer-family and therefore has genetic basis. Revealed for the first time is the statistically significant positive correlations between the regression coefficient of the rate of development for temperature and the threshold of temperature for development of eggs and larvae from different families. The greater the slope of the regression line of the development rate for temperature, the higher the temperature threshold value in this particular family. These results demonstrate for the first time existence of genetic covariation between the regression coefficient and the temperature threshold within the insect populations. It is suggested that the intrapopulational genetic variability in the development time, regression coefficient, and the temperature threshold for development, which is the subject of natural selection, might be the source of the interpopulation and interspecies variability of the temperature reaction norms of development. It was found that value of the linear regression coefficient of development rates for temperature were statistically significantly higher, while the temperature threshold values--lower in eggs as compared with the corresponding parameters in larvae. These results obviously are in contradiction with the concept of the "developmental rate isomorphy in insects and mites" (Jarosik et al., 2002) which claims that the temperature threshold for development should be the same for all species cycle stages, so that only slopes of the regression lines can differ. Shown for the first time was the absence of genetic co-variability of the temperature reaction norms for development of different life cycle stages, i. e., eggs and larvae. This means that the regression coefficient (as well as the temperature requirement of the sum of the degree-days) and the temperature threshold for development in eggs and larvae are inherited independently and thereby they can change in evolution independently according to specific environmental condition under which these life cycle stages exist.

REACTION NORM VARIANTS FOR MALE CALLING SONG IN POPULATIONS OF ACHROIA GRISELLA (LEPIDOPTERA: PYRALIDAE): TOWARD A RESOLUTION OF THE LEK PARADOX

Significant additive genetic variance often occurs for male advertisement traits in spite of the directional selection imposed by female choice, a problem generally known in evolutionary biology as the lek paradox. One hypothesis, which has limited support from recent studies, for the resolution of this paradox is the role of genotype x environment interaction in which no one genotype exhibits the superior performance in all environments--a crossover of reaction norms. However, these studies have not characterized the actual variation of reaction norms present in natural populations, and the extent to which crossover maintains genetic variance remains unknown. Here, we present a study of genotype x environment interaction for the male calling song in populations of Achroia grisella (Lepidoptera: Pyralidae; lesser waxmoth). We report significant variance among reaction norms for male calling song in two North American populations of A. grisella as measured along temperature, food availability, and density gradients, and there is a relatively high incidence of crossover of the temperature reaction norms. This range of reaction norm variants and their crossover may reflect the co-occurrence of plastic and canalized genotypes, and we argue that the different responses of these variants along environmental gradients may contribute toward the maintenance of genetic variance for male song.

Variation, selection and heritability of thermal reaction norms for juvenile growth in Orchesella cincta (Collembola: Entomobryidae)

Genetic variation for thermal plasticity plays an important role in the success or failure of a species with respect to the colonization of different thermal habitats and the ability to deal with climatic change. The aim of this paper is to study the relative contribution of the additive and non-additive components of genetic variation for the slope of the temperature reaction norm for juvenile growth rate in the springtail Orchesella cincta. We present the outcome of an artificial selection experiment for steep and flat temperature reaction norms and the results of a parent-offspring heritability experiment. There was a considerable phenotypic variation for the slope of the reaction norm. The selection experiment and the offspring to parent regression analysis, however, yielded no evidence for significant additive genetic variance. There were also no indications for maternal effects. The full-sib analysis, on the other hand, revealed a significant broad sense heritability of 0.76. An unforeseen result was that the slopes of females were steeper than those of males. This influenced the broad sense heritability of the full-sib analysis, since accidental female or male biased broods inflate the estimate of heritability. A randomization test showed that the probability level of the observed between group variance on the basis of the sexual differences alone was less than 10-5. From this we conclude that autosomal genetic variation played its own separate role. In conclusion, the thermal reaction norm for growth in juvenile O. cincta is not very much determined by the additive effects of a large number of independent genes, but more likely based on a still unknown but mainly non-additive, partially sex-related genetic mechanism, possibly including both dominance and epistatic effects. Hypotheses about the role of phenotypic plasticity in processes of local adaptation and speciation should thus be alert to such a complex genetic architecture.

