Synthetic Biological Systems Research Articles

Interfacing Complex Coacervates with Natural Cells

Coacervates have been investigated as protocells or synthetic cells, as well as subcellular compartments for the creation of new materials, thus bridging the gap between living and non‐living systems in materials science, synthetic biology, and bioengineering. Given the design flexibility and simplicity of coacervates, along with the functionality and complexity of natural cells, the interfacing of complex coacervates with natural cells is considered significant for various biotechnological and biomedical applications. In this review, the fundamental mechanisms and underlying theories of coacervate systems are introduced. Recent efforts to interface coacervates with natural cells are summarized in three key scenarios: (i) the integration of coacervates with natural cell components for the living material assembly into protocells; (ii) communication between therapeutic synthetic cells and natural cells for drug delivery and cell repair; and (iii) the formation of intracellular condensates for metabolic regulation, followed by the regulation of their phase transitions for pathological elucidation. Finally, the potential of coacervate‐natural cell interfaces is discussed in the context of developing living/synthetic cell constructs, creating precise disease therapy strategies, and advancing programmable metabolic engineering networks.

Advancements in Colloidosome Fabrication, Functionalization, and Applications: A Comprehensive Review

Abstract: Among the recent developments in the field of microcapsules, colloidosomes microcapsules made of colloidal particles have elicited much interest in promising perspectives in microencapsulation technologies. First reported by Dinsmore et al., these structures hold a lot of potential in different areas of application, which include gene delivery, targeting the brain, and tumor treatment. However, the challenges associated with their permeability and stability limit the use of these coatings. Nevertheless, these problems define colloidosomes as possessing some features of protocells that include metabolic activities and response to stimuli, which make them significant in synthetic biology and biomimetic systems. In drug delivery, colloidosomes have the potential of providing solubility, stability, and a controlled rate of drug release, which will have an impact on the therapeutic use of drugs. Fabrication of colloidosomes is done in many ways, and the common ones include the mulsion strategy, layer adsorption, and microfluidics strategy. Some of these fabrication techniques have been investigated in the recent past to determine how their application can lead to enhanced colloidosome characteristics. Some of these methods include spray drying, sol-gel processes, and electrostatic assembly. For example, the study by Payizila Zulipiker et al. showed that different levels of permeability are controllable through the use of spray drying technology. Another study by Jia Jia et al. presented the preparation of pH-responsive colloidosomes and the high efficiency of encapsulation. Consequently, improvements in the manufacturing process and new self-assembly technologies that include microfluidics systems have also improved the creation of colloidosomes. New advancements in the field of colloidosome synthesis, as well as their surface modification, will open up numerous application prospects in the fields of pharmaceutics, regenerative medicine, and bioinspired materials science. New trends range from 3D printing to stimuli-responsive materials and design, as well as hybrid systems that are application- specific. Despite the difficulties that remain to be faced, colloidosomes represent an extraordinary opportunity for the growth of biotechnology and materials science to open the path to new generations of drugs and bioinspired applications.

Unique biogenesis and kinetics of hornwort Rubiscos revealed by synthetic biology systems

Hornworts are the only land plants that employ a pyrenoid to optimize Rubisco’s CO2 fixation. Yet, hornwort Rubisco remains poorly characterized. Here we assemble the hornwort Anthoceros agrestis Rubisco (AaRubisco) using the Arabidopsis thaliana SynBio expression system and observed the formation of stalled intermediates, prompting us to develop a new SynBio system with A. agrestis cognate chaperones. We successfully assembled AaRubisco and Rubisco from three other hornwort species. Unlike A. thaliana Rubisco, AaRubisco assembly is not dependent on RbcX or Raf2. Kinetic characterization reveals that hornwort Rubiscos exhibit a range of catalytic rates (3-10 s-1), but with similar affinity (∼30 μM) and specificity (∼70) for CO2. In other words, hornwort Rubiscos do not comply with the long held canonical catalytic trade-off observed in other land plants, providing experimental support that Rubisco kinetics may be phylogenetically constrained. Unexpectedly, we observed a 50% increase in AaRubisco catalytic rates when RbcX was removed from our SynBio system, without any reduction in specificity. Structural biology, biochemistry and proteomic analysis suggest that subtle differences in Rubisco large subunit interactions, when RbcX is absent during biogenesis, increases the accessibility of active sites and catalytic turnover rate. This study uncovered a previously unknown Rubisco kinetic parameter space and provides a SynBio chassis to expand the survey of other Rubisco kinetics. Our discovery could thus reshape the approaches for engineering Rubisco with superior kinetics.

