Symbiotic Stars Research Articles

Unequivocal detection of the tidal deformation of a red giant in a binary system via interferometry

While mass transfer in binary systems is a crucial aspect of binary evolution models, it remains far from understood. HD 352 is a spectroscopic binary exhibiting ellipsoidal variability, likely due to a tidally deformed giant donor filling its Roche lobe and transferring matter to a faint companion. Here, we analyze VLTI/PIONIER interferometric observations of the system, obtained between 2010 to 2020. We demonstrate that observations near the system's quadrature cannot be explained by simple symmetric disk models, but they are consistent with the shape of a Roche-lobe-filling star. We think that this is the first case of tidal deformation of a red giant being observed directly, thanks to the interferometric technique. By combining our interferometric modeling results with the analysis of the optical spectrum, multifrequency spectral energy distribution, and published radial velocities and light curves, we constrained the system parameters and show that HD 352 will likely soon enter the common envelope phase, although we cannot reject the hypothesis that it is undergoing stable mass transfer against theoretical predictions. This has important consequences for modeling a large class of binary systems. Additionally, our observations confirm that Roche-lobe-filling giants can be resolved with interferometry under favorable conditions. Such observations may help resolve the mass transfer dichotomy in systems such as symbiotic binaries, where the predominant mass transfer mode remains unclear.

Analyzing Supervised Machine Learning Models for Classifying Astronomical Objects Using Gaia DR3 Spectral Features

In this paper, we present an analysis of the effectiveness of various machine learning algorithms in classifying astronomical objects using data from the third release (DR3) of the Gaia space mission. The dataset used includes spectral information from the satellite’s red and blue spectrophotometers. The primary goal is to achieve reliable classification with high confidence for symbiotic stars, planetary nebulae, and red giants. Symbiotic stars are binary systems formed by a high-temperature star (a white dwarf in most cases) and an evolved star (Mira type or red giant star); their spectra varies between the typical for these objects (depending on the orbital phase of the object) and present emission lines similar to those observed in PN spectra, which is the reason for this first selection. Several classification algorithms are evaluated, including Random Forest (RF), Support Vector Machine (SVM), Artificial Neural Networks (ANN), Gradient Boosting (GB), and Naive Bayes classifier. The evaluation is based on different metrics such as Precision, Recall, F1-Score, and the Kappa index. The study confirms the effectiveness of classifying the mentioned stars using only their spectral information. The models trained with Artificial Neural Networks and Random Forest demonstrated superior performance, surpassing an accuracy rate of 94.67%.

EROSITA (eRASS1) study of the Canis Major overdensity: Developing a multi-wavelength algorithm for classifying faint X-ray sources

Context. Using data from eROSITA (extended Roentgen Survey with an Imaging Telescope Array) on board Spektrum-Roentgen- Gamma (Spektr-RG, SRG) taken during the first eROSITAall-sky survey (eRASS1), we performed the first X-ray classification and population study in the field of the Canis Major overdensity (CMa OD), which is an elliptical-shaped stellar overdensity located at l = -240°, b = −80°. Aims. This study aims to identify the X-ray sources in CMa OD. We developed a classification algorithm using multi-wavelength criteria as a preliminary method for the classification of faint X-ray sources, specifically in regions with a high source number density. Methods. We used the brightness of the multi-wavelength counterparts (mainly from infrared and optical catalogues), along with the X-ray flux and X-ray hardness ratios (HRs) to classify the sources. Results. Out of a total number of 8311 X-ray sources, we classified 1029 sources as Galactic stars and binaries in the foreground, 946 sources as active galactic nuclei (AGNs) and galaxies in the background, and 435 sources with stellar counterparts that may belong to either the MW or CMa OD. Among the sources with a stellar counterpart, we identified 34 symbiotic star candidates, plus 335 sources, of which the infrared (IR) counterparts have properties of M-giants in CMa OD. Moreover, there is a known high-mass X-ray binary (HMXB, 4U 0728-25) in the field of our study; according to the Gaia parallax of its companion, it appears to be a member of CMa OD. There is also a recently detected transient low-mass X-ray binary (LMXB, SRGt J071522.1-191609) is also present; it may be a member of CMa OD based on its companion, which is most likely highly absorbed and is thus located behind the Galactic disk. In addition, we present the X-ray luminosity function (XLF) of members and candidate members of CMa OD. It is dominated by sources with luminosities of <2 × 1032–1033 erg s−1 in the energy range of 0.2–2.3 keV. These sources are expected to be either accreting white dwarfs or quiescent LMXBs.

