TCR Ligands Research Articles

PD-1 controls differentiation, survival, and TCR affinity evolution of stem-like CD8+ T cells.

Stem-like progenitors are a critical subset of cytotoxic T cells that self-renew and give rise to expanded populations of effector cells critical for successful checkpoint blockade immunotherapy. Emerging evidence suggests that the tumor-draining lymph nodes can support the continuous generation of these stem-like cells that replenish the tumor sites and act as a critical source of expanded effector populations, underlining the importance of understanding what factors promote and maintain activated T cells in the stem-like state. Using advanced 3D multiplex immunofluorescence imaging, here we identified antigen-presentation niches in tumor-draining lymph nodes that support the expansion, maintenance, and affinity evolution of a unique population of TCF-1+PD-1+SLAMF6 hi stem-like CD8+ T cells. Our results show that contrary to the prevailing view that persistent TCR signaling drives terminal effector differentiation, prolonged antigen engagement well beyond the initial priming phase sustained the proliferation and self-renewal of these stem-like T cells in vivo . The inhibitory PD-1 pathway plays a central role in this process by mediating the fine-tuning of TCR and co-stimulatory signal input that enables selective expansion of high affinity TCR stem-like clones, enabling them to act as a renewable source of high affinity effector cells. PD-1 checkpoint blockade disrupts this fine tuning of input signaling, leading to terminal differentiation to the effector state or death of the most avid anti-tumor stem-like cells. Our results thus reveal an unexpected relationship between TCR ligand affinity recognition, a key negative feedback regulatory loop, and T cell stemness programming. Furthermore, these findings raise questions about whether anti-PD-1 checkpoint blockade during cancer immunotherapy provides a short-term anti-tumor effect that comes at the cost of diminishing efficacy due to progressive loss of these critical high affinity stem-like precursors.

TCR ligand potency differentially impacts PD-1 inhibitory effects on diverse signaling pathways.

Checkpoint blockade revolutionized cancer therapy, but we still lack a quantitative, mechanistic understanding of how inhibitory receptors affect diverse signaling pathways. To address this issue, we developed and applied a fluorescent intracellular live multiplex signal transduction activity reporter (FILMSTAR) system to analyze PD-1-induced suppressive effects. These studies identified pathways triggered solely by TCR or requiring both TCR and CD28 inputs. Using presenting cells differing in PD-L1 and CD80 expression while displaying TCR ligands of distinct potency, we found that PD-1-mediated inhibition primarily targets TCR-linked signals in a manner highly sensitive to peptide ligand quality. These findings help resolve discrepancies in existing data about the site(s) of PD-1 inhibition in T cells while emphasizing the importance of neoantigen potency in controlling the effects of checkpoint therapy.

PSGL-1 deficiency re-wires T cell signaling to support development of stem cell like exhausted T cells that control PD-1 blockade resistant melanoma tumor growth

Abstract We previously identified that the adhesion molecule P-selectin glycoprotein ligand-1 (PSGL-1) regulates CD8 +T cell effector functions and promotes exhaustion in responses to chronic viral infection and melanoma tumors. In this study, we investigated cellular and molecular mechanisms by which intrinsic PSGL-1 signaling regulates the differentiation of exhausted T cells (T EX). We show that PSGL-1 localizes with the TCR upon co-ligation and find that PSGL-1 associates with Zap70 and the Zap70 inhibitor, Sts-1. In the absence of PSGL-1, expression of Sts-1 is reduced allowing for greater activation of Zap70 and the downstream signaling molecules Akt and Erk1/2. In addition, PSGL-1-deficiency empowers CD8 +T cells to respond to low affinity TCR ligands. In vivo, PSGL-1 deficiency leads to growth inhibition of a PD-1-blockade resistant melanoma. Notably, PSGL-1-deficiency in T cells enables retention of effector T cell (T EFF) functions, and an increased representation of stem cell-like T cells (T SC) that express TCF-1 and low levels of TOX, which are associated with sustained effector responses and responsiveness to ICB. We now show that concomitant PSGL-1 signaling with repeated TCR stimulation of human T EFFelicits functional exhaustion. Importantly, blockade of PSGL-1 recapitulates PSGL-1 deficiency in anti-tumor as well as antiviral responses, and its distinct mechanism of T cell inhibition underscores the translational potential of targeting PSGL-1 by ICB. Supported by grants from NIH (R01 AI106895, R21 CA249353, R21 CA216678, R03 CA252144) Melanoma Research Alliance MRA 696326, Department of Defense W81XWH-20-1-0324, Sanford Burnham Prebys NCI-Designated Cancer Center Support Grant, P30 CA030199 American Cancer Society Postdoctoral Fellowship (PF-20-113-01-LIB)

