Static Pushover Research Articles

Evaluation of overstrength-based interaction checks for columns in steel moment frames

Current design guidelines in the United States require a check for only column axial force under overstrength seismic loads for capacity-designed steel moment frames. A study is presented to examine the implications of this guidance, which disregards the column interaction check (including both axial force and moment) under overstrength seismic loads. A set of thirteen steel moment frames are designed using multiple rules that apply and disregard overstrength, drift, and cross-sectional compactness checks in various combinations. The frames are subjected to a suite of simulations including linear elastic, nonlinear static pushover, nonlinear response history, and continuum finite element simulations that are able to represent a range of physical behavior modes in the columns including interactive nonlinear geometric instabilities that could trigger loss of the load carrying capacity of the member. The simulations indicate no significant distinction between the seismic performance of steel moment resisting frames designed as per current code-based provisions (i.e., disregarding the column interaction check for overstrength seismic loads), and those designed with the use of the interaction check, with each providing acceptable response without failure. The simulations also indicate that design checks for drift and cross-sectional compactness play a significant role ensuring acceptable response, providing additional margin of safety beyond the member strength checks.

Seismic Collapse Risk Assessment and Fragility Analysis of Reinforced Masonry Core Walls with Boundary Elements Using the FEMA P695 Methodology

In the past, the primary objective of structural design codes was centred around ensuring human life safety, with a strong focus on preventing structural collapse. This approach predominantly relied on force- or strength-based criteria as the basis for design. Nevertheless, a notable shift has occurred recently, transitioning the design philosophy from 'strength' towards a 'performance'-based approach. This shift signifies a growing recognition that strength and performance are not identical. However, to adopt the performance-based seismic design approach, it is essential to develop precise models for estimating damage and potential losses associated with various seismic force-resisting systems (SFRSs). Fragility functions are widely interpreted among the most prevalent damage and loss models. They establish a crucial link between specific demand parameters and the likelihood of exceeding various damage states. Although reinforced masonry (RM) structures have recently gained popularity, the seismic design of mid- to high-rise RM structures is still challenging because it requires a reliable SFRS capable of providing the needed ductility and capacity. Therefore, the main objective of this study is to evaluate the key seismic performance parameters (i.e., system overstrength and ductility) and to perform a collapse capacity risk assessment of reinforced masonry core walls with boundary elements (RMCW+BEs) as the main SFRS in RM structures. The current study utilizes the applied element method (AEM) implemented in the Extreme Loading for Structures software (ELS) to model three RM structures with various heights (10-, 15-, and 20-story buildings). Nonlinear pseudo- static pushover analysis was performed to quantify the ductility and overstrength of the proposed RM system following the FEMA P695 guidelines. In addition, an incremental dynamic analysis (IDA) was carried out to assess the seismic collapse risk of RMCW+BEs by generating system-level-based fragility curves. The results showed that the proposed RM system provides the needed ductility, overstrength and deformation capacity for a ductile SFRS for typical mid- and high-rise RM buildings. Furthermore, the developed collapse fragility curves verified excellent seismic performance, negligible collapse probability values and high reserved collapse capacity at the maximum considered earthquake (MCE) design level. The findings of this study significantly contribute toward adopting RMCW+BEs as an effective SFRS for typical RM buildings in the next generations of North American masonry design standards.

Seismic Collapse Risk Assessment and Fragility Analysis of Reinforced Masonry Core Walls with Boundary Elements Using the FEMA P695 Methodology