Symbiotic stars in X-rays

White dwarf symbiotic binaries are detected in X-rays with luminosities in the range of 1030–1034 ergs s−1. Their X-ray emission arises either from the accretion disk boundary layer, from a region where the winds from both components collide, or from nuclear burning on the surface of the white dwarf (WD). In our continuous effort to identify X-ray-emitting symbiotic stars, we studied four systems using observations from the Neil Gehrels Swift Observatory and XMM-Newton satellites in X-rays and from Transiting Exoplanet Survey Satellite (TESS) in the optical. The X-ray spectra were fit with absorbed optically thin thermal plasma models that are either single- or multitemperature with kT < 8 keV for all targets. Based on the characteristics of their X-ray spectra, we classified BD Cam as possible β-type, V1261 Ori and CD −27 8661 as δ-type, and confirmed NQ Gem as β/δ-type. The δ-type X-ray emission most likely arises from the boundary layer of the accretion disk, while in the case of BD Cam, its mostly soft emission originates from shocks, possibly between the red giant and WD and disk winds. In general, we find that the observed X-ray emission is powered by accretion at a low accretion rate of about 10−11 M⊙ yr−1. The low ratio of X-ray to optical luminosities, however indicates that the accretion-disk boundary layer is mostly optically thick and tends to emit in the far or extreme UV. The detection of flickering in optical data provides evidence of the existence of an accretion disk.

X-Ray Variability in the Symbiotic Binary RT Cru: Principal Component Analysis

Hard X-ray-emitting (δ-type) symbiotic binaries, which exhibit a strong hard X-ray excess, have posed a challenge to our understanding of accretion physics in degenerate dwarfs. RT Cru, which is a member of the δ-type symbiotics, shows stochastic X-ray variability. Timing analyses of X-ray observations from XMM-Newton and NuSTAR, which we consider here, indicate hourly fluctuations, in addition to a spectral transition from 2007 to a harder state in 2012 seen with Suzaku observations. To trace the nature of X-ray variability, we analyze the multimission X-ray data using principal component analysis (PCA), which determines the spectral components that contribute most to the flickering behavior and the hardness transition. The Chandra HRC-S/LETG and XMM-Newton EPIC-pn data provide the primary PCA components, which may contain some variable emission features, especially in the soft excess. Additionally, the absorbing column (first order with 50%), along with the source continuum (20%), and a third component (9%)—which likely accounts for thermal emission in the soft band—are the three principal components found in the Suzaku XIS1 observations. The PCA components of the NuSTAR data also correspond to the continuum and possibly emission features. Our findings suggest that the spectral hardness transition between the two Suzaku observations is mainly due to changes in the absorbing material and X-ray continuum, while some changes in the thermal plasma emission may result in flickering-type variations.

A first systematic characterization of cataclysmic variables in SRG/eROSITA surveys

We present an account of known cataclysmic variables (CVs) that were detected as X-ray sources in eROSITA X-ray surveys and have gai DR3 counterparts. We address standard CVs with main sequence donors and white dwarfs accreting via Roche-lobe overflow (RLOF) and related objects, the double degenerates (DDs), and the symbiotic stars (SySts). We discern between nonmagnetic (dwarf novae and nova-like objects) and magnetic CVs (polars and intermediate polars (IPs)). In the publically available eROSITA catalog from the recent DR1, typically 65<!PCT!> of known cataloged and classified CVs are detected. This fraction rises to over 90<!PCT!> if the stack of all X-ray surveys (called S45 in this paper) is considered and the search volume is restricted to a radius of 500\,pc. We examine the various classes of CVs in various diagnostic diagrams relating X-ray and optical properties (luminosity, absolute magnitude, color, X-ray spectral hardness, and optical variability) and establish their average class properties. We derive spectral properties for the 22 brightest polars and confirm an increase in the ratio of soft to hard X-rays with increasing magnetic field in the accretion region. We report three new soft IPs and present a spectral analysis of all soft IPs. Their blackbody temperatures agree well with published values. The DDs represent the bluest and faintest subcategory but reach the same identification fraction as the standard CVs. The SySts are the most distant systems; only 20 (13<!PCT!>) were detected as X-ray sources in S45, and 7 of those are first-time detections. We investigate their mean properties using an upper limit on the flux of the nondetected CVs. Their X-ray nondetection is indeed a distance effect. We used all properties combined to select candidate CVs for all-sky optical identification programs, with the ultimate aim being to compose large CV samples in order to better constrain the impact of magnetic fields on the evolution of CVs, to derive space densities and luminosity functions, and to quantify the contribution of white-dwarf accreting systems to the Galactic Ridge X-ray emission (GRXE). The results of the optical identification program will be presented in forthcoming papers.