ZAP70 holds the key to kinetic proofreading for TCR ligand discrimination.

ZAP70 holds the key to kinetic proofreading for TCR ligand discrimination.

The T cell receptor displays lateral signal propagation involving non-engaged receptors.

T cells are highly sensitive to low levels of antigen, but how this sensitivity is achieved is currently unknown. Here, we imaged proximal TCR-CD3 signal propagation with single molecule localization microscopy (SMLM) in T cells activated with nanoscale clusters of TCR stimuli. We observed the formation of large TCR-CD3 clusters that exceeded the area of the ligand clusters, and required multivalent interactions facilitated by TCR-CD3 phosphorylation for assembly. Within these clustered TCR-CD3 domains, TCR-CD3 signaling spread laterally for ∼500 nm, far beyond the activating site, via non-engaged receptors. Local receptor density determined the functional cooperativity between engaged and non-engaged receptors, but lateral signal propagation was not influenced by the genetic deletion of ZAP70. Taken together, our data demonstrates that clustered ligands induced the clustering of non-ligated TCR-CD3 into domains that cooperatively facilitate lateral signal propagation.

αβ T cells replacing dermal and epidermal γδ T cells in Tcrd-/- mice express an MHC-independent TCR repertoire.

The epidermis of mouse skin is usually populated by dendritic epidermal T cells (γδDETC) expressing an invariant Vγ5Vδ1+ TCR. In Tcrd-/- mice, skin-resident γδDETC are replaced by αβDETC carrying polyclonal αβ TCRs. Although they exhibit a dendritic morphology, αβDETC were reported to be less functional than genuine γδDETC, likely because their TCR is unable to interact with the original TCR ligands of γδDETC. However, the TCR repertoire of those replacement DETC in Tcrd-/- mice might provide clues for understanding the development and selection of canonical γδDETC. Here, we compare the phenotype and TCR repertoires of wild-type and Tcrd-/- mouse skin T cells. Our data reveal that αβDETC are CD4/CD8 double negative and express an MHC-independent TCR repertoire. Furthermore, we identify a second MHC-independent population of CD103hi CD4/ CD8 double-negative αβ T cells in the dermis of Tcrd-/- mice.

Synthetic Peptides with Inadvertent Chemical Modifications Can Activate Potentially Autoreactive T Cells.

The human CD8+ T cell clone 6C5 has previously been shown to recognize the tert-butyl-modified Bax161-170 peptide LLSY(3-tBu)FGTPT presented by HLA-A*02:01. This nonnatural epitope was likely created as a by-product of fluorenylmethoxycarbonyl protecting group peptide synthesis and bound poorly to HLA-A*02:01. In this study, we used a systematic approach to identify and characterize natural ligands for the 6C5 TCR. Functional analyses revealed that 6C5 T cells only recognized the LLSYFGTPT peptide when tBu was added to the tyrosine residue and did not recognize the LLSYFGTPT peptide modified with larger (di-tBu) or smaller chemical groups (Me). Combinatorial peptide library screening further showed that 6C5 T cells recognized a series of self-derived peptides with dissimilar amino acid sequences to LLSY(3-tBu)FGTPT. Structural studies of LLSY(3-tBu)FGTPT and two other activating nonamers (IIGWMWIPV and LLGWVFAQV) in complex with HLA-A*02:01 demonstrated similar overall peptide conformations and highlighted the importance of the position (P) 4 residue for T cell recognition, particularly the capacity of the bulky amino acid tryptophan to substitute for the tBu-modified tyrosine residue in conjunction with other changes at P5 and P6. Collectively, these results indicated that chemical modifications directly altered the immunogenicity of a synthetic peptide via molecular mimicry, leading to the inadvertent activation of a T cell clone with unexpected and potentially autoreactive specificities.

