This paper introduces a novel multi-stage FOPD(1 + PI) controller for DC motor speed control, optimized using the Pelican Optimization Algorithm (POA). Traditional PID controllers often fall short in handling the complex dynamics of DC motors, leading to suboptimal performance. Our proposed controller integrates fractional-order proportional-derivative (FOPD) and proportional-integral (PI) control actions, optimized via POA to achieve superior control performance. The effectiveness of the proposed controller is validated through rigorous simulations and experimental evaluations. Comparative analysis is conducted against conventional PID and fractional-order PID (FOPID) controllers, fine-tuned using metaheuristic algorithms such as atom search optimization (ASO), stochastic fractal search (SFS), grey wolf optimization (GWO), and sine-cosine algorithm (SCA). Quantitative results demonstrate that the FOPD(1 + PI) controller optimized by POA significantly enhances the dynamic response and stability of the DC motor. Key performance metrics show a reduction in rise time by 28%, settling time by 35%, and overshoot by 22%, while the steady-state error is minimized to 0.3%. The comparative analysis highlights the superior performance, faster response time, high accuracy, and robustness of the proposed controller in various operating conditions, consistently outperforming the PID and FOPID controllers optimized by other metaheuristic algorithms. In conclusion, the POA-optimized multi-stage FOPD(1 + PI) controller presents a significant advancement in DC motor speed control, offering a robust and efficient solution with substantial improvements in performance metrics. This innovative approach has the potential to enhance the efficiency and reliability of DC motor applications in industrial and automotive sectors.