The formation of the magnetic symbiotic star FN Sgr

Context. There are several symbiotic stars (e.g., BF Cyg, Z And, and FN Sgr) in which periodic signals of tens of minutes have been detected. These periods have been interpreted as the spin period of magnetic white dwarfs that accrete through a magnetic stream originating from a truncated accretion disc. Aims. To shed light on the origin of magnetic symbiotic stars, we investigated the system FN Sgr in detail. We searched for a reasonable formation pathway to explain its stellar and binary parameters including the magnetic field of the accreting white dwarf. Methods. We used the MESA code to carry out pre-CE and post-CE binary evolution and determined the outcome of CE evolution assuming the energy formalism. For the origin and evolution of the white dwarf magnetic field, we adopted the crystallization scenario. Results. We found that FN Sgr can be explained as follows. First, a non-magnetic white dwarf is formed through CE evolution. Later, during post-CE evolution, the white dwarf starts to crystallize and a weak magnetic field is generated. After a few hundred million years, the magnetic field penetrates the white dwarf surface and becomes detectable. Meanwhile, its companion evolves and becomes an evolved red giant. Subsequently, the white dwarf accretes part of the angular momentum from the red giant stellar winds. As a result, the white dwarf spin period decreases and its magnetic field reaches super-equipartition, getting amplified due to a rotation- and crystallization-driven dynamo. The binary then evolves into a symbiotic star, with a magnetic white dwarf accreting from an evolved red giant through atmospheric Roche-lobe overflow. Conclusions. We conclude that the rotation- and crystallization-driven dynamo scenario, or any age-dependent scenario, can explain the origin of magnetic symbiotic stars reasonably well. This adds another piece to the pile of evidence supporting this scenario. If our formation channel is correct, our findings suggest that white dwarfs in most symbiotic stars formed through CE evolution might be magnetic, provided that the red giant has spent ≳3 Gyr as a main-sequence star.

Probing the Propeller Regime with Symbiotic X-ray Binaries

At the moment, there are two neutron star X-ray binaries with massive red supergiants as donors. Recently, De et al. (2023) proposed that the system SWIFT J0850.8-4219 contains a neutron star at the propeller stage. We study this possibility by applying various models of propeller spin-down. We demonstrate that the duration of the propeller stage is very sensitive to the regime of rotational losses. Only in the case of a relatively slow propeller model proposed by Davies and Pringle in 1981, the duration of the propeller is long enough to provide a significant probability to observe the system at this stage. Future determination of the system parameters (orbital and spin periods, magnetic field of the compact object, etc.) will allow putting strong constraints on the propeller behavior.

Is the RSGC4 (Alicante 8) Cluster a Real Star Cluster? Peculiar Radial Velocities of Red Supergiant Stars

Young massive star clusters, like the six red supergiant clusters in the Scutum complex, provide valuable insights into star formation and galaxy structures. We investigated the high-resolution near-infrared spectra of 60 RSG candidates in these clusters using the Immersion Grating Infrared Spectrograph. Among the candidates in RSGC4, we found significant scattering in radial velocity (−64 to 115 km s−1), unlike other clusters with velocities of ∼100 km s−1. Most candidates in RSGC4 have Q GK s values larger than 1.7, suggesting that they could be early AGB stars. Four candidates in RSGC4 exhibit infrared excess and distinct absorption features absent in other candidates. Two of these stars exhibit absorption lines resembling those of D-type symbiotic stars, showing radial velocity changes in multiepoch observations. Analysis of relative proper motions revealed no runaway/walkaway stars in RSGC4. The dynamic properties of RSGC4 and RSGC1 differ from the disklike motions of other clusters: RSGC4 has low normalized horizontal action J hor = J ϕ /J tot and vertical action J ver = (J z − J R)/J tot values and high eccentricities, while RSGC1 has vertical motions with high J ver values and inclinations. We propose that RSGC4 may not be a genuine star cluster but rather a composite of RSGs and AGB stars distributed along the line of sight at similar distances, possibly originating from various environments. Our results suggest a complex and hierarchical secular evolution of star clusters in the Scutum complex, emphasizing the importance of considering factors beyond density crowding when identifying star clusters in the bulge regions.

