Structural Analysis Of Protein Complexes Research Articles

Structural Analysis of Protein Complexes by Cryo-Electron Microscopy.

Structural studies of bio-complexes using single particle cryo-Electron Microscopy (cryo-EM) is nowadays a well-established technique in structural biology and has become competitive with X-ray crystallography. Development of digital registration systems for electron microscopy images and algorithms for the fast and efficient processing of the recorded images and their following analysis has facilitated the determination of structures at near-atomic resolution. The latest advances in EM have enabled the determination of protein complex structures at 1.4-3Å resolution for an extremely broad range of sizes (from ~100kDa up to hundreds of MDa (Bartesaghi et al., Science 348(6239):1147-1151, 2015; Herzik et al., Nat Commun 10:1032, 2019; Wu et al., J Struct Biol X 4:100020, 2020; Zhang et al., Nat Commun 10:5511, 2019; Zhang et al., Cell Res 30(12):1136-1139, 2020; Yip et al., Nature 587(7832):157-161, 2020; https://www.ebi.ac.uk/emdb/statistics/emdb_resolution_year )). In 2022, nearly 1200 structures deposited to the EMDB database were at a resolution of better than 3Å ( https://www.ebi.ac.uk/emdb/statistics/emdb_resolution_year ).To date, the highest resolutions have been achieved for apoferritin, which comprises a homo-oligomer of high point group symmetry (O432) and has rigid organization together with high stability (Zhang et al., Cell Res 30(12):1136-1139, 2020; Yip et al., Nature 587(7832):157-161, 2020). It has been used as a test object for the assessments of modern cryo-microscopes and processing methods during the last 5 years. In contrast to apoferritin bacterial secretion systems are typical examples of multi protein complexes exhibiting high flexibility owing to their functions relating to the transportation of small molecules, proteins, and DNA into the extracellular space or target cells. This makes their structural characterization extremely challenging (Barlow, Methods Mol Biol 532:397-411, 2009; Costa et al., Nat Rev Microbiol 13:343-359, 2015). The most feasible approach to reveal their spatial organization and functional modification is cryo-electron microscopy (EM). During the last decade, structural cryo-EM has become broadly used for the analysis of the bio-complexes that comprise multiple components and are not amenable to crystallization (Lyumkis, J Biol Chem 294:5181-5197, 2019; Orlova and Saibil, Methods Enzymol 482:321-341, 2010; Orlova and Saibil, Chem Rev 111(12):7710-7748, 2011).In this review, we will describe the basics of sample preparation for cryo-EM, the principles of digital data collection, and the logistics of image analysis focusing on the common steps required for reconstructions of both small and large biological complexes together with refinement of their structures to nearly atomic resolution. The workflow of processing will be illustrated by examples of EM analysis of Type IV Secretion System.

Improved Cross-Linking Coverage for Protein Complexes Containing Low Levels of Lysine by Using an Enrichable Photo-Cross-Linker.

Chemical cross-linking coupled with mass spectrometry (XL-MS) is an important technique for the structural analysis of protein complexes where the coverage of amino acids and the identification of cross-linked sites are crucial. Photo-cross-linking has multisite reactivity and is valuable for the structural analysis of chemical cross-linking. However, a high degree of heterogeneity results from this multisite reactivity, which results in samples with higher complexity and lower abundance. Additionally, the applicability of photo-cross-linking is limited to purified protein complexes. In this work, we demonstrate a photo-cross-linker, alkynyl-succinimidyl-diazirine (ASD) with the reactive groups of N-hydroxysuccinimide ester and diazirine, as well as the click-enrichable alkyne group. Photo-cross-linkers can provide higher site reactivity for proteins that contain only a small number of lysine residues, thereby complementing the more commonly used lysine-targeting cross-linkers. By systematically analyzing proteins with differing lysine contents and differing flexibilities, we demonstrated clear enhancement in structure elucidation for proteins containing less lysine and with high flexibility. In addition, enrichment approaches of alkynyl-azide click chemistry conjugated with biotin-streptavidin purification (coinciding with parallel orthogonal digestion) improved the identification coverage of cross-links. We show that this photo-cross-linking approach can be used for membrane proteome-wide complex analysis. This method led to the identification of a total of 14066 lysine-X cross-linked site pairs from a total of 2784 proteins. Thus, this cross-linker is a valuable addition to a photo-cross-linking toolkit and improves the identification coverage of XL-MS in functional structure analysis.