Increasing LFA-1 Expression Enhances Immune Synapse Architecture and T Cell Receptor Signaling in Jurkat E6.1 Cells.

The Jurkat E6.1 clone has been extensively used as a powerful tool for the genetic and biochemical dissection of the TCR signaling pathway. More recently, these cells have been exploited in imaging studies to identify key players in immunological synapse (IS) assembly in superantigen-specific conjugates and to track the dynamics of signaling molecules on glass surfaces coated with activating anti-CD3 antibodies. By comparison, Jurkat cells have been used only scantily for imaging on supported lipid bilayers (SLBs) incorporating laterally mobile TCR and integrin ligands, which allow to study synaptic rearrangements of surface molecules and the fine architecture of the mature IS, likely due to limitations in the assembly of immune synapses with well-defined architecture. Here we have explored whether upregulating the low levels of endogenous LFA-1 expression on Jurkat E6.1 cells through transduction with CD11a- and CD18-encoding lentiviruses can improve IS architecture. We show that, while forced LFA-1 expression did not affect TCR recruitment to the IS, E6.1 LFA-1high cells assembled better structured synapses, with a tighter distribution of signaling-competent TCRs at the center of the IS. LFA-1 upregulation enhanced protein phosphotyrosine signaling on SLBs but not at the IS formed in conjugates with SEE-pulsed APCs, and led to the constitutive formation of an intracellular phosphotyrosine pool co-localizing with endosomal CD3ζ. This was paralleled by an increase in the levels of p-ZAP-70 and p-Erk both under basal conditions and following activation, and in enhanced Ca2+ mobilization from intracellular stores. The enhancement in early signaling E6.1 LFA-1high cells did not affect expression of the early activation marker CD69 but led to an increase in IL-2 expression. Our results highlight a new role for LFA-1 in the core architecture of the IS that can be exploited to study the spatiotemporal redistribution of surface receptors on SLBs, thereby extending the potential of E6.1 cells and their derivatives for fine-scale imaging studies.

Cross-TCR Antagonism Revealed by Optogenetically Tuning the Half-Life of the TCR Ligand Binding.

Activation of T cells by agonistic peptide-MHC can be inhibited by antagonistic ones. However, the exact mechanism remains elusive. We used Jurkat cells expressing two different TCRs and tested whether stimulation of the endogenous TCR by agonistic anti-Vβ8 antibodies can be modulated by ligand-binding to the second, optogenetic TCR. The latter TCR uses phytochrome B tetramers (PhyBt) as ligand, the binding half-life of which can be altered by light. We show that this half-life determined whether the PhyBt acted as a second agonist (long half-life), an antagonist (short half-life) or did not have any influence (very short half-life) on calcium influx. A mathematical model of this cross-antagonism shows that a mechanism based on an inhibitory signal generated by early recruitment of a phosphatase and an activating signal by later recruitment of a kinase explains the data.

