With growing survival rates for Adolescent and Young Adults (AYAs) diagnosed with gynecological cancer, the focus shifted to Quality of Life (QoL). Fertility-sparing surgery offers a viable alternative to standard, usually fertility-impairing treatments. Treatment choice remains difficult and renders perspectives of AYAs on decision-making and psychological outcomes afterwards. This review examines the impact of (in)fertility on psychological well-being both during cancer treatment, and in the long term. A systematic review of the peer-reviewed literature was conducted by searching Pubmed, Web of Science, Cochrane Trial database and PsycINFO on 30 November 2023. The review included studies with a focus on gynecological cancer, fertility and pregnancy related psychological outcomes, QoL, and psychosocial factors influencing decision-making. Case reports and reviews were excluded. Quality was assessed with the Mixed Methods Appraisal Tool (MMAT). 15 studies, published between 2005 and 2023, involving 1328 participants, were included. Key findings highlight the significance of informing all AYAs about cancer treatment effects on fertility and discussing fertility preservation options. Feeling time-pressured and conflicted between choosing the best oncological outcomes and preserving fertility were common. Factors such as younger age at diagnosis, time pressure, and inadequate counseling by healthcare workers increased reproductive concerns which contributed to long term psychological distress. Research on AYAs with gynecological cancer without fertility preservation possibilities is limited and should be prioritized. This review shows that both Shared Decision-Making (SDM) and follow-up processes can be improved by addressing fertility-related questions and concerns, therefore increasing long-term QoL. This review is registered in PROSPERO (ID 448119).