Below 3\xa0\xc5 structure of apoferritin using a multipurpose TEM with a side entry cryoholder

Recently, the structural analysis of protein complexes by cryo-electron microscopy (cryo-EM) single particle analysis (SPA) has had great impact as a biophysical method. Many results of cryo-EM SPA are based on data acquired on state-of-the-art cryo-electron microscopes customized for SPA. These are currently only available in limited locations around the world, where securing machine time is highly competitive. One potential solution for this time-competitive situation is to reuse existing multi-purpose equipment, although this comes with performance limitations. Here, a multi-purpose TEM with a side entry cryo-holder was used to evaluate the potential of high-resolution SPA, resulting in a 3 Å resolution map of apoferritin with local resolution extending to 2.6 Å. This map clearly showed two positions of an aromatic side chain. Further, examination of optimal imaging conditions depending on two different multi-purpose electron microscope and camera combinations was carried out, demonstrating that higher magnifications are not always necessary or desirable. Since automation is effectively a requirement for large-scale data collection, and augmenting the multi-purpose equipment is possible, we expanded testing by acquiring data with SerialEM using a β-galactosidase test sample. This study demonstrates the possibilities of more widely available and established electron microscopes, and their applications for cryo-EM SPA.

Surface-Induced Dissociation of Protein Complexes Selected by Trapped Ion Mobility Spectrometry.

Native mass spectrometry (nMS), particularly in conjunction with gas-phase ion mobility spectrometry measurements, has proven useful as a structural biology tool for evaluating the stoichiometry, conformation, and topology of protein complexes. Here, we demonstrate the combination of trapped ion mobility spectrometry (TIMS) and surface-induced dissociation (SID) on a Bruker SolariX XR 15 T FT-ICR mass spectrometer for the structural analysis of protein complexes. We successfully performed SID on mobility-selected protein complexes, including the streptavidin tetramer and cholera toxin B with bound ligands. Additionally, TIMS-SID was employed on a mixture of the peptides desArg1 and desArg9 bradykinin to mobility-separate and identify the individual peptides. Importantly, results show that native-like conformations can be maintained throughout the TIMS analysis. The TIMS-SID spectra are analogous to SID spectra acquired using quadrupole mass selection, indicating little measurable, if any, structural rearrangement during mobility selection. Mobility parking was used on the ion or mobility of interest and 50-200 SID mass spectra were averaged. High-quality TIMS-SID spectra were acquired over a period of 2-10 min, comparable to or slightly longer than SID coupled with ion mobility on various instrument platforms in our laboratory. The ultrahigh resolving power of the 15 T FT-ICR allowed for the identification and relative quantification of overlapping SID fragments with the same nominal m/z based on isotope patterns, and it shows promise as a platform to probe small mass differences, such as protein/ligand binding or post-translational modifications. These results represent the potential of TIMS-SID-MS for the analysis of both protein complexes and peptides.

Chemical Cross-Linking and Mass Spectrometric Analysis of the Endogenous Yeast Exosome Complexes.

Chemical cross-linking and mass spectrometric readout (CX-MS) has become a useful toolkit for structural analysis of protein complexes. CX-MS enables rapid detection of a larger number of cross-link peptides from the chemically cross-linked protein assembly, providing invaluable cross-link spatial restraints to understand the architecture of the complex. Since CX-MS is complementary with other structural and computational modeling tools, it can be used for integrative structural determination of large native protein assemblies. However, due to technical limitations, current CX-MS applications have still been predominantly confined to complexes reconstituted from recombinant proteins where large amount of purified materials are available. Cross-linking and hybrid structural proteomic analysis of endogenous protein complexes remains a challenge. In this chapter, we present a protocol that efficiently couples affinity capture of endogenous complexes with sensitive CX-MS analysis, with particular application to the yeast RNA processing exosome complexes.

