Stellar Populations In Globular Clusters Research Articles

He-enriched starevol models for globular cluster multiple populations. Self-consistent isochrones from ZAMS to the TP-AGB phase

A common property of globular clusters (GCs) is to host multiple populations characterized by peculiar chemical abundances. Recent photometric studies suggest that the He content could vary between the populations of a GC by up to Delta He sim 0.13, in mass fraction. The initial He content impacts the evolution of low-mass stars by ultimately modifying their lifetimes, luminosity, temperatures, and, more generally, the morphology of post-red giant branch (RGB) evolutionary tracks in the Hertzsprung-Russell diagram. We present new physically accurate isochrones with different initial He enrichments and metallicities, with a focus on the methods implemented to deal with the post-RGB phases. The isochrones are based on tracks computed with the stellar evolution code starevol for different metallicities (Z = 0.0002, 0.0009, 0.002, and 0.008) and with a different He enrichment (from 0.25 to 0.6 in mass fraction). We describe the effect of He enrichment on the morphology of the isochrones, and we tested these by comparing the predicted number counts of horizontal branch and asymptotic giant branch stars with those of selected GCs. Comparing the number ratios, we find that our new theoretical ones agree with the observed values within $1 in most cases. The work presented here sets the ground for future studies on stellar populations in GCs, in which the abundances of light elements in He-enhanced models will rely on different assumptions for the causes of this enrichment. The developed methodology permits the computation of isochrones from new stellar tracks with noncanonical stellar processes. The checked number counts ensure that, at least in this reference set, the contribution of the luminous late stages of stellar evolution to the integrated light of a GC is represented adequately.

Extending the chemical reach of the H3 survey: detailed abundances of the dwarf-galaxy stellar stream Wukong/LMS-1

ABSTRACT We present the first detailed chemical-abundance analysis of stars from the dwarf-galaxy stellar stream Wukong/LMS-1 covering a wide metallicity range ($-3.5 \lt \rm [Fe/H] \lesssim -1.3$). We find abundance patterns that are effectively indistinguishable from the bulk of Indus and Jhelum, a pair of smaller stellar streams proposed to be dynamically associated with Wukong/LMS-1. We confirmed a carbon-enhanced metal-poor star ($\rm [C/Fe] \gt +0.7$ and $\rm [Fe/H] \sim -2.9$) in Wukong/LMS-1 with strong enhancements in Sr, Y, and Zr, which is peculiar given its solar-level [Ba/Fe]. Wukong/LMS-1 stars have high abundances of α elements up to $\rm [Fe/H] \gtrsim -2$, which is expected for relatively massive dwarfs. Towards the high-metallicity end, Wukong/LMS-1 becomes α-poor, revealing that it probably experienced fairly standard chemical evolution. We identified a pair of N- and Na-rich stars in Wukong/LMS-1, reminiscent of multiple stellar populations in globular clusters. This indicates that this dwarf galaxy contained at least one globular cluster that was completely disrupted in addition to two intact ones previously known to be associated with Wukong/LMS-1, which is possibly connected to similar evidence found in Indus. From these ≥3 globular clusters, we estimate the total mass of Wukong/LMS-1 to be ${\approx }10^{10} \, \mathrm{M}_\odot$, representing ∼1 per cent of the present-day Milky Way. Finally, the [Eu/Mg] ratio in Wukong/LMS-1 continuously increases with metallicity, making this the first example of a dwarf galaxy where the production of r-process elements is clearly dominated by delayed sources, presumably neutron-star mergers.

A JWST Project on 47 Tucanae. Overview, Photometry, and Early Spectroscopic Results of M Dwarfs and Observations of Brown Dwarfs* *The main data set presented in this article was obtained from the Mikulski Archive for Space Telescopes (MAST) at the Space Telescope Science Institute. The specific observations analyzed can be accessed via doi:10.17909/6t82-4360.

