Based on a soft rock tunnel in a mountainous area of northwest Yunnan Province, a refined numerical model of different support forms considering structural interaction is established to comprehensively evaluate the structural failure mechanisms and mechanical responses of different support forms. Research shows that compared to steel rib structures, the axial force and bending moment of sprayed concrete structures is larger under different combinations of support structures. Compared with a single-layer support structure, the stress distribution at each position of the double-layer I-shaped steel structure is more uniform, and the sprayed concrete structure only experiences compression damage at the corner of the side wall. As the strength of sprayed concrete increases, the stress distribution of sprayed concrete at the arch waist becomes more uniform. The stress concentration state of sprayed concrete at the corner of the tunnel wall and the plastic yield state of the steel rib structure have also been improved. The higher the concrete strength, the lower the stress ratio on the steel rib’s inner and outer sides.