Miniaturized Sample Preparation for Transmission Electron Microscopy

Due to recent technological progress, cryo-electron microscopy (cryo-EM) is rapidly becoming a standard method for the structural analysis of protein complexes to atomic resolution. However, protein isolation techniques and sample preparation methods for EM remain a bottleneck. A relatively small number (100,000 to a few million) of individual protein particles need to be imaged for the high-resolution analysis of proteins by the single particle EM approach, making miniaturized sample handling techniques and microfluidic principles feasible. A miniaturized, paper-blotting-free EM grid preparation method for sample pre-conditioning, EM grid priming and post processing that only consumes nanoliter-volumes of sample is presented. The method uses a dispensing system with sub-nanoliter precision to control liquid uptake and EM grid priming, a platform to control the grid temperature thereby determining the relative humidity above the EM grid, and a pick-and-plunge-mechanism for sample vitrification. For cryo-EM, an EM grid is placed on the temperature-controlled stage and the sample is aspirated into a capillary. The capillary tip is positioned in proximity to the grid surface, the grid is loaded with the sample and excess is re-aspirated into the microcapillary. Subsequently, the sample film is stabilized and slightly thinned by controlled water evaporation regulated by the offset of the platform temperature relative to the dew-point. At a given point the pick-and-plunge mechanism is triggered, rapidly transferring the primed EM grid into liquid ethane for sample vitrification. Alternatively, sample-conditioning methods are available to prepare nanoliter-sized sample volumes for negative stain (NS) EM. The methodologies greatly reduce sample consumption and avoid approaches potentially harmful to proteins, such as the filter paper blotting used in conventional methods. Furthermore, the minuscule amount of sample required allows novel experimental strategies, such as fast sample conditioning, combination with single-cell lysis for "visual proteomics," or "lossless" total sample preparation for quantitative analysis of complex samples.

Miniaturized Sample Preparation for Transmission Electron Microscopy.

Due to recent technological progress, cryo-electron microscopy (cryo-EM) is rapidly becoming a standard method for the structural analysis of protein complexes to atomic resolution. However, protein isolation techniques and sample preparation methods for EM remain a bottleneck. A relatively small number (100,000 to a few million) of individual protein particles need to be imaged for the high-resolution analysis of proteins by the single particle EM approach, making miniaturized sample handling techniques and microfluidic principles feasible.A miniaturized, paper-blotting-free EM grid preparation method for sample pre-conditioning, EM grid priming and post processing that only consumes nanoliter-volumes of sample is presented. The method uses a dispensing system with sub-nanoliter precision to control liquid uptake and EM grid priming, a platform to control the grid temperature thereby determining the relative humidity above the EM grid, and a pick-and-plunge-mechanism for sample vitrification. For cryo-EM, an EM grid is placed on the temperature-controlled stage and the sample is aspirated into a capillary. The capillary tip is positioned in proximity to the grid surface, the grid is loaded with the sample and excess is re-aspirated into the microcapillary. Subsequently, the sample film is stabilized and slightly thinned by controlled water evaporation regulated by the offset of the platform temperature relative to the dew-point. At a given point the pick-and-plunge mechanism is triggered, rapidly transferring the primed EM grid into liquid ethane for sample vitrification. Alternatively, sample-conditioning methods are available to prepare nanoliter-sized sample volumes for negative stain (NS) EM.The methodologies greatly reduce sample consumption and avoid approaches potentially harmful to proteins, such as the filter paper blotting used in conventional methods. Furthermore, the minuscule amount of sample required allows novel experimental strategies, such as fast sample conditioning, combination with single-cell lysis for "visual proteomics," or "lossless" total sample preparation for quantitative analysis of complex samples.

Analysis of nano-crystals: Evaluation of heavy metal-embedded biological specimen by high voltage electron microscopy

Heavy metal compounds are adsorbed onto biological specimen in order to enhance the contrast as well as to preserve the structural features of the specimen against electron beam-induced radiation damage. In particular, in combination with computational image processing, negative staining is widely used for structural analysis of protein complexes to moderate resolutions. Image analysis of negatively stained biological specimen is known to suffer from limited achievable resolution due to dehydration and large grain size of staining molecules although the extent of such effect remains somewhat dubious.Stain molecules exist as grains under electron beam. However, clear observation of the crystalline nature of the grains and their association with biological specimen has not been thoroughly demonstrated. In this study, we attempted high-resolution TEM (HRTEM) using high voltage electron microscopy and electron crystallography analysis for the detailed characterization of negatively stained biological specimen, focusing on physical state and chemical composition of the stain molecules. The electron crystallography analysis allowed for the identification of the crystal constituents of widely used stains, hence revealing the chemical nature and the morphology of the stain molecules at specimen level. This study re-evaluated generally accepted notions on negative staining, and may help correctly interpreting the structural analysis of stained biological specimen.

