Sterile Mosquitoes Research Articles

Residual Longevity of Recaptured Sterile Mosquitoes as a Tool to Understand Field Performance and Reveal Quality

Invasive mosquito species, such as Aedes albopictus, pose significant threats to both ecosystems and public health due to their role in transmitting diseases, such as dengue, Zika, and chikungunya. The Sterile Insect Technique (SIT) is a promising vector control strategy aimed at reducing mosquito populations by releasing sterile males to mate with wild females and reduce their reproduction rates. In this study, we employed the captive cohort method, which assesses the remaining longevity of randomly caught released individuals, to assess the longevity and frailty dynamics of sterile and non-sterile Ae. albopictus males. Using a mark–release–recapture approach (MRR), we compared the residual lifespan of sterile and non-sterile released males with that of wild, non-sterile males, aiming to understand the frailty dynamics of released males and, therefore, their quality and field performance. Contrary to expectations, our results revealed that released sterile males showed increased longevity compared to non-sterile males. Further, the marking process did not impact the longevity between lab-kept and marked males, suggesting that the marking process does not adversely affect survival under controlled conditions. These findings underscore the importance of optimizing pre-release and mass-rearing practices to enhance the effectiveness of SIT programs. Our study also demonstrates for the first time the use of the captive cohort method for understanding the biological dynamics of sterile mosquito populations in SIT programs, providing valuable insights for improving vector control strategies.

Mark-Release-Recapture Trial with Aedes albopictus (Diptera, Culicidae) Irradiated Males: Population Parameters and Climatic Factors.

Aedes albopictus is considered one of the major invasive species in the world and can transmit viruses such as dengue, Zika, or chikungunya. The Sterile Insect Technique (SIT) can be used to suppress the native populations of Ae. albopictus. Mark-release-recapture (MRR) studies are crucial to support the development of the release strategy during the SIT application. Meanwhile, weather conditions can affect the MRR trial's results and it is critical to understand the influence of climatic factors on the results. In October 2022, 84,000 irradiated sterile males were released for three consecutive weeks in Faro, Southern Portugal. Mosquitoes were recaptured by human landing collection (HLC) one, two, four, and six days after release. Generalized linear models with a negative binomial family and log function were used to estimate the factors associated with the number of recaptured mosquitoes, prevalence ratios, and the 95% confidence intervals (CIs). A total of 84,000 sterile male mosquitoes were released, with 528 recaptured (0.8%) by HLC. The prevalence of recaptured mosquitoes was 23% lower when the wind intensity was moderate. Marked sterile males had an average median distance travelled of 88.7 m. The median probability of daily survival and the average life expectancy were 61.6% and 2.1 days, respectively. The wild male population estimate was 443.33 males/ha. Despite no statistically significant association being found with humidity, temperature, and precipitation, it is important to consider weather conditions during MRR trial analyses to obtain the best determinant estimation and a more efficient application of the SIT in an integrated vector management program.

Global dynamics of a simple model for wild and sterile mosquitoes.

There are known methods to manage the population dynamics of wild and sterile mosquitoes by releasing genetically engineered sterile mosquitoes. Even if a two-dimensional system of ordinary differential equations is considered as a simple mathematical model for developing release strategies, fully understanding the global behavior of the solutions is challenging, due to the fact that the probability of mating is ratio-dependent. In this paper, we combine a geometric approach called the time-scale transformation and blow-up technique with the center manifold theorem to provide a complete understanding of dynamical systems near the origin. Then, the global behavior of the solution of the two-dimensional ordinary differential equation system is classified in a two-parameter plane represented by the natural death rate of mosquitoes and the sterile mosquito release rate. We also offer a discussion of the sterile mosquito release strategy. In addition, we obtain a better exposition of the previous results on the existence and local stability of positive equilibria. This paper provides a framework for the mathematical analysis of models with ratio-dependent terms, and we expect that it will theoretically withstand the complexity of improved models.

Upscaling the production of sterile male mosquitoes with an automated pupa sex sorter.

