Strong Gravity Research Articles

Egg-shaped sections of fluid structures around black holes

Astrophysical fluids subjected to the strong gravity of black holes can form rotating toroidal-like structures known as thick accretion discs. In order to facilitate the study of such structures, we introduce approximate empirical formulae for a relatively simple analytical description of their poloidal cross-sections that are usually described only numerically. Our comparisons of the approximate and exact descriptions of the cross-sections of the structures rotating around Schwarzschild and Kerr central black holes, together with the determination of the associated total masses of these structure, indicate a high degree of accuracy for these introduced formulae.

Loosely Trapped Surface for Slowly Rotating Black Hole

Abstract We construct the marginal loosely trapped surface (marginal LTS) for the Kerr spacetime with a small Kerr parameter perturbatively, where the LTS condition is saturated. An LTS is a surface that specifies the strong gravity region, which is a generalization of the photon sphere in the Schwarzschild spacetime. It turns out that there are an infinite number of marginal LTSs. At the leading order of the small Kerr parameter, all of the marginal LTSs have the same area. However, one can see that the maximal marginal LTS among them is uniquely determined at the higher order.

Underdetermination in classic and modern tests of general relativity

Canonically, ‘classic’ tests of general relativity (GR) include perihelion precession, the bending of light around stars, and gravitational redshift; ‘modern’ tests have to do with, inter alia, relativistic time delay, equivalence principle tests, gravitational lensing, strong field gravity, and gravitational waves. The orthodoxy is that both classic and modern tests of GR afford experimental confirmation of that theory in particular. In this article, we question this orthodoxy, by showing there are classes of both relativistic theories (with spatiotemporal geometrical properties different from those of GR) and non-relativistic theories (in which the lightcones of a relativistic spacetime are ‘widened’) which would also pass such tests. Thus, (a) issues of underdetermination in the context of GR loom much larger than one might have thought, and (b) given this, one has to think more carefully about what exactly such tests in fact are testing.

Tectonics of Cauvery basin (India) in onshore and offshore portions

Morphometric studies coupled with geophysical investigations from petroliferous basins provide valuable information about tectonics of the regions. We deduce six morphologic parameters from the River Cauvery's designated (sub)watersheds and perform dendrogram clustering analysis. The main channels of the (sub)watersheds showcase steeper gradient and meandering nature with less concavity. On the other hand, the distributaries portray lesser gradient and straight nature with greater concavity. From the offshore region of the Cauvery basin, we perform gravity modeling. The results show variations in gravity values from low to high, -150 to 50 mGal probably because of the basement ridge-depression features. This anomaly orientation indicates the extension of the sub-basin in the region. A strong NE-SW gravity trend possibly suggests a high-density plug at mid-crust. The low gravity values near the Vedaranyam region indicate low-density rocks within the basement. Places of high gravity anomaly show a decrease in bathymetry depth and vice versa. This indicates isostatic compensation of the Moho geometry, possibly due to crustal thinning in the offshore areas. Isostatic regional gravity fields are manifested by Moho relief and can have implications on the lithospheric mechanical strengths. Bathymetric studies indicate multi-directional slopes. Relatively flat areas can indicate depocenters. E-W trending lineaments mapped on the Precambrian basement from a portion of the study area is presumably a manifestation of Cauvery Shear zone, which also persists in the offshore region.

Imaging fermionic dark matter cores at the centre of galaxies

ABSTRACT Current images of the supermassive black hole (SMBH) candidates at the centre of our Galaxy and M87 have opened an unprecedented era for studying strong gravity and the nature of relativistic sources. Very-long-baseline interferometry data show images consistent with a central SMBH within General Relativity (GR). However, it is essential to consider whether other well-motivated dark compact objects within GR could produce similar images. Recent studies have shown that dark matter (DM) haloes modelled as self-gravitating systems of neutral fermions can harbour very dense fermionic cores at their centres, which can mimic the space–time features of a black hole (BH). Such dense, horizonless DM cores can satisfy the observational constraints: they can be supermassive and compact and lack a hard surface. We investigate whether such cores can produce similar observational signatures to those of BHs when illuminated by an accretion disc. We compute images and spectra of the fermion cores with a general-relativistic ray tracing technique, assuming the radiation originates from standard $\alpha$ discs, which are self-consistently solved within the current DM framework. Our simulated images possess a central brightness depression surrounded by a ring-like feature, resembling what is expected in the BH scenario. For Milky Way-like haloes, the central brightness depressions have diameters down to ${\sim} 35\, \mu \text{as}$ as measured from a distance of approximately $8\,$ kpc. Finally, we show that the DM cores do not possess photon rings, a key difference from the BH paradigm, which could help discriminate between the models.