Structural Analysis of Protein Complexes by Cross-Linking and Mass Spectrometry.

Cross-linking and mass spectrometry is used more and more for the structural analysis of large proteins and protein complexes. Although essentially a low-resolution method, it avoids the main drawbacks of established structural techniques. Particularly, it is largely insensitive to the inherent flexibility of the studied complexes and is applied under native conditions. It is also applicable to nearly every structural system. Therefore, cross-linking and mass spectrometry is the method of choice for elucidating the general architecture of protein complexes. Advances in instrumentation, techniques, and software now allow every lab that is working with proteins to apply the approach without much difficulty. The most specialized step in the workflow, the mass spectrometry measurement, can be done in most facilities that are performing standard proteomics. We detail here a step-by-step protocol of how to successfully apply the approach in collaboration with the mass spectrometry facility in your institution.

Structural Analysis of Protein Complexes by Cryo Electron Microscopy.

Structural studies of biocomplexes using single-particle cryo-electron microscopy (cryo-EM) is now a well-established technique in structural biology and has become competitive with X-ray crystallography. The latest advances in EM enable us to determine structures of protein complexes at 3-5 Å resolution for an extremely broad range of sizes from ~200 kDa up to hundreds of megadaltons (Bartesaghi et al., Science 348(6239):1147-1151, 2051; Bai et al., Nature 525(7568):212-217, 2015; Vinothkumar et al., Nature 515(7525):80-84, 2014; Grigorieff and Harrison, Curr Opin Struct Biol 21(2):265-273, 2011). The majority of biocomplexes comprise a number of different components and are not amenable to crystallisation. Secretion systems are typical examples of such multi-protein complexes, and structural studies of them are extremely challenging. The only feasible approach to revealing their spatial organisation and functional modification is cryo-EM. The development of systems for digital registration of images and algorithms for the fast and efficient processing of recorded images and subsequent analysis facilitated the determination of structures at near-atomic resolution. In this review we will describe sample preparation for cryo-EM, how data are collected by new detectors, and the logistics of image analysis through the basic steps required for reconstructions of both small and large biological complexes and their refinement to nearly atomic resolution. The processing workflow is illustrated using examples of EM analysis of a Type IV Secretion System.

Developing a Multiplexed Quantitative Cross-Linking Mass Spectrometry Platform for Comparative Structural Analysis of Protein Complexes.

Cross-linking mass spectrometry (XL-MS) represents a recently popularized hybrid methodology for defining protein-protein interactions (PPIs) and analyzing structures of large protein assemblies. In particular, XL-MS strategies have been demonstrated to be effective in elucidating molecular details of PPIs at the peptide resolution, providing a complementary set of structural data that can be utilized to refine existing complex structures or direct de novo modeling of unknown protein structures. To study structural and interaction dynamics of protein complexes, quantitative cross-linking mass spectrometry (QXL-MS) strategies based on isotope-labeled cross-linkers have been developed. Although successful, these approaches are mostly limited to pairwise comparisons. In order to establish a robust workflow enabling comparative analysis of multiple cross-linked samples simultaneously, we have developed a multiplexed QXL-MS strategy, namely, QMIX (Quantitation of Multiplexed, Isobaric-labeled cross (X)-linked peptides) by integrating MS-cleavable cross-linkers with isobaric labeling reagents. This study has established a new analytical platform for quantitative analysis of cross-linked peptides, which can be directly applied for multiplexed comparisons of the conformational dynamics of protein complexes and PPIs at the proteome scale in future studies.

Increasing the Depth of Mass-Spectrometry-Based Structural Analysis of Protein Complexes through the Use of Multiple Cross-Linkers.