James Webb Space Telescope (JWST) observations have been demonstrated to be efficient in detecting multiple stellar populations in globular clusters (GCs) in the low-mass regime of M dwarfs. We present an overview, and first results, of different projects that can be explored by using the JWST observations gathered under program GO2560 for 47 Tucanae, the first program entirely devoted to the investigation of multiple populations in very-low-mass stars, which includes spectroscopic data for the faintest GC stars for which spectra are available. Our color–magnitude diagram (CMD) shows some substructures for ultracool stars, including gaps and breaks in slope. In particular, we observe both a gap and a minimum in the F322W2 luminosity function less than 1 mag apart, and discuss which it could be associated with the H-burning limit. We detect stars fainter than this minimum, very likely brown dwarfs. We corroborate the ubiquity of the multiple populations across different masses, from ∼0.1 M ⊙ up to red giants (∼0.8 M ⊙). The oxygen range inferred for the M dwarfs, both from the CMD and from the spectra of two M dwarfs associated with different populations, is similar to that observed for giants. We have not detected any difference between the fractions of stars in distinct populations across stellar masses ≳ 0.1 M ⊙. This work demonstrates the JWST's capability in uncovering multiple populations within M dwarfs and illustrates the possibility to analyze very-low-mass stars in GCs approaching the H-burning limit and the brown-dwarf sequence.

Towards a holistic view of the origin of multiple stellar populations in globular clusters

The presence of multiple stellar populations in globular clusters is now well accepted, however, very little is known regarding how they formed. Answering this question is one of the major challenges of stellar astrophysics, yet of great interest, given the importance of globular clusters in different fields, from stellar evolution to gravitational wave emission and galaxy assembly. We present a series of 3D hydrodynamic simulations both of isolated clusters and at a cosmological scale aimed at probing the formation of globular clusters and their multiple stellar populations. We focus first on the effects of both rotation and Type Ia supernovae on the formation of the second population with particular attention on the chemical composition of the newborn stars. Then, we present the first simulations of the SImulating the Environment where Globular clusters Emerged project aimed at probing the formation of globular clusters through sub-parsec cosmological zoom-in simulations.

Nitrogen-enriched, Highly Pressurized Nebular Clouds Surrounding a Super Star Cluster at Cosmic Noon

Strong lensing offers a precious opportunity for studying the formation and early evolution of super star clusters that are rare in our cosmic backyard. The Sunburst Arc, a lensed Cosmic Noon galaxy, hosts a young super star cluster with escaping Lyman continuum radiation. Analyzing archival Hubble Space Telescope images and emission line data from Very Large Telescope/MUSE and X-shooter, we construct a physical model for the cluster and its surrounding photoionized nebula. We confirm that the cluster is ≲4 Myr old, is extremely massive M ⋆ ∼ 107 M ⊙, and yet has a central component as compact as several parsecs, and we find a gas-phase metallicity Z = (0.22 ± 0.03)Z ⊙. The cluster is surrounded by ≳105 M ⊙ of dense clouds that have been pressurized to P ∼ 109 K cm−3 by perhaps stellar radiation at within 10 pc. These should have large neutral columns N HI > 1022.8 cm−2 to survive rapid ejection by radiation pressure. The clouds are likely dusty as they show gas-phase depletion of silicon, and may be conducive to secondary star formation if N HI > 1024 cm−2 or if they sink farther toward the cluster center. Detecting strong [N iii]λ λ 1750,1752, we infer heavy nitrogen enrichment . This requires efficiently retaining ≳500 M ⊙ of nitrogen in the high-pressure clouds from massive stars heavier than 60 M ⊙ up to 4 Myr. We suggest a physical origin of the high-pressure clouds from partial or complete condensation of slow massive star ejecta, which may have an important implication for the puzzle of multiple stellar populations in globular clusters.