Tilt in quadratic gravity

In this work, tilted source solutions in both Einstein–Hilbert General Relativity (GR) and Quadratic Gravity (QG) for the anisotropic Bianchi V model are addressed. Since the excellent CMBR match of Starobinsky’s inflation with Planck’s team measurements data, QG has acquired a prominent status in the effective sense, for sufficiently strong gravity fields. The main interest is in the numeric time evolution to the past towards the singularity and the behavior of the kinematic variables, vorticity, acceleration, and the expansion of this source substance. In QG we found that for universes with higher and smaller matter densities fall into the Kasner or isotropic singularity attractors to the past, respectively. We also found that the Kasner singularity attractor to the past has always zero vorticity, for both GR and QG theories. While for QG the isotropic singularity attractor may have divergent vorticity. For the set of assumptions and conditions supposed in this work, the isotropic singularity attractor, favors QG as compared to GR. Only in QG we were able to find a geometric singularity with divergences in all of the kinematic variables of the substance, decreasing to finite values to the future, upon time reversing. That is, we obtained an initial kinematic singularity substance, that approaches a perfect fluid source.

Exploring the viability of a pseudo-Nambu-Goldstone boson as ultralight dark matter in a mass range relevant for strong gravity applications

We study a simple extension of the Standard Model featuring a dark sector with an ultralight pseudo-Nambu-Goldstone boson as a dark matter candidate. We focus on the mass range O(10−20–10−10) eV, relevant for strong gravity applications, and explore its production and evolution in the early Universe. The model is formulated in such a way that dark matter does not couple directly to photons or other Standard Model particles avoiding some of the most stringent cosmological bounds related to axionlike particles. In this work, two different scenarios are considered depending on whether dark matter is produced in a preinflationary or postinflationary regime. We also discuss the effect from emergent topological defects such as cosmic strings and domain walls and estimate the spectrum of stochastic gravitational waves produced by their decay, enabling us to test the model at current and future gravitational-wave experiments. Published by the American Physical Society 2024

Detecting relativistic Doppler in galaxy clustering with tailored galaxy samples

We present a method to obtain a high-significance detection of relativistic effects on cosmological scales. Measurements of such effects would be instrumental for our understanding of the Universe, as they would provide a further confirmation of the validity of general relativity as the correct description of the gravitational interaction, in a regime very far from that of strong gravity, where it has been tested to exquisite accuracy. Despite its relevance, the detection of relativistic effects has hitherto eluded us, mainly because they are stronger on the largest cosmic scales, plagued by cosmic variance. Our work focuses on the cosmological probe of galaxy clustering, describing the excess probability of finding pairs of galaxies at a given separation due to them being part of the same underlying cosmic large-scale structure. We focus on the two-point correlation function of the distribution of galaxies in Fourier space — the power spectrum — where relativistic effects appear as an imaginary contribution to the real power spectrum. By carefully tailoring cuts in magnitude/luminosity, we are able to obtain two samples (bright and faint) of the same galaxy population, whose cross-correlation power spectrum allows for a detection of the relativistic contribution. In particular, we optimise the definition of the samples to maximise the detection significance of the relativistic Doppler term for both a low-z Bright Galaxy Sample and a high-z Hα emission line galaxy population.

