Study Of Trophic Interactions Research Articles

What determines demographic growth in green anacondas? Strong interactions among vertebrates in a neotropical ecosystem

IntroductionTrophic cascades can produce important effects on a community where some species may have strong effects on other parts of the community up, down the food chain, or both. Top predators are often controlled from the bottom-up by the abundance of their prey base while prey animals are often controlled from the top-down. Studies of trophic interactions in the tropics suggest that the trophic chains are longer because of the high productivity; and because of the high diversity there is abundant intraguild redundancy which results in weak interactions.MethodsWe studied the effect of bottom-up forces affecting the population of green Anaconda (Eunectes murinus) in the Venezuelan llanos; looking at net primary productivity, precipitation, and the abundance of an important prey item, Capybara (Hydrochaeris hydrochaeris).ResultsOur data show a strong interaction of these variables on the percentage of Anacondas that reproduce in a given year (here forth breeding ratio). In particular Capybara abundance has a strong effect. Capybara abundance itself is also under strong bottom-up influence determined by precipitation and Net Primary Productivity.DiscussionThese strong interactions are not what is expected from a tropical ecosystem. We also found an unexpected strong influence of precipitation and primary productivity on Anaconda breeding ratio not related to the abundance of Capybara, likely affecting abundance of other prey or affecting non-trophic variables. This later evidence supports the notion that there is redundancy in tropical food chains and, strong as the effect of Capybara abundance might be, Anacondas do not entirely rely on them.

Disentangling arthropod and plant resources consumed by Orius spp. in peach and alfalfa crops by metagenomic analysis

Agricultural intensification is affecting the biological control of insect pests, an important component for sustainable crop production. To understand the changing patterns of insect abundance within an agroecosystem, it is necessary to disentangle the trophic interactions between species, and metabarcoding is an excellent alternative to show them. In the Ebro Basin (NE Iberian Peninsula), agricultural landscapes are composed of a mosaic of crops scattered with natural and semi-natural habitats, where the presence of Orius spp., used as biocontrol agents, is well known. To shed light on their predatory role in this area, a previously developed metabarcoding multi-primer method has been used to study the arthropod and plant most frequently resources consumed by some field-collected Orius, sampled at different dates in a peach and an alfalfa adjacent crop. Their high-throughput sequencing (HTS) analysis showed the consumption of 15 arthropod and 12 plant taxa. Eight of them were consumed by O. laevigatus, six by O. majusculus and 23 by O. niger. The obtained results showed that HTS is a powerful tool in studies of trophic interactions in agroecosystems. Among the detected arthropods, other natural enemies were present, showing a certain degree of intraguild predation, which has been demonstrated by developing a new added strategy in the bioinformatic analysis. Detected plant consumption indicates that Orius forages on several plant species, showing their movement from them to the sampled crops. These plants could have a potential role in attracting or maintaining these predators in both crops in biological control strategies.

Use of plants by Myzus persicae in agroecosystems: Potential applications in conservation biological control

AbstractMyzus persicae (Sulzer) is a highly polyphagous aphid species that attacks several economically important crop plants. Here, trophic webs involving M. persicae, its host plants and its parasitoids were described and quantified in wheat, oat and alfalfa agroecosystems from central Argentina, with special emphasis on the sub‐habitats where interactions occur: crops and adjacent field margins. Three fields cultivated with each crop species and their margins were sampled during three years; aphid abundance and mummification percentage were compared among crop plants and the diverse natural vegetation in the borders. Interactions were described using a quantitative food web approach, and abundance and mummification percentage e data were analysed using a generalized linear model. Four plant species present in the borders (Capsella bursa‐pastori, Rapistrum sp., Melilotus sp. and Trifolium repens) hosted M. persicae and its parasitoids. The alfalfa agroecosystem produced a significantly higher number of aphids than oat and wheat; however, in all cases, crops and borders sustained similar aphid abundance. A total of six Aphidiinae species attacked M. persicae, with no significant differences in the richness of parasitoid species between the borders and the crops, but with significant differences in parasitoid abundance, being higher in the crops. Mummification percentage were higher in crops than in the borders, with Lysiphlebus testaceipes, Aphidius colemani and A. ervi being the most abundant species. Almost 70% of M. persicae individuals were collected from fields borders, which highlights the importance of including these sites in studies of trophic interactions in crop fields.