A Review: Development of a Synthetic Lactoferrin Biological System.

Lactoferrin is an iron-binding glycoprotein with antibacterial, antitumor, and immunomodulatory functions derived from milk and mucosal secretions. Lactoferrin is used in various products, such as infant formula milk powder, nutritional supplements, and cosmetics. Researchers have developed new technologies to produce lactoferrin because there are limitations in the separation and purification of lactoferrin from milk that cannot compensate for the market demand. Therefore, synthetic systems of lactoferrin have been developed with the development of genetic engineering, and the structure of lactoferrin expressed in heterologous systems is very similar to that of natural lactoferrin. The structure and functions of lactoferrin and the design and construction of synthetic lactoferrin biological systems, especially microbial synthetic systems, including prokaryotic and eukaryotic host-expression systems, are described. On the basis of these results, we summarize the challenges and solutions for constructing systems of high-yield lactoferrin. The development directions of recombinant lactoferrin are discussed in this review. Overall, the design and development of these synthetic biological systems have allowed us to explore the great potential of the industrial large-scale preparation of lactoferrin.

A new era of synthetic biology-microbial community design.

Synthetic biology conceptualizes biological complexity as a network of biological parts, devices, and systems with predetermined functionalities and has had a revolutionary impact on fundamental and applied research. With the unprecedented ability to synthesize and transfer any DNA and RNA across organisms, the scope of synthetic biology is expanding and being recreated in previously unimaginable ways. The field has matured to a level where highly complex networks, such as artificial communities of synthetic organisms, can be constructed. In parallel, computational biology became an integral part of biological studies, with computational models aiding the unravelling of the escalating complexity and emerging properties of biological phenomena. However, there is still a vast untapped potential for the complete integration of modelling into the synthetic design process, presenting exciting opportunities for scientific advancements. Here, we first highlight the most recent advances in computer-aided design of microbial communities. Next, we propose that such a design can benefit from an organism-free modular modelling approach that places its emphasis on modules of organismal function towards the design of multispecies communities. We argue for a shift in perspective from single organism-centred approaches to emphasizing the functional contributions of organisms within the community. By assembling synthetic biological systems using modular computational models with mathematical descriptions of parts and circuits, we can tailor organisms to fulfil specific functional roles within the community. This approach aligns with synthetic biology strategies and presents exciting possibilities for the design of artificial communities. Graphical Abstract.

A new synthetic biology system for investigating the biosynthesis of antibiotics and other secondary metabolites in streptomycetes

We have created a novel synthetic biology expression system allowing easy refactoring of biosynthetic gene clusters (BGCs) as monocistronic transcriptional units. The system is based on a set of plasmids containing a strong kasOp* promoter, RBS and terminators. It allows the cloning of biosynthetic genes into transcriptional units kasOp*-gene(s)-terminator flanked by several rare restriction cloning sites that can be sequentially combined into the artificial BGC in three compatible Streptomyces integration vectors. They allow a simultaneous integration of these BGCs at three different attB sites in the Streptomyces chromosome. The system was validated with biosynthetic genes from two known BGCs for aromatic polyketides landomycin and mithramycin.

Biology System Description Language (BiSDL): a modeling language for the design of multicellular synthetic biological systems

BackgroundThe Biology System Description Language (BiSDL) is an accessible, easy-to-use computational language for multicellular synthetic biology. It allows synthetic biologists to represent spatiality and multi-level cellular dynamics inherent to multicellular designs, filling a gap in the state of the art. Developed for designing and simulating spatial, multicellular synthetic biological systems, BiSDL integrates high-level conceptual design with detailed low-level modeling, fostering collaboration in the Design-Build-Test-Learn cycle. BiSDL descriptions directly compile into Nets-Within-Nets (NWNs) models, offering a unique approach to spatial and hierarchical modeling in biological systems.ResultsBiSDL’s effectiveness is showcased through three case studies on complex multicellular systems: a bacterial consortium, a synthetic morphogen system and a conjugative plasmid transfer process. These studies highlight the BiSDL proficiency in representing spatial interactions and multi-level cellular dynamics. The language facilitates the compilation of conceptual designs into detailed, simulatable models, leveraging the NWNs formalism. This enables intuitive modeling of complex biological systems, making advanced computational tools more accessible to a broader range of researchers.ConclusionsBiSDL represents a significant step forward in computational languages for synthetic biology, providing a sophisticated yet user-friendly tool for designing and simulating complex biological systems with an emphasis on spatiality and cellular dynamics. Its introduction has the potential to transform research and development in synthetic biology, allowing for deeper insights and novel applications in understanding and manipulating multicellular systems.