T cell receptor diversity, specificity and promiscuity of functionally heterogeneous human MR1-restricted T cells

The monomorphic MHC-class I-like molecule, MR1, presents small metabolites to T cells. MR1 is the restriction element for microbe-reactive mucosal-associated invariant T (MAIT) cells. MAIT cells have limited TCR usage, including a semi-invariant TCR alpha chain and express high levels of CD161 and CD26. In addition to microbial lumazine metabolites, recent studies have demonstrated that MR1 is able to capture a variety of diverse chemical entities including folate-derivatives, a number of drug-like and other synthetic small molecules, and as yet undefined compounds of self-origin. This capacity of MR1 to bind distinct ligands likely accounts for the recent identification of additional, non-canonical, subsets of MR1-restricted T (MR1T) cells. These subsets can be defined based on their ability to recognize diverse microbes as well as their reactivity to non-microbial cell-endogenous ligands, including tumor-associated antigens. Herein, we will discuss our current understanding of MR1T cell diversity in terms of TCR usage, ligand recognition and functional attributes.

Structure of MHC-Independent TCRs and Their Recognition of Native Antigen CD155.

During normal T cell development in the thymus, αβ TCRs signal immature thymocytes to differentiate into mature T cells by binding to peptide-MHC ligands together with CD4/CD8 coreceptors. Conversely, in MHC and CD4/CD8 coreceptor-deficient mice, the thymus generates mature T cells expressing MHC-independent TCRs that recognize native conformational epitopes rather than linear antigenic-peptides presented by MHC. To date, no structural information of MHC-independent TCRs is available, and their structural recognition of non-MHC ligand remains unknown. To our knowledge in this study, we determined the first structures of two murine MHC-independent TCRs (A11 and B12A) that bind with high nanomolar affinities to mouse adhesion receptor CD155. Solution binding demonstrated the Vαβ-domain is responsible for MHC-independent B12A recognition of its ligand. Analysis of A11 and B12A sequences against various MHC-restricted and -independent TCR sequence repertoires showed that individual V-genes of A11 and B12A did not exhibit preference against MHC-restriction. Likewise, CDR3 alone did not discriminate against MHC binding, suggesting VDJ recombination together with Vα/Vβ pairing determine their MHC-independent specificity for CD155. The structures of A11 and B12A TCR are nearly identical to those of MHC-restricted TCR, including the conformations of CDR1 and 2. Mutational analysis, together with negative-staining electron microscopy images, showed that the CDR regions of A11 and B12A recognized epitopes on D1 domain of CD155, a region also involved in CD155 binding to poliovirus and Tactile in human. Taken together, MHC-independent TCRs adopt canonical TCR structures to recognize native Ags, highlighting the importance of thymic selection in determining TCR ligand specificity.

Interferons in Treg development and function

Abstract Thymus-derived regulatory T-cells (Tregs) are critical for controlling immune responses and preventing autoimmunity. In the setting of viral infection, Tregs are important modulators of anti-viral immune responses and help resolve inflammation. The subset of Tregs responsible for responding to viral infections and the types of antigens they recognize are not well understood. Using single-cell RNA sequencing we identified a unique subset of thymic Treg progenitors and mature Tregs that express a strong interferon stimulated gene (ISG) signature, as well as a comparable population in the spleen. Importantly, the ISG signature is much stronger than that expressed by thymocytes receiving tonic IFN stimulation in the final stages of maturation prior to thymic egress. Using flow cytometry we established that APCs in the thymus, including mTECs, as well as SIRPα+ and CD8α+ dendritic cells, require IFNα/β or IFNλ, acting via STAT1 signaling, for the expression of the canonical ISG BST2. TCR specificity was important for selection into this subset as SM1 TCR transgenic mice, which express a TCR that recognizes a non-ISG encoded antigen, have a reduced compartment of ISG-expressing CD4SP T-cells in the thymus. We are currently generating mice that specifically lack the ISG-signature Treg subset to test their function in vivo. Based on our current findings, we propose that thymic ISG antigens serve as TCR ligands for inducing the differentiation of ISG-signature Tregs that are in close physical proximity to the ISG-producing APCs. Furthermore, we hypothesize that ISG-signature Tregs are specialized for responding to ISGs induced during antiviral immune responses and play a key role in controlling IFN-driven inflammation.