Effects of mammal exclusion on invertebrate communities in New Zealand

AbstractIn the absence of mammals, the fauna of islands is characterised by high endemism levels and a tendency towards gigantism, flightlessness and longevity. These characteristics have resulted in a high vulnerability to introduced animals, either directly via predation or indirectly through an alteration of food web interactions. Because invertebrates are important components of food webs and essential for many ecosystem processes, we investigated how different mammal and bird communities, present inside and outside a fenced reserve, influenced ground‐dwelling invertebrates on the mainland of New Zealand. Some significant differences in invertebrate community composition were apparent inside versus outside the fenced reserve, predominantly Ctenognathus adamsi (Carabidae) being twenty times more abundant inside the reserve, and rove beetles (Staphylinidae) being eight times more abundant outside the reserve. The introduced blackbird (Turdus merula) was observed more regularly than other predators of invertebrates outside the reserve, while native robins (Petroica longipes) were more highly detected inside the reserve. Despite differences in the vertebrate insectivore community outside the reserve (multiple mammals and introduced birds) compared to inside (mainly native birds), the resulting similarity in net predation pressure may explain the apparent similarity in abundance for most of the other 24 invertebrate taxa examined. Removal of most mammals from within fenced reserves in New Zealand may enable introduced and native birds to flourish, with flow‐on effects on the invertebrate community. We conclude that further study of trophic interactions and additional intervention, may need to be considered if invertebrate conservation is a desired outcome from fenced reserves.

Decrypting stable‐isotope (δ13C and δ15N) variability in aquatic plants

Abstract Variability in C and N stable isotopes has been acknowledged to hinder their use as tracers of food sources in the study of trophic interactions in ecosystems. This is particularly so whenever benthic primary production is substantial (variability in δ13C) and the ecosystem under study is affected by human impacts (variability in δ15N) in aquatic ecosystems. In this study, we aim to better understand the large and often unexplained variability in the natural abundance of δ13C and δ15N signatures of aquatic plants by analyzing the isotopic composition of plants from 81 lentic systems from NE Spain in relation to extrinsic (alkalinity, pH, nutrient concentrations, water body typology and basin land use) and intrinsic (functional group, carbon assimilation metabolism, elemental composition) predictors. We have encountered significant plasticity in isotopic signatures of aquatic plants associated with the variation in local conditions at the regional scale. The δ13C signature varied from −43.1‰ to −7.5‰ (35.7‰ range) and drivers were both intrinsic and extrinsic. The functional group was the most important factor as it is influenced by different carbon sources. Aquatic plants with leaves in contact with the atmosphere (helophytes, free floating and floating attached; −34.8‰ to −14.6‰) responded in a similar way as terrestrial plants. This contrasted with the enriched mean values of rooted submerged plants (−16.7‰ to −10.5‰) that were more enriched than the described terrestrial C3 range (−34‰ to −22‰) and completely overlapped the terrestrial C4 range (−20‰ to −8‰). Concentration of DIC and pH also emerged as important extrinsic factors driving δ13C variability. The δ15N signature ranged from −5.2‰ to 20.1‰ (25.2‰ range) and the variability was mostly associated with extrinsic factors such as water body type and basin land use, as they influence both the δ15N signature and concentration of the dissolved inorganic nitrogen in the aquatic ecosystems. Only one multifactorial model including the functional group (with the largest contribution), DIC and pH was selected as the best model explaining the variability in δ13C signatures of aquatic plants. The final model had a relatively large explained deviance and was consistent with the previous unifactorial results. Two different models were selected as the best models explaining variability in δ15N signatures of aquatic plants. The models included the geomorphological type of water body as the variable with the largest contribution, and the percentage of either natural or agricultural coverage in the basin. These results are summarized in a conceptual model showing the predictors and their range and direction of variation. This study shows that extrinsic factors are of greater importance in influencing the stable‐isotope signatures of aquatic plants compared to terrestrial plants, because of varied sources and an often limited isotopic discrimination.