In the past, the primary objective of structural design codes was centred around ensuring human life safety, with a strong focus on preventing structural collapse. This approach predominantly relied on force- or strength-based criteria as the basis for design. Nevertheless, a notable shift has occurred recently, transitioning the design philosophy from 'strength' towards a 'performance'-based approach. This shift signifies a growing recognition that strength and performance are not identical. However, to adopt the performance-based seismic design approach, it is essential to develop precise models for estimating damage and potential losses associated with various seismic force-resisting systems (SFRSs). Fragility functions are widely interpreted among the most prevalent damage and loss models. They establish a crucial link between specific demand parameters and the likelihood of exceeding various damage states. Although reinforced masonry (RM) structures have recently gained popularity, the seismic design of mid- to high-rise RM structures is still challenging because it requires a reliable SFRS capable of providing the needed ductility and capacity. Therefore, the main objective of this study is to evaluate the key seismic performance parameters (i.e., system overstrength and ductility) and to perform a collapse capacity risk assessment of reinforced masonry core walls with boundary elements (RMCW+BEs) as the main SFRS in RM structures. The current study utilizes the applied element method (AEM) implemented in the Extreme Loading for Structures software (ELS) to model three RM structures with various heights (10-, 15-, and 20-story buildings). Nonlinear pseudo- static pushover analysis was performed to quantify the ductility and overstrength of the proposed RM system following the FEMA P695 guidelines. In addition, an incremental dynamic analysis (IDA) was carried out to assess the seismic collapse risk of RMCW+BEs by generating system-level-based fragility curves. The results showed that the proposed RM system provides the needed ductility, overstrength and deformation capacity for a ductile SFRS for typical mid- and high-rise RM buildings. Furthermore, the developed collapse fragility curves verified excellent seismic performance, negligible collapse probability values and high reserved collapse capacity at the maximum considered earthquake (MCE) design level. The findings of this study significantly contribute toward adopting RMCW+BEs as an effective SFRS for typical RM buildings in the next generations of North American masonry design standards.

Seismic Performance of Reinforced Concrete Frames on Sloped Ground Using Non-Linear Static Pushover Analysis

Nepal, renowned for its majestic Himalayan Ranges, is also highly vulnerable to seismic activity. Buildings on hill slopes often endure more significant damage during earthquakes than those on flat terrain. Traditional seismic analyses of buildings typically employ linear-static and dynamic methods, which might not fully represent the building's behavior under actual seismic conditions. This research addresses this gap by assessing the seismic performance of buildings on hill slopes using non-linear static analysis techniques. Specifically, the study evaluates the seismic response of 5-story buildings with stepback and stepback-setback configurations on slopes of 15°, 30°, and 45°. This evaluation is conducted through non-linear static analysis, also known as Pushover Analysis, using ETABSv20 software. Key performance metrics analyzed include the building's period, topstorey displacement, and base shear. The findings reveal that buildings with stepbacksetback configurations demonstrate superior seismic performance on the sloping ground compared to those with stepback configurations. This study underscores the importance of employing non-linear analysis methods to better understand and improve seismic resilience in hilly terrains.

Mitigating inter-story drift concentration in seismic-resistant self-centering braced frames by using strong backup systems

Seismic-resistant self-centering concentrically braced frames (SC-CBFs) are susceptible to the concentration of inter-story drifts during earthquakes owing to the relatively low energy dissipation ability of braces. To address this limitation, this study proposed a novel solution by designing a strong backup (SB) system to mitigate inter-story deformation concentration in “weak” stories. The proposed SB system consisting of truss members can be attached to the existing SC-CBF through pin connections, forming a system, termed strong backup SC-CBF (SC-CBF-SB), to promote a more uniform distribution of inter-story drifts along the height of the frame and mitigate the weak story behavior. A six-story chevron-braced frame is adopted to investigate the seismic performance of SC-CBF and SC-CBF-SB. Finite element models of SC-CBF and SC-CBF-SB are built. The mechanical characteristics and dynamic responses of the SC-CBF-SB are examined. To comprehensively evaluate the performance of both SC-CBF and SC-CBF-SB, static pushover analyses and nonlinear time-history analyses are conducted. Additionally, incremental dynamic analysis (IDA) is performed to evaluate the responses (particularly drift concentration) of both frame types subjected to increasing seismic intensity levels. Numerical results show that the maximum value of the drift concentration factor (DCF) is around 1.3 and 1.8 for SC-CBF-SB and SC-CBF, respectively, indicating that SC-CBF-SB can effectively mitigate inter-story drift concentration of SC-CBF. Meanwhile, the proposed SB system has a minimal negative impact on the favorable SC ability of the frame.