A 1.9 solar-mass neutron star candidate in a 2-year orbit

We report discovery and characterization of a main-sequence G star orbiting a dark object with mass 1.90±0.04M⊙. The system was discovered via Gaia astrometry and has an orbital period of 731 days. We obtained multi-epoch RV follow-up over a period of 639 days, allowing us to refine the Gaia orbital solution and precisely constrain the masses of both components. The luminous star is a ≳12,Gyr-old, low-metallicity halo star near the main-sequence turnoff (,K; ; ; M≈0.79M⊙) with a highly enhanced lithium abundance. The RV mass function sets a minimum companion mass for an edge-on orbit of M2>1.67M⊙, well above the Chandrasekhar limit. The Gaia inclination constraint, i=68.7±1.4,deg, then implies a companion mass of M2=1.90±0.04M⊙. The companion is most likely a massive neutron star: the only viable alternative is two massive white dwarfs in a close binary, but this scenario is disfavored on evolutionary grounds. The system’s low eccentricity ( e=0.122±0.002) disfavors dynamical formation channels and implies that the neutron star likely formed with little mass loss ( ≲1M⊙) and with a weak natal kick (). Stronger kicks with more mass loss are not fully ruled out but would imply that a larger population of similar systems with higher eccentricities should exist. The current orbit is too small to have accommodated the neutron star progenitor as a red supergiant or super-AGB star. The simplest formation scenario – isolated binary evolution – requires the system to have survived unstable mass transfer and common envelope evolution with a donor-to-accretor mass ratio >10. The system, which we call Gaia NS1, is likely a progenitor of symbiotic X-ray binaries and long-period millisecond pulsars. Its discovery challenges binary evolution models and bodes well for Gaia’s census of compact objects in wide binaries.

Gaia23ckh: Symbiotic outburst of the assumed Mira variable V390 Sco

AbstractThe poorly studied variable star V390 Sco, previously classified as a Mira pulsator, was detected in a brightening event by the ESA Gaia satellite in September 2023. This work presents an analysis of available archival multifrequency photometric data of this target, along with our spectroscopic observations. Our findings lead to the conclusion that V390 Sco is a new symbiotic star identified by Gaia, currently undergoing a classical symbiotic outburst. Additionally, we uncovered three prior outbursts of this system through archival photometry. The outbursts recur approximately every 2330–2400 days, and we hypothesize the periastron passage in an eccentric orbit may trigger them, similarly to the case of BX Mon, DD Mic, or MWC 560. A detailed investigation into the nature of the donor star suggested that V390 Sco is an S‐type symbiotic star, likely hosting a less evolved, semiregularly pulsating giant donor, but not a Mira variable.

Chandra and HST studies of the X-ray sources in the globular cluster NGC 362

ABSTRACT We analyse a Chandra observation of the rich globular cluster NGC 362, finding 33 X-ray sources within 1 arcmin (1.2 half-mass radii) of the cluster centre. Spectral analysis of the brightest source (X1) shows blackbody-like emission, indicating it is likely a quiescent low-mass X-ray binary; we find a possible counterpart that falls in the sub-subgiant region. We use Hubble Space Telescope ultraviolet (UV) Globular Cluster Survey photometry to identify 15 potential optical/UV counterparts to these X-ray sources, including two background active galactic nuclei. We identify no likely cataclysmic variables (CVs), probably due to crowding in optical filters in the core, though we predict of order 8 CVs among the detected X-ray sources. We identify three other sub-subgiants and two red straggler counterparts, which are likely powered by coronal activity, along with five other potential coronally active binary counterparts to three X-ray sources. Finally, we note two unusual counterpart candidates that lie to the red of the red giant branch in V606 − I814, and shift well to the blue of the red giant branch in ultraviolet colour–magnitude diagrams. These systems seem to contain a red giant with a distorted evolutionary history, plus a bright blue light source, either a blue straggler star (an Algol-like system) or an accreting white dwarf (a long-period CV, or a symbiotic star).