A cautionary lesson from Gaia systematics: the mono-metallic globular cluster NGC 5904

ABSTRACT The study of the chemistry of the stellar populations in globular clusters (GCs) is a fundamental task to unveil their formation in the high-redshift universe and to reconstruct the build-up of our Galaxy. Using metallicity estimates from BP/RP low-resolution Gaia DR3 spectra, a recent work presented the surprizing detection of two stellar populations with distinct metallicities in the stellar stream of the GC NGC 5904, otherwise considered a mono-metallic system. The presence of these two populations, with [Fe/H] ∼ −1.4 and [Fe/H] ∼ −2.0 dex, was taken as the evidence of a merger origin of the cluster. In this Letter, using the same data set complemented by new robust metallicity estimates, we carry out a detailed analysis of the metallicity distribution of stars belonging both to the cluster and to its stellar stream, explicitly focusing on the subtle effects of data systematics. We demonstrate that the population at [Fe/H] ∼ −2.0 dex is a data artefact due to error systematics, affecting especially faint stars. The new higher quality metallicity sample corroborates this finding, and it indicates the presence of only one population of stars with metallicity of [Fe/H] ∼ −1.3 dex, in agreement with previous literature studies. We, therefore, conclude that both NGC 5904 and its stellar stream are mono-metallic systems, and emphasize the need of carefully examining systematic effects in large and complex data.

Multiple stellar populations in globular clusters with JWST: an NIRCam view of 47 Tucanae

ABSTRACT We use images collected with the near-infrared camera (NIRCam) onboard the JWST and with the Hubble Space Telescope (HST) to investigate multiple populations at the bottom of the main sequence (MS) of 47 Tucanae. The mF115W versus mF115W − mF322W2 colour–magnitude diagram (CMD) from NIRCam shows that, below the knee, the MS stars span a wide colour range, where the majority of M-dwarfs exhibit blue colours, and a tail of stars are distributed towards the red. A similar pattern is observed from the mF160W versus mF110W − mF160W CMD from HST, and multiple populations of M-dwarfs are also visible in the optical mF606W versus mF606W − mF814W CMD. The NIRCam CMD shows a narrow sequence of faint MS stars with masses smaller than $0.1\, \mathcal {M}_{\odot }$. We introduce a chromosome map of M-dwarfs that reveals an extended first population and three main groups of second-population stars. By combining isochrones and synthetic spectra with appropriate chemical composition, we simulate colours and magnitudes of different stellar populations in the NIRCam filters (at metallicities [Fe/H] = −1.5 and [Fe/H] = −0.75) and identify the photometric bands that provide the most efficient diagrams to investigate the multiple populations in globular clusters. Models are compared with the observed CMDs of 47 Tucanae to constrain M-dwarfs’ chemical composition. Our analysis suggests that the oxygen range needed to reproduce the colours of first- and second-population M-dwarfs is similar to that inferred from spectroscopy of red giants, constraining the proposal that the chemical variations are due to mass transfer phenomena in proto-clusters.

Evidence for a bottom-light initial mass function in massive star clusters

ABSTRACT We have determined stellar mass functions of 120 Milky Way globular clusters and massive Large Magellanic Cloud/Small Magellanic Cloud star clusters based on a comparison of archival Hubble Space Telescope photometry with a large grid of direct N-body simulations. We find a strong correlation of the global mass function slopes of star clusters with both their internal relaxation times and their lifetimes. Once dynamical effects are being accounted for, the mass functions of most star clusters are compatible with an initial mass function described by a broken power-law distribution N(m) ∼ mα with break masses at 0.4 and 1.0 M⊙ and mass function slopes of αLow = −0.3 for stars with masses m < 0.4 M⊙, αHigh = −2.30 for stars with m > 1.0 M⊙, and αMed = −1.65 for intermediate-mass stars. Alternatively, a lognormal mass function with a characteristic mass log MC = −0.36 and width σC = 0.28 for low-mass stars and a power-law mass function for stars with m > 1 M⊙ also fit our data. We do not find a significant environmental dependence of the initial mass function on cluster mass, density, global velocity dispersion, or metallicity. Our results lead to a larger fraction of high-mass stars in globular clusters compared to canonical Kroupa/Chabrier mass functions, increasing the efficiency of self-enrichment in clusters and helping to alleviate the mass budget problem of multiple stellar populations in globular clusters. By comparing our results with direct N-body simulations, we finally find that only simulations in which most black holes are ejected by natal birth kicks correctly reproduce the observed correlations.