Herbivore effect traits and their impact on plant community biomass: an experimental test using grasshoppers

Summary Using trait‐based approaches to study trophic interactions may represent one of the most promising approaches to evaluate the impact of trophic interactions on ecosystem functioning. To achieve this goal, it is necessary to clearly identify which traits determine the impact of one trophic level on another. Using functionally contrasting grasshopper species, we tested the ability of multiple traits (morphological, chemical and biomechanical) to predict herbivore impact on the biomass of a diverse plant community. We set‐up a cage experiment in an old species rich grassland field and evaluated how multiple candidate grasshopper effect traits mediated herbivore impact on plant biomass. Grasshoppers had different impact on plant community biomass (consuming up to 60% of plant community biomass). Grasshopper impact was positively correlated with their incisive strength while body size or grasshopper C:N ratio exhibited low predictive ability. Importantly, the strong relationship between the incisive strength and the impact was mediated by the grasshopper feeding niche, which was well predicted in our study by two simple plant traits (leaf dry matter content, leaf C:N ratio). Feeding niche differences between grasshoppers were explained by differences in incisive strength, highlighting the fundamental linkage between grasshopper effect traits and their niche. Our study contributes to the development of the trait‐based approach in the study of trophic interactions by providing a first experimental test of the relationship between herbivore effect traits, their impact on plant community biomass, and in a larger extent on ecosystem functioning. By comparing the relative importance of multiple interacting grasshopper traits, our study showed that incisive strength was a key effect trait which determined grasshopper feeding niche and its relative impact on plant community biomass.

Ecologically based definition of seasons clarifies predator–prey interactions

Species interactions within food webs are driven by multiple constraints, including those imposed by seasonal changes in the environment. Ecologically sound definitions of seasons may therefore be a prerequisite for clarifying predator prey interactions. Most studies define biological seasons based on fixed schedules or on temporal changes in a single movement measurement. We used a novel clustering approach based on homogeneous space‐use patterns of GPS‐collared animals to reveal 7 biological seasons for caribouRangifer tarandus caribou, and 5 for both mooseAlces alcesand grey wolvesCanis lupusinteracting in a boreal ecosystem. Subsequent evaluation of niche overlap showed that, as predicted, wolves had a stronger spatio‐temporal connection with moose, its main prey, than with caribou. Movement constraints and limiting resource distributions similarly affected all species in some instances, but also caused temporal changes in the extent of niche overlap between wolves and its two prey. The risk that caribou faced was not only linked to the niche overlap with wolves, but also to the extent of wolf‐moose niche overlap during the same period. Food‐web properties emerged from the analysis, with temporal changes in relative niche overlap reflecting the strength of trophic interactions during the year. Our study demonstrates how the study of trophic interactions can benefit from comprehensive definitions of biological seasons.

Algal populations controlled by fish herbivory across a wave exposure gradient on southern temperate shores

