Continuous renal replacement therapy (CRRT) is a dialysis modality used in critically ill patients with acute kidney injury (AKI). Although most dialysate and replacement fluids are dextrose-containing, CRRT-associated hypophosphatemia sometimes warrants the use of phosphorus-containing solutions which are dextrose free. The other less commonly used dextrose-free dialysate solutions are certain formulations of Prismasol and Prismasate. As glucose is a small molecule, which is readily cleared with dialysis, use of these solutions can result in increased caloric loss, net glucose deficit, and shifting of the metabolic pathway towards gluconeogenesis and ketogenesis. Starvation ketosis is usually a benign entity, however when combined with factors such as stress of critical illness, can produce metabolic acidosis which at times can be severe. We describe five patients who developed worsening metabolic acidosis despite adequate clearance from CRRT and were diagnosed with CRRT-associated ketoacidosis. Administration of dextrose-containing fluids or tube feeds promptly resulted in resolution of ketonemia and acidosis. Recognition of this entity is of great importance as the reflexive reaction to increase the prescribed dose of CRRT to improve the acidosis, in fact worsens the problem.