What the JWST can tell us about the Origin of Multiple Stellar Populations in Globular Clusters

AbstractI present the first results of multiple stellar populations in globular clusters from James Webb Space Telescope (JWST) data. We obtained combined NIRSpec and NIRCam data of the GC 47 Tucanae to investigate the properties of the different stellar populations in the low-mass regime, down to ∼0.5 M⊙. Our analysis of both the photometric data and the spectra suggests that the multiple stellar populations among M dwarfs share similar properties of those extensively studied on bright red giant branch stars. The comparison between stellar populations’ properties at different stellar mass, e.g. at the red giants and M dwarfs’ phases, can potentially provide strong constraints to the formation scenarios of the still eluding phenomenon of the multiple populations in star clusters.

Multiple Stellar Populations in Globular Clusters with JWST

AbstractI present the first evidence of multiple populations in the globular cluster (GCs) 47 Tucanae based on images collected with the near-infrared camera (NIRCam) on board the James Webb Space Telescope (JWST). While NIRCam photometry is poorly sensitive to multiple populations among stars brighter than the main-sequence (MS) knee, the M-dwarfs more-massive than ∼0.1 define a wide color range due to multiple populations. The star-to-star color differences are mostly due to the different amounts of water vapor (hence oxygen) that affect the spectra of M-dwarfs. The chromosome map unveils an extended first population (1P) composed of M-dwarfs with different metallicities and three main groups of second-population (2P) stars that are depleted in oxygen with respect to the 1P. I present the discovery of an MS of very-low-mass stars and tentatively associated it with a sequence composed of O-rich stars alone.

Multiple Stellar Populations of Globular Clusters from Homogeneous Ca–CN–CH–NH Photometry. VII. Metal-poor Populations in 47 Tucanae (NGC 104)* * Based on observations made with the Cerro Tololo Inter-American Observatory (CTIO) 1 m telescope, which is operated by the SMARTS consortium. † †This work presents results from the European Space Agency space mission Gaia. Gaia data are being processed by the

We present new large field-of-view (∼1°×1°) Ca-CN photometry of the prototypical metal-rich globular cluster 47 Tucanae (NGC 104). Our results are the following. (1) The populational number ratios of the red giant branch (RGB) and red horizontal branch (RHB) are in excellent agreement: n(CN-w):n(CN-s) = 30:70 (±1–2), where the CN-w and CN-s stand for the CN-weak and CN-strong populations, respectively. Both the CN-s RGB and RHB populations are more centrally concentrated than those of CN-w populations are. (2) Our photometric metallicities of individual RGB stars in each population can be well described by bimodal distributions with two metallicity peaks, [Fe/H] ∼−0.72 and −0.92 dex, where the metal-poor components occupy ∼13% of the total RGB stars. The metal-poor populations are more significantly centrally concentrated than the metal-rich populations, showing a similar result that we found in M3. (3) The RGB bump V magnitudes of individual populations indicate that there is no difference in the helium abundance between the two metal-poor populations, while the helium enhancement of ΔY ∼0.02–0.03 is required between the the two metal-rich populations. (4) The RHB morphology of 47 Tuc appears to support our idea of the bimodal metallicity distribution of the cluster. We suggest that 47 Tuc could be another example of merger remnants of two globular clusters, similar to M3 and M22.

Multiple stellar populations in the high-temperature regime: Potassium abundances in the globular cluster M 54 (NGC 6715)