Elastic-plastic analysis of a novel prefabricated SRC column-steel beam composite frame structure

The objective of this study is to examine the mechanical behavior of a novel PSRCS (Prefabricated SRC Column-Steel Beam) frame structure under static and dynamic loads. To this end, a PSRCS frame structure with PSRCS joints has been constructed using the OpenSees software, and an elastoplastic analysis has been conducted. The principal findings of the study are as follows: Firstly, a comparison of the test results for the PSRCS joints with the FE (finite element) simulation results demonstrated that the FE model based on OpenSees is an effective means of simulating the load-bearing and deformation performance of the PSRCS joints. Subsequently, a PSRCS frame structure was constructed using OpenSees, and static and dynamic elastoplastic analyses were performed. Compared to the more conventional SRC column-steel beam frame structures, the PSRCS frame structure displays superior deformation capacity when subjected to static pushover action. The PSRCS frame structure exhibits a 'beam hinge' failure mode due to the plastic deformation of the flange connection plates, whereas the failure location of the conventional frame tends to be at the column ends, resulting in a 'column hinge' failure mode. In the context of dynamic analysis, an increase in the number of stories results in an augmented hysteresis of the vertex displacement-time history curve at the upper level of the PSRCS framework. The fundamental natural period T1 of the PSRCS frame is approximately 27.6 % to 34.0 % larger than that of the common frame, contributing to the maintenance of structural stability. In conclusion, a series of design objectives and methodologies based on performance were put forth for the PSRCS frame structure.

The Impact of Buckling Restrained Braces in Strengthening Deficient Reinforced Concrete Structures

Seismic strengthening for existing structures is a sustainable solution that is utilized to enhance building safety, reduce damages, and prevent failure in a future earthquake event. The choice of seismic strengthening techniques has to be accurate, efficient, and adjusted to make RC structures stronger in the building sector. Buckling-restrained brace (BRB) system is one of the successful strengthening strategies, that it is possible to utilize in both RC and steel structures. Therefore, this paper explores the possibility of employing buckling restrained braces in existing RC buildings and assesses the impact of different BRB bracing distributions and positions on seismic force resistance. In this work, a five-story RC building was considered, and to upgrade their performance seismic was modeled using four types of BRB systems, consisting of two types of bracing configurations with two arrangements: diagonal in the central bay, diagonal in the corner bays, chevron in the central bay, and chevron in the corner bays. To assess the efficiency of the four proposed BRB systems, firstly, the nonlinear static pushover method was conducted to investigate the lateral strength of structures. Secondly, a parametric study was undertaken using dynamic time history analysis to study various factors such as roof displacement, shear force, and roof acceleration of the original and strengthened models. The numerical study was executed using the Seismostruct software. The results and different performance levels were examined and compared. The obtained results indicate that the BRB and concrete structures can successfully work together to resist the reliability of strengthening RC structures. It was observed that the four prediction systems of the BRB models were excessively effective at upgrading the seismic resistance of the existing structure and provided significantly less damage, especially when using the chevron BRBs with the corner arrangement compared to the other models.

Effect of Infilled Frames on Reduction Factor (R) for RC Irregular Structure

Investigating the modification factors as a critical seismic design tool, delineating the anticipated level of inelastic behavior within structural systems during seismic events. Both damping and ductility are included in this factor, particularly at movement nearing maximum capacity. Moreover, it offers valuable insights into buildings' response during earthquakes and the anticipated behavior of structures compliant with building codes during design earthquakes. Essentially, it mirrors the structure's capacity to dissipate energy via an inelastic mechanism. In this research, the infill (RC) structures with various structural irregularities were focused. The selected irregularities included dimension, elevation, and mass. Infill location, number of bays, and seismic zone were the expected R factors for RC frames. Non-linear static pushover analysis was adopted in numerical simulation. The available data gathered from the literature was used to validate the outcomes of the developed models. Additionally, the effects of different types of soil were taken into consideration, and the research results demonstrated that the value of the modification factor (R) for change in stiffness and mass of high-rise buildings for bare and infill (RC) structures is less compared to irregular (RC) structures. It was concluded that the same structure with different types of soil and different parameters has a great effect on the value of R for bare and infill regular and irregular (RC) structures. Furthermore, recommendations for accurate R estimation for RC structures were discussed. Doi: 10.28991/CEJ-2024-010-08-09 Full Text: PDF