Consumers that forage across habitats can affect communities by altering the abundance and distribution of key species. In marine communities, studies of trophic interactions have generally focused on the effects of herbivorous and predatory invertebrates on benthic algae and mussel populations. However, large mobile consumers that move across habitats, such as fishes, can strongly affect community dynamics through consumption of habitat-dominating species, but their effects often vary over environmental gradients. On temperate rocky shores, herbivorous fishes are generally a small part of the fish fauna compared to the tropics, and there is sparse evidence that they play a major direct role in algal community dynamics, particularly of large brown algae that dominate many reefs. In New Zealand, however, a wide-ranging herbivorous fish, Odax pullus, feeds exclusively on macroalgae, including Durvillaea antarctica, a large low-intertidal fucoid reaching 10 m in length and 70 kg in mass. In four experiments we tested the extent of fish herbivory and how it was affected by algal canopy structure across a gradient of wave exposure at multiple sites. Exclusion experiments showed that fish impacts greatly reduced the cover and biomass of Durvillaea and that these effects decreased with increasing wave stress and algal canopy cover, effectively restricting the alga to exposed conditions. Almost all plants were entirely removed by fish where there was a sparse algal canopy in sheltered and semi-exposed sites, but there was significantly less grazing in exposed sites. Recruit Durvillaea beneath canopies were less affected by fish grazing, but they grew slowly. Successful natural recruitment, therefore, occurred almost exclusively on exposed shores outside canopies where many plants escaped severe grazing, and growth to maturity was far greater than elsewhere. Such large and direct impacts on the local and regional distribution of large brown algal populations by mobile vertebrate consumers are rare and were mediated by an environmental gradient and plant density, both of which interact with algal demographics. The study highlights that, even though herbivorous fish diversity may be low, the impacts of particular species may still be high, even in cool temperate waters where fish herbivory is usually considered to be minimal.

Evaluation of DNA extraction and handling procedures for PCR-based copepod feeding studies

Molecular methods are becoming increasingly common for taxonomic and ecological studies of marine and freshwater plankton. Recently, nucleic acids have been used as target molecules for identification and quantification of prey species in studies of trophic interactions. A critical step in the quantification of mesozooplankton feeding by molecular analysis is the isolation of microalgal DNA from predator guts and in the food environment. It is essential that total genomic DNA extraction provides maximum quantitative yield suitable for downstream analysis. In this study, we compared the efficacy and experimental variability of eight different protocols for total genomic DNA extraction from free-living microalgae and microalgae within the gut of copepods. We also developed and evaluated different sampling procedures for copepods prior to genomic extraction. The optimal protocol was evaluated using real time quantitative polymerase chain reaction (qPCR) and the integrity of the genomic DNA was determined by amplifying PCR targets of increasing size. Considerable variability was observed between purification protocols. Qiagen DNeasy® Blood & Tissue kit was the most efficient of the tested methods for genomic extraction from both free-living microalgae and microalgae inside copepod guts. Furthermore, the appropriate handling of predator copepods prior to genomic extraction was essential for quantitative gut content estimates.

Identification of trophic interactions between Macrolophus caliginosus (Heteroptera: Miridae) and Myzus persicae (Homoptera: Aphididae) using real time PCR

Understanding food web interactions in native or agricultural ecosystems is an important step towards establishing sustainable pest management strategies. While the role of generalist predators as biological control agents is increasingly appreciated, the study of trophic interactions between individual predator species and their prey provides practical difficulties. Recently, different approaches have been suggested to determine prey items from predator guts using molecular methods. Macrolophus caliginosus is a generalist predator active in herbaceous agro-ecosystems. We developed a system to identify the DNA of its prey after ingestion, using Myzus persicae as a model. Esterase (MpEST) and cytochrome oxidase I (MpCOI) genes were targeted in the aphid, while M. caliginosus COI gene was used as control for predator DNA. Real time PCR proved to be specific and sensitive enough to detect prey DNA upon ingestion after feeding experiments. The system provided a linear amplification response with only 10 fg of prey genomic DNA as template. The detection system of MpCOI gene was more sensitive than MpEST, while the detection period was similar for both genes. Possibilities for using the system in ecological and biosafety studies with regard to sustainable pest management are discussed.