Kinetic Model for the Heterogeneous Biocatalytic Reactions Using Tethered Cofactors.

Understanding the mechanism of interfacial enzyme kinetics is critical to the development of synthetic biological systems for the production of value-added chemicals. Here, the interfacial kinetics of the catalysis of β-nicotinamide adenine dinucleotide (NAD+)-dependent enzymes acting on NAD+ tethered to the surface of silica nanoparticles (SiNPs) has been investigated using two complementary and supporting kinetic approaches: enzyme excess and reactant (NAD+) excess. Kinetic models developed for these two approaches characterize several critical reaction steps including reversible enzyme adsorption, complexation, decomplexation, and catalysis of the surface-bound enzyme/NAD+ complex. The analysis reveals a concentrating effect resulting in a very high local concentration of enzyme and cofactor on the particle surface, in which the enzyme is saturated by surface-bound NAD, facilitating a rate enhancement of enzyme/NAD+ complexation and catalysis. This resulted in high enzyme efficiency within the tethered NAD+ system compared to that of the free enzyme/NAD+ system, which increases with decreasing enzyme concentration. The role of enzyme adsorption onto solid substrates with a tethered catalyst (such as NAD+) has potential for creating highly efficient flow biocatalytic systems.

Designer Micro-/Nanocrumpled MXene Multilayer Coatings Accelerate Osteogenesis and Regulate Macrophage Polarization.

Effective tissue regeneration and immune responses are essential for the success of biomaterial implantation. Although the interaction between synthetic materials and biological systems is well-recognized, the role of surface topographical cues in regulating the local osteoimmune microenvironment─specifically, their impact on host tissue and immune cells, and their dynamic interactions─remains underexplored. This study addresses this gap by investigating the impact of surface topography on osteogenesis and immunomodulation. We fabricated MXene/hydroxyapatite (HAP)-coated surfaces with controlled 2.5D nano-, submicro-, and microscale topographical patterns using our custom bottom-up patterning method. These engineered surfaces were employed to assess the behavior of osteoblast precursor cells and macrophage polarization. Our results demonstrate that MXene/HAP-coated surfaces with microscale crumpled topography significantly influence osteogenic activity and macrophage polarization: these surfaces notably enhanced osteoblast precursor cell spreading, proliferation, and differentiation and facilitated a shift in macrophages toward an anti-inflammatory, prohealing M2 phenotype. The observed cell responses indicate that the physical cues from the crumpled topographies, combined with the chemical cues from the MXene/HAP coatings, synergistically create a favorable osteoimmune microenvironment. This study presents the first evidence of employing MXene/HAP-multilayer coated surfaces with finely crumpled topography to concurrently facilitate osteogenesis and immunomodulation for improved implant-to-tissue integration. The tunable topographic patterns of these coatings coupled with a facile and scalable fabrication process make them widely applicable for various biomedical purposes. Our results highlight the potential of these multilayer coatings with controlled topography to improve the in vivo performance and fate of implants by modulating the host response at the material interface.

Measuring differential fitness costs and interactions between genetic cassettes using fluorescent spectrophotometry.

In this article, we present a method for designing, executing, and analyzing data from a microbial competition experiment. We use fluorescent reporters to label different competing strains and resolve individual growth curves using a fluorescent spectrophotometer. Our comprehensive data analysis pipeline integrates multiple experiments to simultaneously infer sources of variation, extract selection coefficients, and estimate the genetic contributions to fitness for various synthetic genetic cassettes (SGCs). To demonstrate the method, we employ a synthetic biological system based on Escherichia coli. Strains carry 1 of 10 different plasmids and one of three genomically integrated fluorescent markers. All strains are co-cultured to obtain real-time measurements of optical density (total population density) and fluorescence (sub-population densities). We identify challenges in calibrating between fluorescence and density and of fluorescent proteins maturing at different rates. To resolve these issues, we compare two methods of fluorescence calibration and correct for maturation by measuring in vivo maturation times. We provide evidence of genetic interactions occurring between our SGCs and further show how to use our statistical model to test some hypotheses about microbial growth and the costs of protein expression.IMPORTANCEFluorescently labeled co-cultures are becoming increasingly popular. The approach proposed here offers a high standard for experimental design and data analysis to measure selection coefficients and growth rates in competition. Measuring competitive differences is useful in many laboratory studies, allowing for fitness cost-correction of growth rates and ecological interactions and testing hypotheses in synthetic biology. Using time-resolved growth curves, rather than endpoint measurements, for competition assays allows us to construct a detailed scientific model that can be used to ask questions about fine-grained phenomena, such as bacterial growth dynamics, as well as higher-level phenomena, such as the interactions between synthetic cassette expression.

