TAK-875 (compound 1) was the only GPR40 agonist with promising oral glucose-lowering effect, which entered phase III clinical trials. In previous studies, we successfully synthesized the TAK-875 sulfoxide analog 2, which was further separated to optically pure compounds 3 (S, S, 100.0% de) and 4 (R, S, 100.0% de). In vitro biological evaluation revealed that the sulfoxide analogs 3 and 4 possessed comparable GPR40 agonist activity to TAK-875. Herein, in order to further evaluate the druglikeness of TAK-875 sulfoxide analogs, the pharmacokinetic properties of compounds 2, 3, and 4 in rats were investigated and compared with that of TAK-875. The results showed that sulfoxide (2, 3, and 4) and sulfone (TAK-875) could be converted into each other in different degrees in vivo. Interestingly, compound 3 showed higher drug exposure calculated by the AUC sum of sulfoxide and sulfone in plasma than TAK-875, 2 and 4. In order to further investigate the in vivo glucose-lowering potency of sulfoxide analogs, asymmetric synthesis was carried out and led to two sulfoxides with moderate de values, 5 (S, S, 66.4% de) and 6 (R, S, 71.0% de). The following oral glucose tolerance test (OGTT) in rats showed that 5 (S, S, 66.4% de) had stronger glucose-lowering effect in vivo than 6 (R, S, 71.0% de) and TAK-875, which could be partly rationalized by the superior pharmacokinetic property of sulfoxide 3 (the main component of 5) relative to sulfoxide 4 (the main component of 6) and TAK-875.