Among the multiple stellar populations in globular clusters (GCs) the very high-temperature H-burning regime, able to produce elements up to potassium, is still poorly explored. Here we present the first abundance analysis of K in 42 giants of NGC 6715 (M 54) with homogeneous abundances of light elements previously derived in our FLAMES survey. Owing to the large mass and low metallicity, a large excess of K could be expected in this GC, which is located in the nucleus of the Sagittarius dwarf galaxy. We actually found a spread in [K/Fe] spanning about 1 dex, with [K/Fe] presenting a significant anti-correlation with [O/Fe] ratios, regardless of the metallicity component in M 54. Evidence for a K–Mg anti-correlation also exists, but this is statistically marginal because of the lack of very Mg-poor stars in this GC. We found, however, a strong correlation between K and Ca. These observations clearly show that the K enhancement in M 54 is probably due to the same network of nuclear reactions generating the phenomenon of multiple stellar populations, at work in a regime of very high temperature. The comparison with recent results in ω Cen is hampered by an unexplained trend with the temperatures for K abundances from optical spectroscopy, and somewhat by a limited sample size for infrared APOGEE data. There are few doubts, however, that the two most massive GCs in the Milky Way host a K–Mg anti-correlation.

The Next Generation Virgo Cluster Survey. XXXIII. Stellar Population Gradients in the Virgo Cluster Core Globular Cluster System

We present a study of the stellar populations of globular clusters (GCs) in the Virgo Cluster core with a homogeneous spectroscopic catalog of 692 GCs within a major-axis distance R maj = 840 kpc from M87. We investigate radial and azimuthal variations in the mean age, total metallicity, [Fe/H], and α-element abundance of blue (metal-poor) and red (metal-rich) GCs using their co-added spectra. We find that the blue GCs have a steep radial gradient in [Z/H] within R maj = 165 kpc, with roughly equal contributions from [Fe/H] and [α/Fe], and flat gradients beyond. By contrast, the red GCs show a much shallower gradient in [Z/H], which is entirely driven by [Fe/H]. We use GC-tagged Illustris simulations to demonstrate an accretion scenario where more massive satellites (with more metal- and α-rich GCs) sink further into the central galaxy than less massive ones, and where the gradient flattening occurs because of the low GC occupation fraction of low-mass dwarfs disrupted at larger distances. The dense environment around M87 may also cause the steep [α/Fe] gradient of the blue GCs, mirroring what is seen in the dwarf galaxy population. The progenitors of red GCs have a narrower mass range than those of blue GCs, which makes their gradients shallower. We also explore spatial inhomogeneity in GC abundances, finding that the red GCs to the northwest of M87 are slightly more metal-rich. Future observations of GC stellar population gradients will be useful diagnostics of halo merger histories.

Compact-object Formation, Retention, and Growth through Accretion onto Gas-embedded White Dwarfs/Neutron Stars in Gas-enriched Globular Clusters

Abstract Observations of pulsars in globular clusters (GCs) give evidence that more than >10%–20% of neutron stars (NSs) that ever formed in GCs were retained there. However, the velocity distribution of field pulsars peaks at 5–10 times the escape velocities of GCs. Consequently, only a small fraction of GC NSs should have been retained, which is potentially difficult to explain even accounting for low-velocity NSs formed through electron-capture supernovae (SNe). Thus, too few low-velocity NSs should have been retained, giving rise to the NS retention problem in GCs. Here we suggest a novel solution, in which the progenitors of most GC NSs were ONe white dwarfs (WDs) that accreted ambient intracluster gas and formed low-velocity NSs through accretion-induced collapse (AIC). The existence of an early gas-enriched environment in GCs is supported by observations of multiple stellar populations in GCs. It is thought that 10–100s of megayears after the formation of the first generation of stars, and after ONe WDs were already formed, GCs were replenished with gas, which formed a second generation of stars. Accretion of such replenished gas onto the ONe WDs catalyzed the AIC processes. The number of AIC-formed NSs is then sufficient to explain the large number of NSs retained in GCs. Similar processes might also drive CO WDs to produce Type Ia SNe or to merge and form NSs and similarly drive NSs to AIC and mergers producing BHs. Moreover, the wide variety of gas-catalyzed binary mergers and explosive transients suggested to occur in the gas-rich environments of an active galactic nucleus disk could similarly, and even more efficiently, occur in second-generation gas in GCs.

