Tapetal-like Reflex Research Articles

RP2-Associated X-linked Retinopathy: Clinical Findings, Molecular Genetics, and Natural History in a Large Cohort of Female Carriers

RP2-associated retinopathy typically causes severe early onset retinitis pigmentosa (RP) in affected males. However, there is a scarcity of reports describing the clinical phenotype of female carriers. We tested the hypothesis that RP2 variants manifest in female carriers with a range of functional and anatomic characteristics. Retrospective case series. Females with disease-causing variants in RP2 were identified from investigation of pedigrees affected by RP2 retinopathy. All case notes and results of molecular genetic testing, retinal imaging (fundus autofluorescence imaging, optical coherence tomography (OCT)), and electrophysiology were reviewed. Forty pedigrees were investigated. Twenty-nine pedigrees had obligate carriers or molecularly confirmed female members with recorded relevant history and/or examination. For 8 pedigrees, data were available only from history, with patients reporting affected female relatives with RP in 4 cases and unaffected female relatives in the other 4 cases. Twenty-seven females from 21 pedigrees were examined by a retinal genetics specialist. Twenty-three patients (85%) reported no complaints and had normal vision and 4 patients had RP-associated complaints (15%). Eight patients had normal fundus examination (30%), 10 had a tapetal-like reflex (TLR; 37%), 5 had scattered peripheral pigmentation (19%), and the 4 symptomatic patients had fundus findings compatible with RP (15%). All asymptomatic patients with normal fundus, TLR, or asymptomatic pigmentary changes had a continuous ellipsoid zone on OCT when available. The electroretinograms revealed mild to severe photoreceptor dysfunction in 9 of 11 subjects, often asymmetrical, including 5 with pattern electroretinogram evidence of symmetrical (n = 4) or unilateral (n = 1 subject) macular dysfunction. Most carriers were asymptomatic, exhibiting subclinical characteristics such as TLR and pigmentary changes. However, female carriers of RP2 variants can manifest RP. Family history of affected females with RP does not exclude X-linked disease. The phenotypic spectrum as described herein has prognostic and counselling implications for RP2 carriers and patients.

Microperimetry and Adaptive Optics Imaging Reveal Localized Functional and Structural Changes in Asymptomatic RPGR Mutation Carriers.

Female carriers of RPGR mutations demonstrate no significant retinal dysfunction or structural change despite a characteristic tapetal-like reflex. In this study, we examined localized changes of pointwise sensitivity (PWS) and cone density (CD) using microperimetry (MP) and adaptive optics (AO) imaging in female carriers of RPGR mutations. In this cross-sectional case-control study, MP (MAIA, 10-2 test grid) and AO imaging (rtx1) were performed in female carriers of RPGR mutations and unrelated age-matched healthy controls. PWS at 68 loci located 1 degree to 9 degrees away from the preferred retinal locus and CD at 12 loci located 1 degree to 3 degrees away from the foveal center were measured. Severity of defect was defined by standard deviation (SD) from age-matched healthy control means: normal (<1 SD from normal average), moderate defect (1-2 SD from normal average), and severe defect (>2 SD from normal average). Twelve patients from seven unrelated families were enrolled. Seven patients were asymptomatic, 5 of whom had visual acuity 20/20 or better in both eyes. PWS and CD were available in 12 and 8 patients, respectively. Severe PWS and CD defect in at least 1 test location was observed in 10 of 12 patients and 7 of 8 patients, respectively. Among the five asymptomatic patients who had normal visual acuity, severe PWS and CD defects were observed in three of five and four of five patients, respectively. MP and AO imaging revealed early functional and structural changes in asymptomatic RPGR mutation carriers and should be considered in clinical assessment of these patients.

CELLULAR IMAGING OF THE TAPETAL-LIKE REFLEX IN CARRIERS OF RPGR-ASSOCIATED RETINOPATHY.

