Although there has been much interest in the performance of short patrolmen and those of normal height (White & Bloch, 1975), there appear to be few differences. The present study was designed to explore the opinions of supervisors about short patrolmen. A 20-item questionnaire was completed anonymously by 29 supervisors whose mean age was 40.3 yr. (SD = 5.7), mean years of supervising 8.1 (SD = 4.9) on their opinions about short police officers. They were from four small departments (with 20 to 25 police officers each). Their mean height was 71.7 in.; 17 were average (68 to 72 in.); 11 were tall (more than 72 In ); and one was short (less than 68 in). Of these supervisors, 62% felt that short patrolmen receive more complaints from citizens, 62% believed that they cause more frequent disciplinary problems, 59% believed that they issue more vehicle summonses and arrests, 55% believed that they cause poor morale, 52% believed that they initiate most of the internal department complaints, and 38% believed that they are involved in more accidents than the average or tall patrolman. Tall patrolmen were believed to be least often disciplinary problems by 55% of the supervisors, and to take the most sick time (by 45% ). Patrolmen of average height were believed to receive letters of commendation more (by 93%), to give more warnings for motor vehicle violations (by 86%), to get along better with their co-workers (by 86%), to receive more job-related injuries (by 79%), and more often to be chosen as the patrolman most preferred to help a member of the supervisor's family (by 76%). Opinions about short patrolmen were not, on the whole, related to the supervisor's age, years of police work, rank, or weight. However, taller supervisors more often viewed short patrolmen as sources of poor morale, as sources of internal complaints, and as involved in more accidents. Supervisors with more years of supervising less often saw short patrolmen as making more arrests or tall patrolmen as taking more sick time. The opinions about short police officers varied also between the four departments studied. In summary, these supervisors tended to see short patrolmen as more aggressive law enforcers and as more likely to be sources of discontent in the police department. Further research is needed to discover whether these perceptions are correct.
Read full abstract