NATURAL SELECTION AND GENETIC VARIATION FOR REPRODUCTIVE REACTION NORMS IN A WILD BIRD POPULATION

Many morphological and life-history traits show phenotypic plasticity that can be described by reaction norms, but few studies have attempted individual-level analyses of reaction norms in the wild. We analyzed variation in individual reaction norms between laying date and three climatic variables (local temperature, local rainfall, and North Atlantic Oscillation) of 1126 female collared flycatchers (Ficedula albicollis) with a restricted maximum likehood linear mixed model approach using random-effect best linear unbiased predictor estimates for the elevation (i.e., expected laying date in the average environment) and slope (i.e., adjustment in laying date as a function of environment) of females' reaction norms. Variation in laying date was best explained by local temperature, and individual females differed in both the elevation and the slope of their laying date–temperature reaction norms. As revealed by animal model analyses, there was weak evidence for additive genetic variance of elevation (h2 ± SE = 0.09 ± 0.09), whereas there was no evidence for heritability of slope (h2 ± SE = 0.00 ± 0.01). Selection analysis, using a female's lifetime production of fledglings or recruits as an estimate of her fitness, revealed significant selection for a lower phenotypic value and breeding value for elevation (i.e., earlier laying date at the average temperature). There was selection for steeper phenotypic values of slope (i.e., greater plasticity in the adjustment of laying date to temperature), but no significant selection on the breeding values of slope. Although these results suggest that phenotypic laying date is influenced by additive genetic factors, as well as by an interaction with the environment, selection on plasticity would not produce an evolutionary response.

The effect of temperature and wing morphology on quantitative genetic variation in the cricket Gryllus firmus, with an appendix examining the statistical properties of the Jackknife–manova method of matrix comparison

We investigated the effect of temperature and wing morphology on the quantitative genetic variances and covariances of five size-related traits in the sand cricket, Gryllus firmus. Micropterous and macropterous crickets were reared in the laboratory at 24, 28 and 32 degrees C. Quantitative genetic parameters were estimated using a nested full-sib family design, and (co)variance matrices were compared using the T method, Flury hierarchy and Jackknife-manova method. The results revealed that the mean phenotypic value of each trait varied significantly among temperatures and wing morphs, but temperature reaction norms were not similar across all traits. Micropterous individuals were always smaller than macropterous individuals while expressing more phenotypic variation, a finding discussed in terms of canalization and life-history trade-offs. We observed little variation between the matrices of among-family (co)variation corresponding to each combination of temperature and wing morphology, with only one matrix of six differing in structure from the others. The implications of this result are discussed with respect to the prediction of evolutionary trajectories.

Coexistence of similar genotypes of Daphnia magna in intermittent populations: response to thermal stress

We investigated the diversity and thermal response of a fitness related trait, juvenile growth rate, in seasonal population samples of Daphnia magna from two temperate ponds. Both populations were intermittent, i.e. they disappeared from the water body and recolonized seasonally by hatching from resting eggs in the sediment.Temporally isolated clones of Daphniamagna showed the typical asymmetric response for growth rate with temperature and a sharp decline after the maximum response at 26°C (TMR). There was no evidence for genetically adapted seasonal groups. Despite significant genetic variation among clones and for phenotypic plasticity (G×E interactions without genetic correlations), seasonal groups of clones showed no shift in TMR and mean temperature reaction norms were similar among groups and both populations. Heritabilities remained similar among temperatures despite a large increase in genetic variance at stressfully high temperatures of 29°C and 32°C, due to simultaneous increase in environmental variance. Further, heritabilities remained high among sample periods and were not eroded during several months of asexual reproduction.Regular diapause, an intrinsic feature of intermittent Daphnia populations, may replace the need for physiological temperature adaptation and promote maintenance of diversity through phenotypic similarity by reducing the time over which competitive interactions occur. Such populations are unlikely to be directly affected by elevated temperatures. They have a large potential for phenotypic plasticity as their TMR is higher than the temperature normally encountered.

Temperature reaction norms of Daphnia magna: the effect of food concentration

1. The effects of temperature and food concentration on the fitness of Daphnia magna were tested in a 4×4 factorial flow‐through design. Food ranged from 0.1 to 1.0 mg C L−1 and temperature ranged from 15 to 30 °C. 2. The juvenile growth rate (gj) was used to construct reaction norms for temperature at varying food concentrations. Two clones isolated from the same pond at different seasons did not differ with respect to their temperature responses. Reaction norms had the shape of an optimum curve with highest values around 20 °C. There was a significant temperature–food interaction as the temperature response was most pronounced when the food was not limiting. 3. Differences in fitness were a consequence of different responses of physiological parameters to food and temperature. Age and size at first reproduction, as well as egg numbers, decreased with increasing temperature and decreasing food concentration. 4. As the temperature effect was strongest at the highest food concentrations, it can be concluded that environmental warming may affect D. magna more through a temperature rise earlier in spring rather than in summer.

Temperature adaptation in a geographically widespread zooplankter, Daphnia magna

Abstract Evidence for temperature adaptation in Daphnia magna was inferred from variation in the shape of temperature reaction norms for somatic growth rate, a fitness-related trait. Ex-ephippial clones from eight populations across Europe were grown under standardized conditions after preacclimation at five temperatures (17–29 °C). Significant variation for grand mean growth rates occurred both within populations (among clones) and between populations. Genetic variation for reaction norm shape was found within populations, with temperature-dependent trade-offs in clone relative fitness. However, the population average responses to temperature were similar, following approximately parallel reaction norms. The among-population variation is not evidence for temperature adaptation. Lack of temperature adaptation at the population level may be a feature of intermittent populations where environmentally terminated diapause can entrain the planktonic stage of the life-history within a similar range of temperatures.