An Investigation of Seismic Behaviour of Prestressed Concrete Frame Structures using Pushover Analysis

Abstract: The prestressed concrete system is a prominent material in civil engineering, with applications ranging from buildings, bridges, foundations, piling, silos, stadiums, roadways, and other infrastructure. However, this work is primarily concerned with its applicability to building frame constructions subjected to seismic loading. The prestressed concrete system for frame constructions not only reduces the amount of structural components, but it is also a cost-effective technology that provides outstanding strength and stiffness, as well as quick and simple site erection. Hence, we will be able to use these prestressed concrete components to their full capacity, unlocking engineering and social benefits that were previously impossible. Prestressed concrete designs, as opposed to reinforced concrete designs, can give structures with substantially longer spans, no cracks, or fewer cracks with tiny crack widths. Nonetheless, research on the seismic behaviour of prestressed concrete frame structures is relatively restricted, with the majority of studies focusing on reinforced concrete structures. Finally, the provisional versions of modern building codes such as ACI 318, GB50010, and EC2 do not provide thorough processes for seismic design of prestressed concrete structures. In this work, the seismic design and behaviour of prestressed concrete building frames are explored using the most recent design code. Three model-building codes will be investigated and compared, including ACI 318- 14, Eurocode 2004-2, and Chinese GB500010-2010. The 10-story prestressed concrete frame system is subjected to gravity and seismic loading, and the strong-column weak beam mechanism is archived to conform with the newly implemented building design code. To examine the behaviour of prestressed concrete frame structures, nonlinear static pushover analysis is used to capture the reaction under earthquake loading. The stiffness and strength needed will be designed in compliance with the three major building codes indicated. In addition, the finite element model will be created using CSI Sap200 to capture its actions.

ANALISIS KINERJA STRUKTUR PADA GEDUNG BERTINGKAT DENGAN ANALISIS PUSHOVER BERDASARKAN ATC-40

Indonesia is an area prone to earthquakes. Earthquakes can cause infrastructure damage and casualties. Efforts are needed to reduce the risk of earthquake hazards by strengthening earthquake-resistant infrastructure. The design procedures for earthquake-resistant buildings are carried out using a performance-based design approach. Building performance can be estimated through non-linear static pushover analysis. This research takes a case study in Jongke Market, Surakarta. This research aims to determine the capacity curve, performance level, and structure collapse mechanism. The method used is pushover analysis with the capacity spectrum. The result of this analysis is a capacity curve that processed to determine the level of structure performance referring to the drift ratio limitation table in the Applied Technology Council (ATC-40). Based on the results of this research, displacement that occurred in the x direction is 92 mm and in the y direction is 77 mm. Building displacement is good because the displacement that occurred is smaller than the displacement limit (control). The total maximum drift in the x direction is 0.007 and in the y direction is 0.006. The maximum inelastic total drift in the x direction is 0.005 and in the y direction is 0.004. Based on the drift ratio limitation table in the ATC-40 document, this building has an immediate occupancy performance level. Based on the plastic hinge mechanism formed, the existing structure also meets the ideal collapse concept (strong column-weak beam).

Seismic retrofitting optimization model using fiber-reinforced polymer jacketing and NSGA-III

Fiber-reinforced polymer (FRP) is widely used for retrofitting structural elements due to its easy application. However, establishing a retrofit strategy is challenging due to conflicting objectives, such as cost and performance level, requiring optimization for effective decision-making. This study proposes a many-objective optimization model for seismic retrofitting using FRP and the Non-dominated Sorting Genetic Algorithm (NSGA)-III. The model's efficacy was demonstrated through two numerical examples: a reinforced concrete building retrofitted with FRP jackets and a masonry-infilled reinforced concrete building retrofitted with FRP bracings. Each example included three objective functions and multiple constraints. Nonlinear static pushover analysis provided optimal strategies to enhance base shear and energy dissipation while minimizing costs and retrofitting locations. Among the Pareto-optimal solutions, the optimal solution with the minimum Euclidean distance was selected. NSGA-III offered a wider distribution and more Pareto-optimal solutions compared to NSGA-II, demonstrating its potential in addressing many-objective problems related to retrofit decision-making.