The power of binary pulsars in testing Gauss-Bonnet gravity

Context. Binary pulsars are a powerful tool for probing strong gravity that still outperform direct gravitational wave observations in a number of ways due to the remarkable accuracy of the pulsar timing. They can constrain the presence of additional charges of the orbiting neutron stars very precisely, leading to new channels of energy and angular momentum loss, such as scalar dipole radiation. Aims. In the present paper, we explore in detail the possibility of constraining different classes of scalar-Gauss-Bonnet gravity with binary pulsars. Additionally, we updated the existing constraints related to the observed maximum mass of neutron stars. Methods. Interestingly, depending on the equation of state, the resulting limits on the theory coupling parameters can outperform the constraints coming from binary merger observations by up to a factor of two, even for so-called Einstein-dilaton-Gauss-Bonnet gravity where neutron stars are often underestimated as relevant theory probes. As an additional merit, precise Bayesian methods are compared with approximate approaches, with the latter showing a very good performance despite their simplicity.

Non-Minimally Coupled Electromagnetic Fields and Observable Implications for Primordial Black Holes

General relativity (GR) postulates have been verified with high precision, yet our understanding of how gravity interacts with matter fields remains incomplete. Various modifications to GR have been proposed in both classical and quantum realms to address these interactions within the strong gravity regime. One such approach is non-minimal coupling (NMC), where the space-time curvature (scalar and tensor) interacts with matter fields, resulting in matter fields not following the geodesics. To probe the astrophysical implications of NMC, in this work, we investigate non-minimally coupled electromagnetic (EM) fields in the presence of black holes. Specifically, we show that primordial black holes (PBHs) provide a possible tool to constrain the NMC parameter. PBHs represent an intriguing cosmological black hole class that does not conform to the no-hair theorem. We model the PBH as a Sultana–Dyer black hole and compare it with Schwarzschild. We examine observables such as the radius of the photon sphere, critical impact parameter, and total deflection angles for non-minimally coupled photons for Schwarzschild and Sultana–Dyer black holes. Both the black hole space-times lead to similar constraints on the NMC parameter. For a PBH of mass M=10−5 M⊙, the photon sphere will not be formed for one mode. Hence, the photons forming the photon sphere will be highly polarized, potentially leading to observable implications.

Bounds to strong gravity from electron-positron annihilations near threshold

Bounds to strong gravity from electron-positron annihilations near threshold

Low-redshift absorption in the Seyfert galaxy PG1211+143 – a distant inflow maintaining off-plane accretion or the gravitational redshift of matter orbiting the SMBH?

ABSTRACT The detection of a high-velocity (∼0.3c) inflow of highly ionized matter during an extended XMM–Newton observation of the luminous Seyfert galaxy PG1211+143 in 2014 provided the first direct evidence of a short-lived accretion event, and an explanation for the powerful winds (UFOs) now recognized as a common property of many luminous Seyfert galaxies. Although the ultra-fast inflow observed at a redshift of 0.483 was detected in only one of seven spacecraft orbits, weaker (lower column) but more persistent absorption is seen at a redshift of 0.123 in the high-exposure soft X-ray (RGS) spectra summed over all seven individual spacecraft orbits. Similar stacking of the higher energy (pn camera) spectra reveals underlying absorption at a redshift of 0.148. Interpreted, conventionally, as a Doppler redshift, the RGS observation indicates a line-of-sight inflow velocity v ∼ 0.038c and (free-fall) radial location at 1400 Rg, with the higher redshift and ionization in pn camera spectra perhaps detecting that inflow closer to the black hole. A very different explanation would be absorption in matter subject to the strong gravity close to the SMBH, an interpretation supported by the launch of a new UFO in the final spacecraft orbit.

