Steady State Fluctuation Relation Research Articles

Fluctuation Relation for the Dissipative Flux: The Role of Dynamics, Correlations and Heat Baths.

The fluctuation relation stands as a fundamental result in nonequilibrium statistical physics. Its derivation, particularly in the stationary state, places stringent conditions on the physical systems of interest. On the other hand, numerical analyses usually do not directly reveal any specific connection with such physical properties. This study proposes an investigation of such a connection with the fundamental ingredients of the derivation of the fluctuation relation for the dissipation, which includes the decay of correlations, in the case of heat transport in one-dimensional systems. The role of the heat baths in connection with the system's inherent properties is then highlighted. A crucial discovery of our research is that different lattice models obeying the steady-state fluctuation relation may do so through fundamentally different mechanisms, characterizing their intrinsic nature. Systems with normal heat conduction, such as the lattice ϕ4 model, comply with the theorem after surpassing a certain observational time window, irrespective of lattice size. In contrast, systems characterized by anomalous heat conduction, such as Fermi-Pasta-Ulam-Tsingou-β and harmonic oscillator chains, require extended observation periods for theoretical alignment, particularly as the lattice size increases. In these systems, the heat bath's fluctuations significantly influence the entire lattice, linking the system's fluctuations with those of the bath. Here, the current autocorrelation function allows us to discern the varying conditions under which different systems satisfy with the fluctuation relation. Our findings significantly expand the understanding of the stationary fluctuation relation and its broader implications in the field of nonequilibrium phenomena.

Testing the Steady-State Fluctuation Relation in the Solar Photospheric Convection.

The turbulent thermal convection on the Sun is an example of an irreversible non-equilibrium phenomenon in a quasi-steady state characterized by a continuous entropy production rate. Here, the statistical features of a proxy of the local entropy production rate, in solar quiet regions at different timescales, are investigated and compared with the symmetry conjecture of the steady-state fluctuation theorem by Gallavotti and Cohen. Our results show that solar turbulent convection satisfies the symmetries predicted by the fluctuation relation of the Gallavotti and Cohen theorem at a local level.

Work fluctuation relations for a dragged Brownian particle in active bath

We study the work distribution of a Brownian particle diffusing in an environment of active particles and being trapped in a harmonic potential, the center of which is subjected to a time-dependent protocol. Employing phase space path integral technique we find an expression of work distribution for any generic model of active noise. Here we consider two active noise models — Gaussian correlated and Poisson white, each of which can represent some physical systems. For both the cases, it is found that transient fluctuation relation of work is not applicable though at steady state it holds by defining a renormalized temperature τr in place of bath temperature. Interestingly, τr is the same for both the models and can be expressed in terms of diffusivities of active and thermal noises. For correlated Gaussian bath, an alternative approach is presented. Analogous to the formalism given by Hatano and Sasa (2001), we obtain a work like quantity from nonequilibrium potential with the inclusion of a new stationary parameter Ω. With proper choice of Ω, a steady-state fluctuation relation, namely Jarzynski equality is satisfied.

Entropy production and work fluctuation relations for a single particle in active bath

A colloidal particle immersed in a bath of bacteria is a typical example of a passive particle in an active bath. To model this, we take an overdamped harmonically trapped particle subjected to a thermal and a non-equilibrium noise arising from the active bath. The harmonic well can be attributed to a laser trap or to the small amplitude motion of the sedimented colloid at the bottom of the capillary. In the long time, the system reaches a non-equilibrium steady state that can be described by an effective temperature. Here we investigate whether fluctuation relations for entropy hold in the presence of Gaussian active noise. In addition, when subjected to a deterministic time dependent drag, we find that transient fluctuation theorem for work cannot be applied in conventional form. However, a steady state fluctuation relation for work emerges out with a renormalized temperature.

Role of ergodicity in the transient Fluctuation Relation and a new relation for a dissipative non-chaotic map

Toy model dynamical systems, such as the baker maps, are useful to shed light on some of the conditions verified by deterministic models in non-equilibrium statistical physics. We investigate a 2D dynamical system, enjoying a weak form of reversibility, with peculiar basins of attraction and steady states. In particular, we test the conditions required for the validity of the transient Fluctuation Relation. Our analysis illustrates by means of concrete examples why ergodicity of the equilibrium dynamics (also known as “ergodic consistency”) seems to be a necessary condition for the transient Fluctuation Relation. This investigation then leads to the numerical verification of a kind of transient relation which, differently from the usual transient Fluctuation Relation, holds only asymptotically. At the same time, this relation is not a steady state Fluctuation Relation, because the steady state is a fixed point without fluctuations.