Comparison of Performance Analysis Results with Developed Site-Specific Response Spectra and Turkish Seismic Design Code: A Case Study from the SW Türkiye Region

On 6 February 2023, the Kahramanmaraş earthquakes clearly showed that the elastic spectrum curves in TBEC-2018 are insufficient to represent earthquake behavior. In this study, the effect of using a site-specific spectrum curve instead of the elastic spectrum given in TBEC-2018 on the earthquake safety of a building is investigated. For this purpose, the provinces in southwest Anatolia, Türkiye, which is one of the most tectonically complex regions with frequent seismic events, were selected. In the first stage of the study, spectrum curves were obtained for earthquakes with return periods of 2475, 475, and 72 years for each of the provinces in this region. These spectrum curves were obtained using probabilistic seismic hazard studies that take into account the active faults of the provinces and earthquake activity in both historical and instrumental periods. In the second stage of the study, analytical models of a selected model RC building were created according to each province, and static pushover analyses of these building models were performed both according to the elastic spectrum given in TBEC-2018 and according to the spectrum curve created specifically for the province. The results of the analyses show that the change in the spectrum changes the target displacement level of the buildings, and as a result, the cross-sectional damage zone of the structural elements under the earthquake effect is changed. So much so that using the site-specific instead of the elastic spectrum given in TBEC-2018 changed the damage zone of 43% of the beams and 26.4% of the columns in the İzmir model. The change in the section damage zones changed the performance level of some floors of the models and the performance level of the building. The study revealed the importance of using the most realistic elastic spectrum curves in order to determine the earthquake performance of buildings that is as close as possible to their behavior in a possible earthquake.

Determination of response modification coefficient of SPSW in RC frame using plastic design method

ABSTRACT In the last few decades, the idea of using thin steel plate shear walls (SPSW) as a resistant system against lateral loads in designing and reinforcing buildings has been of concern to researchers and designers. In this research, we studied the response modification coefficient (R), the overstrength factor (Ω0), and the deflection amplification factor (C d ) in a reinforced concrete special moment frame (RC-SMF) with thin SPSW. We used the performance-based plastic design (PBPD) method. For this purpose, we consider frames with SPSW systems with different story numbers. Static pushover analysis is performed on these frames using the strip model in OpenSees software. OpenSees software is the Open System for Earthquake Engineering Simulation located at http://opensees.berkeley.edu. Simulation results were compared with experimental results, and acceptable matching was observed between the two. Finally, the values of response modification coefficient (R), overstrength factor (Ω0), and deflection amplification factor (C d ) for RC-SMF with thin SPSW were calculated based on the Uang method. The ultimate limit design method proposed them as 9.37, 2.21, and 11.06.

A plastic hinge method for static pushover analysis of 3D frame structures

ABSTRACT In this paper, a nonlinear elasto-plastic analysis method under incremental external loads is presented to determine static pushover curves of 3D frame structures. Geometric nonlinearity is taken into account with stability functions, and the nonlinear behaviour of material is considered by plastic hinge hypothesis. Improved matrices and matrix operations for 3D frame elements are given, and the results obtained from a six-storey 3D frame, which is used as a benchmark example, are given comparatively with the related studies. Furthermore, in order to perform these analyses with the developed algorithms, the upgraded computer program TUNAL is used to present pushover curves of a 2-storey RC building for an assumption on torsional stiffness caused by plastic hinges. It is shown that the proposed methodology and the computer program give accurate and reliable results.