Development of new binary expression systems for plant synthetic biology.

A novel plant binary expression system was developed from the compactin biosynthetic pathway 27 of Penicillium citrinum ML-236B. The system achieved >fivefold activation of gene expression in 28 transgenic tobacco. A diverse and well-characterized genetic toolset is fundamental to achieve the overall goals of plant synthetic biology. To properly coordinate expression of a multigene pathway, this toolset should include binary systems that control gene expression at the level of transcription. In plants, few highly functional, orthogonal transcriptional regulators have been identified. Here, we describe the process of developing synthetic plant transcription factors using regulatory elements from the Penicillium citrinum ML-236B (compactin) pathway. This pathway contains several genes including mlcA and mlcC that are transcriptionally regulated in a dose-dependent manner by the activator mlcR. In Nicotiana benthamiana, we first expressed mlcR with several cognate synthetic promoters driving expression of GFP. Synthetic promoters contained operator sequences from the compactin gene cluster. Following identification of the most active synthetic promoter, the DNA-binding domain from mlcR was used to generate chimeric transcription factors containing variable activation domains, including QF from the Neurospora crassa Q-system. Activity was measured at both protein and RNA levels which correlated with an R2 value of 0.94. A synthetic transcription factor with a QF activation domain increased gene expression from its synthetic promoter up to sixfold in N. benthamiana. Two systems were characterized in transgenic tobacco plants. The QF-based plants maintained high expression in tobacco, increasing expression from the cognate synthetic promoter by fivefold. Transgenic plants and non-transgenic plants were morphologically indistinguishable. The framework of this study can easily be adopted for other putative transcription factors to continue improvement of the plant synthetic biology toolbox.

Organization of an Artificial Multicellular System with a Tunable DNA Patch on a Membrane Surface.

Coordinating multiple artificial cellular compartments into a well-organized artificial multicellular system (AMS) is of great interest in bottom-up synthetic biology. However, developing a facile strategy for fabricating an AMS with a controlled arrangement remains a challenge. Herein, utilizing in situ DNA hybridization chain reaction on the membrane surface, we developed a DNA patch-based strategy to direct the interconnection of vesicles. By tuning the DNA patch that generates heterotrophic adhesion for the attachment of vesicles, we could produce an AMS with higher-order structures straightforwardly and effectively. Furthermore, a hybrid AMS comprising live cells and vesicles was fabricated, and we found the hybrid AMS with higher-order structures arouses efficient molecular transportation from vesicles to living cells. In brief, our work provides a versatile strategy for modulating the self-assembly of AMSs, which could expand our capability to engineer synthetic biological systems and benefit synthetic cell research in programmable manipulation of intercellular communications.

The Construction of the Self-Induced Sal System and Its Application in Salicylic Acid Production

The design and construction of more complex and delicate genetic control circuits suffer from poor orthogonality in quorum sensing (QS) systems. The Sal system, which relies on salicylic acid as a signaling molecule, is an artificially engineered regulatory system with a structure that differs significantly from that of natural QS signaling molecules. Salicylic acid is an important drug precursor, mainly used in the production of drugs such as aspirin and anti-HIV drugs. However, there have been no reports on the construction of a self-induced Sal system in single cells. In this study, a high-copy plasmid backbone was used to construct the regulatory proteins and a self-induced promoter of salicylic acid in E. coli by adjusting the precise regulation of key gene expression; the sensitivity and induction range of this system were improved. Subsequently, the exogenous gene pchBA was introduced in E. coli to extend the shikimate pathway and synthesize salicylic acid, resulting in the construction of the first complete self-induced Sal system. Finally, the self-induced Sal System was combined with artificial trans-encoded sRNAs (atsRNAs) to repress the growth-essential gene ppc and accumulate the precursor substance PEP, thereby increasing the titer of salicylic acid by 151%. This construction of a self-induced artificial system introduces a new tool for selecting communication tools and induction systems in synthetic biology and metabolic engineering, but also demonstrates a self-inducible pathway design strategy for salicylic acid biosynthesis.