The Dynamics and Gravitational-wave Signal of a Binary Flying Closely by a Kerr Supermassive Black Hole

Recent astrophysical models predict that stellar-mass binary black holes (BBHs) could form and coalesce within a few gravitational radii of a supermassive black hole (SMBH). Detecting the gravitational waves (GWs) from such systems requires numerical tools that can track the dynamics of the binaries while capturing all the essential relativistic effects. This work develops upon our earlier study of a BBH moving along a circular orbit in the equatorial plane of a Kerr SMBH. Here we modify the numerical method to simulate a BBH falling toward the SMBH along a parabolic orbit of arbitrary inclination with respect to the equator. By tracking the evolution in a frame freely falling alongside the binary, we find that the eccentricity of the BBH is more easily excited than it is in the previous equatorial case, and that the cause is the asymmetry of the tidal tensor imposed on the binary when the binary moves out of the equatorial plane. Since the eccentricity reaches maximum around the same time as the BBH becomes the closest to the SMBH, multiband GW bursts could be produced that are simultaneously detectable by space- and ground-based detectors. We show that the effective spin parameters of such GW events also undergo significant variation due to the rapid reorientation of the inner BBHs during their interaction with SMBHs. These results demonstrate the richness of three-body dynamics in the region of strong gravity, and highlight the necessity of building new numerical tools to simulate such systems.

Ray-traced spectra of a hot neutron star for various metallicities

General relativity strongly affects the observed spectra of compact objects. New models of hot nonrotating neutron star (NS) atmospheres are presented for various chemical compositions. We demonstrate the influence of strong gravity on the value of the hardening factor measured by a distant observer. We prepare new xspec fitting packages based on our extended numerical models for hot NS atmospheres in order to use them for a spectral analysis in the X-ray domain. For the Schwarzschild metric, ray-tracing calculations were performed to determine the observational appearance of the continuum emission of an NS. The grid of intensity spectra emerging from the NS surface was computed with the code which solves the model atmosphere equations with an accurate treatment of the Compton scattering of photons on free electrons in fully relativistic thermal motion. For the single value of the surface gravity, $ =14.34$ (cgs), the emerging specific intensity spectra were then ray-traced from the surface to the distant observer with the code across the spacetime of a nonrotating NS obtained using the lo library. The color-correction factors were determined for a large grid of models of different chemical compositions for surface gravities from the critical gravity $ g_ crit $ up to $15.00$ (cgs), and for effective temperatures in the range of $10^ eff $ K. Comptonized spectra seen at the source rest frame display hardening factors in the range from 1.4 up to 2.0 in the case of a highly luminous metal-rich atmosphere. The ratio of the color temperature $T_ c $ to the effective temperature $T_ eff $ for ray-traced spectra is in the range $0.9-1.4$. In the strong gravity regime, the structure of a hot atmosphere strongly depends on the surface gravity, luminosity, and atmospheric metal abundance of the NS. The theoretical hardening factors of the ray-traced spectra are systematically lower then the hardening factors of spectra at the source by about 30<!PCT!> on average.

Binary mergers in strong gravity background of Kerr black hole

ABSTRACT Binary-black-hole (BBH) mergers can take place close to a supermassive black hole (SMBH) while being in a bound orbit around the SMBH. In this paper, we study such bound triple systems and show that including the strong gravity effects of describing the SMBH with a Kerr metric can significantly modify the dynamics, as compared to a Newtonian point particle description of the SMBH. We extract the dynamics of the system, using a quadrupole approximation to the tidal forces due to the SMBH. We exhibit how the gyroscope precession is built into this dynamics, and find the secular Hamiltonian by both averaging over the inner and outer orbits, the latter being the orbit of the BBH around the SMBH. We study the long-time-scale dynamics, including the periastron precession and gravitational wave (GW) radiation reaction of the binary system, finding that the strong gravity effects of the SMBH can enhance the von Zeipel–Lidov–Kozai mechanism, resulting in more cycles, higher maximum eccentricity, and thereby a shorter merger time, particularly when the binary is close to, or at, the innermost stable orbit of the SMBH. We end with an analysis of the peak frequency of the GW emission from the binary system, highlighting possible observable signatures in the Einstein Telescope and Laser Interferometer Space Antenna frequency bands.