Chemical cross-linking of proteins coupled with mass spectrometry (CXMS) is a powerful tool to study protein folding and to map the interfaces between interacting proteins. The most commonly used cross-linkers in CXMS are BS(3) and DSS, which have similar structures and generate the same linkages between pairs of lysine residues in spatial proximity. However, there are cases where no cross-linkable lysine pairs are present at certain regions of a protein or at the interface of two interacting proteins. In order to find the cross-linkers that can best complement the performance of BS(3) and DSS, we tested seven additional cross-linkers that either have different spacer arm structures or that target different amino acids (BS(2)G, EGS, AMAS, GMBS, Sulfo-GMBS, EDC, and TFCS). Using BSA, aldolase, the yeast H/ACA protein complex, and E. coli 70S ribosomes, we showed that, in terms of providing structural information not obtained through the use of BS(3) and DSS, EGS and Sulfo-GMBS worked better than the other cross-linkers that we tested. EGS generated a large number of cross-links not seen with the other amine-specific cross-linkers, possibly due to its hydrophilic spacer arm. We demonstrate that incorporating the cross-links contributed by the EGS and amine-sulfhydryl cross-linkers greatly increased the accuracy of Rosetta in docking the structure of the yeast H/ACA protein complex. Given the improved depth of useful information it can provide, we suggest that the multilinker CXMS approach should be used routinely when the amount of a sample permits.

XVis: a web server for the schematic visualization and interpretation of crosslink-derived spatial restraints.

The identification of crosslinks by mass spectrometry has recently been established as an integral part of the hybrid structural analysis of protein complexes and networks. The crosslinking analysis determines distance restraints between two covalently linked amino acids which are typically summarized in a table format that precludes the immediate and comprehensive interpretation of the topological data. xVis displays crosslinks in clear schematic representations in form of a circular, bar or network diagram. The interactive graphs indicate the linkage sites and identification scores, depict the spatial proximity of structurally and functionally annotated protein regions and the evolutionary conservation of amino acids and facilitate clustering of proteins into subcomplexes according to the crosslink density. Furthermore, xVis offers two options for the qualitative assessment of the crosslink identifications by filtering crosslinks according to identification scores or false discovery rates and by displaying the corresponding fragment ion spectrum of each crosslink for the manual validation of the mass spectrometric data. Our web server provides an easy-to-use tool for the fast topological and functional interpretation of distance information on protein complex architectures and for the evaluation of crosslink fragment ion spectra. xVis is available under a Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 4.0 International license at http://xvis.genzentrum.lmu.de/.

The dynamic duo: Combining NMR and small angle scattering in structural biology

Structural biology provides essential information for elucidating molecular mechanisms that underlie biological function. Advances in hardware, sample preparation, experimental methods, and computational approaches now enable structural analysis of protein complexes with increasing complexity that more closely represent biologically entities in the cellular environment. Integrated multidisciplinary approaches are required to overcome limitations of individual methods and take advantage of complementary aspects provided by different structural biology techniques. Although X-ray crystallography remains the method of choice for structural analysis of large complexes, crystallization of flexible systems is often difficult and does typically not provide insights into conformational dynamics present in solution. Nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy (NMR) is well-suited to study dynamics at picosecond to second time scales, and to map binding interfaces even of large systems at residue resolution but suffers from poor sensitivity with increasing molecular weight. Small angle scattering (SAS) methods provide low resolution information in solution and can characterize dynamics and conformational equilibria complementary to crystallography and NMR. The combination of NMR, crystallography, and SAS is, thus, very useful for analysis of the structure and conformational dynamics of (large) protein complexes in solution. In high molecular weight systems, where NMR data are often sparse, SAS provides additional structural information and can differentiate between NMR-derived models. Scattering data can also validate the solution conformation of a crystal structure and indicate the presence of conformational equilibria. Here, we review current state-of-the-art approaches for combining NMR, crystallography, and SAS data to characterize protein complexes in solution.