An orthogonalized PYR1-based CID module with reprogrammable ligand-binding specificity

Plants sense abscisic acid (ABA) using chemical-induced dimerization (CID) modules, including the receptor PYR1 and HAB1, a phosphatase inhibited by ligand-activated PYR1. This system is unique because of the relative ease with which ligand recognition can be reprogrammed. To expand the PYR1 system, we designed an orthogonal ‘*’ module, which harbors a dimer interface salt bridge; X-ray crystallographic, biochemical and in vivo analyses confirm its orthogonality. We used this module to create PYR1*MANDI/HAB1* and PYR1*AZIN/HAB1*, which possess nanomolar sensitivities to their activating ligands mandipropamid and azinphos-ethyl. Experiments in Arabidopsis thaliana and Saccharomyces cerevisiae demonstrate the sensitive detection of banned organophosphate contaminants using living biosensors and the construction of multi-input/output genetic circuits. Our new modules enable ligand-programmable multi-channel CID systems for plant and eukaryotic synthetic biology that can empower new plant-based and microbe-based sensing modalities.

What’s next for computational systems biology?

Largely unknown just a few decades ago, computational systems biology is now a central methodology for biological and medical research. This amazing ascent raises the question of what the community should do next. The article outlines our personal vision for the future of computational systems biology, suggesting the need to address both mindsets and methodologies. We present this vision by focusing on current and anticipated research goals, the development of strong computational tools, likely prominent applications, education of the next-generation of scientists, and outreach to the public. In our opinion, two classes of broad research goals have emerged in recent years and will guide future efforts. The first goal targets computational models of increasing size and complexity, aimed at solving emerging health-related challenges, such as realistic whole-cell and organ models, disease simulators and digital twins, in silico clinical trials, and clinically translational applications in the context of therapeutic drug development. Such large models will also lead us toward solutions to pressing issues in agriculture and environmental sustainability, including sufficient food availability and life in changing habitats. The second goal is a deep understanding of the essence of system designs and strategies with which nature solves problems. This understanding will help us explain observed biological structures and guide forays into synthetic biological systems. Regarding effective methodologies, we suggest efforts toward automated data pipelines from raw biomedical data all the way to spatiotemporal mechanistic model. These will be supported by dynamic methods of statistics, machine learning, artificial intelligence and streamlined strategies of dynamic model design, striking a fine balance between modeling realistic complexity and abstracted simplicity. Finally, we suggest the need for a concerted, community-wide emphasis on effective education in systems biology, implemented as a combination of formal instruction and hands-on mentoring. The educational efforts should furthermore be extended toward the public through books, blogs, social media, and interactive networking opportunities, with the ultimate goal of training in state-of-the-art technology while recapturing the lost art of synthesis.

An Intelligent Synthetic Bacterium for Chronological Toxicant Detection, Biodegradation, and Its Subsequent Suicide.

Modules, toolboxes, and synthetic biology systems may be designed to address environmental bioremediation. However, weak and decentralized functional modules require complex control. To address this issue, an integrated system for toxicant detection and biodegradation, and subsequent suicide in chronological order without exogenous inducers is constructed. Salicylic acid, a typical pollutant in industrial wastewater, is selected as an example to demonstrate this design. Biosensors are optimized by regulating the expression of receptors and reporters to get 2-fold sensitivity and 6-fold maximum output. Several stationary phase promoters are compared, and promoter Pfic is chosen to express the degradation enzyme. Two concepts for suicide circuits are developed, with the toxin/antitoxin circuit showing potent lethality. The three modules are coupled in a stepwise manner. Detection and biodegradation, and suicide are sequentially completed with partial attenuation compared to pre-integration, except for biodegradation, being improved by the replacements of ribosome binding site. Finally, a long-term stability test reveals that the engineered strain maintained its function for ten generations. The study provides a novel concept for integrating and controlling functional modules that can accelerate the transition of synthetic biology from conceptual to practical applications.