Robust statistical tools for identifying multiple stellar populations in globular clusters in the presence of measurement errors

Context.The finding of multiple stellar populations (MPs), which are defined by patterns in the stellar element abundances, is considered today a distinctive feature of globular clusters. However, while data availability and quality have improved in the past decades, this is not always true for the techniques that are adopted to analyse them, which creates problems of objectivity for the claims and reproducibility.Aims.Using NGC 2808 as test case, we show the use of well-established statistical clustering methods. We focus our analysis on the red giant branch phase, where two data sets are available in the recent literature for low- and high-resolution spectroscopy.Methods.We adopted hierarchical clustering and partition methods. We explicitly addressed the usually neglected problem of measurement errors, for which we relied on techniques that were recently introduced in the statistical literature. The results of the clustering algorithms were subjected to a silhouette width analysis to compare the performance of the split into different numbers of MPs.Results.For both data sets the results of the statistical pipeline are at odds with those reported in the literature. Two MPs are detected for both data sets, while the literature reports five and four MPs from high- and low-resolution spectroscopy, respectively. The silhouette analysis suggests that the population substructure is reliable for high-resolution spectroscopy data, while the actual existence of MP is questionable for the low-resolution spectroscopy data. The discrepancy with literature claims can be explained with the different methods that were adopted to characterise MPs. By means of Monte Carlo simulations and multimodality statistical tests, we show that the often adopted study of the histogram of the differences in some key elements is prone to multiple false-positive findings.Conclusions.The adoption of statistically grounded methods, which adopt all the available information to split the data into subsets and explicitly address the problem of data uncertainty, is of paramount importance to present more robust and reproducible research.

The fractions of post-binary-interaction stars and evolved blue straggler stars on the red giant branch of globular clusters

The red giant branch (RGB) of globular clusters (GCs) is home to some exotic stars, which may provide clues on the formation of multiple stellar populations in GCs. It is well known that binary interactions are responsible for many exotic stars. Thus, it is important to understand what fraction of stars on the RGB of GCs is the result of binary interactions. In this paper, we performed a binary population synthesis study to track the number of post-binary-interaction (post-BI) stars that appear on the RGB, with particular emphasis on the evolved blue straggler stars (E-BSSs). Assuming an initial binary fraction of nearly 50%, we find that about half of the objects on the RGB (called giants) underwent the binary interactions, and that E-BSSs account for around 10% of the giants in our standard simulation. We also compare the properties of post-BI giants that evolved from different channels. We find that the initial orbital period and mass ratio distributions significantly affect the fraction of post-BI giants. Our results imply that the non-standard stars from binary interactions provide a non-negligible contribution to the RGB stars in GCs, which should be considered in future investigations of the origin of multiple stellar populations.

Integrated Photometry of Multiple Stellar Populations in Globular Clusters

Abstract Evidence that multiple populations (MPs) are common properties of globular clusters (GCs) has accumulated over the past decades from clusters in the Milky Way and in its satellites. This finding has revived research into GCs, and suggested that their formation at high redshift must have been a much more complex phenomenon than imagined before. However, most information on MPs is limited to nearby GCs. The main limitation is that most studies of MPs rely on resolved stars, posing a major challenge to the investigation of the MP phenomenon in distant galaxies. Here we search for integrated colors of old GCs that are sensitive to the MP phenomenon. To do this, we exploit integrated magnitudes of simulated GCs with MPs, and multiband Hubble Space Telescope photometry of 56 Galactic GCs, where MPs are widely studied, and characterized as part of the UV Legacy Survey of Galactic GCs. We find that both integrated C F275W,F336W,F438W and m F275W − m F814W colors strongly correlate with the iron abundance of the host GC. To second order, the pseudo two-color diagram built with these integrated colors is sensitive to the MP phenomenon. In particular, once the dependence on cluster metallicity is removed, the color residuals depend on the maximum internal helium variation within GCs and on the fraction of second-generation stars. This diagram, which we define here for Galactic GCs, has the potential to detect and characterize MPs from integrated photometry of old GCs, thus providing the possibility to extend their investigation outside the Local Group.