Breakthrough of cryo-TEM for high resolution structural analysis of protein complexes(The 52nd Annual Meeting of the Biophysical Society of Japan(BSJ2014))

Breakthrough of cryo-TEM for high resolution structural analysis of protein complexes(The 52nd Annual Meeting of the Biophysical Society of Japan(BSJ2014))

Strategies for the structural analysis of multi-protein complexes: Lessons from the 3D-Repertoire project

Structural studies of multi-protein complexes, whether by X-ray diffraction, scattering, NMR spectroscopy or electron microscopy, require stringent quality control of the component samples. The inability to produce 'keystone' subunits in a soluble and correctly folded form is a serious impediment to the reconstitution of the complexes. Co-expression of the components offers a valuable alternative to the expression of single proteins as a route to obtain sufficient amounts of the sample of interest. Even in cases where milligram-scale quantities of purified complex of interest become available, there is still no guarantee that good quality crystals can be obtained. At this step, protein engineering of one or more components of the complex is frequently required to improve solubility, yield or the ability to crystallize the sample. Subsequent characterization of these constructs may be performed by solution techniques such as Small Angle X-ray Scattering and Nuclear Magnetic Resonance to identify 'well behaved' complexes. Herein, we recount our experiences gained at protein production and complex assembly during the European 3D Repertoire project (3DR). The goal of this consortium was to obtain structural information on multi-protein complexes from yeast by combining crystallography, electron microscopy, NMR and in silico modeling methods. We present here representative set case studies of complexes that were produced and analyzed within the 3DR project. Our experience provides useful insight into strategies that are more generally applicable for structural analysis of protein complexes.

Structural Analysis of Large Protein Complexes Using Solvent Paramagnetic Relaxation Enhancements

The solvent helps out: Conventional protocols for structural analysis of protein complexes often fail if only sparse experimental data are available. NMR-spectroscopy-derived solvent paramagnetic relaxation enhancements (PREs) from a soluble spin label (picture) significantly improve the structural quality of a 150 kDa protein complex. This general protocol is an efficient approach for structural analysis of large protein complexes in solution.

Structural Analysis of Protein Complexes with Sodium Alkyl Sulfates by Small-Angle Scattering and Polyacrylamide Gel Electrophoresis

Small-angle X-ray (SAXS) and neutron (SANS) scattering is used to probe the structure of protein-surfactant complexes in solution and to correlate this information with their performance in gel electrophoresis. Proteins with sizes between 6.5 to 116 kDa are denatured with sodium alkyl sulfates (SC(x)S) of variable tail lengths. Several combinations of proteins and surfactants are analyzed to measure micelle radii, the distance between micelles, the extension of the complex, the radius of gyration, and the electrophoretic mobility. The structural characterization shows that most protein-surfactant complexes can be accurately described as pearl-necklace structures with spherical micelles. However, protein complexes with short surfactants (SC(8)S) bind with micelles that deviate significantly from spherical shape. Sodium decyl (SC(10)S) and dodecyl (SC(12)S, more commonly abbreviated as SDS) sulfates result in the best protein separations in standard gel electrophoresis. Particularly, SC(10)S shows higher resolutions for complexes of low molecular weight. The systematic characterization of alkyl sulfate surfactants demonstrates that changes in the chain architecture can significantly affect electrophoretic migration so that protein-surfactant structures could be optimized for high resolution protein separations.

NMR and small-angle scattering-based structural analysis of protein complexes in solution

Structural analysis of multi-domain protein complexes is a key challenge in current biology and a prerequisite for understanding the molecular basis of essential cellular processes. The use of solution techniques is important for characterizing the quaternary arrangements and dynamics of domains and subunits of these complexes. In this respect solution NMR is the only technique that allows atomic- or residue-resolution structure determination and investigation of dynamic properties of multi-domain proteins and their complexes. As experimental NMR data for large protein complexes are sparse, it is advantageous to combine these data with additional information from other solution techniques. Here, the utility and computational approaches of combining solution state NMR with small-angle X-ray and Neutron scattering (SAXS/SANS) experiments for structural analysis of large protein complexes is reviewed. Recent progress in experimental and computational approaches of combining NMR and SAS are discussed and illustrated with recent examples from the literature. The complementary aspects of combining NMR and SAS data for studying multi-domain proteins, i.e. where weakly interacting domains are connected by flexible linkers, are illustrated with the structural analysis of the tandem RNA recognition motif (RRM) domains (RRM1-RRM2) of the human splicing factor U2AF65 bound to a nine-uridine (U9) RNA oligonucleotide.