To examine the features of the tapetal-like reflex (TLR) in female carriers of RPGR-associated retinopathy by means of adaptive optics scanning light ophthalmoscopy (AOSLO) and spectral domain optical coherence tomography. Nine molecularly confirmed RPGR carriers and three healthy controls underwent ocular examination and the following retinal imaging modalities: color photography, near-infrared reflectance, fundus autofluorescence, spectral domain optical coherence tomography, and AOSLO. After identifying TLR areas across all imaging modalities, normalized local contrast of outer retinal bands on spectral domain optical coherence tomography was calculated and AOSLO-acquired photoreceptor mosaic analysis was performed. Seven carriers had TLR areas, which colocalized with increased rod photoreceptor reflectivity on confocal AOSLO and reduced cone photoreceptor densities. Parafoveal TLR areas also exhibited reduced local contrast (i.e., increased reflectivity) of the outer retinal bands on spectral domain optical coherence tomography (inner segment ellipsoid zone and outer segment interdigitation zone). Healthy controls did not show TLR. The cellular resolution provided by AOSLO affords the characterization of the photoreceptor mosaic in RPGR carriers with a TLR. Features revealed include reduced cone density, increased cone inner segment diameter, and increased rod outer segment reflectivity.

MULTIMODAL IMAGING OF MOSAIC RETINOPATHY IN CARRIERS OF HEREDITARY X-LINKED RECESSIVE DISEASES.

To investigate the clinical features in carriers of X-linked retinitis pigmentosa, X-linked ocular albinism, and choroideremia (CHM) using multimodal imaging and to assess their diagnostic value in these three mosaic retinopathies. We prospectively examined 14 carriers of 3 X-linked recessive disorders (X-linked retinitis pigmentosa, X-linked ocular albinism, and CHM). Details of abnormalities of retinal morphology were evaluated using fundus photography, fundus autofluorescence (FAF) imaging, and spectral domain optical coherence tomography. In six X-linked retinitis pigmentosa carriers, fundus appearance varied from unremarkable to the presence of tapetal-like reflex and pigmentary changes. On FAF imaging, all carriers exhibited a bright radial reflex against a dark background. By spectral domain optical coherence tomography, loss of the ellipsoid zone in the macula was observed in 3 carriers (50%). Regarding the retinal laminar architecture, 4 carriers (66.7%) showed thinning of the outer nuclear layer and a dentate appearance of the outer plexiform layer. All five X-linked ocular albinism carriers showed a characteristic mud-splatter patterned fundus, dark radial streaks against a bright background on FAF imaging, and a normal-appearing retinal structure by spectral domain optical coherence tomography imaging. Two of the 3 CHM carriers (66.7%) showed a diffuse moth-eaten appearance of the fundus, and all 3 showed irregular hyper-FAF and hypo-FAF spots throughout the affected area. In the CHM carriers, the structural changes observed by spectral domain optical coherence tomography imaging were variable. Our findings in an Asian cohort suggest that FAF imaging is a practical diagnostic test for differentiating X-linked retinitis pigmentosa, X-linked ocular albinism, and CHM carriers. Wide-field FAF is an easy and helpful adjunct to testing for the correct diagnosis and identification of lyonization in carriers of these three mosaic retinopathies.

DETAILED RETINAL IMAGING IN CARRIERS OF OCULAR ALBINISM.

Albinism refers to a group of disorders primarily characterized by hypopigmentation. Affected individuals usually manifest both ocular and cutaneous features of the disease, but occasionally hair and skin pigmentation may appear normal. This is the case in ocular albinism, an X chromosome linked disorder resulting from mutation of GPR143. Female carriers may be recognized by a "mud-splatter" appearance in the peripheral retina. The macula is thought to be normal, however. Obligate female carriers of pathogenic GPR143 alleles were recruited. Molecular confirmation of disease was performed only for atypical cases. Detailed retinal imaging was performed (colour fundus photography, optical coherence tomography, fundus autofluorescence. Eight individuals were ascertained. A novel GPR143 mutation was identified in one family (p.Gln328Ter). Foveal fundus autofluorescence was subjectively reduced in 6/6 patients imaged. A "tapetal-like" pattern of autofluorescence was visible at the macula in 3/6. Persistence of the inner retinal layers at the fovea was observed in 6/8 females. Female carriers of ocular albinism may manifest signs of retinal pigment epithelium mosaicism at the macula and the peripheral fundus. A tapetal-like reflex on fundus autofluorescence may be considered the macular correlate of "mud-splatter."