Response Reduction Factor for Structures with Significant Irregularities on Different Soil Stratum

The ability of a structure to dissipate energy through inelastic behavior is reflected in the response reduction factor (R), which is influenced by redundancy, ductility, and overstrength. Accurate determination of R is crucial for seismic design. This study focuses on determining the response factor for reinforced concrete (RC) structures with various irregularities. Non-linear static pushover analysis using SAP2000 was employed for numerical simulations to assess the impact of soil-structure interaction (SSI). The analysis included elevational and in-plan irregularities, revealing that buildings with irregular vertical geometries have lower inelastic seismic capacities compared to regular buildings. Consequently, R should be reduced by 15–40% from the ECP 2020 standard before the design phase for such structures. Irregularity was found to have a significant impact on weak soil conditions (C), leading to a reduction in R of 20.3% and 13.1% for fixed and isolated supports, respectively, on loose soil. Additionally, stiffer base soils were associated with higher R values for the same structure. Doi: 10.28991/CEJ-2024-010-03-07 Full Text: PDF

A Comparative Study of Seismic Performance Evaluation of Reinforced Concrete Frame Structures Using Chinese and African Seismic Codes

The evaluation of various earthquake codes, it is one of the significant challenges in the study area of earthquake engineering. However, according to the literature review, most research works have not addressed comparing Chinese and African seismic codes. Therefore, the purpose of this study is to identify each code’s advantages by comparing assessment of the seismic efficacy of moment resistance frame reinforced concrete (MRF-RC) frames using four different codes: the Ethiopian Building Code Standard (EBCS-8), the Egyptian Code for Design and Construction of Reinforced Concrete Structures (ECP-201), the Algerian Seismic Regulations (RPA-99), and the Chinese Code for Seismic Design of Buildings (GB-50011), the first three are the major codes used in Africa. The seismic provisions of these codes are compared and evaluated using nonlinear time-history analysis (NL-THA) and nonlinear static pushover to validate the results. These analyses are performed on four MRF-RC frame models with different heights. The results include various parameters that reflect the seismic performance of the structures. The study revealed that the Chinese code is more conservative and overestimates seismic performance compared with African codes. However, the Chinese code can be applied in African projects considering the African soil classifications, and seismic weight are adjusted to meet the African design criteria.

Conservativeness Study on the Seismic Analysis Method for Research Reactor Plant Structure Based on TMSR-LF1

The seismic performance analysis of research reactor plants is crucial for ensuring the safety of the entire reactor system. This paper analyzes the plant structure seismic performance of the 2WMt Thorium Molten Salt Reactor-Liquid Fuel 1 (TMSR-LF1) at the Shanghai Institute of Applied Physics, Chinese Academy of Sciences under the action of frequent earthquakes, fortification earthquakes, and rare earthquakes was analyzed by finite element software PKPM based on the seismic design method of civil code +1°. On this basis, a comparison was made between the seismic responses of structural pushover analysis and elastoplastic time history analysis under the action of rare earthquakes, and the conservatism of these two commonly used methods for elastoplastic analysis was systematically analyzed. The results indicate that the TMSR-LF1 plant structure exhibits well bearing and deformation capacity. It meets the seismic design goal of “no damage under small earthquakes,” “no unrepairable damage under medium earthquakes,” and “no collapse under large earthquakes (using static pushover analysis),” and the critical regions are entirely within the elastic range. Furthermore, the analysis reveals that the elastoplastic time history analysis method produced a significantly higher seismic response than the pushover analysis method, which indicates the conservativeness of the time history method. Therefore, it is recommended to use the elastoplastic time history analysis method to evaluate the seismic performance of research reactor plants under rare earthquake actions. The research in this paper provides important references for the seismic performance analysis of other Class II research reactor plants.

