Switchgrass (Panicum virgatum) and miscanthus (Miscanthus spp.) are C4 perennial biomass crops (PBCs) commonly cultivated in Ontario. The 13C natural abundance technique was used to assess the following: i) quantify the proportion of C4-derived soil organic carbon (SOC) stock (Mg C ha-1) within the SOC stocks of the whole soil, ii) determine the C4-derived SOC sequestration rate and iii) quantify C4-derived SOC stocks in soil particle size fractions. This was achieved by analyzing the δ13C values in SOC of both the whole soil and various soil particle size fractions in PBC fields that were converted from agriculture. At Guelph after 11 years of PBC, C4-derived SOC stock as a proportion of SOC stock in the whole soil accounted for 30% in switchgrass and 31% in miscanthus fields, while at Elora it comprised 41% in switchgrass and 50% in miscanthus. However, in Burlington after 4 years, C4-derived SOC represented 10-12% in PBC fields compared to 17% in agriculture fields. The C4 derived SOC sequestration rates were 0.8, 0.7 and 0.4 Mg C ha-1 y-1 in switchgrass, miscanthus and agriculture fields, respectively at the Guelph site. In miscanthus fields, lower C4-derived SOC stock in macro soil particles were observed, yet higher percentages were observed in micro soil particles and the silt plus clay fractions compared to switchgrass and agriculture fields. Agriculture fields had higher C4-derived SOC in macro soil particles, indicating lower SOC stability. Therefore, cultivating PBCs on low-productive agricultural lands could contribute to climate change mitigation practices due to increased SOC stability.
Read full abstract