TRAMPLING, PEELING AND NIBBLING MUSSELS: AN EXPERIMENTAL ASSESSMENT OF MECHANICAL AND PREDATORY DAMAGE TO SHELLS OF MYTILUS TROSSULUS (MOLLUSCA: MYTILIDAE)

Shell damage, if properly recognized, can provide information about biotic interactions between molluscs and their predators. However, it can be difficult to distinguish predatory damage from mechanical breakage, thus making interpretation of damaged modern and fossil shells problematic. To establish a clear-cut distinction between antemortem predatory crab damage and ante- and postmortem mechanical damage in Mytilus trossulus shells, a combined field and experimental approach was used. Mussels were exposed to predation by crabs, tumbled-live, tumbled-dead, and trampled. After 100 h of tumbling, live-collected mussel shells were abraded and disarticulated but not otherwise damaged. Eight percent of the dead-collected shells were broken during tumbling. There was a proportional (length, width, and thickness) size reduction in both tumbled-live and tumbled-dead shells after 100 h. Breakage caused by crab predation under laboratory conditions was ;19% of the prey offered. Three types of diagnostic damage were inflicted by crab predation: nibbles, nibbles and chips, and peels. Trampling and tumbling yielded three diagnostic breakage patterns: crescentic chips, angular chips, and slivered chips. Crushed shells and shells with fractured margins were caused by predation and trampling. Only twenty percent of the trampled-shells could be mistaken for preyed-upon shells. Only twenty-seven percent of the preyed-on shells could be mistaken for mechanically- damaged shells. Overall, the source of damage could be correctly identified in 74% of the shells. Proper identification of crab predation in dead shells of this commercially important resource may prove valuable in studies of trophic interactions in modern environments. Inferring levels of crab predation, based on damage in fossil specimens, can be reliable if such analyses are calibrated by experimental studies of living representatives or analogs.

Presence of Lythrum salicaria enhances the bodyguard effects of the parasitoid Asecodes mento for Filipendula ulmaria

This paper reports significant effects of a co‐occurring plant species (Lythrum salicaria, Lythraceae) on the reproductive success of the perennial herb Filipendula ulmaria (Rosaceae). We studied 15 Filipendula populations in the Skeppsvik Archipelago; seven of which were monospecific and eight mixed with Lythrum. All the Filipendula populations studied harbored the chrysomelid beetle Galerucella tenella, and in 2005 seed set was strongly negatively correlated with the percentage leaf area consumed. Moreover, data from 2004 showed that 25–100% of the G. tenella larvae were parasitized by the hymenopteran parasitoid Asecodes mento, and we found a strong cascading top‐down effect of parasitism in 2004 on Filipendula seed set in 2005. In 2004, parasitism (at the population level) was negatively correlated with percentage leaf area consumed and positively correlated with seed set in 2005. The parasitoid Asecodes also parasitized G. calmariensis, which is monophagous on Lythrum. Mixed populations of Filipendula and Lythrum supported higher densities of their shared ‘bodyguard’Asecodes. Further, Y‐tube bioassays showed that floriferous Filipendula attracted more than twice as many gravid Asecodes females as floriferous Lythrum. Taken together, these findings suggest that coexistence of the two plants results in ‘associational resistance’ for Filipendula and ‘associational susceptibility’ for Lythrum. This scenario was supported for Filipendula since, for this species, we found lower leaf consumption followed by higher seed production in mixed than in monospecific populations. Considered together, our results show that bodyguards may increase the reproductive fitness of a perennial herb, and that the strength of the cascading ‘bodyguard’ effect can be strongly influenced by co‐occurring plants through ‘apparent competition’. This is the first paper to demonstrate that, in the wild, plant species may use odors to compete for ‘bodyguards’, thereby causing asymmetrical ‘apparent competition’ between the herbivores involved. Our data emphasize the need to consider community factors in studies of trophic interactions.