Multimodal Imaging of the Tapetal-like Reflex in Carriers of RPGR-associated Retinopathy

Multimodal Imaging of the Tapetal-like Reflex in Carriers of RPGR-associated Retinopathy

The Role of X-Chromosome Inactivation in Retinal Development and Disease.

The expression of X-linked genes is equalized between males and females in mammalian species through X-Chromosome inactivation (XCI). Every cell in a female mammalian embryo randomly chooses one X Chromosome for epigenetic silencing at the 8-16 cell stage, resulting in a Gaussian distribution of XCI ratios with a peak at 50:50. At the tail extremes of this distribution, X-linked recessive mutations can manifest in disease in female carriers if the mutant allele is disproportionately active. The role of XCI skewing, if any, in X-linked retinal disease is still unknown, although many have speculated that such skewing accounts for phenotypic variation in female carriers of X-linked retinitis pigmentosa (XlRP). Some investigators have used clinical findings such as tapetal-like reflex, pigmentary changes, and multifocal ERG parameters to approximate XCI patches in the retina. These studies are limited by small cohorts and the relative inaccessibility of retinal tissue for genetic and epigenetic analysis. Although blood has been used as a proxy for other tissues in determining XCI ratios, blood XCI skews with age out of proportion to other tissues and may not accurately reflect retinal XCI ratios. Future investigations in determining retinal XCI ratios and the contribution of XCI to phenotype could potentially impact prognosis for female carriers of X-linked retinal disease.

Radial fundus autofluorescence in the periphery in patients with X-linked retinitis pigmentosa.

PurposeTo describe the peripheral autofluorescence images and clinical features of patients with retinal dystrophy who showed radial fundus autofluorescence (FAF) at the posterior pole.MethodsThe authors retrospectively reviewed pooled wide-field FAF images of 711 patients with retinal dystrophy and 56 family members.ResultsEleven eyes of seven women exhibited radial FAF at the posterior pole. Wide-field FAF showed extension of the radial pattern to the periphery in all eyes except one. One woman showed radial hyper-FAF only in the periphery, not at the posterior pole. These eight individuals were X-linked retinitis pigmentosa patients or carriers. The tapetal-like reflex was not observed in their color fundus photographs. The peripheral visual field showed wedge-shaped restriction in some individuals.ConclusionWide-field FAF imaging can depict radial FAF not only at the posterior pole but also in the periphery in X-linked retinitis pigmentosa carriers. The authors therefore agree with previous reports that radial FAF may be a hallmark of X-linked retinitis pigmentosa.

Association of Retinal Artery and Other Inner Retinal Structures With Distribution of Tapetal-like Reflex in Oguchi's Disease.

To report novel ophthalmoscopic features of patients with Oguchi's disease, and to describe how they may be related to the unusual tapetal-like fundus appearance. Twenty-one eyes of 11 patients who were diagnosed with Oguchi's disease were investigated. Genetic screening of seven cases showed homozygous mutations in the SAG gene (c.926delA). The retinal appearance was retrospectively assessed in the fundus photographs, and the optical coherence tomographic (OCT) and fundus autofluorescence (AF) images. In 11 eyes of 7 patients, clearly demarcated dark regions without tapetal-like reflex were observed in the midperipheral retinal regions. In the dark regions, OCT showed lower reflectances in the photoreceptor layer but the AF images had normal reflectances. In nine eyes of six patients, the dark regions were partially demarcated by retinal arteries but not by veins. In nine eyes of five patients, the extent of the dark regions either increased or decreased during the course of the disease process, and these changes were not due to the state of adaptation or a posterior vitreous detachment. In all eyes, the peripheral retinal arteries but not veins had either high or low reflective regions along one side. Although the alterations of the outer retinal layers are believed to be most responsible for the abnormal tapetal-like reflex in patients with Oguchi's disease, these ophthalmoscopic features cannot be explained solely by the abnormality of the outer retina. Our findings suggest that the appearance of tapetal-like reflex is strongly affected by alterations of structures in the inner retinal layers.

