Interleukin-2 (IL-2) holds promise for the treatment of cancer and autoimmune diseases, but its high-dose usage is associated with systemic immunotoxicity. Differential IL-2 receptor (IL-2R) regulation might impact function of cells upon IL-2 stimulation, possibly inducing cellular changes similar to patients with hypomorphic IL2RB mutations, presenting with multiorgan autoimmunity. Here, we show that sustained high-dose IL-2 stimulation of human lymphocytes drastically reduces IL-2Rβ surface expression especially on T cells, resulting in impaired IL-2R signaling which correlates with high IL-2Rα baseline expression. IL-2R signaling in NK cells is maintained. CD4+ T cells, especially regulatory T cells are more broadly affected than CD8+ T cells, consistent with lineage-specific differences in IL-2 responsiveness. Given the resemblance of cellular characteristics of high-dose IL-2-stimulated cells and cells from patients with IL-2Rβ defects, impact of continuous IL-2 stimulation on IL-2R signaling should be considered in the onset of clinical adverse events during IL-2 therapy.