Effect of Beam-Column Connection Types on the Response Modification Factors of Steel Frames

A key component of steel structural design is the careful selection of structural modeling joints in steel structures, as the behavior of the joints affects the structure's strength and displacement characteristics. According to the capacity for transferring moment, connections in the analysis of frames are categorized as rigid, semi-rigid, or pinned. Also, the response modification factor (R-factor) is an effective parameter used in the seismic design of structures. However, the influence of the beam-column connection's stiffness factor on the response modification factor did not seem to have been considered in seismic design codes. Consequently, the R-factor under static pushover and dynamic loading is being studied for moment-resisting steel frames (MRSFs) with 3-, 6-, and 12-story using three different forms of beam-column connections depending on the connections' stiffness (m). The rigidities of the connections are taken 20, 10, and 5 for rigid, stiff semi-rigid, and flexible semi-rigid connections, respectively. The MRSFs are subjected to ten records with varying frequency contents and ground motion durations. The ductility reduction factor (Rμ), the over-strength reduction factor (Ro), and the R-factor were determined. The results indicated that the beam-column connection rigidity factors affected the R0, Rμ, and R-factors. Also, the R-factors were more affected by the rigidity factors for the beam-column connections and the number of story frames.

Photogrammetry-aided numerical seismic assessment of historical structures composed of adobe, stone and brick masonry. Application to the San Juan Bautista Church built on the Inca temple of Huaytará, Peru

This research presents a cost-effective surveying methodology to assist the seismic assessment of complex heritage buildings, based on terrestrial structure-from-motion (SfM) photogrammetry. The method was applied to the study of the seismic performance of the church of San Juan Bautista – Inca temple of Huaytará, Peru, an emblematic case study due to its complex architecture and coexistence of different construction materials. The geometrical model for the seismic assessment was developed with an error of less than 2 % using SfM photogrammetry. Non-linear static pushover analyses were performed on 3D FEM models of the nave and the towers to evaluate their individual response under seismic loading. Mechanical properties of different structural materials of the church were evaluated based on laboratory experimental tests on mortar and adobe, contemporary and ancient fired brick, Inca stone, colonial stone and rubble stone units. Non-linear pushover analyses were conducted in four directions perpendicular to the perimeter walls, and the response of the structure was compared with the seismic demand specified in Peruvian Standards. The simulations show that damage-prone areas are the western and eastern facades, with cracking at the connections between orthogonal walls, as well as at the interface of adobe masonry with Inca stone masonry. The towers exhibit similar seismic response, with lower strength capacities compared to the main nave. In this case, flexural overturning mechanisms and cracking at the interface between stone and adobe masonry were observed. The displacement-based seismic assessment using the N2 method shows that a peak ground acceleration of 0.21 g could lead to the collapse of the north and south facades of the main nave. The towers showed a much smaller capacity with PGA leading to collapse of approximately 0.09 g. Overall, this study contributes to the understanding of the seismic performance of the Huaytará-Huancavelica church, highlighting vulnerabilities and providing valuable information for its preservation and future interventions. Future investigations should focus on on-site tests that will allow the estimation of the effect of existing damage on the structural response and their incorporation in the numerical model.

Seismic Resilience of Concrete Moment Frames with Fibrous Rubberized Beam-Column Joints

ABSTRACT Ensuring resilience through rapid buildings recovery in seismic zones has been placed at the forefront of recent studies. However, studies that compare the relative resilience of buildings constructed with different materials are lacking. This paper focuses on a comparative resilience analysis of concrete moment frames where beam-column connections are made with varying types of concrete mixtures. The connections are made with normal strength concrete (NSC), rubberized concrete (RbC), steel fiber rubberized concrete (STFRC), synthetic fiber rubberized concrete (SYFRC), and high strength concrete (HSC). Nonlinear static pushover and incremental dynamic analysis (IDA) are utilized to understand system response and the level of damage sustained following an earthquake. Subsequently, seismic fragility functions are constructed for the five considered frame types. The frames are subjected to different seismic scenarios, and the corresponding losses, recovery time, and resilience are quantified. A comparison between the five frame types is carried out to examine the optimal concrete mixture to be used to reduce damage probabilities, total direct losses, and recovery time and subsequently enhance resilience. The results show that rubberized concrete strengthened with steel and synthetic fibers can reduce economic losses by up to 19% and increase building resilience by up to 37% compared with the frames constructed with normal strength concrete.