Abstract It is well known that the risk of cancer increases with age, but when viewed through a comparative lens, this risk is species specific and exists at a relatively low background in the animal kingdom. The exceptions, where cancer is a major cause of mortality, are humans and companion dogs and cats. Indeed, it is estimated that more than 50% of pet dogs that reach the age of 10-years will die from cancer. Colloquially, there is a perception that there is a “cancer epidemic” in dogs caused by exposures to real or perceived mutagens, but this hypothesis is based on presumptions for which supporting evidence is weak or absent. Here, we propose an alternative hypothesis, that replacing natural selection with artificial selection for form and function, and superimposing longevity that breaks the evolutionary constraints for that species inevitably creates cancer-prone phenotypes. Modern pet dogs have achieved a social status equivalent to human family members. With this have come better health care, reduced early mortality, and greater longevity. Although dogs were first domesticated15,000 to 20,000 years ago and breeds were derived over the last 200 to 400 years, significant gains in longevity and the recognition of cancer as a major cause of mortality in pet dogs have taken place over the past 40 to 60 years, coinciding with the transition of dogs from working animals to pets. Breaking through the evolutionary constraint on longevity comes at a price: long-lived species such as elephants, whales, mole rats, and others have acquired a diversity of cancer-protective mechanisms, achieving a balance between longevity and their reproductive and energetic investments over tens of millions of years. But no such cancer-protective mechanisms have been identified in dogs, or for that matter in humans. In both species, risk increases with age, but in dogs, risk is magnified by artificial selection. Osteosarcoma provides an example that can be generalized. The underlying causal factor is selective breeding for large size, but this is only able to manifest itself because modern pet dogs exceed their evolutionarily expected lifespan by at least 2 or 3 times. We conclude that appreciating the role of longevity as a major cause of cancer in pet dogs, as well as in other model organisms will improve our ability to design and interpret experiments that will show greater fidelity when translated to humans, where the same risk factors are operative, although they are partly masked by the influence of behavioral or occupational exposures to strong mutagens. Citation Format: Jaime F. Modiano, Aaron L. Sarver. Cancer as a consequence of breaking through evolutionary constraints on longevity [abstract]. In: Proceedings of the American Association for Cancer Research Annual Meeting 2019; 2019 Mar 29-Apr 3; Atlanta, GA. Philadelphia (PA): AACR; Cancer Res 2019;79(13 Suppl):Abstract nr 3715.
Read full abstract