Role of host galaxy in the formation of multiple stellar populations: analysis of NGC 1786 and NGC 1898

ABSTRACT Even after decades of research, the origin of multiple stellar populations in globular clusters (GCs) remains enigmatic. The question as to whether the galaxy environment plays a role in their formation remains unanswered. To that extent, we analysed two classical (>10 Gyr old) Large Magellanic Cloud GCs, NGC 1786 and NGC 1898, using imaging data from Hubble Space Telescope to compare and contrast them with ancient Galactic GCs to assess systematic differences that might exist between their abundance variations. We calculated their red giant branch width, subtracted the effect of metallicity, and compared it with the available data on Galactic GCs by plotting them against initial and current cluster mass. We see that the two clusters follow the same general trend as that of the Galactic GCs, and Galactic GCs from different progenitors follow the same general trend as one another, indicating that the galaxy environment may only play a minor role in the formation of multiple stellar populations within GCs.

Multiple Stellar Populations of Globular Clusters from Homogeneous Ca–CN–CH–NH Photometry. VI. M3 (NGC 5272) Is Not a Prototypical Normal Globular Cluster* †

Abstract We present Ca–CN–CH–NH photometry for the well-known globular cluster (GC) M3 (NGC 5272). We show new evidence for two M3 populations with distinctly different carbon and nitrogen abundances, seen in a sharp division between CN-weak and CN-strong red-giant branches (RGBs) in M3. The CN-strong population shows a C–N anticorrelation that is a natural consequence of the CN cycle, while the CN-weak population shows at most a very weak C–N anticorrelation. Additionally, the CN-weak population exhibits an elongated spatial distribution that is likely linked to its fast rotation. Our derived metallicities reveal bimodal distributions in both populations, with 〈[Fe/H]〉 ≈ −1.60 and −1.45, which appear to be responsible for the discrete double RGB bumps in the CN-weak population and the large range. From this discovery, we propose that M3 consists of two GCs, namely C1 (23%, 〈[Fe/H]〉 ≈ −1.60) and C2 (77%, 〈[Fe/H]〉 ≈ −1.45), each of which has its own C–N anticorrelation and structural and kinematical properties, which are strong indications of independent systems in M3. The fractions of the CN-weak population for both C1 and C2 are high compared to Galactic GCs but they are in good agreement with GCs in the Magellanic Clouds. We suggest that M3 is a merger remnant of two GCs, most likely in a dwarf galaxy environment, and accreted to our Galaxy later in time. This is consistent with recent proposals of an ex situ origin for M3.

Excess of Ca (and Sc) produced in globular cluster multiple populations: a first census in 77 Galactic globular clusters

Multiple stellar populations in globular clusters (GCs) are distinct by their different abundances of light elements. The abundance anti-correlations point towards a nucleosynthesis origin due to high-temperature H burning, but it remains to be assessed which type of stars altered primordial abundances in GCs. In particular, the regime at very high temperature that shapes the variations in potassium as well as calcium and scandium, which has been detected in a few notable cases such as NGC 2419 and NGC 2808, is still poorly explored. We started a systematic search for excess of Ca (and Sc) in GC stars with respect to the level of unmodified field stars. This method has recently been proven to be highly efficient in revealing the outcome of the proton-capture reactions at very high temperatures. Statistically robust evidence of such excess was found in a small number of GCs (NGC 4833, NGC 6715, NGC 6402, NGC 5296, NGC 5824, and NGC 5139/ωCentauri) that join the previously known two clusters. For the first time we show that NGC 4833 is likely to host anti-correlated K and Mg abundances. All these GCs are among the most massive ones in the Galaxy. We found that the fraction of stars with Ca enhancement at 3σabove the field star distribution is a multivariate function of the GC mass and metallicity, as in other manifestations of the multiple population phenomenon in GCs. We argue that these alterations in only a few GCs can be reproduced by two different channels: either a class of ordinary stars, that is common to all GCs, acts only in particular environments, or an on-off mechanism is generated by the occurrence of a peculiar type of stars (or lack of such stars). Hot bottom-burning in asymptotic giant branch stars in the low-metallicity regime is a good candidate for the first class. Alternatively, a metallicity dependence is also expected for supermassive stars, which are predicted to preferentially form in massive GCs.