The bright black hole X-ray binary 4U 1543–47 during the 2021 outburst: A thick accretion disk inflated by high luminosity

The black hole X-ray binary source 4U 1543–47 experienced a super-Eddington outburst in 2021, reaching a peak flux of up to ∼1.96 × 10−7 erg cm−2 s−1 (∼8.2 Crab) in the 2−10 keV band. Soon after the outburst began, it rapidly transitioned into the soft state. Our goal is to understand how the accretion disk structure deviates from a standard thin disk when the accretion rate is near Eddington. To do so, we analyzed spectra obtained from quasi-simultaneous observations conducted by the Hard X-ray Modulation Telescope (Insight-HXMT), the Nuclear Spectroscopic Telescope Array (NuSTAR), and the Neil Gehrels Swift Observatory (Swift). These spectra are well fitted by a model comprising a disk, a weak corona, and a reflection component. We suggest that the reflection component is caused by disk self-irradiation, that is by photons emitted from the inner disk that return to the accretion disk surface as their trajectories are bent by the strong gravity field. In this scenario, the best-fitting parameters imply that the reflected flux represents more than half of the total flux. Using general relativistic ray-tracing simulations, we show that this scenario is viable when the disk becomes geometrically thick, with a funnel-like shape, as the accretion rate is near or above the Eddington limit. In the specific case of 4U 1543–47, an angle ≳45 deg between the disk surface and the equatorial plane can explain the required amount of self-irradiation.

Revisiting the Cosmic String Origin of GW190521.

For the first time we analyze gravitational-wave strain data using waveforms constructed from strong gravity simulations of cosmic string loops collapsing to Schwarzschild black holes; a previously unconsidered source. Since the expected signal is dominated by a black-hole ringdown, it can mimic the observed gravitational waves from high-mass binary black hole mergers. To illustrate this, we consider GW190521, a short duration gravitational-wave event observed in the third LIGO-Virgo-KAGRA observing run. We show that describing this event as a collapsing cosmic string loop is favored over previous cosmic string analyses by an approximate log Bayes factor of 22. The binary black hole hypothesis is still preferred, mostly because the cosmic string remnant is nonspinning. It remains an open question whether a spinning remnant could form from loops with angular momentum, but if possible, it would likely bring into contention the binary black hole preference. Finally, we suggest that searches for ringdown-only waveforms would be a viable approach for identifying collapsing cosmic string events and estimating their event rate. This Letter opens up an important new direction for the cosmic-string and gravitational-wave communities.

Bridging relativistic jets from black hole scales to long-term electromagnetic radiation distances: A moving-mesh general relativistic hydrodynamics code with the HLLC Riemann solver

Relativistic jets accompany the collapse of massive stars, the merger of compact objects, or the accretion of gas in active galactic nuclei. They carry information about the central engine and generate electromagnetic radiation. No self-consistent simulations have been able to follow these jets from their birth at the black hole scale to the Newtonian dissipation phase, making the inference of central engine property through astronomical observations undetermined. We present the general relativistic moving-mesh framework to achieve the continuity of jet simulations throughout space and time. We implement the general relativistic extension for the moving-mesh relativistic hydrodynamic code, , and develop a tetrad formulation to utilize the Harten-Lax-van Leer Contact Riemann solver in the general relativistic moving-mesh code. The new framework is able to trace the radial movement of relativistic jets from central regions where strong gravity holds all the way to distances of jet dissipation. Published by the American Physical Society 2024

Strong gravity extruding peaks in speed of sound profiles of massive neutron stars

Strong gravity extruding peaks in speed of sound profiles of massive neutron stars

IXPE observation confirms a high spin in the accreting black hole 4U 1957+115

We present the results of the first X-ray polarimetric observation of the low-mass X-ray binary 4U 1957+115, performed with the Imaging X-ray Polarimetry Explorer in May 2023. The binary system has been in a high-soft spectral state since its discovery and is thought to host a black hole. The ∼571 ks observation reveals a linear polarisation degree of 1.9%±0.6% and a polarisation angle of −41.°8±7.°9 in the 2–8 keV energy range. Spectral modelling is consistent with the dominant contribution coming from the standard accretion disc, while polarimetric data suggest a significant role of returning radiation: photons that are bent by strong gravity effects and forced to return to the disc surface, where they can be reflected before eventually reaching the observer. In this setting, we find that models with a black hole spin lower than 0.96 and an inclination lower than 50° are disfavoured.