Effective mosquito population suppression has been repeatedly demonstrated in field trials through the release of male mosquitoes to induce sterile mating with wild females using the incompatible insect technique (IIT), the sterile insect technique (SIT), or their combination. However, upscaling these techniques requires a highly efficient and scalable approach for the sex separation of mass-reared mosquitoes to minimize the unintentional release of females, which can lead to either population replacement or biting nuisance, a major bottleneck up to now. Here, we report the successful development of an automated mosquito pupa sex sorter that can effectively separate large numbers of males from females for population suppression of Aedes aegypti, A. albopictus, and Culex quinquefasciatus. The male production capacity of the automated sex sorter was increased by ~17-fold compared with manual sex separation with the Fay-Morlan sorter and enabled one person to separate 16 million males per week. With ~0.5% female contamination, the produced males exhibited high flight ability and mating performance. The field trial demonstrates that the quality of A. albopictus males produced using the automated sex sorter is suitable for inducing population suppression. These results indicate that the automated sex sorter offers the potential to upscale IIT and SIT against mosquito vectors for disease control.

MODELING AND ANALYSIS OF OPTIMAL IMPLEMENTATION OF STERILE INSECT TECHNIQUE TO SUPPRESS MOSQUITO POPULATION

Sterile Insect Technique (SIT) is a biological insect (or pest) control tool aiming to reduce or eliminate wild insect (or pest) populations by releasing sterile insects (or pests). In this paper, we propose and study a stage- and sex-structured entomological model describing the dynamics of wild-type mosquito population and observed that the extinction equilibrium of the model is globally asymptotically stable when the basic offspring number is less than unity. However, when the basic offspring number is greater than unity, the extinction equilibrium becomes unstable, followed by the emergence of the stable interior equilibrium. We extend the model by introducing sterile male mosquitoes as a biological control agent against wild-type mosquito species. We have considered the Allee effect in the fertile female mosquito population due to the presence of non-egg-laying females in the mosquito population. While the wild mosquito-free equilibrium of the SIT model is always locally asymptotically stable, there exists either no interior equilibrium or a pair of interior equilibria, among which one is always unstable, and the other is always locally asymptotically stable. We observed that the wild mosquito population of the SIT system goes to extinction, followed by a saddle-node bifurcation when the supply rate of sterile males increases through some critical threshold value. As an alternative to the eradication policy, we formulated an optimal control problem to suppress the wild mosquito population, which suggests increasing the investment in awareness campaigns to suppress the mosquito population.

Discrete-time models for interactive wild and transgenic sterile mosquitoes

To gain insights into the effectiveness of the newly proposed and developed genetic sterile insect technique in control of mosquitoes, that releases mosquitoes carrying a dominant lethal (RIDL), we formulate discrete-time models based on difference equations. We incorporate, respectively, the four release strategies, early acting bisex (EBS), late acting bisex (LBS), early acting female-killing (EFK), and late acting female-killing (EFK) lethality in the models. We investigate the existence and stability of positive fixed points and derive a release threshold of sterile mosquitoes for each model. We compare the different release strategies by numerical examples.

Modelling mosquito population suppression based on competition system with strong and weak Allee effect.

Mosquito-borne diseases are threatening half of the world's population. To prevent the spread of malaria, dengue fever, or other mosquito-borne diseases, a new disease control strategy is to reduce or eradicate the wild mosquito population by releasing sterile mosquitoes. To study the effects of sterile insect technique on mosquito populations, we developed a mathematical model of constant release of sterile Aedes aegypti mosquitoes with strong and weak Allee effect and considered interspecific competition with Anopheles mosquitoes. We calculated multiple release thresholds and investigated the dynamical behavior of this model. In order to get closer to reality, an impulsive differential equation model was also introduced to study mosquito suppression dynamics under the strategy of releasing $ c $ sterile male mosquitoes at each interval time $ T $. Finally, the relationship between the releasing amount or the waiting period and the number of days required to suppress mosquitoes was illustrated by numerical simulations.

Dynamics of interactive wild and sterile mosquitoes in spatially heterogenous environment

Dynamics of interactive wild and sterile mosquitoes in spatially heterogenous environment

Comparative analysis of sterile mosquito release strategies based on a population suppression model

<p>In this paper, we proposed a model for suppressing mosquito populations, evaluating various release strategies for sterilized mosquitoes, including constant continuous release, open-loop control, closed-loop control, and composite control strategies. We established release amount thresholds for each strategy to ensure the ultimate extinction of the wild population. Through numerical simulations, we validated our theoretical results and assessed the efficacy of each strategy. The results indicated that the closed-loop control mechanism significantly enhanced population suppression effectiveness. Higher intensity control notably shortened the control duration, and strategies that incorporated shorter release periods and more frequent population assessments markedly reduced the cumulative release quantity. Furthermore, we found that, compared to closed-loop control, the composite control strategy reduced single release amounts but did not show advantages in other aspects at low control intensities. However, it significantly decreased the cumulative release quantity at high control intensities.</p>

Sterile Insect Technique (SIT) field trial targeting the suppression of Aedes albopictus in Greece.