Evaluation of multimodal imaging in carriers of X-linked retinitis pigmentosa

The aim of this study was to investigate visualization of the tapetal-like reflex using current imaging modalities and evaluate SD-OCT changes in known carriers of X-linked retinitis pigmentosa (XLRP); the objective being the development of an optimal protocol for clinicians to identify carriers. Ten XLRP carriers (19 eyes) were examined using color fundus photography, 488 nm reflectance (488-R), near-infrared reflectance (NIR-R), autofluorescence (AF) and spectral domain optical coherence tomography (SD-OCT) imaging (Spectralis SLO-OCT, Heidelberg). Horizontal line scans through the fovea were acquired in all subjects and in a group of 10 age-similar controls. Peripheral SD-OCT scans (extending to 27.5° eccentricity) were also acquired in both eyes of 7 carriers. MP-1 microperimetery (10-2 pattern; Nidek) was performed in one eye of each carrier. For the XLRP carriers, a tapetal reflex was observed with all imaging modalities in 8 of 19 eyes. It had the same retinal location on color fundus, 488-R and NIR-R imaging but a different location on AF. The tapetal reflex was most easily detected in 488-R images. The horizontal foveal SD-OCT scans were qualitatively normal, but measurements showed significant outer retinal layer thinning in all eyes. Additionally, the 14 eyes with peripheral SD-OCTs demonstrated patchy loss of the inner segment ellipsoid band. Microperimetry exhibited patchy visual sensitivity loss in 9 eyes. Full field ERGs were variable, ranging from normal to severely abnormal rod and cone responses. Our findings suggest that an optimal protocol for identifying carriers of XLRP should include 488-R imaging in a multimodal approach. Peripheral SD-OCT imaging and central retinal layer quantification revealed significant structural abnormalities.

STRUCTURAL AND FUNCTIONAL CHARACTERISTICS IN CARRIERS OF X-LINKED RETINITIS PIGMENTOSA WITH A TAPETAL-LIKE REFLEX

The purpose of this study was to identify the functional and structural characteristics in three female obligate carriers of X-linked retinitis pigmentosa from the same family by using spectral domain optical coherence tomography, fundus autofluorescence, and microperimetry. Three female obligate carriers with a tapetal-like reflex, 21, 49, and 57 years of age, from a single family of X-linked retinitis pigmentosa that was seen in the ophthalmology department at the University of Illinois at Chicago, were enrolled in the study. All carriers underwent a complete ophthalmic examination. Spectral domain optical coherence tomography measurements, a macular microperimetry examination, and fundus autofluorescence testing were performed. The spectral domain optical coherence tomography examination in all three carriers showed a normal retinal microstructure and thickness. Microperimeter testing showed subnormal retinal sensitivity in the areas of the tapetal-like reflex. Fundus autofluorescence examination showed the presence of speckled areas of enhanced autofluorescence. Our study demonstrates that the carriers of X-linked retinitis pigmentosa with a tapetal-like reflex can show an enhanced reflectance on infrared images, abnormal autofluorescence properties, elevated retinal thresholds, and a normal retinal morphology within the posterior pole on spectral domain optical coherence tomography testing.

A 34-year-old man with visual complaints and a tapetal-like reflex.

A 34-year-old man with visual complaints and a tapetal-like reflex.

Detection using the multifocal electroretinogram of mosaic retinal dysfunction in carriers of X-linked retinitis pigmentosa

PurposeTo examine whether a mosaic pattern of retinal dysfunction in obligate carriers of X-linked retinitis pigmentosa (XLRP) could be observed in local electroretinographic responses obtained with the multifocal electroretinogram (mfERG). DesignProspective observational case series. ParticipantsFive obligate carriers of XLRP (mean age, 53.2 years) were recruited into the study. MethodsExamination of each subject included a complete ocular examination, Humphrey visual field, standard full-field electroretinogram (ERG), and mfERG testing. For the mfERG, we used a 103-scaled hexagonal stimulus array that subtended a retinal area of approximately 40° in diameter. The amplitudes and implicit times in each location for the mfERG was compared with the corresponding value determined for a group of normally sighted, age-corrected control subjects. Main outcome measuresMapping of 103 local electroretinographic response amplitudes and implicit times within the central 40° with the multifocal electroretinogram. ResultsLocalized regions of reduced mfERG amplitudes and/or delayed implicit times were found in four of five carriers. In one of these four carriers, a mosaic pattern of mfERG dysfunction was present even in the absence of any clinically apparent retinal changes, retinal sensitivity losses on Humphrey field testing, or abnormal full-field cone ERG responses. However, one carrier with a typical tapetal-like reflex demonstrated no deficit on any functional tests. ConclusionsThe mfERG demonstrated patchy areas of retinal dysfunction in some carriers of XLRP. This mosaic pattern of dysfunction may be observed in some patients with a normal-appearing fundus, normal psychophysical thresholds, and normal amplitude and implicit time full-field ERG cone responses.