Affinity threshold conversion: the progressive differentiation checkpoint at which the TCRα/CD3δ signaling axis controls thymic positive selection

Abstract Upon positive selection of conventional αβ T cells, CD4+ CD8+ double-positive (DP) cells transition to single-positive (SP) and reduce their responsiveness to weak peptide/MHC ligands (affinity threshold conversion, ATC). We report that ATC actually begins prior to the completion of positive selection in the DP stage, and this checkpoint is where the TCRα/CD3δ signaling axis controls positive selection. We dissected ATC in the OT1 TCR transgenic system in conjunction with several different genes whose null mutations block thymic development at DP stage: β2m, CD3δ, and/or TCRα-Connecting Peptide Motif (αCPM). In the absence of MHC class I (β2m0), CD3δ or αCPM mutants were blocked at pre-selection DP stage and displayed immature, high-sensitivity to weak TCR ligands. In contrast, when MHC class I was present (β2m+), CD3δ or αCPM mutants were blocked at DP stage but underwent partial ATC; they began positive selection but did not complete it. Upon exogenous TCR engagement of partial-ATC thymocytes, the proximal signaling protein interaction network showed overall weakened activity, notably decreasing SOS1 participation linked to the downstream Ras/Raf/ERK selection pathway. Provision of high affinity peptide/MHC in FTOC rescued completion of positive selection for partial-ATC mutant thymocytes. Finally, comparing nontransgenic, polyclonal B6 vs. CD3δ0 DP thymocytes, although most cells showed equal maturation state, a subset of cells in B6 progressed in maturation relative to CD3δ0. We propose the existence of an intermediate checkpoint inside DP stage, in which ATC already begins to reduce responsiveness to selection ligands, yet further TCR signaling is required to complete positive selection.

Butyrophilin-2A1 Directly Binds Germline-Encoded Regions of the Vγ9Vδ2 TCR and Is Essential for Phosphoantigen Sensing

SummaryVγ9Vδ2 T cells respond in a TCR-dependent fashion to both microbial and host-derived pyrophosphate compounds (phosphoantigens, or P-Ag). Butyrophilin-3A1 (BTN3A1), a protein structurally related to the B7 family of costimulatory molecules, is necessary but insufficient for this process. We performed radiation hybrid screens to uncover direct TCR ligands and cofactors that potentiate BTN3A1’s P-Ag sensing function. These experiments identified butyrophilin-2A1 (BTN2A1) as essential to Vγ9Vδ2 T cell recognition. BTN2A1 synergised with BTN3A1 in sensitizing P-Ag-exposed cells for Vγ9Vδ2 TCR-mediated responses. Surface plasmon resonance experiments established Vγ9Vδ2 TCRs used germline-encoded Vγ9 regions to directly bind the BTN2A1 CFG-IgV domain surface. Notably, somatically recombined CDR3 loops implicated in P-Ag recognition were uninvolved. Immunoprecipitations demonstrated close cell-surface BTN2A1-BTN3A1 association independent of P-Ag stimulation. Thus, BTN2A1 is a BTN3A1-linked co-factor critical to Vγ9Vδ2 TCR recognition. Furthermore, these results suggest a composite-ligand model of P-Ag sensing wherein the Vγ9Vδ2 TCR directly interacts with both BTN2A1 and an additional ligand recognized in a CDR3-dependent manner.

αβ and γδ T cell receptors: Similar but different.

