Background: An exclusive human milk (EHM) diet has numerous benefits. Formula supplementation may be recommended for former preterm infants at the time of neonatal intensive care unit (NICU) discharge to meet perceived metabolic demands and caloric goals. Recommendations addressing postdischarge nutrition for very preterm infants (VPTIs) are controversial, as the benefits of human milk supplementation regarding long-term growth, neurodevelopment, and chronic conditions are mixed. Objective: To compare growth and neurodevelopment of former VPTI fed an EHM diet to a supplemented/formula diet at NICU discharge. Materials and Methods: A retrospective cohort study of VPTI was followed at the Regional Neonatal Follow-up Program. Patients were categorized by diet at NICU discharge: EHM diet; mixed diet (EHM and formula); and exclusive formula diet. Growth percentile ranks at the first neonatal follow-up visit and 3 years of age were compared by diet type at NICU discharge. Neurodevelopmental outcomes as measured by the Bayley Scales of Infant Development 3rd Edition at 3 years of age were also compared. Results: Among 835 VPTIs, weight percentiles at the first neonatal follow-up visit were similar between the three NICU discharge diet types. One hundred fifty-eight subjects received neurodevelopmental evaluations at 3 years of age; anthropometrics and neurodevelopment were similar irrespective of diet at NICU discharge. Conclusion: An EHM diet at NICU discharge is appropriate to support growth in infancy as well as growth and neurodevelopment through 3 years of age. Thus, this raises the question of whether routine nutritional supplementation is necessary for VPTIs at NICU discharge.