The sterile insect technique (SIT) involves releasing large numbers of sterile males to outcompete wild males in mating with females, leading to a decline in pest populations. In the current study, we conducted a suppression trial in Greece against the invasive dengue vector mosquito Aedes albopictus (Skuse) through the weekly release of sterile males for 22 weeks from June to September 2019. Our approach included the long-distance transport of sterile mosquitoes, and their release at a density of 2,547±159 sterile males per hectare per week as part of an area-wide integrated pest management strategy (AW-IPM). The repeated releases of sterile males resulted in a gradual reduction in egg density, reaching 78% from mid-June to early September. This reduction remained between 70% and 78% for four weeks after the end of the releases. Additionally, in the SIT intervention area, the ovitrap index, representing the percentage of traps containing eggs, remained lower throughout the trial than in the control area. This trial represents a significant advance in the field of mosquito control, as it explores the viability and efficacy of producing and transporting sterile males from a distant facility to the release area. Our results provide valuable insights for future SIT programmes targeting Ae. Albopictus, and the methodology we employed can serve as a starting point for developing more refined and effective release protocols, including the transportation of sterile males over long distances from production units to intervention areas.

Mathematical modelling and release thresholds of transgenic sterile mosquitoes

ABSTRACT We formulate simple differential equation models to study the impact of releases of transgenic sterile mosquitoes carrying a dominant lethal on mosquito control based on the modified sterile insects technique. The early acting bisex, late acting bisex, early acting female-killing, and late acting female-killing lethality strategies are all considered. We determine release thresholds of the transgenic sterile mosquitoes, respectively, for these models by investigating the existence of positive equilibria and their stability. We compare the model dynamics, in particular, the thresholds of the models numerically. The late acting lethality strategies are generally more effective than their corresponding early acting lethality strategies, but the comparison between the late acting bisex and early acting female-killing lethality strategies depends on different parameter settings.

Efficacy and Safety of Makabuhay (Tinospora rumphii) 25% Cream Versus Hydrocortisone 1% Cream in the Management of Mosquito Bite Reactions: Randomized Double-Blind Controlled Trial.

Most insect bite reactions resolve spontaneously, but the inflammation and pruritus induced have been shown to decrease the quality of life. Previous studies have shown the potential anti-inflammatory properties of Tinospora rumphii. The aim of the study is to assess the efficacy and safety of T rumphii 25% cream versus hydrocortisone 1% cream in the management of local cutaneous reactions caused by mosquito bites. This study was a parallel-group, double-blind, randomized, placebo-controlled trial with a 1-week duration in a span of 3 months (June 2019 to August 2019). Participants were exposed to sterile noninfectious mosquitoes (Aedes aegypti) for 5-10 minutes to elicit cutaneous lesions. Tinospora 25% cream or hydrocortisone 1% cream was applied twice daily throughout the 7-day study period. Of the 70 participants screened for this study, which was approved by an institutional review board (IRB 2019-07) at the Dermatology Outpatient Department of the Research Institute for Tropical Medicine, Alabang, Muntinlupa, Philippines, 58 participants in total met the inclusion criteria and were randomized to treatment (Tinospora: n=29) and active control (hydrocortisone: n=29) groups. In total, 58 participants were randomized to receive Tinospora cream (n=29) or hydrocortisone cream (n=29). All participants completed the follow-up. There was a significant decrease in lesion size in both groups from the first 15 minutes to day 7 (P<.001). Comparing the lesion size in both groups, there was a statistically significant decrease in lesion size in the first hour (P=.003) and after 24 hours (P=.03). On day 1, 10% (n=29) of participants in the hydrocortisone group and 7% (n=29) in the Tinospora group experienced complete resolution. On day 3, all participants experienced complete resolution. No adverse effects were documented. Tinospora 25% cream is safe, effective, and comparable to hydrocortisone 1% cream as an anti-inflammatory agent for mosquito bite reactions based on the decrease in lesion size, the proportion of participants with complete resolution of wheals, and improvement in pruritus intensity score using a visual analog scale. Long-term safety studies are recommended. Philippine Health Research Registry PHRR230716-005932; https://www.herdin.ph/index.php/registry?view=research&layout=details&cid=5932.

Qualitative analysis of a Filippov wild-sterile mosquito population model with immigration.