There are 2 populations of T lymphocytes, αβ T and γδ T cells, that can be distinguished by the expression of either an αβ TCR or a γδTCR, respectively. Pairing of the Ag binding heterodimer, which consists of TCR-α/TCR-β (TCRαβ) or TCR-γ/TCR-δ (TCRγδ), with proteins of the CD3 complex forms the complete αβ or γδ TCR. Despite some similarities in the structure of TCRαβ and TCRγδ and the shared subunits of the CD3 complex, the 2 receptors differ in important aspects. These include the assembly geometry of the complex, the glycosylation pattern, the plasma membrane organization, as well as the accessibility of signaling motifs in the CD3 intracellular tails. These differences are reflected in the different demands and outcomes of ligand-induced signaling. It was shown that exposure of the proline-rich sequence (PRS) in CD3ε occurs with all activating αβ TCR ligands and is required to induce αβ TCR signaling. In sharp contrast, CD3ε PRS exposure was not induced by binding of those ligands to the γδ TCR that have been studied. Further, signaling by the γδ TCR occurs independently of CD3ε PRS exposure. Interestingly, it can be enhanced by anti-CD3ε Ab-induced enforcement of CD3ε PRS exposure. This review contrasts these two similar, but different immune receptors.

Slow phosphor-Y-LAT-ion for TCR ligand discrimination.

A report sheds new light on the molecular mechanisms responsible for the discrimination of self versus non-self TCR ligands and reveals the crucial role of the kinetics of LAT tyrosine phosphorylation in this.

TCR-pMHC bond length controls TCR ligand discrimination

Abstract T-cell receptors (TCRs) detect specifically and sensitively a small number of agonist peptide-major histocompatibility complexes (pMHCs) from an ocean of structurally similar self-pMHCs to trigger antigen-specific adaptive immune responses. Despite intense efforts, the mechanism underlying TCR ligand discrimination remains a major unanswered question in immunology. Here we show that a TCR discriminates between closely related peptides by forming TCR-pMHC bonds with different lengths, which precisely control the accessibility of CD3ζ immunoreceptor tyrosine-based activation motifs (ITAMs) for phosphorylation. Using in situ fluorescence resonance energy transfer (FRET), we measured the intermolecular length of single TCR-pMHC bonds and the intramolecular distance of individual TCR-CD3ζ complexes at the membrane of live primary T cells. We found that an agonist forms a short TCR-pMHC bond to pull the otherwise sequestered CD3ζ off the inner leaflet of the plasma membrane, leading to full exposure of its ITAMs for strong phosphorylation. By contrast, a structurally similar weaker peptide forms a longer bond with the TCR, resulting in partial dissociation of CD3ζ from the membrane and weak phosphorylation. Furthermore, we found that TCR-pMHC bond length determines 2D TCR binding kinetics and affinity, T-cell calcium signaling and T-cell proliferation, governing the entire process of signal reception, transduction and regulation. Thus, our data reveal the fundamental mechanism by which a TCR deciphers the structural differences between foreign antigens and self-peptides via TCR-pMHC bond length to initiate different TCR signaling for ligand discrimination.

γδ TCR ligands: the quest to solve a 500-million-year-old mystery.

γδ T cells have been retained as a lineage over the majority of vertebrate evolution, are able to respond to immune challenges in unique ways, and are of increasing therapeutic interest. However, one central mystery has endured: the identity of the ligands recognized by the γδ T cell antigen receptor. Here we discuss the inherent challenges in answering this question, the new opportunities provided by recent studies, and the criteria by which the field might judge success.

Trogocytosis-based cell platform for TCR ligand discovery

Trogocytosis-based cell platform for TCR ligand discovery

Natural Killer T Cells (NKT cells) Functions in Malignancies

CD1d-restricted natural killer (NKT) cells are unique innate like T lymphocyte that recognize glycolipid antigens. Two major NKT cell subsets, type I and type II, are different in their TCR repertoire and ligand specificity. Up on activation, NKT cells mediated strong and rapid responses through their ability to rapidly produce a large amount of both pro- and anti-inflammatory cytokines. Despite being a small population of αβ T lymphocytes, they can bridge the innate and adaptive arm of immune system through interaction with other immune components. These two subsets of NKT cells play critical apposite roles in anti-tumor immunity. This review focuses on the progress made in understanding the role of NKT cells in tumor immunity and how their activities can be useful in immunotherapeutic strategies.