A longitudinal study of visual function in carriers of X-linked recessive retinitis pigmentosa

ObjectiveThis study was carried out to evaluate the progression of visual function impairment in carriers of X-linked recessive retinitis pigmentosa. We also assessed the relationship between the retinal findings at presentation and the extent of deterioration. DesignObservational, retrospective, case series. ParticipantsTwenty-seven carriers of X-linked recessive retinitis pigmentosa. MethodsEach carrier was clinically categorized into one of four grades (grades 0 through 3) depending on the presence or absence of a tapetal-like retinal reflex and the extent of peripheral pigmentary degeneration. A complete ophthalmologic examination was performed and data for visual acuity, visual field area, and electroretinographic measurements were collected on the most recent visit in both eyes. These were then compared with similar data obtained on their initial visits. Main outcome measuresA comparison of visual function was carried out between the initial visit and the most recent visit on each carrier. The visual acuity was measured with Snellen’s acuity charts. The visual fields to targets V-4-e and II-4-e were planimeterized and used for the analysis. The electroretinographic (ERG) measures used were light-adapted single-flash b-wave amplitudes and 30-Hz red flicker for cone function, dark-adapted maximal b-wave amplitudes, and response to a low intensity blue-flash for rod function. ResultsNone of the 11 carriers with a tapetal-like reflex only (grade 1) showed any significant change in visual acuity or fields as compared with 3 of 7 (43%) carriers with diffuse peripheral pigmentary findings (grade 3) who showed significant deterioration in visual acuity in at least one eye, and 6 of 7 (86%) who showed a significant decrease in visual field area with at least one target size in at least one eye. By comparison, only 1 of 10 carriers with a grade 1 fundus finding demonstrated a significant decrease in maximal dark-adapted ERG function as compared with 5 of 6 (83%) carriers with grade 3 in response to a single-flash stimulus and with 4 of 5 (80%) carriers in response to a single-flash blue stimulus. For the single-flash photopic response, none of the 10 carriers with grade 1 showed any significant deterioration, whereas 2 of 4 (50%) with grade 3 did show such deterioration. The ERG responses for carriers with grade 2 were in between the extent of decrease in ERG amplitudes of those in carriers with grades 1 and 3. ConclusionsIn our cohort of X-linked retinitis pigmentosa carriers, those with only a tapetal-like retinal reflex at presentation had a better prognosis to retain visual function than those with peripheral retinal pigmentation. These data are useful in counseling such carriers as to their visual prognosis.

X-linked retinitis pigmentosa in two families with a missense mutation in the RPGR gene and putative change of glycine to valine at codon 60