Effectively combating mosquito-borne diseases necessitates innovative strategies beyond traditional methods like insecticide spraying and bed nets. Among these strategies, the sterile insect technique (SIT) emerges as a promising approach. Previous studies have utilized ordinary differential equations to simulate the release of sterile mosquitoes, aiming to reduce or eradicate wild mosquito populations. However, these models assume immediate release, leading to escalated costs. Inspired by this, we propose a non-smooth Filippov model that examines the interaction between wild and sterile mosquitoes. In our model, the release of sterile mosquitoes occurs when the population density of wild mosquitoes surpasses a specified threshold. We incorporate a density-dependent birth rate for wild mosquitoes and consider the impact of immigration. This paper unveils the complex dynamics exhibited by the proposed model, encompassing local sliding bifurcation and the presence of bistability, which entails the coexistence of regular equilibria and pseudo-equilibria, as crucial model parameters, including the threshold value, are varied. Moreover, the system exhibits hysteresis phenomena when manipulating the rate of sterile mosquito release. The existence of three types of limit cycles in the Filippov system is ruled out. Our main findings indicate that reducing the threshold value to an appropriate level can enhance the effectiveness of controlling wild insects. This highlights the economic benefits of employing SIT with a threshold policy control to impede the spread of disease-carrying insects while bolstering economic outcomes.

A simple model to control the wild mosquito with sterile release

This article studies a simple population dynamics model for interaction between wild and sterile mosquitoes. The model has at most two positive equilibria. Local stability of the positive equilibria is analyzed with respect to the total number of offspring production and the natural death rate. Numerical studies show the bi-stability of the positive equilibrium and the extinction equilibrium, as there always exist solutions that converge to the extinction equilibrium. We also discuss the threshold release rate of the sterile population to achieve the extinction of wild mosquitoes and perform sensitivity analysis with respect to the release rate.

Challenge and opportunity for vector control strategies on key mosquito-borne diseases during the COVID-19 pandemic.

Mosquito-borne diseases are major global health problems that threaten nearly half of the world's population. Conflicting resources and infrastructure required by the coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19) global pandemic have resulted in the vector control process being more demanding than ever. Although novel vector control paradigms may have been more applicable and efficacious in these challenging settings, there were virtually no reports of novel strategies being developed or implemented during COVID-19 pandemic. Evidence shows that the COVID-19 pandemic has dramatically impacted the implementation of conventional mosquito vector measures. Varying degrees of disruptions in malaria control and insecticide-treated nets (ITNs) and indoor residual spray (IRS) distributions worldwide from 2020 to 2021 were reported. Control measures such as mosquito net distribution and community education were significantly reduced in sub-Saharan countries. The COVID-19 pandemic has provided an opportunity for innovative vector control technologies currently being developed. Releasing sterile or lethal gene-carrying male mosquitoes and novel biopesticides may have advantages that are not matched by traditional vector measures in the current context. Here, we review the effects of COVID-19 pandemic on current vector control measures from 2020 to 2021 and discuss the future direction of vector control, taking into account probable evolving conditions of the COVID-19 pandemic.

Prevention of a dengue outbreak via the large-scale deployment of Sterile Insect Technology in a Brazilian city: a prospective study

Dengue is a global problem that seems to be worsening, as hyper-urbanization associated with climate change has led to a significant increase in the abundance and geographical spread of its principal vector, the Aedes aegypti mosquito. Currently available solutions have not been able to stop the spread of dengue which shows the urgent need to implement alternative technologies as practical solutions. In a previous pilot trial, we demonstrated the efficacy and safety of the method 'Natural Vector Control' (NVC) in suppressing the Ae. aegypti vector population and in blocking the occurrence of an outbreak of dengue in the treated areas. Here, we expand the use of the NVC program in a large-scale 20 months intervention period in an entire city in southern Brazil. Sterile male mosquitoes were produced from locally sourced Ae. aegypti mosquitoes by using a treatment that includes double-stranded RNA and thiotepa. Weekly massive releases of sterile male mosquitoes were performed in predefined areas of Ortigueira city from November 2020 to July 2022. Mosquito monitoring was performed by using ovitraps during the entire intervention period. Dengue incidence data was obtained from the Brazilian National Disease Surveillance System. During the two epidemiological seasons, the intervention in Ortigueira resulted in up to 98.7% suppression of live progeny of field Ae. aegypti mosquitoes recorded over time. More importantly, when comparing the 2020 and 2022 dengue outbreaks that occurred in the region, the post-intervention dengue incidence in Ortigueira was 97% lower compared to the control cities. The NVC method was confirmed to be a safe and efficient way to suppress Ae. aegypti field populations and prevent the occurrence of a dengue outbreak. Importantly, it has been shown to be applicable in large-scale, real-world conditions. This study was funded by Klabin S/A and Forrest Innovations Ltd.