Acoustic Levitation-Assisted Contactless Printing of Microdroplets for Biomedical Applications

Abstract The cell is a microcapsule system wherein biological materials are encapsulated by a thin membrane, which provides valuable information on the metabolism, morphology, development, and signal transduction pathways of the studied cell. The cell-inspired microdroplet has the characteristics of efficient nanoscale substance transportation, self-organization, and morphological adaptation. However, it is extremely difficult to manufacture such systems. Mostly vesicles such as liposomes, polymersomes, and microcapsules are first produced by a high-pressure homogenizer and microfluidizer as an emulsion and then encapsulated microcapsules by the drop or emulsion method. Currently, acoustic levitation opens entirely new possibilities for creating bioinspired microdroplets because of its ability to suspend tiny droplets in an antigravity and noncontact manner. Herein, we propose contactless printing of single-core or multi-core cell-inspired microdroplets via acoustic levitation. First, the oscillation mode and microscopic morphology of the droplets under different ultrasonic vibration frequencies are shown by simulation, and the curing characteristics of the shell structure under different ultraviolet illumination conditions are quantitatively measured. The feasibility of manufacturing multi-core microdroplets and manufacturing submillimeter-scale particles based on oil trapping is extensively studied. To explore the morphological adaptability of microdroplets, ferromagnetic Fe3O4 nanoparticles are used to give magnetic-responsive properties to cells, and the microscopic deformation and motion in microfluidic channels under the magnetic field are characterized. Finally, the proposed printing method proves the versatility of in-space contactless printing of complex 3D beam structures and provides a powerful platform for developing biomedical devices and microrobots and studying morphogenesis and synthetic biological systems.

Antimicrobial Peptides: The Production of Novel Peptide-Based Therapeutics in Plant Systems.

The increased prevalence of antibiotic resistance is alarming and has a significant impact on the economies of emerging and underdeveloped nations. The redundancy of antibiotic discovery platforms (ADPs) and injudicious use of conventional antibiotics has severely impacted millions, across the globe. Potent antimicrobials from biological sources have been extensively explored as a ray of hope to counter the growing menace of antibiotic resistance in the population. Antimicrobial peptides (AMPs) are gaining momentum as powerful antimicrobial therapies to combat drug-resistant bacterial strains. The tremendous therapeutic potential of natural and synthesized AMPs as novel and potent antimicrobials is highlighted by their unique mode of action, as exemplified by multiple research initiatives. Recent advances and developments in antimicrobial discovery and research have increased our understanding of the structure, characteristics, and function of AMPs; nevertheless, knowledge gaps still need to be addressed before these therapeutic options can be fully exploited. This thematic article provides a comprehensive insight into the potential of AMPs as potent arsenals to counter drug-resistant pathogens, a historical overview and recent advances, and their efficient production in plants, defining novel upcoming trends in drug discovery and research. The advances in synthetic biology and plant-based expression systems for AMP production have defined new paradigms in the efficient production of potent antimicrobials in plant systems, a prospective approach to countering drug-resistant pathogens.

Next generation synthetic memory via intercepting recombinase function

Here we present a technology to facilitate synthetic memory in a living system via repurposing Transcriptional Programming (i.e., our decision-making technology) parts, to regulate (intercept) recombinase function post-translation. We show that interception synthetic memory can facilitate programmable loss-of-function via site-specific deletion, programmable gain-of-function by way of site-specific inversion, and synthetic memory operations with nested Boolean logical operations. We can expand interception synthetic memory capacity more than 5-fold for a single recombinase, with reconfiguration specificity for multiple sites in parallel. Interception synthetic memory is ~10-times faster than previous generations of recombinase-based memory. We posit that the faster recombination speed of our next-generation memory technology is due to the post-translational regulation of recombinase function. This iteration of synthetic memory is complementary to decision-making via Transcriptional Programming – thus can be used to develop intelligent synthetic biological systems for myriad applications.

Carotenoid ornaments and the spandrels of physiology: a critique of theory to explain condition dependency.

Even as numerous studies have documented that the red and yellow coloration resulting from the deposition of carotenoids serves as an honest signal of condition, the evolution of condition dependency is contentious. The resource trade-off hypothesis proposes that condition-dependent honest signalling relies on a trade-off of resources between ornamental display and body maintenance. By this model, condition dependency can evolve through selection for a re-allocation of resources to promote ornament expression. By contrast, the index hypothesis proposes that selection focuses mate choice on carotenoid coloration that is inherently condition dependent because production of such coloration is inexorably tied to vital cellular processes. These hypotheses for the origins of condition dependency make strongly contrasting and testable predictions about ornamental traits. To assess these two models, we review the mechanisms of production of carotenoids, patterns of condition dependency involving different classes of carotenoids, and patterns of behavioural responses to carotenoid coloration. We review evidence that traits can be condition dependent without the influence of sexual selection and that novel traits can show condition-dependent expression as soon as they appear in a population, without the possibility of sexual selection. We conclude by highlighting new opportunities for studying condition-dependent signalling made possible by genetic manipulation and expression of ornamental traits in synthetic biological systems.