Time Reversibility, Correlation Decay and the Steady State Fluctuation Relation for Dissipation

Steady state fluctuation relations for nonequilibrium systems are under intense investigation because of their important practical implications in nanotechnology and biology. However the precise conditions under which they hold need clarification. Using the dissipation function, which is related to the entropy production of linear irreversible thermodynamics, we show time reversibility, ergodic consistency and a recently introduced form of correlation decay, called T-mixing, are sufficient conditions for steady state fluctuation relations to hold. Our results are not restricted to a particular model and show that the steady state fluctuation relation for the dissipation function holds near or far from equilibrium subject to these conditions. The dissipation function thus plays a comparable role in nonequilibrium systems to thermodynamic potentials in equilibrium systems.

Yielding and large deviations in micellar gels: a model

We present a simple model that can be used to account for the rheological behaviour observed in recent experiments on micellar gels. The model combines attachment–detachment kinetics with stretching due to shear, and shows well-defined jammed and flowing states. The large-deviation function (LDF) for the coarse-grained velocity becomes increasingly non-quadratic as the applied force F is increased, in a range near the yield threshold. The power fluctuations are found to obey a steady-state fluctuation relation (FR) at small F. However, the FR is violated when F is near the transition from the flowing to the jammed state although the LDF still exists; the antisymmetric part of the LDF is found to be nonlinear in its argument. Our approach suggests that large fluctuations and motion in a direction opposite to an imposed force are likely to occur in a wider class of systems near yielding.

Statistical properties of entropy-consuming fluctuations in jammed states of laponite suspensions: Fluctuation relations and generalized Gumbel distribution

We report a universal large deviation behavior of spatially averaged global injected power just before the rejuvenation of the jammed state formed by an aging suspension of laponite clay under an applied stress. The probability distribution function (PDF) of these entropy consuming strongly non-Gaussian fluctuations follow an universal large deviation functional form described by the generalized Gumbel (GG) distribution like many other equilibrium and nonequilibrium systems with high degree of correlations but do not obey the Gallavotti-Cohen steady-state fluctuation relation (SSFR). However, far from the unjamming transition (for smaller applied stresses) SSFR is satisfied for both Gaussian as well as non-Gaussian PDF. The observed slow variation of the mean shear rate with system size supports a recent theoretical prediction for observing GG distribution.

Steady state fluctuation relations and time reversibility for non-smooth chaoticmaps

Steady state fluctuation relations for dynamical systems are commonly derivedunder the assumption of some form of time reversibility and of chaos. There are,however, cases in which they are observed to hold even if the usual notion oftime reversal invariance is violated, e.g. for local fluctuations of Navier–Stokessystems. Here we construct and study analytically a simple non-smooth map inwhich the standard steady state fluctuation relation is valid, although the modelviolates the Anosov property of chaotic dynamical systems. In particular, the timereversal operation is performed by a discontinuous involution, and the invariantmeasure is also discontinuous along the unstable manifolds. This further indicatesthat the validity of fluctuation relations for dynamical systems does not rely onparticularly elaborate conditions, usually violated by systems of interest in physics.Indeed, even an irreversible map is proved to verify the steady state fluctuationrelation.

Shear banding in a yield stress bearing Langmuir monolayer

We examine the shear-thinning behaviour of a two dimensional yield stress bearing monolayer of sorbitan tristearate at air/water interface. The flow curve consists of a linear region at low shear stresses/shear rates, followed by a stress plateau at higher values. The velocity profile obtained from particle imaging velocimetry indicates that shear banding occurs, showing coexistence of the fluidized region near the rotor and solid region with vanishing shear-rate away from the rotor. In the fluidized region, the velocity profile, which is linear at low shear rates, becomes exponential at the onset of shear-thinning, followed by a time varying velocity profile in the plateau region. At low values of constant applied shear rates, the viscosity of the film increases with time, thus showing aging behaviour like in soft glassy three-dimensional (3D) systems. Further, at the low values of the applied stress in the yield stress regime, the shear-rate fluctuations in time show both positive and negative values, similar to that observed in sheared 3D jammed systems. By carrying out a statistical analysis of these shear-rate fluctuations, we estimate the effective temperature of the soft glassy monolayer using the Galavatti-Cohen steady state fluctuation relation.