Global suppression and periodic change of the mosquito population in a sterile release model with delay

In this paper, we study a mosquito population suppression model with a time-delay effect, which includes explicitly the growth stage and sex structure of the mosquito population. According to the release function of sexually active sterile male mosquitoes in the field, we determine a release threshold and obtain sufficient conditions to successfully suppress the wild mosquito population. When these conditions are not satisfied, we use the fixed point theorem to obtain the existence of positive periodic solutions and determine their existence region for the common periodic release case in practice. Finally, we present a numerical example to support our theoretical results.

Sterility of Aedes albopictus by X-ray Irradiation as an Alternative to γ-ray Irradiation for the Sterile Insect Technique.

The mosquito Aedes albopictus can transmit various arboviral diseases, posing a severe threat to human health. As an environmentally friendly method, sterile insect technology (SIT) is considered an alternative to traditional methods such as chemical pesticides to control Ae. albopictus. In SIT, the sterility of male mosquitoes can be achieved by γ-ray or X-ray radiation. Compared with γ-rays, X-rays are easier to obtain, cheaper, and less harmful. However, there is a lack of comparative assessment of these two types of radiation for SIT under the same controlled conditions. Here, we compared the effects of X-ray and γ-ray radiation on the sterility of Ae. albopictus males under laboratory-controlled conditions. Neither type of radiation affected the number of eggs but significantly reduced the survival time and hatch rate. The same dose of γ-rays caused a higher sterility effect on males than X-rays but had a more significant impact on survival. However, X-rays could achieve the same sterility effect as γ-rays by increasing the radiation dose. For example, X-rays of 60 Gy induced 99% sterility, similar to γ-rays of 40 Gy. In the test of male mating competitiveness, the induced sterility and the male mating competitiveness index were also identical at the same release ratio (sterile males/fertile males). At a release ratio of 7:1, nearly 80% of eggs failed to hatch. Sterile males produced by X-ray and γ-ray radiation had similar male competitiveness in competition with field males. In conclusion, a higher dose of X-rays is required to achieve the same sterility effect, compared to γ-rays. When γ-rays are not readily available, high-dose X-rays can be used instead. This study provides data supporting the selection of more suitable radiation for the field release of sterile male mosquitoes.

Global dynamics of a mosquito population suppression model with stage and sex structure

&lt;abstract&gt;&lt;p&gt;In this paper, we study a kind of mosquito population suppression model incorporating the growth stage as well as the sex structure of mosquitoes. For the general non-autonomous case, a threshold $ m^* $ for the number of sexually active sterile mosquitoes in the field is defined, and sufficient conditions for successful suppression and partial suppression of wild mosquito population are obtained. For the first special case when the release period of the sterile mosquito is equal to its sexual lifespan, we determined the initial population size under which the mosquito population can be suppressed finally for different release intensities. For the latter special case when sterile mosquitoes are released with a constant rate, we give a threshold $ u^* $ for the release rate, and investigate the dynamic behavior of the system based on this threshold. Finally, some numerical examples are presented to confirm the theoretical results.&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/abstract&gt;

Dynamic analysis of a mosquito population model with a stage structure and periodic releases of sterile males

&lt;abstract&gt;&lt;p&gt;This paper focuses on the key issues of mosquito population control, particularly exploring the impact of periodic releases of sterile males in the population model with a stage structure. We construct and analyze a model that includes only sexually active sterile mosquitoes in the dynamic interaction system. We focus on the system's dynamical behaviors under two scenarios: when the sexual lifespan $ \bar{T} $ equals the release period $ T $ of sterile mosquitoes, and when $ \bar{T} $ is less than $ T $. In the first scenario, we explore the existence and stability of equilibria, identifying a pivotal threshold $ m^* $ that determines the requisite release amount. In the second scenario, we convert the problem into an impulsive switched system and derive sufficient conditions for the local asymptotic stability of the extinction equilibrium. We also establish the existence of positive periodic solutions using the geometric method of differential equations and the fixed point theorem. Our conclusions show that the relationship between the sexual lifespan and release period of sterile mosquitoes significantly impacts the stability of the mosquito population. Additionally, our numerical simulations not only corroborate but they also complement our theoretical findings.&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/abstract&gt;