ObjectiveThis study describes the ophthalmic findings in two unrelated white families with X-linked retinitis pigmentosa (XLRP) caused by a missense mutation in the retinitis pigmentosa GTPase regulator (RPGR) gene. DesignGenetic screening and clinical correlation. ParticipantsThirty-six families with XLRP seen by the authors were screened for a possible mutation in the RPGR gene to identify three affected hemizygotes with retinitis pigmentosa and four heterozygote carriers in one family and one hemizygote and one carrier in a second family. InterventionAll nine patients underwent a routine ocular examination, including slit-lamp biomicroscopy and a dilated fundus examination. Goldmann visual field kinetic perimetry, static threshold perimetry, and electroretinography also were obtained. The DNA screening was performed on the three affected male patients and four obligate carriers examined from one family and the two examined patients, plus an additional male and obligate carrier, from the second family to determine the presence of any causative mutation in the RPGR gene. Main outcome measuresFindings on fundus examination, static threshold and kinetic perimetry, and electroretinography testing were the main outcome measures. ResultsA G→T nucleotide change at position 238 in exon 3 of the RPGR gene resulting in a putative substitute of Gly→Val at codon 60 was shown to segregate with RP in affected males and the carrier state in female heterozygotes in these two families. The ophthalmologic findings in hemizygotes as well as the carriers in this family were within the spectrum of findings characteristically noted in XLRP families. A tapetal-like reflex was not observed in any of the five female carriers. Psychophysical and electrophysiologic testing on the carriers indicated that cone and rod functions were impaired equivalently. When present in the carriers, visual field restriction was most apparent in, or limited to, the superotemporal quadrant, which corresponded to the retinal pigmentary changes that tended to occur in the inferonasal retina. ConclusionsA mutation in exon 3 of the RPGR gene, which would result in a putative glycine to valine substitution at codon 60, is associated with a severe clinical phenotype in male patients and a patchy retinopathy without a tapetal-like reflex in carrier females. In these families, heterozygote carriers showed equivalent impairment of their cone and rod function.

X-linked retinitis pigmentosa associated with a 2-base pair insertion in codon 99 of the RP3 gene RPGR.

Mutations in the RPGR gene at the RP3 locus have been found to cause x-linked retinitis pigmentosa in some families. To identify a previously undescribed 2-base pair insertion in codon 99 of the RPGR gene and to describe the phenotype in a well-characterized family with X-linked retinitis pigmentosa. Case reports with clinical features, fluorescein angiography, kinetic perimetry, electrophysiological studies, and molecular genetics. University medical centers. Eight members of the family were screened for the codon 99 insertion in the RPGR gene. Three affected males were found to be hemizygous for the 2-base pair insertion; 2 carriers were heterozygous. This insertion creates a frameshift that would be expected to cause a premature arrest of translation after only 132 amino acids (683 amino acids less than the normal protein). The affected males had typical retinitis pigmentosa with visual field contraction and abnormal findings on electroretinograms with little to no rod activity, profoundly subnormal residual cone responses to single flash and 30-Hz flicker stimuli, and prolonged b-wave implicit times. The electroretinogram of a 49-year-old carrier showed amplitudes that were roughly half of normal. Carrier women did not show a tapetallike fundus reflex but showed asymmetrical patchy pigmentary disturbances consistent with lyonization. A frameshifting 2-base pair insertion at codon 99 of the RPGR gene produced typical retinitis pigmentosa and carrier findings (but no tapetallike reflex) in this family.

X-linked retinitis pigmentosa: re-evaluation of fundus findings and the use of haplotype analysis in clarification of carrier female status.

The identification by fundus examination of those females carrying an X-linked retinitis pigmentosa (RP) gene can reportedly be as high as 87%. In genetic counselling sessions with young females with a 50% risk of being a carrier who wished to know their status, it has not been possible to achieve such a level of success. A review and reanalysis of previous reports indicated that if a tapetal-like reflex was not present in those age 35 years or less, the likelihood of identifying a carrier by fundus examination was small. A family with 7 females with a 50% risk of being a carrier of X-linked RP was evaluated using haplotype analysis in an attempt to identify the X chromosome carrying the RP gene. In the family described, it was possible to establish that a mutation in the RP3 locus most likely causes the disease. This has permitted the determination of the carrier status in each of the females with a high degree of certainty.

A new syndrome of tapetal-like fundic reflexes with ring scotomata. Report of two cases.

Mann1has drawn attention to very rare instances in which human beings have demonstrated a tapetal-like reflex from the fundus oculi. Her 2 cases presented discrete bright yellow spots in the posterior polar region which seemed to be located deep to the retinal vessels. A similar fundus picture was described by Niccol2in the mother of 2 children with atrophic macular lesions. Falls and Cotterman3reported a family in which females presented the picture of a tapetal-like reflex and males developed typical retinitis pigmentosa. In all of the above cases the tapetal-like reflex appeared to be a benign lesion, with no defects in visual acuity or visual fields. It is the purpose of this communication to present 2 patients with tapetal-like reflexes in the fundi accompanied by defects in the visual fields. Report of Cases Case 1. —A 41-year-old white, married male of Greek origin was seen