The covariant dissipation function for transient nonequilibrium states

It has recently become apparent that the dissipation function, first defined by Evans and Searles [J. Chem. Phys. 113, 3503 (2000)], is one of the most important functions in classical nonequilibrium statistical mechanics. It is the argument of the Evans-Searles fluctuation theorem, the dissipation theorem, and the relaxation theorems. It is a function of both the initial distribution and the dynamics. We pose the following question: How does the dissipation function change if we define that function with respect to the time evolving phase space distribution as one relaxes from the initial equilibrium distribution toward the nonequilibrium steady state distribution? We prove that this covariant dissipation function has a rather simple fixed relationship to the dissipation function defined with respect to the initial distribution function. We also show that there is no exact, time-local, Evans-Searles nonequilibrium steady state fluctuation relation for deterministic systems. Only an asymptotic version exists.

Fluctuation relation and heterogeneous superdiffusion in glassy transport

Current fluctuations and related steady-state fluctuation relation are investigated in simple coarse-grained lattice-gas analogs of a non-Newtonian fluid driven by a constant and uniform force field in two regimes of small entropy production. Non-Gaussian current fluctuations and deviations from fluctuation relation are observed and related to the existence of growing amorphous correlations and heterogeneous anomalous diffusion regimes.

On the Fluctuation Relation for Nosé-Hoover Boundary Thermostated Systems

We discuss the transient and steady state fluctuation relation for a mechanical system in contact with two deterministic thermostats at different temperatures. The system is a modified Lorentz gas in which the fixed scatterers exchange energy with the gas of particles, and the thermostats are modelled by two Nos\'e-Hoover thermostats applied at the boundaries of the system. The transient fluctuation relation, which holds only for a precise choice of the initial ensemble, is verified at all times, as expected. Times longer than the mesoscopic scale, needed for local equilibrium to be settled, are required if a different initial ensemble is considered. This shows how the transient fluctuation relation asymptotically leads to the steady state relation when, as explicitly checked in our systems, the condition found in [D.J. Searles, {\em et al.}, J. Stat. Phys. 128, 1337 (2007)], for the validity of the steady state fluctuation relation, is verified. For the steady state fluctuations of the phase space contraction rate $\zL$ and of the dissipation function $\zW$, a similar relaxation regime at shorter averaging times is found. The quantity $\zW$ satisfies with good accuracy the fluctuation relation for times larger than the mesoscopic time scale; the quantity $\zL$ appears to begin a monotonic convergence after such times. This is consistent with the fact that $\zW$ and $\zL$ differ by a total time derivative, and that the tails of the probability distribution function of $\zL$ are Gaussian.

Nonequilibrium Fluctuation Relation for Sheared Micellar Gel in a Jammed State

We show that the shear rate at a fixed shear stress in a micellar gel in a jammed state exhibits large fluctuations, showing positive and negative values, with the mean shear rate being positive. The resulting probability distribution functions of the global power flux to the system vary from Gaussian to non-Gaussian, depending on the driving stress, and in all cases show similar symmetry properties as predicted by the Gallavotti-Cohen steady state fluctuation relation. The fluctuation relation allows us to determine an effective temperature related to the structural constraints of the jammed state. We have measured the stress dependence of the effective temperature. Further, experiments reveal that the effective temperature and the standard deviation of the shear-rate fluctuations increase with the decrease of the system size.

The Steady State Fluctuation Relation for the Dissipation Function

We give a proof of transient fluctuation relations for the entropy production (dissipation function) in nonequilibrium systems, which is valid for most time reversible dynamics. We then consider the conditions under which a transient fluctuation relation yields a steady state fluctuation relation for driven nonequilibrium systems whose transients relax, producing a unique nonequilibrium steady state. Although the necessary and sufficient conditions for the production of a unique nonequilibrium steady state are unknown, if such a steady state exists, the generation of the steady state fluctuation relation from the transient relation is shown to be very general. It is essentially a consequence of time reversibility and of a form of decay of correlations in the dissipation, which is needed also for, e.g., the existence of transport coefficients. Because of this generality the resulting steady state fluctuation relation has the same degree of robustness as do equilibrium thermodynamic equalities. The steady state fluctuation relation for the dissipation stands in contrast with the one for the phase space compression factor, whose convergence is problematic, for systems close to equilibrium. We examine some model dynamics that have been considered previously, and show how they are described in the context of this work.