Secondary Metabolites as Mediators of Trophic Interactions Among Antarctic Marine Organisms

Secondary metabolites are widespread among lower phyla and understanding their functional role(s) in the producing organism has been under study in recent decades. Considerable progress has been made in understanding chemical ecological interactions among terrestrial organisms, and similar research in the marine realm has been initiated in recent years. Polar regions are more difficult to access and thus progress has been slower. Nevertheless, the extreme and often unique marine environments surrounding Antarctica as well as the many unusual trophic interactions in antarctic marine communities might well be expected to select for novel secondary metabolites and/or novel functional roles for secondary metabolites. Indeed, recent studies have documented novel, chemically-mediated interactions between molluscs and amphipods, between algae, urchins and anemones, and between sponges and their predators. The Porifera are the dominant phylum on the McMurdo Sound benthos, and representatives of this phylum have been shown to elaborate sea star feeding deterrents, inhibitors of fouling or infectious organisms, and metabolites which mediate predation via molt inhibition. As a result of studies on Antarctic sponges, new insights into functional roles of pigments and the ability of sponges to sequester metabolites have been gained, and a new mechanism of chemical defense has been described. Herein we describe recent results of our studies of trophic interactions between sponges and their predators that are mediated by specific sponge secondary metabolites. Moreover, we highlight unusual chemically-mediated interactions in antarctic marine invertebrates other than sponges.

Top‐Down Cascade from a Bitrophic Predator in an Old‐Field Community

We tested the hypothesis that a bitrophic (third and fourth level) arthropod predator can exert a cascading, top—down influence on other arthropods and plants in an early successional old field. First—stadium mantids, Tenodera sinensis, were added to replicated open—field plots in numbers corresponding to naturally occurring egg hatch density and allowed to remain for $\approx 2$ mo. Sticky—trap dispersal barriers around both control and mantid—addition plots allowed us to monitor emigration of arthropods continuously during the experiment. Biomass of herbivores, carnivores, and plants, and abundances of arthropod taxa within plots were determined at the beginning, middle, and end of the experiment. The impact of mantids on the community was a top—down trophic cascade, beginning at the fourth trophic level and evident at each of the lower three levels. Mantids induced marked behavioral responses in other predators, but inteference among predators did not prevent the trophic cascade. The most common predators, cursorial spiders, emigrated from mantid addition plots in significantly greater numbers than from controls. This behavioral response may have resulted from avoidance of predation or competition. Mantids decreased biomass of herbivorous arthropods through predation, and this decrease in turn increased biomass of plants. Therefore, these generalist predators were able to decrease herbivory enough to affect plant growth. This and other recent studies indicate that top—down effects can be important in structuring terrestrial communities. Ours is the first example of a top—down cascade by a generalist arthropod predator in a nonagricultural ecosystem and illustrates the importance of detecting behavioral responses in studies of trophic interactions.

Neurite complexes with Merkel cells in larval tentacles of Xenopus laevis

Electron microscopy of larval tentacles of Xenopus laevis tadpoles revealed that they are richly innervated structures containing a high concentration of neurite complexes with epidermal Merkel cells. Myelinated sensory nerve fibres supplying each tentacle are abundant. Prior to penetrating the epidermis, they gradually shed their myelin sheaths and Schwann-cell coverings, and subsequently end as naked axon terminals within the epidermis. Many of these intra-epidermal neurites terminate in intimate synaptic contact with granulated Merkel cells. Groups of dense-cored vesicles characterize the Merkel cell, while clusters of clear synaptic vesicles occupy the adjacent sensory nerve terminals. At sites of synaptic contact, the two cells often exhibit an increased thickening of their apposing membranes. Such Merkel cell — sensory neurite complexes occur as isolated units and are profusely scattered throughout the extent of each tentacle. Their ultrastructure is, in most respects, similar to that described previously in specialized regions of other vertebrate and amphibian species. It is suggested that they represent the morphological basis for tactile sensitivity and impart a mechanoreceptive function to the larval tentacle prior to metamorphosis. The larval tentacle in this anuran species may represent a new and convenient research model for future developmental and experimental studies of trophic interactions between sensory nerve fibres and Merkel cells.