Accretion-induced flickering variability among symbiotic stars from space photometry with NASA TESS

Context. Symbiotic binaries exhibit a wide range of photometric variability across different timescales. These changes can be attributed to factors such as orbital motion, intrinsic variability of the individual components, or interactions between the two stars. In the range from minutes to hours, a variability induced by accretion processes that is likely to originate from the accretion disks has been detected and subsequently denoted as flickering. This variability could mimic solar-like oscillations exhibited by luminous red giants. Aims. We aim to investigate whether it is possible to utilize the precise observations of the NASA TESS mission to detect flickering in symbiotic stars, despite the fact that such studies are usually performed at shorter wavelengths than those of TESS observations. Additionally, our goal is to develop a quantitative method for the detection of accretion-induced flickering that does not rely solely on a subjective assessment of the light curves. Methods. We obtained the light curves of known symbiotic stars and a comprehensive control sample of assumed single red giants from the TESS full-frame images. To ensure consistency, all the data were processed using the same methodology, which involves filtering out the background, systematic, and long-term trends. From the processed light curves and their power spectral densities, we measured the amplitudes of the variability and other relevant parameters. Results. We introduce a method that enables a differentiation between flickering sources and stars that do not exhibit this type of variability. We detected flickering-like variability in 20 symbiotic stars utilizing TESS data, of which 13 had not previously been identified as flickering sources. Moreover, the TESS observations facilitate the detection of related variations occurring over timescales of a few days, as well as changes in the flickering behavior across multiple sectors. Conclusions. The flickering is now likely to be detected in a total of 35 known symbiotic stars. While this represents only a small subset of all symbiotic binaries, when focusing solely on accreting-only symbiotic stars where the detection of flickering is presumably more straightforward, the fraction could reach as high as ∼80%. This result suggests that accretion disks may indeed be prevalent in these binaries.

Exploring outbursts of accreting white dwarfs in symbiotic binaries -- basic concept

Exploring outbursts of accreting white dwarfs in symbiotic binaries -- basic concept

The Missing Symbiotic Stars: A Joint Analysis with Gaia, GALEX, and XMM-Newton Data

The existence of a population of low-accretion-rate symbiotic stars (SySts), consisting of a giant star and a compact companion (usually a white dwarf), has been proposed recently. However, their population has not been fully understood. In this work, we present an investigation on SySts candidates consisting of asymptotic giant branch stars (AGBs) by cross-correlating the Gaia DR3, the Galaxy Evolution Explorer All-Sky Imaging Survey, and the 4XMM DR13 catalogs. We first build a sample of AGBs within 500 pc based on their locations in the Gaia color–absolute magnitude diagram. We then explore the UV and X-ray properties of the sampled AGBs and compare them to known SySts and candidates. We find 10 SySts candidates based on the far-ultraviolet excess. The typical UV luminosity of the candidates is 1031 erg s−1, which corresponds to a typical accretion rate of 10−12–10−11 M ⊙ yr−1, which is more than 1 order of magnitude lower than known SySts. Based on these findings, the total number of SySts within 500 pc is estimated to be 18. The number of AGBs with X-ray flux above 10−14 erg s−1 cm−2 within 500 pc is estimated to be 37. Our finding implies that a large number of low-accretion-rate SySts are yet to be detected, which provides a base for a complete understanding of their population.

No X-Rays or Radio from the Nearest Black Holes and Implications for Future Searches

Astrometry from the Gaia mission was recently used to discover the two nearest known stellar-mass black holes (BHs), Gaia BH1 and Gaia BH2. These objects are among the first stellar-mass BHs not discovered via X-rays or gravitational waves. Both systems contain ∼1 M ⊙ stars in wide orbits (a ≈ 1.4 au, 4.96 au) around ∼9 M ⊙ BHs, with both stars (solar-type main sequence star, red giant) well within their Roche lobes in Gaia BH1 and BH2, respectively. However, the BHs are still expected to accrete stellar winds, leading to potentially detectable X-ray or radio emission. Here, we report observations of both systems with the Chandra X-ray Observatory, the Very Large Array (for Gaia BH1) and MeerKAT (for Gaia BH2). We did not detect either system, leading to X-ray upper limits of L X < 9.4 × 1028 and L X < 4.0 × 1029 erg s−1 and radio upper limits of L r < 1.6 × 1025 and L r < 1.0 × 1026 erg s−1 for Gaia BH1 and BH2, respectively. For Gaia BH2, the non-detection implies that the accretion rate near the horizon is much lower than the Bondi rate, consistent with recent models for hot accretion flows. We discuss implications of these non-detections for broader BH searches, concluding that it is unlikely that isolated BHs will be detected via interstellar medium accretion in the near future. We also calculate evolutionary models for the binaries’ future evolution using Modules for Experiments in Stellar Astrophysics, and find that Gaia BH1 will be visible as a symbiotic BH X-ray binary for 5–50 Myr. Since no symbiotic BH X-ray binaries are known, this implies either that fewer than ∼104 Gaia BH1-like binaries exist in the Milky Way, or that they are common but have evaded detection.

Accreting-only symbiotic stars in the era of large Galactic Archeology spectroscopic surveys

Accreting-only symbiotic stars in the era of large Galactic Archeology spectroscopic surveys

Reflection physics in X-ray-emitting symbiotic stars

ABSTRACT X-ray-emitting symbiotic stars exhibit a variety of spectral shapes classified as α, β, γ, δ, and β/δ types, which have been attributed to different phenomena such as thermonuclear burning on the surface of the white dwarf component, shocks between winds and jets with the red giant companion’s extended atmosphere, the presence of heavily extinguished hot plasma from the inner region from an accretion disc, and/or a combination of these. However, there is observational evidence that this classification scheme is not definite and, for example, some sources change from one type to another within months or years. In this work, it is proposed that a simple disc-like model can be used to explain the X-ray properties observed from reflection-dominated symbiotic stars. For this purpose, we use the Stellar Kinematics Including Radiative Transfer (skirt) code, which has been recently upgraded to include radiative transfer from X-ray photons. It is found that the properties of the accretion disc (geometry and density) in combination with the viewing angle can be invoked to explain the spectral properties of β, δ, and β/δ X-ray-emitting symbiotic stars. Spectral variations and type swaps observed for some X-ray-emitting sources can also be explained by variations in the disc properties.

Luminosity class of the symbiotic stars 4U1954+319 and ZZ CMi

We performed optical photometry and spectral observations of the symbiotic stars 4U1954+319 and ZZ CMi. For 4U1954+319, using high-resolution spectra, we, measure the equivalent widths of diffuse interstellar bands (DIBs) and estimate the interstellar reddening E(B-V ) = 0:83?0:09. Using the GAIA distances and our photometry, we find: (1) the absolute V -band magnitude MV =-5:23 ? 0:08 of 4U1954+319 and that the mass donor is a supergiant of luminosity class Ib, and (2) MV = -0:27?0:2 for ZZ CMi and that the mass donor is a giant of luminosity class III.

Front-row Seat of the Recent R Aqr Periastron Passage: X-Ray Multiepoch Spectral and Spatial Analysis

We report on the X-ray spectral and spatial evolution of the symbiotic star R Aqr. Through a multiepoch observational campaign performed with Chandra between 2017 and 2022, we study the X-ray emission of this binary system, composed of an evolved red giant star and a white dwarf (WD). This analysis is particularly timely as the WD approached the periastron in late 2018/early 2019; thus, mass transfer, jet emission, and outburst phenomena are to be expected. Through detailed spectral analysis, we detect a significant rise in the soft X-ray (0.5–2 keV) emission of R Aqr, likely linked to jet emission, followed by a decay toward the previous quiescent state. The hard X-ray emission (5–8 keV) is not immediately affected by the periastron passage; the hard component, after maintaining the same flux level between 2017 and 2021, rapidly decays after 2022. Possible explanations for this are a change in the reflection properties of the medium surrounding the binary, obscuration of the central region by material ejected during the periastron passage, or even the partial/complete destruction of the inner regions of the accretion disk surrounding the WD. In addition to this activity in the central region, extended emission is also detected, likely linked to a hot spot in a pre-outburst-emitted jet, which can be observed moving away from the system’s central region.